{ "title": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "canonical_origin": "https://archive.museumofone.art", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "scope": "Selected corpus; not a complete recovery of the previous catalogue", "records": [ { "id": "19864099", "accession": "MOO-CAT-001", "title": "Post-Interpretive Criticism: Volume I - The Foundational Essays", "source_title": "Post-Interpretive Criticism: Volume I - The Foundational Essays", "short_title": "Volume I — The Foundational Essays", "author": "Dorian Vale", "creators": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "affiliation": "MuseumofOne", "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094" } ], "doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864099", "conceptdoi": "10.5281/zenodo.17058411", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864099", "date": "2026-04", "type": "Book", "source_resource_type": { "title": "Book", "type": "publication", "subtype": "book" }, "version": "Repository release v5 (source description)", "collection": "Books & volumes", "summary": "Collected foundational writings introducing Post-Interpretive Criticism through doctrines, theoretical propositions, and applications concerned with restraint, presence, and witnessing.", "subjects": [ "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Aesthetics", "Art criticism", "Foundational writings" ], "keywords": [ "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Stillmark Theory", "Absential Aesthetics", "Witness Aesthetics", "Hauntmark Theory", "Presence-Based Criticism", "Custodianship of Art", "Art as Ontology", "Restraint in front of art", "Moral proximity", "Interpretive silence", "Erasure as ethics", "Temporal scarcity", "Silence as method", "Ontology of beauty", "Aesthetic mercy", "Language as violence", "Art encounter ethics", "Epistemology of witness", "Philosophy of Art", "Aesthetics", "Art Theory", "Contemporary Aesthetics", "Phenomenology and Art", "Ethics in Art Criticism", "Interpretation and Meaning", "Criticism and Reception Theory", "Epistemology of Art", "Visual Culture Studies", "Dorian Vale", "Founder of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Post-Aesthetic Critic", "Independent Philosopher of Art", "Museum of One", "Art Writer and Theorist", "Aesthetic Philosopher", "Custodian of Witness Aesthetics", "The Doctrine of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "The Custodian's Oath", "The Canon of Witnesses", "Art as Truth", "Art as Presence", "The Viewer as Evidence", "Interpretation vs. Witnessing", "Language as Custody", "Erasure as Afterlife", "Museum of One Manifesto", "Post-Interpretive Lexicon", "Alternative art criticism", "New art criticism movement", "Ethical art theory", "Criticism beyond interpretation", "Quiet philosophy of art", "Radical art restraint", "Witness over interpretation", "Interpretive Restraint", "Aesthetics of Mercy", "Art Criticism Ethics", "Museum Of One", "https://www.museumofone.art/", "https://hcommons.org/members/dorianvale/", "https://philpeople.org/profiles/dorian-vale", "https://osf.io/xa5jw/", "https://independent.academia.edu/DorianVale", "https://figshare.com/authors/Dorian_Vale/22186984", "osf.io/zhnre", "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17112807", "https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/KVE9Y", "https://archive.org/details/osf-registrations-kve9y-v1", "https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5443334", "http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.5443334", "Part of the Post-Interpretive Criticism movement (Q136308909), published by Museum of One (Q136308879), authored by Dorian Vale (Q136308916).", "Q136308909", "Q136308879", "Q136308916", "https://zenodo.org/communities/post-interpretive-criticism", "https://www.semanticscholar.org/author/Dorian-Vale/2380743266", "https://scholar.google.com/citations?hl=en&authuser=1&user=15tvhjAAAAAJ", "Q136530009" ], "license": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "files": [ { "name": "post-interprative-criticism-volume-i-STANDARD.pdf", "url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19864099/files/post-interprative-criticism-volume-i-STANDARD.pdf/content", "size": 1044796, "size_label": "1020 KB", "checksum": "md5:2cbd120db1c6358cb65702d5090d042a", "mimetype": "application/pdf" } ], "institutional_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "corroboration": "Museum of One’s matching publication page confirms Dorian Vale’s authorship and the work’s institutional context. It links the selected Zenodo edition DOI. Web-record dates are not treated as dates of the deposited edition. Source review: 4 November 2026.", "discrepancies": [ "The source describes a title-page variant, “Post–Interprative Criticism: Volume I,” alongside the current publisher citation title. The deposited PDF is unchanged.", "The source states first publication in 2025, first edition; April 2026 identifies repository release v5 rather than a new book edition. The ISBN is retained as printed; an agency assignment has not been independently verified." ], "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "publisher": "Museum of One", "language": null, "isbn": "978-1-06-982030-3", "related_identifiers": [ { "identifier": "https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5443334", "relation": "isDocumentedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "10.2139/ssrn.5443334", "relation": "isDocumentedBy", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Post-Interprative-Criticism%3A-Foundational-Essays-Vale/09538ab14a89022e2886f9cccaf133e8d5c9cf7d", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://core.ac.uk/works/299792897", "relation": "isDocumentedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "http://eprints.rclis.org/47182/", "relation": "isDocumentedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://repository.africarxiv.org/handle/1/10438", "relation": "isDocumentedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://open.icm.edu.pl/workspaceitems/33643/view", "relation": "isDocumentedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://repository.crossasia.org/receive/crossasia_mods_00000623", "relation": "isDocumentedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://repository.crossasia.org/receive/crossasia_mods_00000624", "relation": "isDocumentedBy", "scheme": "url" } ], "alternate_identifiers": [ { "identifier": "https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5443334" }, { "identifier": "10.2139/ssrn.5443334" }, { "identifier": "https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Post-Interprative-Criticism%3A-Foundational-Essays-Vale/09538ab14a89022e2886f9cccaf133e8d5c9cf7d" }, { "identifier": "978-1-06-982030-3" }, { "identifier": "https://core.ac.uk/works/299792897" }, { "identifier": "http://eprints.rclis.org/47182/" }, { "identifier": "https://repository.africarxiv.org/handle/1/10438" }, { "identifier": "https://open.icm.edu.pl/workspaceitems/33643/view" }, { "identifier": "https://repository.crossasia.org/receive/crossasia_mods_00000623" }, { "identifier": "https://repository.crossasia.org/receive/crossasia_mods_00000624" } ], "source_references": [ "https://www.museumofone.art/", "https://hcommons.org/members/dorianvale/", "https://philpeople.org/profiles/dorian-vale", "https://osf.io/xa5jw/", "https://independent.academia.edu/DorianVale", "https://figshare.com/authors/Dorian_Vale/22186984", "osf.io/zhnre", "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17112807", "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17069115", "https://archive.org/details/osf-registrations-kve9y-v1", "https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/KVE9Y", "https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5443334", "http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.5443334", "Q136308909", "Q136308879", "Q136308916", "https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Post-Interprative-Criticism%3A-Foundational-Essays-Vale/09538ab14a89022e2886f9cccaf133e8d5c9cf7d", "https://www.semanticscholar.org/author/Dorian-Vale/2380743266", "https://zenodo.org/communities/post-interpretive-criticism", "https://scholar.google.com/citations?hl=en&authuser=1&user=15tvhjAAAAAJ", "https://ssrn.com/abstract=5471149", "http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.5471149", "https://www.researchcatalogue.net/profile", "https://www.researchcatalogue.net/profile/show-exposition?exposition=3921018", "0000000528819744", "0000000528819787", "0000000528819728" ], "source_journal": null, "source_imprint": {}, "source_contributors": [ { "name": "Museum Of One", "affiliation": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "type": "HostingInstitution" } ], "source_created": "2026-04-28T19:07:18.070464+00:00", "source_modified": "2026-10-15T14:32:18.509095+00:00", "source_description_html": "

Bibliographic clarification

\n

The publisher's current citation title is Post-Interpretive Criticism: Volume I - The Foundational Essays. The title page of the unchanged deposited PDF (PDF page 3) reads Post–Interprative Criticism: Volume I, with the subtitle Foundational Essays (Collected Doctrines, Treaties, Theories, and Application). The cover uses Post-Interpretive Criticism. These are title variants of this deposited work; the corrected publisher citation does not alter or purport to transcribe the PDF title page.

\n

The copyright page (PDF page 4) states first publication by Museum of One in 2025, First edition, and prints ISBN 978-1-0698203-0-3. The April 2026 date identifies repository release v5, not a new book edition. The printed ISBN is retained as printed, without asserting a newly verified ISBN-agency assignment.

\n

Publisher citation and edition record: Museum of One publication record. Stable concept DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17058411.

\n

Museum of One / Archive and Research (ISNI: 0000000528819728)

\n

Journal of Post-Interpretive Criticism (ISNI: 0000000528819787)

\n

Dorian Vale (ISNI: 0000000528819744)

\n

Post-Interpretive Criticism: Foundational Essays is the inaugural volume in a groundbreaking aesthetic philosophy movement pioneered by art critic and theorist Dorian Vale. This collected body of doctrine, theory, and application offers a radical alternative to traditional art criticism—one grounded not in interpretation, but in restraint, reverence, and moral proximity.

\n

 

\n

Rather than decoding or distilling meaning, Vale’s Post-Interpretive Criticism proposes a mode of custodial encounter: the critic as witness, the viewer as evidence, and language as stewardship.

\n

 

\n

This volume gathers all core philosophical structures and establishes the intellectual foundation of the Post-Interpretive Movement, including:

\n

 

\n\n

 

\n

 

\n

It also includes cornerstone essays on Viewer-as-Evidence, The Custodian’s Oath, and applied case studies on artists such as Zarina Hashmi, Doris Salcedo, and Teresa Margolles—each explored through the lens of sacred witnessing and restrained presence.

\n

 

\n

This book is not merely a collection. It is the founding architecture of a new philosophical tradition in aesthetics.

\n

 

\n

Vale, Dorian. Post-Interprative Criticism: Foundational Essays (Collected Doctrines, Treaties, Theories, and Application). Museum of One, 2025. DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17069115

\n

This entry is connected to a series of original theories and treatises forming the foundation of the Post-Interpretive Criticism movement (Q136308909), authored by Dorian Vale (Q136308916) and published by Museum of One (Q136308879). These include: Stillmark Theory (Q136328254), Hauntmark Theory (Q136328273), Absential Aesthetic Theory (Q136328330), Viewer-as-Evidence Theory (Q136328828), Message-Transfer Theory (Q136329002), Aesthetic Displacement Theory (Q136329014), Theory of Misplacement (Q136329054), and Art as Truth: A Treatise (Q136329071), Aesthetic Recursion Theory (Q136339843), The Journal of Post-Interpretive Criticism (Q136530009)

\n

Post-Interpretive Criticism, Dorian Vale, contemporary art theory, philosophy of aesthetics, Absential Aesthetics, Stillmark Theory, Hauntmark Theory, Theory of Aesthetic Displacement, Theory of Misplacement, Art as Truth, ethics of art criticism, sacred criticism, witnessing aesthetics, non-interpretive art, Zarina Hashmi, Doris Salcedo, Teresa Margolles, trauma in contemporary art, moral proximity, restraint in criticism, ontology of art, post-criticism, viewer as evidence, presence in art, post-structuralist art theory, slow criticism

", "provenance": { "repository": "Zenodo REST API response supplied in query.json", "retrieved": "2026-11-04", "editorial_fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "source_snapshot": "source/19864099.json", "institutional_review": "Reviewed page-level title, author and repository links in saved public institutional HTML, 2026-11-04." }, "first_edition": "First published by Museum of One in 2025; first edition (source bibliographic clarification).", "cover": "assets/foundational-essays.jpg", "cover_alt": "Published cover of Post-Interpretive Criticism: Volume I - The Foundational Essays", "cover_source": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "source_review": "2026-11-04", "relations": [ { "identifier": "https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5443334", "relation": "isDocumentedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "10.2139/ssrn.5443334", "relation": "isDocumentedBy", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Post-Interprative-Criticism%3A-Foundational-Essays-Vale/09538ab14a89022e2886f9cccaf133e8d5c9cf7d", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://core.ac.uk/works/299792897", "relation": "isDocumentedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "http://eprints.rclis.org/47182/", "relation": "isDocumentedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://repository.africarxiv.org/handle/1/10438", "relation": "isDocumentedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://open.icm.edu.pl/workspaceitems/33643/view", "relation": "isDocumentedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://repository.crossasia.org/receive/crossasia_mods_00000623", "relation": "isDocumentedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://repository.crossasia.org/receive/crossasia_mods_00000624", "relation": "isDocumentedBy", "scheme": "url" } ], "institutional_metadata": { "title": "The Foundational Essays", "author": "Dorian Vale", "web_publication": "2026-10-14T00:00:00.000Z", "web_updated": "2026-10-14T16:23:08.000Z", "linked_zenodo_dois": [ "10.5281/zenodo.19864099" ], "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "publication_title": "Post-Interpretive Criticism: Volume I - The Foundational Essays", "publication_status": "Published book, Volume I; first edition, 2025", "publication_date": "2025", "edition": "First edition" }, "research_programmes": [ { "title": "Intellectual History and Conceptual Development", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-intellectual-history/", "status": "Continuing research", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "relation": "Earlier foundation examined by this programme.", "relation_label": "Earlier foundation examined by this programme." }, { "title": "Phenomenological Methods and Diagnostic Reading", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-methods/", "status": "Continuing research", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "relation": "Earlier theoretical foundation for methodological investigation.", "relation_label": "Earlier theoretical foundation for methodological investigation." } ], "record_level": "Item", "record_status": "Published source; selected catalogue record", "digital_formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "extent": "1 digital file; 1044796 bytes", "medium": "Digital document", "record_reviewed": "2026-11-04", "date_precision": "month", "alternate_titles": [ { "title": "The Foundational Essays", "kind": "institutional_web_record_title", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/" }, { "title": "Post–Interprative Criticism: Volume I", "kind": "title_page_variant_reported_by_repository", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864099" }, { "title": "Foundational Essays (Collected Doctrines, Treaties, Theories, and Application)", "kind": "title_page_subtitle_reported_by_repository", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864099" } ], "digital_extent": { "file_count": 1, "total_bytes": 1044796, "formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "checksums": [ { "filename": "post-interprative-criticism-volume-i-STANDARD.pdf", "algorithm": "md5", "value": "2cbd120db1c6358cb65702d5090d042a", "syntax_valid": true, "verification": "source_checksum_transcription; bytes not independently recomputed" } ], "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864099", "derivation": "File count and total bytes calculated from repository file metadata; MIME inferred from filename when absent." }, "identifier_validation": { "orcid": { "source_value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "ISO 7064 MOD 11-2 checksum only; this is not a live registry verification." }, "isbn": [ { "source_value": "978-1-06-982030-3", "normalized": "9781069820303", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "Checksum validation tests the identifier syntax only; it does not verify assignment, format or edition applicability.", "scope": "title_level_book_identifier; format applicability follows edition source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864099" } ], "doi": { "source_value": "10.5281/zenodo.19864099", "syntax_valid": true, "note": "Syntax check only; repository snapshot supplies the identifier." } }, "isbn_applicability": "title_level_book_identifier", "serial": null, "contributor_roles": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": "MuseumofOne", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864099" }, { "name": "Museum Of One", "source_category": "contributor", "source_role": "HostingInstitution", "role_label": "HostingInstitution", "affiliation_as_supplied": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864099" } ], "authority_links": [ { "title": "E-LIS repository record", "url": "https://eprints.rclis.org/47182/", "kind": "repository_record", "status": "verified_record", "evidence": "Title, Vale, Dorian, year 2025 and DOI 10.5281/zenodo.17069115 observed. E-LIS labels item Unpublished / In collection while file label says Published version; retain discrepancy. File is deposited by author, not an independent review.", "identifier": "http://hdl.handle.net/10760/47182", "note": "Do not transfer E-LIS licence to a different Zenodo edition.", "scope": "Bibliographic context; inspect source for edition applicability", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/post-interpretive-criticism-volume-i-foundational-essays/" }, { "title": "BiblioBoard catalogue access", "url": "https://library.biblioboard.com/content/f8192c42-14a5-4c79-8b38-c16c078f5331", "kind": "catalogue_access", "status": "institutional_link_access_restricted", "note": "Institution verifies title; record format, edition and ISBN not inspectable. Landing page only loaded generic shell.", "scope": "Bibliographic context; inspect source for edition applicability", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/post-interpretive-criticism-volume-i-foundational-essays/" } ], "metadata_profile": { "name": "Museum of One source-qualified catalogue profile", "version": "3.0.0", "url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/metadata-profile.json", "source_snapshot_preserved": true }, "reading_copy": { "id": "19864099", "title": "Post-Interpretive Criticism: Volume I - The Foundational Essays", "accession": "MOO-CAT-001", "pdf_url": "../assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19864099/files/post-interprative-criticism-volume-i-STANDARD.pdf/content", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864099", "source_filename": "post-interprative-criticism-volume-i-STANDARD.pdf", "checksum": "md5:2cbd120db1c6358cb65702d5090d042a", "sha256": "cff270ffc96c98812c0ab708cd159c2c34cbd43f13f378696802a7f2a939ac3d", "bytes": 1044796, "page_count": 82, "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "checksum_match": true, "rights": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "role": "Local reading copy; original repository file retained unchanged" }, "page_count": 82, "field_assertions": [ { "field": "title", "value": "Post-Interpretive Criticism: Volume I - The Foundational Essays", "status": "catalogue_title", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "note": "Local display title; the deposited title is retained separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_title", "value": "Post-Interpretive Criticism: Volume I - The Foundational Essays", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864099", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "doi", "value": "10.5281/zenodo.19864099", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864099", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "date", "value": "2026-04", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864099", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "version", "value": "Repository release v5 (source description)", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864099", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "conceptdoi", "value": "10.5281/zenodo.17058411", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864099", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "creators", "value": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "affiliation": "MuseumofOne", "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864099", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "keywords", "value": [ "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Stillmark Theory", "Absential Aesthetics", "Witness Aesthetics", "Hauntmark Theory", "Presence-Based Criticism", "Custodianship of Art", "Art as Ontology", "Restraint in front of art", "Moral proximity", "Interpretive silence", "Erasure as ethics", "Temporal scarcity", "Silence as method", "Ontology of beauty", "Aesthetic mercy", "Language as violence", "Art encounter ethics", "Epistemology of witness", "Philosophy of Art", "Aesthetics", "Art Theory", "Contemporary Aesthetics", "Phenomenology and Art", "Ethics in Art Criticism", "Interpretation and Meaning", "Criticism and Reception Theory", "Epistemology of Art", "Visual Culture Studies", "Dorian Vale", "Founder of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Post-Aesthetic Critic", "Independent Philosopher of Art", "Museum of One", "Art Writer and Theorist", "Aesthetic Philosopher", "Custodian of Witness Aesthetics", "The Doctrine of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "The Custodian's Oath", "The Canon of Witnesses", "Art as Truth", "Art as Presence", "The Viewer as Evidence", "Interpretation vs. Witnessing", "Language as Custody", "Erasure as Afterlife", "Museum of One Manifesto", "Post-Interpretive Lexicon", "Alternative art criticism", "New art criticism movement", "Ethical art theory", "Criticism beyond interpretation", "Quiet philosophy of art", "Radical art restraint", "Witness over interpretation", "Interpretive Restraint", "Aesthetics of Mercy", "Art Criticism Ethics", "Museum Of One", "https://www.museumofone.art/", "https://hcommons.org/members/dorianvale/", "https://philpeople.org/profiles/dorian-vale", "https://osf.io/xa5jw/", "https://independent.academia.edu/DorianVale", "https://figshare.com/authors/Dorian_Vale/22186984", "osf.io/zhnre", "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17112807", "https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/KVE9Y", "https://archive.org/details/osf-registrations-kve9y-v1", "https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5443334", "http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.5443334", "Part of the Post-Interpretive Criticism movement (Q136308909), published by Museum of One (Q136308879), authored by Dorian Vale (Q136308916).", "Q136308909", "Q136308879", "Q136308916", "https://zenodo.org/communities/post-interpretive-criticism", "https://www.semanticscholar.org/author/Dorian-Vale/2380743266", "https://scholar.google.com/citations?hl=en&authuser=1&user=15tvhjAAAAAJ", "Q136530009" ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864099", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "license", "value": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864099", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "files", "value": [ { "name": "post-interprative-criticism-volume-i-STANDARD.pdf", "url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19864099/files/post-interprative-criticism-volume-i-STANDARD.pdf/content", "size": 1044796, "size_label": "1020 KB", "checksum": "md5:2cbd120db1c6358cb65702d5090d042a", "mimetype": "application/pdf" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864099", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_created", "value": "2026-04-28T19:07:18.070464+00:00", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864099", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_modified", "value": "2026-10-15T14:32:18.509095+00:00", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864099", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "record_modified", "value": "2026-11-04", "status": "derived_from_description_history", "note": "Latest documented local description event; not a publication, repository or source-review date.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_review", "value": "2026-11-04", "status": "catalogue_source_review", "note": "Review of descriptive sources; not the creation or modification date of the work or repository record.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "author", "value": "Dorian Vale", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "note": "Institutional responsibility statement; original repository creator roles remain separate.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "publisher", "value": "Museum of One", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "note": "Institutional responsibility statement; original repository creator roles remain separate.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "first_edition", "value": "First published by Museum of One in 2025; first edition (source bibliographic clarification).", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "note": "Consult the linked edition record; a repository version is not a new book edition.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "isbn", "value": "978-1-06-982030-3", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "note": "Consult the linked edition record; a repository version is not a new book edition.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "orcid", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "source_linked_identifier", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "note": "Creator identifier supplied by the linked sources; no affiliation or endorsement is inferred.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "orcid_authority", "value": { "scheme": "ORCID", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "evidence_urls": [ "https://www.museumofone.art/archives-scholarly-infrastructure/", "https://eprints.rclis.org/47182/", "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ], "access_note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "evidence_receipt": "data/source/authority-review-2026-11-04.json" }, "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "source_url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "summary", "value": "Collected foundational writings introducing Post-Interpretive Criticism through doctrines, theoretical propositions, and applications concerned with restraint, presence, and witnessing.", "status": "editorial_enrichment", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "note": "Catalogue-editor summary based on the linked work; not an original publisher abstract.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "subjects", "value": [ "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Aesthetics", "Art criticism", "Foundational writings" ], "status": "editorial_enrichment", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "note": "Local discovery terms; no controlled-vocabulary assignment is claimed.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "collection", "value": "Books & volumes", "status": "editorial_grouping", "note": "A local browsing collection, not an original repository collection.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "corroboration", "value": "Museum of One’s matching publication page confirms Dorian Vale’s authorship and the work’s institutional context. It links the selected Zenodo edition DOI. Web-record dates are not treated as dates of the deposited edition. Source review: 4 November 2026.", "status": "catalogue_review_note", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "discrepancies", "value": [ "The source describes a title-page variant, “Post–Interprative Criticism: Volume I,” alongside the current publisher citation title. The deposited PDF is unchanged.", "The source states first publication in 2025, first edition; April 2026 identifies repository release v5 rather than a new book edition. The ISBN is retained as printed; an agency assignment has not been independently verified." ], "status": "catalogue_review_note", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "alternate_titles", "value": [ { "title": "The Foundational Essays", "kind": "institutional_web_record_title", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/" }, { "title": "Post–Interprative Criticism: Volume I", "kind": "title_page_variant_reported_by_repository", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864099" }, { "title": "Foundational Essays (Collected Doctrines, Treaties, Theories, and Application)", "kind": "title_page_subtitle_reported_by_repository", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864099" } ], "status": "source_qualified_title_variants", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "note": "Each variant retains its own source and scope; a web page title is not a title-page transcription.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "date_precision", "value": "month", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864099", "note": "Precision reported exactly as supplied; missing month or day is not filled.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "medium", "value": "Digital document", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864099", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "digital_formats", "value": [ "application/pdf" ], "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864099", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "extent", "value": "1 digital file; 1044796 bytes", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864099", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "digital_extent", "value": { "file_count": 1, "total_bytes": 1044796, "formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "checksums": [ { "filename": "post-interprative-criticism-volume-i-STANDARD.pdf", "algorithm": "md5", "value": "2cbd120db1c6358cb65702d5090d042a", "syntax_valid": true, "verification": "source_checksum_transcription; bytes not independently recomputed" } ], "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864099", "derivation": "File count and total bytes calculated from repository file metadata; MIME inferred from filename when absent." }, "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864099", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "identifier_validation", "value": { "orcid": { "source_value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "ISO 7064 MOD 11-2 checksum only; this is not a live registry verification." }, "isbn": [ { "source_value": "978-1-06-982030-3", "normalized": "9781069820303", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "Checksum validation tests the identifier syntax only; it does not verify assignment, format or edition applicability.", "scope": "title_level_book_identifier; format applicability follows edition source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864099" } ], "doi": { "source_value": "10.5281/zenodo.19864099", "syntax_valid": true, "note": "Syntax check only; repository snapshot supplies the identifier." } }, "status": "local_syntax_validation", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864099", "note": "Checksum/syntax validation does not verify registration, assignment or edition applicability.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "contributor_roles", "value": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": "MuseumofOne", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864099" }, { "name": "Museum Of One", "source_category": "contributor", "source_role": "HostingInstitution", "role_label": "HostingInstitution", "affiliation_as_supplied": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864099" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864099", "note": "Creator and contributor roles are transcribed, not inferred from names or affiliations.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "authority_links", "value": [ { "title": "E-LIS repository record", "url": "https://eprints.rclis.org/47182/", "kind": "repository_record", "status": "verified_record", "evidence": "Title, Vale, Dorian, year 2025 and DOI 10.5281/zenodo.17069115 observed. E-LIS labels item Unpublished / In collection while file label says Published version; retain discrepancy. File is deposited by author, not an independent review.", "identifier": "http://hdl.handle.net/10760/47182", "note": "Do not transfer E-LIS licence to a different Zenodo edition.", "scope": "Bibliographic context; inspect source for edition applicability", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/post-interpretive-criticism-volume-i-foundational-essays/" }, { "title": "BiblioBoard catalogue access", "url": "https://library.biblioboard.com/content/f8192c42-14a5-4c79-8b38-c16c078f5331", "kind": "catalogue_access", "status": "institutional_link_access_restricted", "note": "Institution verifies title; record format, edition and ISBN not inspectable. Landing page only loaded generic shell.", "scope": "Bibliographic context; inspect source for edition applicability", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/post-interpretive-criticism-volume-i-foundational-essays/" } ], "status": "source_qualified_external_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "note": "External records have separate status and edition scope; links are not endorsements or equivalence assertions.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "research_programme:https://www.museumofone.art/research-intellectual-history/", "value": { "title": "Intellectual History and Conceptual Development", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-intellectual-history/", "status": "Continuing research", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "relation": "Earlier foundation examined by this programme.", "relation_label": "Earlier foundation examined by this programme." }, "status": "institutional_work_relationship", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "note": "Programme relationship and stage follow the work-specific institutional badge; publication does not imply a completed programme or collaboration.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "research_programme:https://www.museumofone.art/research-methods/", "value": { "title": "Phenomenological Methods and Diagnostic Reading", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-methods/", "status": "Continuing research", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "relation": "Earlier theoretical foundation for methodological investigation.", "relation_label": "Earlier theoretical foundation for methodological investigation." }, "status": "institutional_work_relationship", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "note": "Programme relationship and stage follow the work-specific institutional badge; publication does not imply a completed programme or collaboration.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "entity_link:dorian-vale:author", "value": { "id": "dorian-vale", "label": "Dorian Vale", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "author", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author.", "variants": [ "Vale, Dorian" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:3bd40f6440eb63034377e3d23be3b003153cfd9e815dd6ac9d74eb5359ab4463", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19864099.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." } }, { "field": "entity_link:museum-of-one:publisher", "value": { "id": "museum-of-one", "label": "Museum of One", "entity_type": "Organization", "relation": "publisher", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record.", "variants": [ "MuseumofOne", "MUSEUM OF ONE" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:d1ca756bc59a8357de71cb33c4cd56172c202222c4b7dde049b6bab8105ce4e1", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19864099.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." } }, { "field": "contents", "value": [ { "title": "Preface", "type": "Preface", "pdf_start": 6, "pdf_end": 7, "printed_start": "iv", "printed_end": "v", "id": "c001", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 6, 7 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 6; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864099", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864099", "reference": "MOO-CAT-001/C001", "url": "parts/19864099-c001.html", "reader_url": "read/19864099.html#page=6", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "page_count": 82, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 1, "title": "Post-Interpretive Criticism: A Doctrine of Restraint, Witness, and Moral Proximity in Contemporary Art Writing", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 9, "printed_start": "1", "id": "c002", "pdf_end": 15, "printed_end": "7", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 9, 15 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 9; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864099", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864099", "reference": "MOO-CAT-001/C002", "url": "parts/19864099-c002.html", "reader_url": "read/19864099.html#page=9", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "page_count": 82, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 2, "title": "A Philosophical Departure from Post-Criticism", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 16, "printed_start": "8", "id": "c003", "pdf_end": 21, "printed_end": "13", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 16, 21 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 16; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864099", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864099", "reference": "MOO-CAT-001/C003", "url": "parts/19864099-c003.html", "reader_url": "read/19864099.html#page=16", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "page_count": 82, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 3, "title": "Art as Truth: A Treatise", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 22, "printed_start": "14", "id": "c004", "pdf_end": 27, "printed_end": "19", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 22, 27 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 22; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864099", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864099", "reference": "MOO-CAT-001/C004", "url": "parts/19864099-c004.html", "reader_url": "read/19864099.html#page=22", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "page_count": 82, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 4, "title": "Stillmark Theory: A Treatise on Presence, Vanishing, and the Discipline of the Fleeting", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 28, "printed_start": "20", "id": "c005", "pdf_end": 34, "printed_end": "26", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 28, 34 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 28; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864099", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864099", "reference": "MOO-CAT-001/C005", "url": "parts/19864099-c005.html", "reader_url": "read/19864099.html#page=28", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "page_count": 82, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 5, "title": "Absential Aesthetics Theory: On Ghosts, Absence, and the Afterlife of Art", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 35, "printed_start": "27", "id": "c006", "pdf_end": 39, "printed_end": "31", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 35, 39 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 35; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864099", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864099", "reference": "MOO-CAT-001/C006", "url": "parts/19864099-c006.html", "reader_url": "read/19864099.html#page=35", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "page_count": 82, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 6, "title": "Hauntmark Theory: The Lingering Weight of Words", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 40, "printed_start": "32", "id": "c007", "pdf_end": 46, "printed_end": "38", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 40, 46 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 40; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864099", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864099", "reference": "MOO-CAT-001/C007", "url": "parts/19864099-c007.html", "reader_url": "read/19864099.html#page=40", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "page_count": 82, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 7, "title": "Language as a Blade: The Ethics of Precision in Post-Interpretive Criticism", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 47, "printed_start": "39", "id": "c008", "pdf_end": 53, "printed_end": "45", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 47, 53 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 47; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864099", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864099", "reference": "MOO-CAT-001/C008", "url": "parts/19864099-c008.html", "reader_url": "read/19864099.html#page=47", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "page_count": 82, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 8, "title": "Message Transfer Theory (MTT): A Treatise on the Reversal of Meaning, the Displacement of Intent, and the Object as Conduit", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 54, "printed_start": "46", "id": "c009", "pdf_end": 60, "printed_end": "52", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 54, 60 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 54; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864099", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864099", "reference": "MOO-CAT-001/C009", "url": "parts/19864099-c009.html", "reader_url": "read/19864099.html#page=54", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "page_count": 82, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 9, "title": "The Viewer as Evidence: A Treatise on Witness, Residue, and Critical Consequence", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 61, "printed_start": "53", "id": "c010", "pdf_end": 69, "printed_end": "61", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 61, 69 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 61; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864099", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864099", "reference": "MOO-CAT-001/C010", "url": "parts/19864099-c010.html", "reader_url": "read/19864099.html#page=61", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "page_count": 82, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 10, "title": "Theory of Aesthetic Displacement: A Treatise on Witness, Alteration, and the Irreversible Encounter", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 70, "printed_start": "62", "id": "c011", "pdf_end": 73, "printed_end": "65", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 70, 73 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 70; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864099", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864099", "reference": "MOO-CAT-001/C011", "url": "parts/19864099-c011.html", "reader_url": "read/19864099.html#page=70", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "page_count": 82, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 11, "title": "The Theory of Misplacement", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 74, "printed_start": "66", "id": "c012", "pdf_end": 78, "printed_end": "70", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 74, 78 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 74; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864099", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864099", "reference": "MOO-CAT-001/C012", "url": "parts/19864099-c012.html", "reader_url": "read/19864099.html#page=74", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "page_count": 82, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 12, "title": "The Archive as Movement", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 79, "printed_start": "71", "id": "c013", "pdf_end": 80, "printed_end": "72", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 79, 80 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 79; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864099", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864099", "reference": "MOO-CAT-001/C013", "url": "parts/19864099-c013.html", "reader_url": "read/19864099.html#page=79", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "page_count": 82, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "title": "About the Author", "type": "Biographical note", "pdf_start": 81, "printed_start": "73", "id": "c014", "pdf_end": 81, "printed_end": "73", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 81, 81 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 81; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864099", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864099", "reference": "MOO-CAT-001/C014", "url": "parts/19864099-c014.html", "reader_url": "read/19864099.html#page=81", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "page_count": 82, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19864099/files/post-interprative-criticism-volume-i-STANDARD.pdf/content", "status": "derived_file_inspection", "note": "Analytic descriptions were checked against headings and pagination in the deposited PDF. Component records do not have independent deposits or DOIs." }, { "field": "controlled_subjects", "value": [ { "id": "post-interpretive-criticism", "label": "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#post-interpretive-criticism", "url": "vocabulary.html#post-interpretive-criticism", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:post-interpretive-criticism", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "PIC", "Post Interpretive Criticism" ], "definition": "The critical framework named and developed in the Museum of One publications.", "scope_note": "Local named intellectual framework. Used for records explicitly concerned with it; no Getty, Library of Congress, or other external equivalence is asserted.", "kind": "local-framework-concept", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "custodianship", "ethics-of-witnessing", "foundational-writings", "moral-proximity" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "aesthetics", "label": "Aesthetics", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#aesthetics", "url": "vocabulary.html#aesthetics", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:aesthetics", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Philosophical inquiry into art, perception, and aesthetic experience.", "scope_note": "Used as a broad disciplinary access term; no external vocabulary equivalence is asserted.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [ "aesthetic-theory" ], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "art-criticism", "label": "Art criticism", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#art-criticism", "url": "vocabulary.html#art-criticism", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:art-criticism", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Art Criticism" ], "definition": "Critical examination and discussion of artworks and encounters with art.", "scope_note": "Use for publications addressing criticism as a practice, method, or ethical responsibility.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "art-writing", "interpretation" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "foundational-writings", "label": "Foundational writings", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#foundational-writings", "url": "vocabulary.html#foundational-writings", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:foundational-writings", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Writings presented within the corpus as introducing its foundational propositions.", "scope_note": "Local editorial grouping for discovery; does not confer institutional canonisation or external recognition.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "post-interpretive-criticism" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Local preferred terms with definitions and synonyms. External alignment is scoped in the vocabulary register." }, { "field": "genre_terms", "value": [ { "id": "genre-book", "label": "Book", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#genre-book", "url": "vocabulary.html#genre-book", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:genre-book", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Books", "Digital book" ], "definition": "Book-length publication represented by a deposited digital edition.", "scope_note": "Describes publication genre. The local PDF is not being described as a physical bound volume.", "kind": "genre", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "verified_mapping", "external_mappings": [ { "vocabulary": "Getty Art & Architecture Thesaurus", "label": "books", "uri": "http://vocab.getty.edu/aat/300028051", "source_url": "https://vocab.getty.edu/page/aat/300028051", "relation": "relatedMatch", "status": "verified", "verified_on": "2026-11-04", "note": "Getty’s concept concerns bound physical volumes. It is a related form reference for this digital-publication genre, not an exact equivalence or physical-holdings assertion." } ], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "type", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Local resource-genre classification. Digital file format is recorded separately." }, { "field": "archival_context", "value": { "description_profile": "moo-description-policy-1.0", "catalogue_snapshot_date": "2026-11-04", "snapshot_note": "Selected catalogue snapshot; not a live repository synchronisation.", "record_category": "Published library and repository material", "reference_code_status": "Stable local catalogue reference; not evidence of an archival acquisition or a previous catalogue accession.", "source_repository": { "name": "Zenodo", "record_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864099" }, "institutional_context_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "source_metadata_retrieved": "2026-11-04", "source_metadata_retrieval_status": "Documented in catalogue source provenance", "source_snapshot": "source/19864099.json", "source_filenames": [ "post-interprative-criticism-volume-i-STANDARD.pdf" ], "selection_basis": "Local descriptive selection of publicly published material; public availability does not establish ownership of originals.", "custodial_history": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No donation, physical transfer, acquisition agreement or chain of custody is documented by this catalogue. Zenodo remains the source repository for the deposited version." }, "original_order": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No original archival order is asserted. Current browsing groupings are local editorial arrangement." }, "arrangement": { "status": "local_editorial", "grouping": "Books & volumes", "statement": "A browsing grouping, not an original fonds or archival series." }, "responsible_service": { "name": "Museum of One", "service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "website": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "email": "research@museumofone.art" }, "description_method": "Source-based description with automated drafting and metadata assistance. Responsibility for the public catalogue rests with Museum of One; automated assistance does not constitute independent scholarly or curatorial review.", "policy_url": "policies.html", "correction_email": "research@museumofone.art", "access_copy": { "role": "Local digital reading copy of the deposited file", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19864099/files/post-interprative-criticism-volume-i-STANDARD.pdf/content", "source_filename": "post-interprative-criticism-volume-i-STANDARD.pdf", "local_path": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "source_checksum_match": true, "sha256": "cff270ffc96c98812c0ab708cd159c2c34cbd43f13f378696802a7f2a939ac3d", "statement": "Access copy only; no ownership or physical custody transfer is implied." } }, "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Provenance records what is documented and leaves unknown custody and original order explicit." }, { "field": "description_history", "value": [ { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Source-based catalogue description", "note": "Local description assembled from the identified public repository record and available institutional work record. Source metadata remains separately identifiable.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/19864099", "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Qualified descriptive enrichment", "note": "Local editorial description, arrangement and source-qualified bibliographic context recorded alongside source metadata. Unknown or disputed values remain qualified.", "fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/19864099", "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Automated file checksum and PDF inspection", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Digital reading copy verified", "note": "Downloaded access-copy MD5 matched the source checksum; local SHA-256 and PDF file-page count are recorded in the file manifest. This event does not describe transfer of custody.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19864099/files/post-interprative-criticism-volume-i-STANDARD.pdf/content" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Description policy and provenance context adopted", "note": "Responsible service, source repository, local access-copy role, unknown custody and original order, correction route and dated description history made explicit under moo-description-policy-1.0.", "sources": [ "policies.html" ] }, { "event_id": "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Unify graph identities and qualify exported relationships and citations", "note": "Local graph projection now uses one contextual identity per entity, distinguishes work-level institutional matches from selected-edition links, retains title-level ISBN uncertainty, and derives citations from the source title. Typed relation assertions and a versioned validation profile are introduced. No publication date, original source snapshot or PDF changed.", "fields": [ "metadata_profile", "relationship_assertions", "identity", "institutional_match_scope", "citation_projection" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Source-based metadata implementation and regression validation", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication, source review or acquisition date", "sources": [ "metadata/metadata-profile.json" ] }, { "event_id": "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Record inspected public ORCID profile evidence", "note": "The official ORCID public person API returned the credited name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website. This confirms a matching public profile, not independently verified biographical or affiliation claims. Original creator arrays and source snapshots are unchanged.", "fields": [ "orcid_authority" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Read-only official public API inspection", "date_kind": "Local authority review and catalogue description event; not a publication or original creation date", "sources": [ "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ] } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Catalogue description events; these are not work publication dates or acquisition dates." }, { "field": "pirr_references", "value": [ { "programme_key": "research-intellectual-history", "programme_title": "Intellectual History and Conceptual Development", "programme_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-intellectual-history/", "programme_stage": "Continuing research", "registry_url": "research-registry.html#research-intellectual-history", "identifiers": [ { "scheme": "PIRR project ID", "value": "pir-prj-xgd6wb9d", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-intellectual-history/#programme-record" } ], "relation": "Earlier foundation examined by this programme.", "relation_note": "Earlier foundation examined by this programme.", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/" }, { "programme_key": "research-methods", "programme_title": "Phenomenological Methods and Diagnostic Reading", "programme_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-methods/", "programme_stage": "Continuing research", "registry_url": "research-registry.html#research-methods", "identifiers": [ { "scheme": "PIRR project ID", "value": "pir-prj-pyp5yx3w", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-methods/#programme-record" } ], "relation": "Earlier theoretical foundation for methodological investigation.", "relation_note": "Earlier theoretical foundation for methodological investigation.", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/" } ], "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "PIRR project IDs and programme references identify research records, not publication versions or independent chapter deposits." }, { "field": "relationship_assertions", "value": [ { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:3bd40f6440eb63034377e3d23be3b003153cfd9e815dd6ac9d74eb5359ab4463", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19864099.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:d1ca756bc59a8357de71cb33c4cd56172c202222c4b7dde049b6bab8105ce4e1", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19864099.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:7e93b90b240a3e2d48ae646fa6a1b79104be33a97e6eef058be5ef94178fad93", "subject": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#describes", "object": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19864099", "scope": "exact_edition", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "source_location": { "kind": "metadata_field", "field": "linked_zenodo_dois", "values": [ "10.5281/zenodo.19864099" ] }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "Exact-edition matching requires the selected DOI in the reviewed page metadata; other matches retain their wider scope." } ], "status": "typed_evidence_projection", "note": "Stable, typed assertions retain source scope and explicit unknown review metadata." }, { "field": "reading_copy", "value": { "id": "19864099", "title": "Post-Interpretive Criticism: Volume I - The Foundational Essays", "accession": "MOO-CAT-001", "pdf_url": "../assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19864099/files/post-interprative-criticism-volume-i-STANDARD.pdf/content", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864099", "source_filename": "post-interprative-criticism-volume-i-STANDARD.pdf", "checksum": "md5:2cbd120db1c6358cb65702d5090d042a", "sha256": "cff270ffc96c98812c0ab708cd159c2c34cbd43f13f378696802a7f2a939ac3d", "bytes": 1044796, "page_count": 82, "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "checksum_match": true, "rights": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "role": "Local reading copy; original repository file retained unchanged" }, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19864099/files/post-interprative-criticism-volume-i-STANDARD.pdf/content", "status": "derived_file_inspection", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "note": "Byte-identical local access copy. Source MD5 was recomputed and matched; SHA-256 and page count were measured from the downloaded PDF. This is not a preservation-deposit claim." }, { "field": "page_count", "value": 82, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19864099/files/post-interprative-criticism-volume-i-STANDARD.pdf/content", "status": "derived_file_inspection", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "note": "Total PDF file pages measured from the deposited file, including cover and unnumbered pages. Not a claim about printed pagination." } ], "entity_links": [ { "id": "dorian-vale", "label": "Dorian Vale", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "author", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author.", "variants": [ "Vale, Dorian" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "museum-of-one", "label": "Museum of One", "entity_type": "Organization", "relation": "publisher", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record.", "variants": [ "MuseumofOne", "MUSEUM OF ONE" ], "evidence_scope": "work" } ], "contents": [ { "title": "Preface", "type": "Preface", "pdf_start": 6, "pdf_end": 7, "printed_start": "iv", "printed_end": "v", "id": "c001", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 6, 7 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 6; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864099", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864099", "reference": "MOO-CAT-001/C001", "url": "parts/19864099-c001.html", "reader_url": "read/19864099.html#page=6", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "page_count": 82, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 1, "title": "Post-Interpretive Criticism: A Doctrine of Restraint, Witness, and Moral Proximity in Contemporary Art Writing", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 9, "printed_start": "1", "id": "c002", "pdf_end": 15, "printed_end": "7", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 9, 15 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 9; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864099", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864099", "reference": "MOO-CAT-001/C002", "url": "parts/19864099-c002.html", "reader_url": "read/19864099.html#page=9", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "page_count": 82, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 2, "title": "A Philosophical Departure from Post-Criticism", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 16, "printed_start": "8", "id": "c003", "pdf_end": 21, "printed_end": "13", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 16, 21 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 16; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864099", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864099", "reference": "MOO-CAT-001/C003", "url": "parts/19864099-c003.html", "reader_url": "read/19864099.html#page=16", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "page_count": 82, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 3, "title": "Art as Truth: A Treatise", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 22, "printed_start": "14", "id": "c004", "pdf_end": 27, "printed_end": "19", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 22, 27 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 22; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864099", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864099", "reference": "MOO-CAT-001/C004", "url": "parts/19864099-c004.html", "reader_url": "read/19864099.html#page=22", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "page_count": 82, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 4, "title": "Stillmark Theory: A Treatise on Presence, Vanishing, and the Discipline of the Fleeting", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 28, "printed_start": "20", "id": "c005", "pdf_end": 34, "printed_end": "26", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 28, 34 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 28; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864099", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864099", "reference": "MOO-CAT-001/C005", "url": "parts/19864099-c005.html", "reader_url": "read/19864099.html#page=28", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "page_count": 82, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 5, "title": "Absential Aesthetics Theory: On Ghosts, Absence, and the Afterlife of Art", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 35, "printed_start": "27", "id": "c006", "pdf_end": 39, "printed_end": "31", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 35, 39 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 35; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864099", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864099", "reference": "MOO-CAT-001/C006", "url": "parts/19864099-c006.html", "reader_url": "read/19864099.html#page=35", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "page_count": 82, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 6, "title": "Hauntmark Theory: The Lingering Weight of Words", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 40, "printed_start": "32", "id": "c007", "pdf_end": 46, "printed_end": "38", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 40, 46 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 40; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864099", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864099", "reference": "MOO-CAT-001/C007", "url": "parts/19864099-c007.html", "reader_url": "read/19864099.html#page=40", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "page_count": 82, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 7, "title": "Language as a Blade: The Ethics of Precision in Post-Interpretive Criticism", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 47, "printed_start": "39", "id": "c008", "pdf_end": 53, "printed_end": "45", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 47, 53 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 47; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864099", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864099", "reference": "MOO-CAT-001/C008", "url": "parts/19864099-c008.html", "reader_url": "read/19864099.html#page=47", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "page_count": 82, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 8, "title": "Message Transfer Theory (MTT): A Treatise on the Reversal of Meaning, the Displacement of Intent, and the Object as Conduit", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 54, "printed_start": "46", "id": "c009", "pdf_end": 60, "printed_end": "52", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 54, 60 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 54; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864099", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864099", "reference": "MOO-CAT-001/C009", "url": "parts/19864099-c009.html", "reader_url": "read/19864099.html#page=54", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "page_count": 82, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 9, "title": "The Viewer as Evidence: A Treatise on Witness, Residue, and Critical Consequence", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 61, "printed_start": "53", "id": "c010", "pdf_end": 69, "printed_end": "61", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 61, 69 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 61; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864099", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864099", "reference": "MOO-CAT-001/C010", "url": "parts/19864099-c010.html", "reader_url": "read/19864099.html#page=61", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "page_count": 82, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 10, "title": "Theory of Aesthetic Displacement: A Treatise on Witness, Alteration, and the Irreversible Encounter", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 70, "printed_start": "62", "id": "c011", "pdf_end": 73, "printed_end": "65", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 70, 73 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 70; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864099", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864099", "reference": "MOO-CAT-001/C011", "url": "parts/19864099-c011.html", "reader_url": "read/19864099.html#page=70", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "page_count": 82, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 11, "title": "The Theory of Misplacement", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 74, "printed_start": "66", "id": "c012", "pdf_end": 78, "printed_end": "70", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 74, 78 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 74; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864099", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864099", "reference": "MOO-CAT-001/C012", "url": "parts/19864099-c012.html", "reader_url": "read/19864099.html#page=74", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "page_count": 82, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 12, "title": "The Archive as Movement", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 79, "printed_start": "71", "id": "c013", "pdf_end": 80, "printed_end": "72", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 79, 80 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 79; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864099", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864099", "reference": "MOO-CAT-001/C013", "url": "parts/19864099-c013.html", "reader_url": "read/19864099.html#page=79", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "page_count": 82, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "title": "About the Author", "type": "Biographical note", "pdf_start": 81, "printed_start": "73", "id": "c014", "pdf_end": 81, "printed_end": "73", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 81, 81 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 81; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864099", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864099", "reference": "MOO-CAT-001/C014", "url": "parts/19864099-c014.html", "reader_url": "read/19864099.html#page=81", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "page_count": 82, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "controlled_subjects": [ { "id": "post-interpretive-criticism", "label": "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#post-interpretive-criticism", "url": "vocabulary.html#post-interpretive-criticism", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:post-interpretive-criticism", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "PIC", "Post Interpretive Criticism" ], "definition": "The critical framework named and developed in the Museum of One publications.", "scope_note": "Local named intellectual framework. Used for records explicitly concerned with it; no Getty, Library of Congress, or other external equivalence is asserted.", "kind": "local-framework-concept", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "custodianship", "ethics-of-witnessing", "foundational-writings", "moral-proximity" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "aesthetics", "label": "Aesthetics", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#aesthetics", "url": "vocabulary.html#aesthetics", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:aesthetics", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Philosophical inquiry into art, perception, and aesthetic experience.", "scope_note": "Used as a broad disciplinary access term; no external vocabulary equivalence is asserted.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [ "aesthetic-theory" ], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "art-criticism", "label": "Art criticism", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#art-criticism", "url": "vocabulary.html#art-criticism", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:art-criticism", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Art Criticism" ], "definition": "Critical examination and discussion of artworks and encounters with art.", "scope_note": "Use for publications addressing criticism as a practice, method, or ethical responsibility.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "art-writing", "interpretation" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "foundational-writings", "label": "Foundational writings", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#foundational-writings", "url": "vocabulary.html#foundational-writings", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:foundational-writings", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Writings presented within the corpus as introducing its foundational propositions.", "scope_note": "Local editorial grouping for discovery; does not confer institutional canonisation or external recognition.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "post-interpretive-criticism" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "genre_terms": [ { "id": "genre-book", "label": "Book", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#genre-book", "url": "vocabulary.html#genre-book", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:genre-book", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Books", "Digital book" ], "definition": "Book-length publication represented by a deposited digital edition.", "scope_note": "Describes publication genre. The local PDF is not being described as a physical bound volume.", "kind": "genre", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "verified_mapping", "external_mappings": [ { "vocabulary": "Getty Art & Architecture Thesaurus", "label": "books", "uri": "http://vocab.getty.edu/aat/300028051", "source_url": "https://vocab.getty.edu/page/aat/300028051", "relation": "relatedMatch", "status": "verified", "verified_on": "2026-11-04", "note": "Getty’s concept concerns bound physical volumes. It is a related form reference for this digital-publication genre, not an exact equivalence or physical-holdings assertion." } ], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "type", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "vocabulary_version": 4, "description_history": [ { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Source-based catalogue description", "note": "Local description assembled from the identified public repository record and available institutional work record. Source metadata remains separately identifiable.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/19864099", "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Qualified descriptive enrichment", "note": "Local editorial description, arrangement and source-qualified bibliographic context recorded alongside source metadata. Unknown or disputed values remain qualified.", "fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/19864099", "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Automated file checksum and PDF inspection", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Digital reading copy verified", "note": "Downloaded access-copy MD5 matched the source checksum; local SHA-256 and PDF file-page count are recorded in the file manifest. This event does not describe transfer of custody.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19864099/files/post-interprative-criticism-volume-i-STANDARD.pdf/content" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Description policy and provenance context adopted", "note": "Responsible service, source repository, local access-copy role, unknown custody and original order, correction route and dated description history made explicit under moo-description-policy-1.0.", "sources": [ "policies.html" ] }, { "event_id": "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Unify graph identities and qualify exported relationships and citations", "note": "Local graph projection now uses one contextual identity per entity, distinguishes work-level institutional matches from selected-edition links, retains title-level ISBN uncertainty, and derives citations from the source title. Typed relation assertions and a versioned validation profile are introduced. No publication date, original source snapshot or PDF changed.", "fields": [ "metadata_profile", "relationship_assertions", "identity", "institutional_match_scope", "citation_projection" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Source-based metadata implementation and regression validation", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication, source review or acquisition date", "sources": [ "metadata/metadata-profile.json" ] }, { "event_id": "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Record inspected public ORCID profile evidence", "note": "The official ORCID public person API returned the credited name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website. This confirms a matching public profile, not independently verified biographical or affiliation claims. Original creator arrays and source snapshots are unchanged.", "fields": [ "orcid_authority" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Read-only official public API inspection", "date_kind": "Local authority review and catalogue description event; not a publication or original creation date", "sources": [ "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ] } ], "record_modified": "2026-11-04", "record_modified_provenance": { "status": "derived_from_description_history", "event_ids": [ "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04" ], "note": "Latest documented local description event; not a publication, repository or source-review date." }, "archival_context": { "description_profile": "moo-description-policy-1.0", "catalogue_snapshot_date": "2026-11-04", "snapshot_note": "Selected catalogue snapshot; not a live repository synchronisation.", "record_category": "Published library and repository material", "reference_code_status": "Stable local catalogue reference; not evidence of an archival acquisition or a previous catalogue accession.", "source_repository": { "name": "Zenodo", "record_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864099" }, "institutional_context_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "source_metadata_retrieved": "2026-11-04", "source_metadata_retrieval_status": "Documented in catalogue source provenance", "source_snapshot": "source/19864099.json", "source_filenames": [ "post-interprative-criticism-volume-i-STANDARD.pdf" ], "selection_basis": "Local descriptive selection of publicly published material; public availability does not establish ownership of originals.", "custodial_history": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No donation, physical transfer, acquisition agreement or chain of custody is documented by this catalogue. Zenodo remains the source repository for the deposited version." }, "original_order": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No original archival order is asserted. Current browsing groupings are local editorial arrangement." }, "arrangement": { "status": "local_editorial", "grouping": "Books & volumes", "statement": "A browsing grouping, not an original fonds or archival series." }, "responsible_service": { "name": "Museum of One", "service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "website": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "email": "research@museumofone.art" }, "description_method": "Source-based description with automated drafting and metadata assistance. Responsibility for the public catalogue rests with Museum of One; automated assistance does not constitute independent scholarly or curatorial review.", "policy_url": "policies.html", "correction_email": "research@museumofone.art", "access_copy": { "role": "Local digital reading copy of the deposited file", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19864099/files/post-interprative-criticism-volume-i-STANDARD.pdf/content", "source_filename": "post-interprative-criticism-volume-i-STANDARD.pdf", "local_path": "assets/documents/19864099.pdf", "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "source_checksum_match": true, "sha256": "cff270ffc96c98812c0ab708cd159c2c34cbd43f13f378696802a7f2a939ac3d", "statement": "Access copy only; no ownership or physical custody transfer is implied." } }, "description_policy_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "pirr_references": [ { "programme_key": "research-intellectual-history", "programme_title": "Intellectual History and Conceptual Development", "programme_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-intellectual-history/", "programme_stage": "Continuing research", "registry_url": "research-registry.html#research-intellectual-history", "identifiers": [ { "scheme": "PIRR project ID", "value": "pir-prj-xgd6wb9d", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-intellectual-history/#programme-record" } ], "relation": "Earlier foundation examined by this programme.", "relation_note": "Earlier foundation examined by this programme.", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/" }, { "programme_key": "research-methods", "programme_title": "Phenomenological Methods and Diagnostic Reading", "programme_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-methods/", "programme_stage": "Continuing research", "registry_url": "research-registry.html#research-methods", "identifiers": [ { "scheme": "PIRR project ID", "value": "pir-prj-pyp5yx3w", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-methods/#programme-record" } ], "relation": "Earlier theoretical foundation for methodological investigation.", "relation_note": "Earlier theoretical foundation for methodological investigation.", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/" } ], "pirr_work_identity": { "archive_reference": "MOO-CAT-001", "edition_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864099", "zenodo_record_id": "19864099", "identifier_scope": "Publication identity; PIRR identifiers in programme relationships identify research records, not this publication." }, "metadata_origin": "https://archive.museumofone.art", "identity": { "work": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19864099.html#work", "edition": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19864099", "version_family": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17058411", "catalogue_record": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19864099.html#catalogue-record" }, "institutional_match_scope": "exact_edition", "relationship_assertions": [ { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:3bd40f6440eb63034377e3d23be3b003153cfd9e815dd6ac9d74eb5359ab4463", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19864099.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:d1ca756bc59a8357de71cb33c4cd56172c202222c4b7dde049b6bab8105ce4e1", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19864099.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:7e93b90b240a3e2d48ae646fa6a1b79104be33a97e6eef058be5ef94178fad93", "subject": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#describes", "object": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19864099", "scope": "exact_edition", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-foundational-essays/", "source_location": { "kind": "metadata_field", "field": "linked_zenodo_dois", "values": [ "10.5281/zenodo.19864099" ] }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "Exact-edition matching requires the selected DOI in the reviewed page metadata; other matches retain their wider scope." } ], "orcid_authority": { "scheme": "ORCID", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "evidence_urls": [ "https://www.museumofone.art/archives-scholarly-infrastructure/", "https://eprints.rclis.org/47182/", "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ], "access_note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "evidence_receipt": "data/source/authority-review-2026-11-04.json" } }, { "id": "19864115", "accession": "MOO-CAT-002", "title": "Post-Interpretive Criticism: Volume II — Essays from the Field", "source_title": "Post-Interpretive Criticism: Volume II — Essays from the Field", "short_title": "Volume II — Essays from the Field", "author": "Dorian Vale", "creators": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "affiliation": "MuseumofOne", "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094" } ], "doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864115", "conceptdoi": "10.5281/zenodo.17078846", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864115", "date": "2025", "type": "Book", "source_resource_type": { "title": "Book", "type": "publication", "subtype": "book" }, "version": "", "collection": "Books & volumes", "summary": "A collection connecting Post-Interpretive Criticism with encounters with artworks and practical exercises in viewing and writing. The deposited description distinguishes canonical essays from pedagogical texts.", "subjects": [ "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Art criticism", "Witnessing", "Pedagogy" ], "keywords": [ "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "art criticism", "aesthetics", "ethics of witnessing", "moral proximity", "restraint", "contemporary art" ], "license": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "files": [ { "name": "post-interpretive-criticism-volume-ii-STANDARD.pdf", "url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19864115/files/post-interpretive-criticism-volume-ii-STANDARD.pdf/content", "size": 2610097, "size_label": "2549 KB", "checksum": "md5:9487d0fc48e7afdfb960fc328d8e4881", "mimetype": "application/pdf" } ], "institutional_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "corroboration": "Museum of One’s matching publication page confirms Dorian Vale’s authorship and the work’s institutional context. It links the selected Zenodo edition DOI. Web-record dates are not treated as dates of the deposited edition. Source review: 4 November 2026.", "discrepancies": [], "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "publisher": "Museum of One", "language": null, "isbn": "978-1-06-982031-0", "related_identifiers": [ { "identifier": "10.5281/zenodo.17058411", "relation": "continues", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "2819-7232", "relation": "isPartOf", "scheme": "issn" } ], "alternate_identifiers": [ { "identifier": "978-1-06-982031-0" } ], "source_references": [], "source_journal": null, "source_imprint": {}, "source_contributors": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "affiliation": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "type": "RightsHolder" }, { "name": "Museum of One", "affiliation": null, "type": "HostingInstitution" } ], "source_created": "2026-04-28T19:19:00.113516+00:00", "source_modified": "2026-10-15T12:15:14.061006+00:00", "source_description_html": "

Post-Interpretive Criticism: Volume II — Essays from the Field continues the formal articulation of a new movement in contemporary art thought: one rooted not in interpretation, but in presence. As the second major volume by Dorian Vale, this collection gathers eight pivotal essays that apply and expand the doctrines of Post-Interpretive Criticism (PIC)—a philosophical and aesthetic framework grounded in restraint, moral proximity, and the ethics of witnessing.

\n

Divided into two sections, the book offers:

\n\n

Together, these writings mark the maturation of a critical movement that refuses sensationalism, values silence, and honors the unspoken. This volume cements Dorian Vale’s position not only as the founder of Post-Interpretive Criticism, but as a leading voice in rethinking what it means to encounter art—not to explain it, but to stand beside it.

\n

 

\n

Vale, Dorian. Post-Interpretive Criticism: Volume II — Essays from the Field. Museum of One, 2025. DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17078846

\n

 

\n

First published by Museum of One in 2025. Stable work DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17078846

", "provenance": { "repository": "Zenodo REST API response supplied in query.json", "retrieved": "2026-11-04", "editorial_fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "source_snapshot": "source/19864115.json", "institutional_review": "Reviewed page-level title, author and repository links in saved public institutional HTML, 2026-11-04." }, "cover": "assets/essays-from-field.webp", "cover_alt": "Published cover of Post-Interpretive Criticism: Volume II — Essays from the Field", "cover_source": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "source_review": "2026-11-04", "relations": [ { "identifier": "10.5281/zenodo.17058411", "relation": "continues", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "2819-7232", "relation": "isPartOf", "scheme": "issn" } ], "first_edition": "First edition; institutional publication date 2025", "institutional_metadata": { "title": "Essays from the Field", "author": "Dorian Vale", "web_publication": "2026-10-14T00:00:00.000Z", "web_updated": "2026-10-18T23:36:15.000Z", "linked_zenodo_dois": [ "10.5281/zenodo.19864115" ], "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "publication_title": "Post-Interpretive Criticism: Volume II - Essays from the Field", "publication_status": "Published book, Volume II; first edition, 2025", "publication_date": "2025", "edition": "First edition" }, "research_programmes": [ { "title": "Witness, Material Presence, and Cultural Memory", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/", "status": "Continuing research", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "relation": "Published collection associated with the continuing inquiry.", "relation_label": "Published collection associated with the continuing inquiry." } ], "edition_statement": "First edition, 2025; selected repository release April 2026 (Museum of One publication record)", "record_level": "Item", "record_status": "Published source; selected catalogue record", "digital_formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "extent": "1 digital file; 2610097 bytes", "medium": "Digital document", "record_reviewed": "2026-11-04", "date_precision": "year", "alternate_titles": [ { "title": "Essays from the Field", "kind": "institutional_web_record_title", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/" }, { "title": "Post-Interpretive Criticism: Volume II - Essays from the Field", "kind": "institutional_publication_title", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/" } ], "digital_extent": { "file_count": 1, "total_bytes": 2610097, "formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "checksums": [ { "filename": "post-interpretive-criticism-volume-ii-STANDARD.pdf", "algorithm": "md5", "value": "9487d0fc48e7afdfb960fc328d8e4881", "syntax_valid": true, "verification": "source_checksum_transcription; bytes not independently recomputed" } ], "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864115", "derivation": "File count and total bytes calculated from repository file metadata; MIME inferred from filename when absent." }, "identifier_validation": { "orcid": { "source_value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "ISO 7064 MOD 11-2 checksum only; this is not a live registry verification." }, "isbn": [ { "source_value": "978-1-06-982031-0", "normalized": "9781069820310", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "Checksum validation tests the identifier syntax only; it does not verify assignment, format or edition applicability.", "scope": "title_level_book_identifier; format applicability follows edition source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864115" } ], "doi": { "source_value": "10.5281/zenodo.19864115", "syntax_valid": true, "note": "Syntax check only; repository snapshot supplies the identifier." }, "issn": { "source_value": "2819-7232", "checksum_valid": true, "scope": "serial identifier, not item DOI or ISBN", "note": "Checksum only; source relationship and authority-record status are documented separately." } }, "isbn_applicability": "title_level_book_identifier", "serial": { "title": "Post-interpretive criticism", "issn": "2819-7232", "url": "https://portal.issn.org/resource/ISSN/2819-7232", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864115", "source_relation": "isPartOf", "authority_status": "independent_authority_record_metadata_observed_in_search_index" }, "contributor_roles": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": "MuseumofOne", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864115" }, { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "source_category": "contributor", "source_role": "RightsHolder", "role_label": "RightsHolder", "affiliation_as_supplied": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864115" }, { "name": "Museum of One", "source_category": "contributor", "source_role": "HostingInstitution", "role_label": "HostingInstitution", "affiliation_as_supplied": null, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864115" } ], "authority_links": [ { "title": "BiblioBoard catalogue access", "url": "https://library.biblioboard.com/content/3df5b09d-767c-4f3a-9adb-7d0c619b55b1", "kind": "catalogue_access", "status": "institutional_link_access_restricted", "note": "Institution verifies title; format, edition and ISBN not independently inspectable.", "scope": "Bibliographic context; inspect source for edition applicability", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/post-interpretive-criticism-volume-ii-essays-from-the-field/" }, { "title": "Knowledge Commons repository record", "url": "https://works.hcommons.org/records/9vm5z-cyq62", "kind": "repository_record", "status": "institutional_source_link_not_independently_inspected", "evidence_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/archives-scholarly-infrastructure/", "scope": "Bibliographic context; inspect source for edition applicability", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/archives-scholarly-infrastructure/" } ], "metadata_profile": { "name": "Museum of One source-qualified catalogue profile", "version": "3.0.0", "url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/metadata-profile.json", "source_snapshot_preserved": true }, "reading_copy": { "id": "19864115", "title": "Post-Interpretive Criticism: Volume II — Essays from the Field", "accession": "MOO-CAT-002", "pdf_url": "../assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19864115/files/post-interpretive-criticism-volume-ii-STANDARD.pdf/content", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864115", "source_filename": "post-interpretive-criticism-volume-ii-STANDARD.pdf", "checksum": "md5:9487d0fc48e7afdfb960fc328d8e4881", "sha256": "1ab810a867166d02b30a284db253b32e2794338a59695858385ec85a982e04ac", "bytes": 2610097, "page_count": 96, "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "checksum_match": true, "rights": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "role": "Local reading copy; original repository file retained unchanged" }, "page_count": 96, "field_assertions": [ { "field": "title", "value": "Post-Interpretive Criticism: Volume II — Essays from the Field", "status": "catalogue_title", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "note": "Local display title; the deposited title is retained separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_title", "value": "Post-Interpretive Criticism: Volume II — Essays from the Field", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864115", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "doi", "value": "10.5281/zenodo.19864115", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864115", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "date", "value": "2025", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864115", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "conceptdoi", "value": "10.5281/zenodo.17078846", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864115", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "creators", "value": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "affiliation": "MuseumofOne", "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864115", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "keywords", "value": [ "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "art criticism", "aesthetics", "ethics of witnessing", "moral proximity", "restraint", "contemporary art" ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864115", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "license", "value": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864115", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "files", "value": [ { "name": "post-interpretive-criticism-volume-ii-STANDARD.pdf", "url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19864115/files/post-interpretive-criticism-volume-ii-STANDARD.pdf/content", "size": 2610097, "size_label": "2549 KB", "checksum": "md5:9487d0fc48e7afdfb960fc328d8e4881", "mimetype": "application/pdf" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864115", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_created", "value": "2026-04-28T19:19:00.113516+00:00", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864115", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_modified", "value": "2026-10-15T12:15:14.061006+00:00", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864115", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "record_modified", "value": "2026-11-04", "status": "derived_from_description_history", "note": "Latest documented local description event; not a publication, repository or source-review date.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_review", "value": "2026-11-04", "status": "catalogue_source_review", "note": "Review of descriptive sources; not the creation or modification date of the work or repository record.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "author", "value": "Dorian Vale", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "note": "Institutional responsibility statement; original repository creator roles remain separate.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "publisher", "value": "Museum of One", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "note": "Institutional responsibility statement; original repository creator roles remain separate.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "first_edition", "value": "First edition; institutional publication date 2025", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "note": "Consult the linked edition record; a repository version is not a new book edition.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "edition_statement", "value": "First edition, 2025; selected repository release April 2026 (Museum of One publication record)", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "note": "Consult the linked edition record; a repository version is not a new book edition.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "isbn", "value": "978-1-06-982031-0", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "note": "Consult the linked edition record; a repository version is not a new book edition.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "orcid", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "source_linked_identifier", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "note": "Creator identifier supplied by the linked sources; no affiliation or endorsement is inferred.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "orcid_authority", "value": { "scheme": "ORCID", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "evidence_urls": [ "https://www.museumofone.art/archives-scholarly-infrastructure/", "https://eprints.rclis.org/47182/", "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ], "access_note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "evidence_receipt": "data/source/authority-review-2026-11-04.json" }, "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "source_url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "summary", "value": "A collection connecting Post-Interpretive Criticism with encounters with artworks and practical exercises in viewing and writing. The deposited description distinguishes canonical essays from pedagogical texts.", "status": "editorial_enrichment", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "note": "Catalogue-editor summary based on the linked work; not an original publisher abstract.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "subjects", "value": [ "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Art criticism", "Witnessing", "Pedagogy" ], "status": "editorial_enrichment", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "note": "Local discovery terms; no controlled-vocabulary assignment is claimed.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "collection", "value": "Books & volumes", "status": "editorial_grouping", "note": "A local browsing collection, not an original repository collection.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "corroboration", "value": "Museum of One’s matching publication page confirms Dorian Vale’s authorship and the work’s institutional context. It links the selected Zenodo edition DOI. Web-record dates are not treated as dates of the deposited edition. Source review: 4 November 2026.", "status": "catalogue_review_note", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "alternate_titles", "value": [ { "title": "Essays from the Field", "kind": "institutional_web_record_title", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/" }, { "title": "Post-Interpretive Criticism: Volume II - Essays from the Field", "kind": "institutional_publication_title", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/" } ], "status": "source_qualified_title_variants", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "note": "Each variant retains its own source and scope; a web page title is not a title-page transcription.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "date_precision", "value": "year", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864115", "note": "Precision reported exactly as supplied; missing month or day is not filled.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "medium", "value": "Digital document", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864115", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "digital_formats", "value": [ "application/pdf" ], "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864115", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "extent", "value": "1 digital file; 2610097 bytes", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864115", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "digital_extent", "value": { "file_count": 1, "total_bytes": 2610097, "formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "checksums": [ { "filename": "post-interpretive-criticism-volume-ii-STANDARD.pdf", "algorithm": "md5", "value": "9487d0fc48e7afdfb960fc328d8e4881", "syntax_valid": true, "verification": "source_checksum_transcription; bytes not independently recomputed" } ], "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864115", "derivation": "File count and total bytes calculated from repository file metadata; MIME inferred from filename when absent." }, "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864115", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "identifier_validation", "value": { "orcid": { "source_value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "ISO 7064 MOD 11-2 checksum only; this is not a live registry verification." }, "isbn": [ { "source_value": "978-1-06-982031-0", "normalized": "9781069820310", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "Checksum validation tests the identifier syntax only; it does not verify assignment, format or edition applicability.", "scope": "title_level_book_identifier; format applicability follows edition source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864115" } ], "doi": { "source_value": "10.5281/zenodo.19864115", "syntax_valid": true, "note": "Syntax check only; repository snapshot supplies the identifier." }, "issn": { "source_value": "2819-7232", "checksum_valid": true, "scope": "serial identifier, not item DOI or ISBN", "note": "Checksum only; source relationship and authority-record status are documented separately." } }, "status": "local_syntax_validation", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864115", "note": "Checksum/syntax validation does not verify registration, assignment or edition applicability.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "contributor_roles", "value": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": "MuseumofOne", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864115" }, { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "source_category": "contributor", "source_role": "RightsHolder", "role_label": "RightsHolder", "affiliation_as_supplied": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864115" }, { "name": "Museum of One", "source_category": "contributor", "source_role": "HostingInstitution", "role_label": "HostingInstitution", "affiliation_as_supplied": null, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864115" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864115", "note": "Creator and contributor roles are transcribed, not inferred from names or affiliations.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "serial", "value": { "title": "Post-interpretive criticism", "issn": "2819-7232", "url": "https://portal.issn.org/resource/ISSN/2819-7232", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864115", "source_relation": "isPartOf", "authority_status": "independent_authority_record_metadata_observed_in_search_index" }, "status": "source_declared_relationship", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864115", "note": "Serial context is attached only where the repository declares the ISSN relationship.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "authority_links", "value": [ { "title": "BiblioBoard catalogue access", "url": "https://library.biblioboard.com/content/3df5b09d-767c-4f3a-9adb-7d0c619b55b1", "kind": "catalogue_access", "status": "institutional_link_access_restricted", "note": "Institution verifies title; format, edition and ISBN not independently inspectable.", "scope": "Bibliographic context; inspect source for edition applicability", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/post-interpretive-criticism-volume-ii-essays-from-the-field/" }, { "title": "Knowledge Commons repository record", "url": "https://works.hcommons.org/records/9vm5z-cyq62", "kind": "repository_record", "status": "institutional_source_link_not_independently_inspected", "evidence_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/archives-scholarly-infrastructure/", "scope": "Bibliographic context; inspect source for edition applicability", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/archives-scholarly-infrastructure/" } ], "status": "source_qualified_external_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "note": "External records have separate status and edition scope; links are not endorsements or equivalence assertions.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "research_programme:https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/", "value": { "title": "Witness, Material Presence, and Cultural Memory", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/", "status": "Continuing research", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "relation": "Published collection associated with the continuing inquiry.", "relation_label": "Published collection associated with the continuing inquiry." }, "status": "institutional_work_relationship", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "note": "Programme relationship and stage follow the work-specific institutional badge; publication does not imply a completed programme or collaboration.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "entity_link:dorian-vale:author", "value": { "id": "dorian-vale", "label": "Dorian Vale", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "author", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author.", "variants": [ "Vale, Dorian" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:63fd2ad74f5a120ae03c5ad820cc084845d15d7e7cd41e630e2baa0da387b349", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19864115.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." } }, { "field": "entity_link:museum-of-one:publisher", "value": { "id": "museum-of-one", "label": "Museum of One", "entity_type": "Organization", "relation": "publisher", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record.", "variants": [ "MuseumofOne", "MUSEUM OF ONE" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:8bff333b89219130841a09fc92e44b82cd466ec471b3a78d7c049b03f5af0692", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19864115.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." } }, { "field": "contents", "value": [ { "title": "Preface", "type": "Preface", "pdf_start": 6, "pdf_end": 7, "printed_start": "iv", "printed_end": "v", "id": "c001", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 6, 7 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 6; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864115", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864115", "reference": "MOO-CAT-002/C001", "url": "parts/19864115-c001.html", "reader_url": "read/19864115.html#page=6", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "page_count": 96, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 1, "title": "The Custodian of Consequence: Reframing the Role of the Critic", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 9, "printed_start": "1", "id": "c002", "pdf_end": 15, "printed_end": "7", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 9, 15 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 9; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864115", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864115", "reference": "MOO-CAT-002/C002", "url": "parts/19864115-c002.html", "reader_url": "read/19864115.html#page=9", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "page_count": 96, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 2, "title": "Against the Compulsive Urge to Interpret", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 16, "printed_start": "8", "id": "c003", "pdf_end": 21, "printed_end": "13", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 16, 21 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 16; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864115", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864115", "reference": "MOO-CAT-002/C003", "url": "parts/19864115-c003.html", "reader_url": "read/19864115.html#page=16", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "page_count": 96, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 3, "title": "Moral Proximity: Ethics as Method in Post-Interpretive Criticism", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 22, "printed_start": "14", "id": "c004", "pdf_end": 27, "printed_end": "19", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 22, 27 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 22; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864115", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864115", "reference": "MOO-CAT-002/C004", "url": "parts/19864115-c004.html", "reader_url": "read/19864115.html#page=22", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "page_count": 96, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 4, "title": "The Afterlife of the Work: Viewer as Evidence in Post-Interpretive Criticism", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 28, "printed_start": "20", "id": "c005", "pdf_end": 41, "printed_end": "33", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 28, 41 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 28; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864115", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864115", "reference": "MOO-CAT-002/C005", "url": "parts/19864115-c005.html", "reader_url": "read/19864115.html#page=28", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "page_count": 96, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 5, "title": "Post-Interpretive Method: How to Practice Restraint in Front of a Work of Art", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 42, "printed_start": "34", "id": "c006", "pdf_end": 45, "printed_end": "37", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 42, 45 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 42; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864115", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864115", "reference": "MOO-CAT-002/C006", "url": "parts/19864115-c006.html", "reader_url": "read/19864115.html#page=42", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "page_count": 96, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 6, "title": "Witnessing vs. Interpreting – A Post-Interpretive Comparative Exercise", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 46, "printed_start": "38", "id": "c007", "pdf_end": 51, "printed_end": "43", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 46, 51 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 46; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864115", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864115", "reference": "MOO-CAT-002/C007", "url": "parts/19864115-c007.html", "reader_url": "read/19864115.html#page=46", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "page_count": 96, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 7, "title": "Language as Custody — Writing Without Harm in Post-Interpretive Criticism", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 52, "printed_start": "44", "id": "c008", "pdf_end": 55, "printed_end": "47", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 52, 55 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 52; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864115", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864115", "reference": "MOO-CAT-002/C008", "url": "parts/19864115-c008.html", "reader_url": "read/19864115.html#page=52", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "page_count": 96, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 8, "title": "Five Principles of Post-Interpretive Criticism: A Study Guide", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 56, "printed_start": "48", "id": "c009", "pdf_end": 61, "printed_end": "53", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 56, 61 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 56; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864115", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864115", "reference": "MOO-CAT-002/C009", "url": "parts/19864115-c009.html", "reader_url": "read/19864115.html#page=56", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "page_count": 96, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 9, "title": "Formal Defense of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 62, "printed_start": "54", "id": "c010", "pdf_end": 67, "printed_end": "59", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 62, 67 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 62; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864115", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864115", "reference": "MOO-CAT-002/C010", "url": "parts/19864115-c010.html", "reader_url": "read/19864115.html#page=62", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "page_count": 96, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 10, "title": "A Philosophical Departure from Post-Criticism", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 68, "printed_start": "60", "id": "c011", "pdf_end": 73, "printed_end": "65", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 68, 73 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 68; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864115", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864115", "reference": "MOO-CAT-002/C011", "url": "parts/19864115-c011.html", "reader_url": "read/19864115.html#page=68", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "page_count": 96, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 11, "title": "The First Break Since Postmodernism: The Rise of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 74, "printed_start": "66", "id": "c012", "pdf_end": 95, "printed_end": "87", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 74, 95 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 74; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864115", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864115", "reference": "MOO-CAT-002/C012", "url": "parts/19864115-c012.html", "reader_url": "read/19864115.html#page=74", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "page_count": 96, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19864115/files/post-interpretive-criticism-volume-ii-STANDARD.pdf/content", "status": "derived_file_inspection", "note": "Analytic descriptions were checked against headings and pagination in the deposited PDF. Component records do not have independent deposits or DOIs." }, { "field": "controlled_subjects", "value": [ { "id": "post-interpretive-criticism", "label": "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#post-interpretive-criticism", "url": "vocabulary.html#post-interpretive-criticism", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:post-interpretive-criticism", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "PIC", "Post Interpretive Criticism" ], "definition": "The critical framework named and developed in the Museum of One publications.", "scope_note": "Local named intellectual framework. Used for records explicitly concerned with it; no Getty, Library of Congress, or other external equivalence is asserted.", "kind": "local-framework-concept", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "custodianship", "ethics-of-witnessing", "foundational-writings", "moral-proximity" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "art-criticism", "label": "Art criticism", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#art-criticism", "url": "vocabulary.html#art-criticism", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:art-criticism", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Art Criticism" ], "definition": "Critical examination and discussion of artworks and encounters with art.", "scope_note": "Use for publications addressing criticism as a practice, method, or ethical responsibility.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "art-writing", "interpretation" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "witnessing", "label": "Witnessing", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#witnessing", "url": "vocabulary.html#witnessing", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:witnessing", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Attentive encounter with artworks and their effects within the corpus.", "scope_note": "Use for discussion of witnessing as a critical practice. Ethics of witnessing identifies an explicitly ethical focus.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "ethics-of-witnessing" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "pedagogy", "label": "Pedagogy", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#pedagogy", "url": "vocabulary.html#pedagogy", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:pedagogy", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Teaching and learning practices related to viewing, thinking, and writing about art.", "scope_note": "Use for works containing exercises or explicit discussion of learning; does not imply an accredited course.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Local preferred terms with definitions and synonyms. External alignment is scoped in the vocabulary register." }, { "field": "genre_terms", "value": [ { "id": "genre-book", "label": "Book", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#genre-book", "url": "vocabulary.html#genre-book", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:genre-book", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Books", "Digital book" ], "definition": "Book-length publication represented by a deposited digital edition.", "scope_note": "Describes publication genre. The local PDF is not being described as a physical bound volume.", "kind": "genre", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "verified_mapping", "external_mappings": [ { "vocabulary": "Getty Art & Architecture Thesaurus", "label": "books", "uri": "http://vocab.getty.edu/aat/300028051", "source_url": "https://vocab.getty.edu/page/aat/300028051", "relation": "relatedMatch", "status": "verified", "verified_on": "2026-11-04", "note": "Getty’s concept concerns bound physical volumes. It is a related form reference for this digital-publication genre, not an exact equivalence or physical-holdings assertion." } ], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "type", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Local resource-genre classification. Digital file format is recorded separately." }, { "field": "archival_context", "value": { "description_profile": "moo-description-policy-1.0", "catalogue_snapshot_date": "2026-11-04", "snapshot_note": "Selected catalogue snapshot; not a live repository synchronisation.", "record_category": "Published library and repository material", "reference_code_status": "Stable local catalogue reference; not evidence of an archival acquisition or a previous catalogue accession.", "source_repository": { "name": "Zenodo", "record_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864115" }, "institutional_context_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "source_metadata_retrieved": "2026-11-04", "source_metadata_retrieval_status": "Documented in catalogue source provenance", "source_snapshot": "source/19864115.json", "source_filenames": [ "post-interpretive-criticism-volume-ii-STANDARD.pdf" ], "selection_basis": "Local descriptive selection of publicly published material; public availability does not establish ownership of originals.", "custodial_history": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No donation, physical transfer, acquisition agreement or chain of custody is documented by this catalogue. Zenodo remains the source repository for the deposited version." }, "original_order": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No original archival order is asserted. Current browsing groupings are local editorial arrangement." }, "arrangement": { "status": "local_editorial", "grouping": "Books & volumes", "statement": "A browsing grouping, not an original fonds or archival series." }, "responsible_service": { "name": "Museum of One", "service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "website": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "email": "research@museumofone.art" }, "description_method": "Source-based description with automated drafting and metadata assistance. Responsibility for the public catalogue rests with Museum of One; automated assistance does not constitute independent scholarly or curatorial review.", "policy_url": "policies.html", "correction_email": "research@museumofone.art", "access_copy": { "role": "Local digital reading copy of the deposited file", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19864115/files/post-interpretive-criticism-volume-ii-STANDARD.pdf/content", "source_filename": "post-interpretive-criticism-volume-ii-STANDARD.pdf", "local_path": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "source_checksum_match": true, "sha256": "1ab810a867166d02b30a284db253b32e2794338a59695858385ec85a982e04ac", "statement": "Access copy only; no ownership or physical custody transfer is implied." } }, "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Provenance records what is documented and leaves unknown custody and original order explicit." }, { "field": "description_history", "value": [ { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Source-based catalogue description", "note": "Local description assembled from the identified public repository record and available institutional work record. Source metadata remains separately identifiable.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/19864115", "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Qualified descriptive enrichment", "note": "Local editorial description, arrangement and source-qualified bibliographic context recorded alongside source metadata. Unknown or disputed values remain qualified.", "fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/19864115", "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Automated file checksum and PDF inspection", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Digital reading copy verified", "note": "Downloaded access-copy MD5 matched the source checksum; local SHA-256 and PDF file-page count are recorded in the file manifest. This event does not describe transfer of custody.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19864115/files/post-interpretive-criticism-volume-ii-STANDARD.pdf/content" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Description policy and provenance context adopted", "note": "Responsible service, source repository, local access-copy role, unknown custody and original order, correction route and dated description history made explicit under moo-description-policy-1.0.", "sources": [ "policies.html" ] }, { "event_id": "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Unify graph identities and qualify exported relationships and citations", "note": "Local graph projection now uses one contextual identity per entity, distinguishes work-level institutional matches from selected-edition links, retains title-level ISBN uncertainty, and derives citations from the source title. Typed relation assertions and a versioned validation profile are introduced. No publication date, original source snapshot or PDF changed.", "fields": [ "metadata_profile", "relationship_assertions", "identity", "institutional_match_scope", "citation_projection" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Source-based metadata implementation and regression validation", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication, source review or acquisition date", "sources": [ "metadata/metadata-profile.json" ] }, { "event_id": "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Record inspected public ORCID profile evidence", "note": "The official ORCID public person API returned the credited name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website. This confirms a matching public profile, not independently verified biographical or affiliation claims. Original creator arrays and source snapshots are unchanged.", "fields": [ "orcid_authority" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Read-only official public API inspection", "date_kind": "Local authority review and catalogue description event; not a publication or original creation date", "sources": [ "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ] } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Catalogue description events; these are not work publication dates or acquisition dates." }, { "field": "pirr_references", "value": [ { "programme_key": "research-witness-material-memory", "programme_title": "Witness, Material Presence, and Cultural Memory", "programme_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/", "programme_stage": "Continuing research", "registry_url": "research-registry.html#research-witness-material-memory", "identifiers": [ { "scheme": "PIRR project ID", "value": "pir-prj-dd7kt5rw", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/#programme-record" } ], "relation": "Published collection associated with the continuing inquiry.", "relation_note": "Published collection associated with the continuing inquiry.", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/" } ], "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "PIRR project IDs and programme references identify research records, not publication versions or independent chapter deposits." }, { "field": "relationship_assertions", "value": [ { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:63fd2ad74f5a120ae03c5ad820cc084845d15d7e7cd41e630e2baa0da387b349", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19864115.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:8bff333b89219130841a09fc92e44b82cd466ec471b3a78d7c049b03f5af0692", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19864115.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:3f06c5a7acabb8248587bac049f0bb3e2fd2b5fa18fa6fd1dd8b2b70d9a16054", "subject": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#describes", "object": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19864115", "scope": "exact_edition", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "source_location": { "kind": "metadata_field", "field": "linked_zenodo_dois", "values": [ "10.5281/zenodo.19864115" ] }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "Exact-edition matching requires the selected DOI in the reviewed page metadata; other matches retain their wider scope." } ], "status": "typed_evidence_projection", "note": "Stable, typed assertions retain source scope and explicit unknown review metadata." }, { "field": "reading_copy", "value": { "id": "19864115", "title": "Post-Interpretive Criticism: Volume II — Essays from the Field", "accession": "MOO-CAT-002", "pdf_url": "../assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19864115/files/post-interpretive-criticism-volume-ii-STANDARD.pdf/content", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864115", "source_filename": "post-interpretive-criticism-volume-ii-STANDARD.pdf", "checksum": "md5:9487d0fc48e7afdfb960fc328d8e4881", "sha256": "1ab810a867166d02b30a284db253b32e2794338a59695858385ec85a982e04ac", "bytes": 2610097, "page_count": 96, "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "checksum_match": true, "rights": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "role": "Local reading copy; original repository file retained unchanged" }, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19864115/files/post-interpretive-criticism-volume-ii-STANDARD.pdf/content", "status": "derived_file_inspection", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "note": "Byte-identical local access copy. Source MD5 was recomputed and matched; SHA-256 and page count were measured from the downloaded PDF. This is not a preservation-deposit claim." }, { "field": "page_count", "value": 96, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19864115/files/post-interpretive-criticism-volume-ii-STANDARD.pdf/content", "status": "derived_file_inspection", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "note": "Total PDF file pages measured from the deposited file, including cover and unnumbered pages. Not a claim about printed pagination." } ], "entity_links": [ { "id": "dorian-vale", "label": "Dorian Vale", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "author", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author.", "variants": [ "Vale, Dorian" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "museum-of-one", "label": "Museum of One", "entity_type": "Organization", "relation": "publisher", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record.", "variants": [ "MuseumofOne", "MUSEUM OF ONE" ], "evidence_scope": "work" } ], "contents": [ { "title": "Preface", "type": "Preface", "pdf_start": 6, "pdf_end": 7, "printed_start": "iv", "printed_end": "v", "id": "c001", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 6, 7 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 6; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864115", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864115", "reference": "MOO-CAT-002/C001", "url": "parts/19864115-c001.html", "reader_url": "read/19864115.html#page=6", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "page_count": 96, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 1, "title": "The Custodian of Consequence: Reframing the Role of the Critic", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 9, "printed_start": "1", "id": "c002", "pdf_end": 15, "printed_end": "7", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 9, 15 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 9; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864115", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864115", "reference": "MOO-CAT-002/C002", "url": "parts/19864115-c002.html", "reader_url": "read/19864115.html#page=9", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "page_count": 96, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 2, "title": "Against the Compulsive Urge to Interpret", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 16, "printed_start": "8", "id": "c003", "pdf_end": 21, "printed_end": "13", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 16, 21 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 16; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864115", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864115", "reference": "MOO-CAT-002/C003", "url": "parts/19864115-c003.html", "reader_url": "read/19864115.html#page=16", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "page_count": 96, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 3, "title": "Moral Proximity: Ethics as Method in Post-Interpretive Criticism", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 22, "printed_start": "14", "id": "c004", "pdf_end": 27, "printed_end": "19", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 22, 27 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 22; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864115", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864115", "reference": "MOO-CAT-002/C004", "url": "parts/19864115-c004.html", "reader_url": "read/19864115.html#page=22", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "page_count": 96, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 4, "title": "The Afterlife of the Work: Viewer as Evidence in Post-Interpretive Criticism", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 28, "printed_start": "20", "id": "c005", "pdf_end": 41, "printed_end": "33", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 28, 41 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 28; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864115", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864115", "reference": "MOO-CAT-002/C005", "url": "parts/19864115-c005.html", "reader_url": "read/19864115.html#page=28", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "page_count": 96, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 5, "title": "Post-Interpretive Method: How to Practice Restraint in Front of a Work of Art", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 42, "printed_start": "34", "id": "c006", "pdf_end": 45, "printed_end": "37", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 42, 45 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 42; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864115", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864115", "reference": "MOO-CAT-002/C006", "url": "parts/19864115-c006.html", "reader_url": "read/19864115.html#page=42", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "page_count": 96, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 6, "title": "Witnessing vs. Interpreting – A Post-Interpretive Comparative Exercise", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 46, "printed_start": "38", "id": "c007", "pdf_end": 51, "printed_end": "43", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 46, 51 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 46; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864115", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864115", "reference": "MOO-CAT-002/C007", "url": "parts/19864115-c007.html", "reader_url": "read/19864115.html#page=46", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "page_count": 96, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 7, "title": "Language as Custody — Writing Without Harm in Post-Interpretive Criticism", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 52, "printed_start": "44", "id": "c008", "pdf_end": 55, "printed_end": "47", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 52, 55 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 52; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864115", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864115", "reference": "MOO-CAT-002/C008", "url": "parts/19864115-c008.html", "reader_url": "read/19864115.html#page=52", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "page_count": 96, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 8, "title": "Five Principles of Post-Interpretive Criticism: A Study Guide", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 56, "printed_start": "48", "id": "c009", "pdf_end": 61, "printed_end": "53", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 56, 61 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 56; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864115", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864115", "reference": "MOO-CAT-002/C009", "url": "parts/19864115-c009.html", "reader_url": "read/19864115.html#page=56", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "page_count": 96, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 9, "title": "Formal Defense of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 62, "printed_start": "54", "id": "c010", "pdf_end": 67, "printed_end": "59", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 62, 67 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 62; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864115", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864115", "reference": "MOO-CAT-002/C010", "url": "parts/19864115-c010.html", "reader_url": "read/19864115.html#page=62", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "page_count": 96, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 10, "title": "A Philosophical Departure from Post-Criticism", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 68, "printed_start": "60", "id": "c011", "pdf_end": 73, "printed_end": "65", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 68, 73 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 68; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864115", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864115", "reference": "MOO-CAT-002/C011", "url": "parts/19864115-c011.html", "reader_url": "read/19864115.html#page=68", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "page_count": 96, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 11, "title": "The First Break Since Postmodernism: The Rise of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "type": "Essay", "pdf_start": 74, "printed_start": "66", "id": "c012", "pdf_end": 95, "printed_end": "87", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 74, 95 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 74; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "19864115", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864115", "reference": "MOO-CAT-002/C012", "url": "parts/19864115-c012.html", "reader_url": "read/19864115.html#page=74", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "page_count": 96, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "controlled_subjects": [ { "id": "post-interpretive-criticism", "label": "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#post-interpretive-criticism", "url": "vocabulary.html#post-interpretive-criticism", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:post-interpretive-criticism", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "PIC", "Post Interpretive Criticism" ], "definition": "The critical framework named and developed in the Museum of One publications.", "scope_note": "Local named intellectual framework. Used for records explicitly concerned with it; no Getty, Library of Congress, or other external equivalence is asserted.", "kind": "local-framework-concept", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "custodianship", "ethics-of-witnessing", "foundational-writings", "moral-proximity" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "art-criticism", "label": "Art criticism", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#art-criticism", "url": "vocabulary.html#art-criticism", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:art-criticism", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Art Criticism" ], "definition": "Critical examination and discussion of artworks and encounters with art.", "scope_note": "Use for publications addressing criticism as a practice, method, or ethical responsibility.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "art-writing", "interpretation" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "witnessing", "label": "Witnessing", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#witnessing", "url": "vocabulary.html#witnessing", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:witnessing", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Attentive encounter with artworks and their effects within the corpus.", "scope_note": "Use for discussion of witnessing as a critical practice. Ethics of witnessing identifies an explicitly ethical focus.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "ethics-of-witnessing" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "pedagogy", "label": "Pedagogy", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#pedagogy", "url": "vocabulary.html#pedagogy", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:pedagogy", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Teaching and learning practices related to viewing, thinking, and writing about art.", "scope_note": "Use for works containing exercises or explicit discussion of learning; does not imply an accredited course.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "genre_terms": [ { "id": "genre-book", "label": "Book", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#genre-book", "url": "vocabulary.html#genre-book", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:genre-book", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Books", "Digital book" ], "definition": "Book-length publication represented by a deposited digital edition.", "scope_note": "Describes publication genre. The local PDF is not being described as a physical bound volume.", "kind": "genre", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "verified_mapping", "external_mappings": [ { "vocabulary": "Getty Art & Architecture Thesaurus", "label": "books", "uri": "http://vocab.getty.edu/aat/300028051", "source_url": "https://vocab.getty.edu/page/aat/300028051", "relation": "relatedMatch", "status": "verified", "verified_on": "2026-11-04", "note": "Getty’s concept concerns bound physical volumes. It is a related form reference for this digital-publication genre, not an exact equivalence or physical-holdings assertion." } ], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "type", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "vocabulary_version": 4, "description_history": [ { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Source-based catalogue description", "note": "Local description assembled from the identified public repository record and available institutional work record. Source metadata remains separately identifiable.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/19864115", "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Qualified descriptive enrichment", "note": "Local editorial description, arrangement and source-qualified bibliographic context recorded alongside source metadata. Unknown or disputed values remain qualified.", "fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/19864115", "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Automated file checksum and PDF inspection", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Digital reading copy verified", "note": "Downloaded access-copy MD5 matched the source checksum; local SHA-256 and PDF file-page count are recorded in the file manifest. This event does not describe transfer of custody.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19864115/files/post-interpretive-criticism-volume-ii-STANDARD.pdf/content" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Description policy and provenance context adopted", "note": "Responsible service, source repository, local access-copy role, unknown custody and original order, correction route and dated description history made explicit under moo-description-policy-1.0.", "sources": [ "policies.html" ] }, { "event_id": "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Unify graph identities and qualify exported relationships and citations", "note": "Local graph projection now uses one contextual identity per entity, distinguishes work-level institutional matches from selected-edition links, retains title-level ISBN uncertainty, and derives citations from the source title. Typed relation assertions and a versioned validation profile are introduced. No publication date, original source snapshot or PDF changed.", "fields": [ "metadata_profile", "relationship_assertions", "identity", "institutional_match_scope", "citation_projection" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Source-based metadata implementation and regression validation", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication, source review or acquisition date", "sources": [ "metadata/metadata-profile.json" ] }, { "event_id": "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Record inspected public ORCID profile evidence", "note": "The official ORCID public person API returned the credited name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website. This confirms a matching public profile, not independently verified biographical or affiliation claims. Original creator arrays and source snapshots are unchanged.", "fields": [ "orcid_authority" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Read-only official public API inspection", "date_kind": "Local authority review and catalogue description event; not a publication or original creation date", "sources": [ "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ] } ], "record_modified": "2026-11-04", "record_modified_provenance": { "status": "derived_from_description_history", "event_ids": [ "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04" ], "note": "Latest documented local description event; not a publication, repository or source-review date." }, "archival_context": { "description_profile": "moo-description-policy-1.0", "catalogue_snapshot_date": "2026-11-04", "snapshot_note": "Selected catalogue snapshot; not a live repository synchronisation.", "record_category": "Published library and repository material", "reference_code_status": "Stable local catalogue reference; not evidence of an archival acquisition or a previous catalogue accession.", "source_repository": { "name": "Zenodo", "record_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19864115" }, "institutional_context_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "source_metadata_retrieved": "2026-11-04", "source_metadata_retrieval_status": "Documented in catalogue source provenance", "source_snapshot": "source/19864115.json", "source_filenames": [ "post-interpretive-criticism-volume-ii-STANDARD.pdf" ], "selection_basis": "Local descriptive selection of publicly published material; public availability does not establish ownership of originals.", "custodial_history": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No donation, physical transfer, acquisition agreement or chain of custody is documented by this catalogue. Zenodo remains the source repository for the deposited version." }, "original_order": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No original archival order is asserted. Current browsing groupings are local editorial arrangement." }, "arrangement": { "status": "local_editorial", "grouping": "Books & volumes", "statement": "A browsing grouping, not an original fonds or archival series." }, "responsible_service": { "name": "Museum of One", "service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "website": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "email": "research@museumofone.art" }, "description_method": "Source-based description with automated drafting and metadata assistance. Responsibility for the public catalogue rests with Museum of One; automated assistance does not constitute independent scholarly or curatorial review.", "policy_url": "policies.html", "correction_email": "research@museumofone.art", "access_copy": { "role": "Local digital reading copy of the deposited file", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19864115/files/post-interpretive-criticism-volume-ii-STANDARD.pdf/content", "source_filename": "post-interpretive-criticism-volume-ii-STANDARD.pdf", "local_path": "assets/documents/19864115.pdf", "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "source_checksum_match": true, "sha256": "1ab810a867166d02b30a284db253b32e2794338a59695858385ec85a982e04ac", "statement": "Access copy only; no ownership or physical custody transfer is implied." } }, "description_policy_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "pirr_references": [ { "programme_key": "research-witness-material-memory", "programme_title": "Witness, Material Presence, and Cultural Memory", "programme_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/", "programme_stage": "Continuing research", "registry_url": "research-registry.html#research-witness-material-memory", "identifiers": [ { "scheme": "PIRR project ID", "value": "pir-prj-dd7kt5rw", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/#programme-record" } ], "relation": "Published collection associated with the continuing inquiry.", "relation_note": "Published collection associated with the continuing inquiry.", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/" } ], "pirr_work_identity": { "archive_reference": "MOO-CAT-002", "edition_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19864115", "zenodo_record_id": "19864115", "identifier_scope": "Publication identity; PIRR identifiers in programme relationships identify research records, not this publication." }, "metadata_origin": "https://archive.museumofone.art", "identity": { "work": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19864115.html#work", "edition": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19864115", "version_family": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17078846", "catalogue_record": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19864115.html#catalogue-record" }, "institutional_match_scope": "exact_edition", "relationship_assertions": [ { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:63fd2ad74f5a120ae03c5ad820cc084845d15d7e7cd41e630e2baa0da387b349", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19864115.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:8bff333b89219130841a09fc92e44b82cd466ec471b3a78d7c049b03f5af0692", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19864115.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:3f06c5a7acabb8248587bac049f0bb3e2fd2b5fa18fa6fd1dd8b2b70d9a16054", "subject": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#describes", "object": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19864115", "scope": "exact_edition", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-essays-from-field/", "source_location": { "kind": "metadata_field", "field": "linked_zenodo_dois", "values": [ "10.5281/zenodo.19864115" ] }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "Exact-edition matching requires the selected DOI in the reviewed page metadata; other matches retain their wider scope." } ], "orcid_authority": { "scheme": "ORCID", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "evidence_urls": [ "https://www.museumofone.art/archives-scholarly-infrastructure/", "https://eprints.rclis.org/47182/", "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ], "access_note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "evidence_receipt": "data/source/authority-review-2026-11-04.json" } }, { "id": "23395654", "accession": "MOO-CAT-003", "title": "Threads of Sand, Scar & Scripture: Sudanese Art and the Ethics of Witnessing (A Post-Interpretive Study)", "source_title": "Threads of Sand, Scar & Scripture: Sudanese Art and the Ethics of Witnessing (A Post-Interpretive Study)", "short_title": "Threads of Sand, Scar & Scripture", "author": "Dorian Vale", "creators": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "affiliation": null, "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094" } ], "doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "conceptdoi": "10.5281/zenodo.19207069", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23395654", "date": "2026-05-18", "type": "Book", "source_resource_type": { "title": "Book", "type": "publication", "subtype": "book" }, "version": "", "collection": "Books & volumes", "summary": "A study of Sudanese art in relation to war, displacement, and historical fragmentation. The author approaches critical writing as an ethical practice of proximity and restraint.", "subjects": [ "Sudanese art", "Displacement", "Ethics of witnessing", "Post-Interpretive Criticism" ], "keywords": [ "Sudanese art", "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "ethics of witnessing", "art criticism", "cultural memory", "displacement" ], "license": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "files": [ { "name": "Threads of Sand, Scar & Scripture.pdf", "url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/23395654/files/Threads%20of%20Sand,%20Scar%20&%20Scripture.pdf/content", "size": 1285819, "size_label": "1256 KB", "checksum": "md5:46a6f18c00b10acb6753fcda97d91cd8", "mimetype": "application/pdf" } ], "institutional_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "corroboration": "Museum of One’s matching publication page confirms Dorian Vale’s authorship and the work’s institutional context. It links the selected Zenodo edition DOI. Web-record dates are not treated as dates of the deposited edition. Source review: 4 November 2026.", "discrepancies": [ "The institutional publication register may cite the version-family DOI. This record cites the selected deposited edition DOI and identifies the concept DOI separately.", "Museum of One identifies the selected English-language source as the second edition, dated 18 May 2026. The authorized Arabic translation is a separate work in development, not a deposited translated edition in this catalogue." ], "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "publisher": "Museum of One", "language": null, "isbn": "978-1-06-982033-4", "related_identifiers": [], "alternate_identifiers": [ { "identifier": "978-1-06-982033-4" } ], "source_references": [], "source_journal": null, "source_imprint": {}, "source_contributors": [ { "name": "Museum of One", "affiliation": null, "type": "HostingInstitution" } ], "source_created": "2026-10-15T13:02:22.774012+00:00", "source_modified": "2026-10-15T13:02:23.227934+00:00", "source_description_html": "

Title: Threads of Sand, Scar & Scripture: Sudanese Art and the Ethics of Witnessing (A Post-Interpretive Study)

\n

Author: Dorian Vale

\n

Affiliation: Museum of One — Registered Archive & Independent Research Institute for Contemporary Aesthetics

\n

This book presents a sustained philosophical and critical inquiry into Sudanese art under conditions of war, displacement, and historical fragmentation, advancing Post-Interpretive Criticism (PIC) as an ethical alternative to dominant interpretive frameworks in contemporary art discourse. Rather than treating artworks as objects to be decoded, explained, or culturally translated for external audiences, this study repositions the critic as a witness in proximity—one who resists extraction, narrative closure, and symbolic appropriation.

\n

Through a series of close encounters with Sudanese visual practices—ranging from material craft traditions and domestic forms to contemporary expressions shaped by exile and rupture—the book develops a methodology grounded in restraint, presence, and moral adjacency. It argues that conventional art criticism, particularly within post-1950s interpretive paradigms, has produced a condition of interpretive saturation, wherein artworks are reduced to vehicles for meaning rather than approached as sites of lived continuity and fragile coherence.

\n

Drawing on the philosophical architecture of Post-Interpretive Criticism—including concepts such as viewer-as-evidence, ethical proximity, and the refusal of interpretive closure—the text examines how Sudanese art operates not as representation but as survival infrastructure: a means of carrying memory, dignity, and cultural continuity through conditions of systemic disruption. In doing so, it reframes aesthetic experience as an ethical encounter shaped by limits, rather than an opportunity for discursive expansion.

\n

The book further situates Sudanese art within broader discussions of archive politics, institutional mediation, and the epistemic violence of interpretation, arguing that acts of naming, framing, and explaining often function as forms of displacement. Against this, it proposes a discipline of witnessing that privileges silence, material attention, and positional awareness over interpretive authority.

\n

Positioned at the intersection of aesthetics, anthropology, and philosophy, Threads of Sand, Scar, & Scripture contributes to emerging post-hermeneutic approaches to art criticism by offering both a theoretical framework and a series of applied analyses. It establishes Post-Interpretive Criticism not merely as a method, but as a necessary ethical recalibration in the face of cultural fragility, where the role of criticism is no longer to extract meaning, but to remain answerable to what survives.

\n
\n

Dorian Vale is a chosen pseudonym, not to obscure identity, but to preserve clarity of voice and integrity of message. It creates distance between the writer and the work, allowing the philosophy to stand unclouded by biography. The name exists not to hide, but to honor the seriousness of the task: to speak without spectacle, and to build without needing to be seen.

\n
\n

Repository file correction, 15 October 2026: this version restores the verified Threads PDF from public version 10.5281/zenodo.20272105. It corrects the unrelated Moral Evidence PDF deposited in version 10.5281/zenodo.20274964. The restored PDF is unchanged and identifies itself as the Second edition; this repository correction does not create a new book edition. First publication date for this edition: 18 May 2026. All earlier repository versions remain in the history. Stable concept DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.19207069.

", "provenance": { "repository": "Zenodo REST API response supplied in query.json", "retrieved": "2026-11-04", "editorial_fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "source_snapshot": "source/23395654.json", "institutional_review": "Reviewed page-level title, author and repository links in saved public institutional HTML, 2026-11-04." }, "cover": "assets/threads-of-sand.webp", "cover_alt": "Published cover of Threads of Sand, Scar & Scripture: Sudanese Art and the Ethics of Witnessing (A Post-Interpretive Study)", "cover_source": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "source_review": "2026-11-04", "relations": [], "institutional_metadata": { "title": "Threads of Sand, Scar & Scripture", "author": "Dorian Vale", "web_publication": "2026-10-14T00:00:00.000Z", "web_updated": "2026-11-02T14:41:18.000Z", "linked_zenodo_dois": [ "10.5281/zenodo.23395654" ], "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "publication_title": "Threads of Sand, Scar & Scripture", "publication_status": "Published English-language book; second edition, 18 May 2026", "publication_date": "2026-05-18", "edition": "Second edition" }, "research_programmes": [ { "title": "Witness, Material Presence, and Cultural Memory", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/", "status": "Continuing research", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "relation": "Published study associated with the continuing inquiry.", "relation_label": "Published study associated with the continuing inquiry." }, { "title": "Threads of Sand: Arabic Translation", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/arabic-translation-threads-of-sand/", "status": "In development", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "relation": "Published English-language source edition for translation.", "relation_label": "Published English-language source edition for translation." }, { "title": "Sudanese Art and Aesthetics", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/sudanese-art-and-aesthetics/", "status": "Continuing research", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "relation": "Published study within the continuing programme.", "relation_label": "Published study within the continuing programme." } ], "edition_statement": "Second edition, 18 May 2026 (Museum of One publication record)", "record_level": "Item", "record_status": "Published source; selected catalogue record", "digital_formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "extent": "1 digital file; 1285819 bytes", "medium": "Digital document", "record_reviewed": "2026-11-04", "date_precision": "day", "alternate_titles": [ { "title": "Threads of Sand, Scar & Scripture", "kind": "institutional_web_record_title", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/" } ], "digital_extent": { "file_count": 1, "total_bytes": 1285819, "formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "checksums": [ { "filename": "Threads of Sand, Scar & Scripture.pdf", "algorithm": "md5", "value": "46a6f18c00b10acb6753fcda97d91cd8", "syntax_valid": true, "verification": "source_checksum_transcription; bytes not independently recomputed" } ], "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23395654", "derivation": "File count and total bytes calculated from repository file metadata; MIME inferred from filename when absent." }, "identifier_validation": { "orcid": { "source_value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "ISO 7064 MOD 11-2 checksum only; this is not a live registry verification." }, "isbn": [ { "source_value": "978-1-06-982033-4", "normalized": "9781069820334", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "Checksum validation tests the identifier syntax only; it does not verify assignment, format or edition applicability.", "scope": "title_level_book_identifier; format applicability follows edition source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23395654" } ], "doi": { "source_value": "10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "syntax_valid": true, "note": "Syntax check only; repository snapshot supplies the identifier." } }, "isbn_applicability": "title_level_book_identifier", "serial": null, "contributor_roles": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": null, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23395654" }, { "name": "Museum of One", "source_category": "contributor", "source_role": "HostingInstitution", "role_label": "HostingInstitution", "affiliation_as_supplied": null, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23395654" } ], "authority_links": [ { "title": "Google Books bibliographic record", "url": "https://books.google.com/books/about/Threads_of_Sand_Scar_Scripture_Sudanese.html?hl=en&id=Kr3jEQAAQBAJ&output=html_text", "kind": "bibliographic_record", "status": "record_metadata_observed_in_search_index", "evidence": "Dorian Vale; Museum of One Press, 2026; ISBN 1069820334 / 9781069820334.", "note": "Do not import Google Books subject categories blindly; assess relevance against text.", "scope": "Bibliographic context; inspect source for edition applicability", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/" }, { "title": "BiblioBoard catalogue access", "url": "https://library.biblioboard.com/content/bb70fe23-bf8d-4963-9a32-be559e7af083", "kind": "catalogue_access", "status": "institutional_link_access_restricted", "evidence_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-discovery-and-archive-sources/", "note": "Format, edition and ISBN not independently inspectable.", "scope": "Bibliographic context; inspect source for edition applicability", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-discovery-and-archive-sources/" } ], "metadata_profile": { "name": "Museum of One source-qualified catalogue profile", "version": "3.0.0", "url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/metadata-profile.json", "source_snapshot_preserved": true }, "reading_copy": { "id": "23395654", "title": "Threads of Sand, Scar & Scripture: Sudanese Art and the Ethics of Witnessing (A Post-Interpretive Study)", "accession": "MOO-CAT-003", "pdf_url": "../assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/23395654/files/Threads%20of%20Sand,%20Scar%20&%20Scripture.pdf/content", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23395654", "source_filename": "Threads of Sand, Scar & Scripture.pdf", "checksum": "md5:46a6f18c00b10acb6753fcda97d91cd8", "sha256": "314714912e2fef212ea2960c105309c422b13a7d14a2ff2ec350c938c13a31c6", "bytes": 1285819, "page_count": 226, "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "checksum_match": true, "rights": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "role": "Local reading copy; original repository file retained unchanged" }, "page_count": 226, "field_assertions": [ { "field": "title", "value": "Threads of Sand, Scar & Scripture: Sudanese Art and the Ethics of Witnessing (A Post-Interpretive Study)", "status": "catalogue_title", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "note": "Local display title; the deposited title is retained separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_title", "value": "Threads of Sand, Scar & Scripture: Sudanese Art and the Ethics of Witnessing (A Post-Interpretive Study)", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23395654", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "doi", "value": "10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23395654", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "date", "value": "2026-05-18", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23395654", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "conceptdoi", "value": "10.5281/zenodo.19207069", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23395654", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "creators", "value": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "affiliation": null, "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23395654", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "keywords", "value": [ "Sudanese art", "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "ethics of witnessing", "art criticism", "cultural memory", "displacement" ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23395654", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "license", "value": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23395654", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "files", "value": [ { "name": "Threads of Sand, Scar & Scripture.pdf", "url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/23395654/files/Threads%20of%20Sand,%20Scar%20&%20Scripture.pdf/content", "size": 1285819, "size_label": "1256 KB", "checksum": "md5:46a6f18c00b10acb6753fcda97d91cd8", "mimetype": "application/pdf" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23395654", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_created", "value": "2026-10-15T13:02:22.774012+00:00", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23395654", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_modified", "value": "2026-10-15T13:02:23.227934+00:00", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23395654", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "record_modified", "value": "2026-11-04", "status": "derived_from_description_history", "note": "Latest documented local description event; not a publication, repository or source-review date.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_review", "value": "2026-11-04", "status": "catalogue_source_review", "note": "Review of descriptive sources; not the creation or modification date of the work or repository record.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "author", "value": "Dorian Vale", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "note": "Institutional responsibility statement; original repository creator roles remain separate.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "publisher", "value": "Museum of One", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "note": "Institutional responsibility statement; original repository creator roles remain separate.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "edition_statement", "value": "Second edition, 18 May 2026 (Museum of One publication record)", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "note": "Consult the linked edition record; a repository version is not a new book edition.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "isbn", "value": "978-1-06-982033-4", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "note": "Consult the linked edition record; a repository version is not a new book edition.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "orcid", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "source_linked_identifier", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "note": "Creator identifier supplied by the linked sources; no affiliation or endorsement is inferred.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "orcid_authority", "value": { "scheme": "ORCID", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "evidence_urls": [ "https://www.museumofone.art/archives-scholarly-infrastructure/", "https://eprints.rclis.org/47182/", "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ], "access_note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "evidence_receipt": "data/source/authority-review-2026-11-04.json" }, "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "source_url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "summary", "value": "A study of Sudanese art in relation to war, displacement, and historical fragmentation. The author approaches critical writing as an ethical practice of proximity and restraint.", "status": "editorial_enrichment", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "note": "Catalogue-editor summary based on the linked work; not an original publisher abstract.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "subjects", "value": [ "Sudanese art", "Displacement", "Ethics of witnessing", "Post-Interpretive Criticism" ], "status": "editorial_enrichment", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "note": "Local discovery terms; no controlled-vocabulary assignment is claimed.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "collection", "value": "Books & volumes", "status": "editorial_grouping", "note": "A local browsing collection, not an original repository collection.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "corroboration", "value": "Museum of One’s matching publication page confirms Dorian Vale’s authorship and the work’s institutional context. It links the selected Zenodo edition DOI. Web-record dates are not treated as dates of the deposited edition. Source review: 4 November 2026.", "status": "catalogue_review_note", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "discrepancies", "value": [ "The institutional publication register may cite the version-family DOI. This record cites the selected deposited edition DOI and identifies the concept DOI separately.", "Museum of One identifies the selected English-language source as the second edition, dated 18 May 2026. The authorized Arabic translation is a separate work in development, not a deposited translated edition in this catalogue." ], "status": "catalogue_review_note", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "alternate_titles", "value": [ { "title": "Threads of Sand, Scar & Scripture", "kind": "institutional_web_record_title", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/" } ], "status": "source_qualified_title_variants", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "note": "Each variant retains its own source and scope; a web page title is not a title-page transcription.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "date_precision", "value": "day", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23395654", "note": "Precision reported exactly as supplied; missing month or day is not filled.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "medium", "value": "Digital document", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23395654", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "digital_formats", "value": [ "application/pdf" ], "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23395654", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "extent", "value": "1 digital file; 1285819 bytes", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23395654", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "digital_extent", "value": { "file_count": 1, "total_bytes": 1285819, "formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "checksums": [ { "filename": "Threads of Sand, Scar & Scripture.pdf", "algorithm": "md5", "value": "46a6f18c00b10acb6753fcda97d91cd8", "syntax_valid": true, "verification": "source_checksum_transcription; bytes not independently recomputed" } ], "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23395654", "derivation": "File count and total bytes calculated from repository file metadata; MIME inferred from filename when absent." }, "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23395654", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "identifier_validation", "value": { "orcid": { "source_value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "ISO 7064 MOD 11-2 checksum only; this is not a live registry verification." }, "isbn": [ { "source_value": "978-1-06-982033-4", "normalized": "9781069820334", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "Checksum validation tests the identifier syntax only; it does not verify assignment, format or edition applicability.", "scope": "title_level_book_identifier; format applicability follows edition source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23395654" } ], "doi": { "source_value": "10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "syntax_valid": true, "note": "Syntax check only; repository snapshot supplies the identifier." } }, "status": "local_syntax_validation", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23395654", "note": "Checksum/syntax validation does not verify registration, assignment or edition applicability.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "contributor_roles", "value": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": null, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23395654" }, { "name": "Museum of One", "source_category": "contributor", "source_role": "HostingInstitution", "role_label": "HostingInstitution", "affiliation_as_supplied": null, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23395654" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23395654", "note": "Creator and contributor roles are transcribed, not inferred from names or affiliations.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "authority_links", "value": [ { "title": "Google Books bibliographic record", "url": "https://books.google.com/books/about/Threads_of_Sand_Scar_Scripture_Sudanese.html?hl=en&id=Kr3jEQAAQBAJ&output=html_text", "kind": "bibliographic_record", "status": "record_metadata_observed_in_search_index", "evidence": "Dorian Vale; Museum of One Press, 2026; ISBN 1069820334 / 9781069820334.", "note": "Do not import Google Books subject categories blindly; assess relevance against text.", "scope": "Bibliographic context; inspect source for edition applicability", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/" }, { "title": "BiblioBoard catalogue access", "url": "https://library.biblioboard.com/content/bb70fe23-bf8d-4963-9a32-be559e7af083", "kind": "catalogue_access", "status": "institutional_link_access_restricted", "evidence_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-discovery-and-archive-sources/", "note": "Format, edition and ISBN not independently inspectable.", "scope": "Bibliographic context; inspect source for edition applicability", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-discovery-and-archive-sources/" } ], "status": "source_qualified_external_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "note": "External records have separate status and edition scope; links are not endorsements or equivalence assertions.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "research_programme:https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/", "value": { "title": "Witness, Material Presence, and Cultural Memory", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/", "status": "Continuing research", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "relation": "Published study associated with the continuing inquiry.", "relation_label": "Published study associated with the continuing inquiry." }, "status": "institutional_work_relationship", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "note": "Programme relationship and stage follow the work-specific institutional badge; publication does not imply a completed programme or collaboration.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "research_programme:https://www.museumofone.art/arabic-translation-threads-of-sand/", "value": { "title": "Threads of Sand: Arabic Translation", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/arabic-translation-threads-of-sand/", "status": "In development", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "relation": "Published English-language source edition for translation.", "relation_label": "Published English-language source edition for translation." }, "status": "institutional_work_relationship", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "note": "Programme relationship and stage follow the work-specific institutional badge; publication does not imply a completed programme or collaboration.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "research_programme:https://www.museumofone.art/sudanese-art-and-aesthetics/", "value": { "title": "Sudanese Art and Aesthetics", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/sudanese-art-and-aesthetics/", "status": "Continuing research", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "relation": "Published study within the continuing programme.", "relation_label": "Published study within the continuing programme." }, "status": "institutional_work_relationship", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "note": "Programme relationship and stage follow the work-specific institutional badge; publication does not imply a completed programme or collaboration.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "entity_link:dorian-vale:author", "value": { "id": "dorian-vale", "label": "Dorian Vale", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "author", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author.", "variants": [ "Vale, Dorian" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:7d3ccaa4c0544d3c1f50c8948b752a948c61106ed585e203f288e66163e37f2e", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23395654.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." } }, { "field": "entity_link:museum-of-one:publisher", "value": { "id": "museum-of-one", "label": "Museum of One", "entity_type": "Organization", "relation": "publisher", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record.", "variants": [ "MuseumofOne", "MUSEUM OF ONE" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:9f3c72a22524892c4d67a948806c261493664e751f69e997bc44d64aa3b213f3", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23395654.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." } }, { "field": "contents", "value": [ { "title": "Preface", "type": "Preface", "pdf_start": 7, "pdf_end": 10, "printed_start": "v", "printed_end": "viii", "id": "c001", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 7, 10 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 7; contents pages 5–6", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "23395654", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "reference": "MOO-CAT-003/C001", "url": "parts/23395654-c001.html", "reader_url": "read/23395654.html#page=7", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "page_count": 226, "pdf_pages": [ 5, 6 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 1, "title": "The Lens of Origin: The Unwritten Archive, Before Islam, Before Labels", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 11, "printed_start": "1", "id": "c002", "pdf_end": 27, "printed_end": "17", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 11, 27 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 11; contents pages 5–6", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "23395654", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "reference": "MOO-CAT-003/C002", "url": "parts/23395654-c002.html", "reader_url": "read/23395654.html#page=11", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "page_count": 226, "pdf_pages": [ 5, 6 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 2, "title": "The Lens of the Land: River-Cosmology and Desert Intelligence", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 28, "printed_start": "18", "id": "c003", "pdf_end": 47, "printed_end": "37", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 28, 47 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 28; contents pages 5–6", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "23395654", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "reference": "MOO-CAT-003/C003", "url": "parts/23395654-c003.html", "reader_url": "read/23395654.html#page=28", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "page_count": 226, "pdf_pages": [ 5, 6 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 3, "title": "The Lens of the Body: Scar, Pattern, and Totem", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 48, "printed_start": "38", "id": "c004", "pdf_end": 62, "printed_end": "52", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 48, 62 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 48; contents pages 5–6", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "23395654", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "reference": "MOO-CAT-003/C004", "url": "parts/23395654-c004.html", "reader_url": "read/23395654.html#page=48", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "page_count": 226, "pdf_pages": [ 5, 6 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 4, "title": "The Lens of Aftermath: Art After the Border Was Drawn", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 63, "printed_start": "53", "id": "c005", "pdf_end": 78, "printed_end": "68", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 63, 78 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 63; contents pages 5–6", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "23395654", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "reference": "MOO-CAT-003/C005", "url": "parts/23395654-c005.html", "reader_url": "read/23395654.html#page=63", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "page_count": 226, "pdf_pages": [ 5, 6 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 5, "title": "The Lens of Erasure: When Civilizing Became a Curriculum", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 79, "printed_start": "69", "id": "c006", "pdf_end": 95, "printed_end": "85", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 79, 95 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 79; contents pages 5–6", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "23395654", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "reference": "MOO-CAT-003/C006", "url": "parts/23395654-c006.html", "reader_url": "read/23395654.html#page=79", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "page_count": 226, "pdf_pages": [ 5, 6 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 6, "title": "The Lens of Resistance: When Beauty Became a Code", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 96, "printed_start": "86", "id": "c007", "pdf_end": 109, "printed_end": "99", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 96, 109 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 96; contents pages 5–6", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "23395654", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "reference": "MOO-CAT-003/C007", "url": "parts/23395654-c007.html", "reader_url": "read/23395654.html#page=96", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "page_count": 226, "pdf_pages": [ 5, 6 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 7, "title": "The Lens of the Sacred: The Theology of Repetition", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 110, "printed_start": "100", "id": "c008", "pdf_end": 118, "printed_end": "108", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 110, 118 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 110; contents pages 5–6", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "23395654", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "reference": "MOO-CAT-003/C008", "url": "parts/23395654-c008.html", "reader_url": "read/23395654.html#page=110", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "page_count": 226, "pdf_pages": [ 5, 6 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 8, "title": "The Lens of Sand & Scripture: Aesthetic Islam in Sudan", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 119, "printed_start": "109", "id": "c009", "pdf_end": 133, "printed_end": "123", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 119, 133 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 119; contents pages 5–6", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "23395654", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "reference": "MOO-CAT-003/C009", "url": "parts/23395654-c009.html", "reader_url": "read/23395654.html#page=119", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "page_count": 226, "pdf_pages": [ 5, 6 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 9, "title": "The Lens of Oral Memory: The Artwork That Walks Before the Pen", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 134, "printed_start": "124", "id": "c010", "pdf_end": 143, "printed_end": "133", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 134, 143 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 134; contents pages 5–6", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "23395654", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "reference": "MOO-CAT-003/C010", "url": "parts/23395654-c010.html", "reader_url": "read/23395654.html#page=134", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "page_count": 226, "pdf_pages": [ 5, 6 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 10, "title": "The Lens of Architecture: Sudanese Space as Moral Instruction", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 144, "printed_start": "134", "id": "c011", "pdf_end": 153, "printed_end": "143", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 144, 153 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 144; contents pages 5–6", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "23395654", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "reference": "MOO-CAT-003/C011", "url": "parts/23395654-c011.html", "reader_url": "read/23395654.html#page=144", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "page_count": 226, "pdf_pages": [ 5, 6 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 11, "title": "The Lens of Craft: Inheritance in the Hands", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 154, "printed_start": "144", "id": "c012", "pdf_end": 165, "printed_end": "155", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 154, 165 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 154; contents pages 5–6", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "23395654", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "reference": "MOO-CAT-003/C012", "url": "parts/23395654-c012.html", "reader_url": "read/23395654.html#page=154", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "page_count": 226, "pdf_pages": [ 5, 6 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 12, "title": "The Lens of Migration: The Shadow Canon of Diaspora", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 166, "printed_start": "156", "id": "c013", "pdf_end": 179, "printed_end": "169", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 166, 179 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 166; contents pages 5–6", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "23395654", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "reference": "MOO-CAT-003/C013", "url": "parts/23395654-c013.html", "reader_url": "read/23395654.html#page=166", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "page_count": 226, "pdf_pages": [ 5, 6 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 13, "title": "The Lens of Rupture: The Hand Continues", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 180, "printed_start": "170", "id": "c014", "pdf_end": 193, "printed_end": "183", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 180, 193 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 180; contents pages 5–6", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "23395654", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "reference": "MOO-CAT-003/C014", "url": "parts/23395654-c014.html", "reader_url": "read/23395654.html#page=180", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "page_count": 226, "pdf_pages": [ 5, 6 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 14, "title": "The Lens of Silence: Withheld Testimony as Strategy", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 194, "printed_start": "184", "id": "c015", "pdf_end": 206, "printed_end": "196", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 194, 206 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 194; contents pages 5–6", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "23395654", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "reference": "MOO-CAT-003/C015", "url": "parts/23395654-c015.html", "reader_url": "read/23395654.html#page=194", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "page_count": 226, "pdf_pages": [ 5, 6 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 15, "title": "The Lens of the Ghost: What Sudan Tried to Forget", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 207, "printed_start": "197", "id": "c016", "pdf_end": 223, "printed_end": "213", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 207, 223 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 207; contents pages 5–6", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "23395654", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "reference": "MOO-CAT-003/C016", "url": "parts/23395654-c016.html", "reader_url": "read/23395654.html#page=207", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "page_count": 226, "pdf_pages": [ 5, 6 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 16, "title": "Epilogue: The Custodian’s Oath", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 224, "printed_start": "214", "id": "c017", "pdf_end": 225, "printed_end": "215", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 224, 225 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 224; contents pages 5–6", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "23395654", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "reference": "MOO-CAT-003/C017", "url": "parts/23395654-c017.html", "reader_url": "read/23395654.html#page=224", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "page_count": 226, "pdf_pages": [ 5, 6 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/23395654/files/Threads%20of%20Sand,%20Scar%20&%20Scripture.pdf/content", "status": "derived_file_inspection", "note": "Analytic descriptions were checked against headings and pagination in the deposited PDF. Component records do not have independent deposits or DOIs." }, { "field": "controlled_subjects", "value": [ { "id": "sudanese-art", "label": "Sudanese art", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#sudanese-art", "url": "vocabulary.html#sudanese-art", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:sudanese-art", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Art discussed in relation to Sudan and Sudanese histories or experiences.", "scope_note": "A contextual subject heading, not a statement about any individual’s citizenship or an external geographic authority assignment.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "displacement", "label": "Displacement", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#displacement", "url": "vocabulary.html#displacement", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:displacement", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Dislocation from place or context as a subject of art and critical writing.", "scope_note": "In the current assignment, refers to displacement in the Sudanese art study; do not merge with the author’s named Aesthetic Displacement Theory.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "ethics-of-witnessing", "label": "Ethics of witnessing", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#ethics-of-witnessing", "url": "vocabulary.html#ethics-of-witnessing", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:ethics-of-witnessing", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "ethics of witnessing" ], "definition": "Ethical responsibility in attending to artworks and the histories they engage.", "scope_note": "Local access term used for the Museum of One corpus. Preserve the author’s framework attribution; no equivalence with an external philosophical school is asserted.", "kind": "local-framework-concept", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "post-interpretive-criticism", "witnessing" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "post-interpretive-criticism", "label": "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#post-interpretive-criticism", "url": "vocabulary.html#post-interpretive-criticism", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:post-interpretive-criticism", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "PIC", "Post Interpretive Criticism" ], "definition": "The critical framework named and developed in the Museum of One publications.", "scope_note": "Local named intellectual framework. Used for records explicitly concerned with it; no Getty, Library of Congress, or other external equivalence is asserted.", "kind": "local-framework-concept", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "custodianship", "ethics-of-witnessing", "foundational-writings", "moral-proximity" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Local preferred terms with definitions and synonyms. External alignment is scoped in the vocabulary register." }, { "field": "genre_terms", "value": [ { "id": "genre-book", "label": "Book", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#genre-book", "url": "vocabulary.html#genre-book", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:genre-book", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Books", "Digital book" ], "definition": "Book-length publication represented by a deposited digital edition.", "scope_note": "Describes publication genre. The local PDF is not being described as a physical bound volume.", "kind": "genre", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "verified_mapping", "external_mappings": [ { "vocabulary": "Getty Art & Architecture Thesaurus", "label": "books", "uri": "http://vocab.getty.edu/aat/300028051", "source_url": "https://vocab.getty.edu/page/aat/300028051", "relation": "relatedMatch", "status": "verified", "verified_on": "2026-11-04", "note": "Getty’s concept concerns bound physical volumes. It is a related form reference for this digital-publication genre, not an exact equivalence or physical-holdings assertion." } ], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "type", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Local resource-genre classification. Digital file format is recorded separately." }, { "field": "archival_context", "value": { "description_profile": "moo-description-policy-1.0", "catalogue_snapshot_date": "2026-11-04", "snapshot_note": "Selected catalogue snapshot; not a live repository synchronisation.", "record_category": "Published library and repository material", "reference_code_status": "Stable local catalogue reference; not evidence of an archival acquisition or a previous catalogue accession.", "source_repository": { "name": "Zenodo", "record_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23395654" }, "institutional_context_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "source_metadata_retrieved": "2026-11-04", "source_metadata_retrieval_status": "Documented in catalogue source provenance", "source_snapshot": "source/23395654.json", "source_filenames": [ "Threads of Sand, Scar & Scripture.pdf" ], "selection_basis": "Local descriptive selection of publicly published material; public availability does not establish ownership of originals.", "custodial_history": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No donation, physical transfer, acquisition agreement or chain of custody is documented by this catalogue. Zenodo remains the source repository for the deposited version." }, "original_order": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No original archival order is asserted. Current browsing groupings are local editorial arrangement." }, "arrangement": { "status": "local_editorial", "grouping": "Books & volumes", "statement": "A browsing grouping, not an original fonds or archival series." }, "responsible_service": { "name": "Museum of One", "service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "website": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "email": "research@museumofone.art" }, "description_method": "Source-based description with automated drafting and metadata assistance. Responsibility for the public catalogue rests with Museum of One; automated assistance does not constitute independent scholarly or curatorial review.", "policy_url": "policies.html", "correction_email": "research@museumofone.art", "access_copy": { "role": "Local digital reading copy of the deposited file", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/23395654/files/Threads%20of%20Sand,%20Scar%20&%20Scripture.pdf/content", "source_filename": "Threads of Sand, Scar & Scripture.pdf", "local_path": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "source_checksum_match": true, "sha256": "314714912e2fef212ea2960c105309c422b13a7d14a2ff2ec350c938c13a31c6", "statement": "Access copy only; no ownership or physical custody transfer is implied." } }, "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Provenance records what is documented and leaves unknown custody and original order explicit." }, { "field": "description_history", "value": [ { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Source-based catalogue description", "note": "Local description assembled from the identified public repository record and available institutional work record. Source metadata remains separately identifiable.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/23395654", "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Qualified descriptive enrichment", "note": "Local editorial description, arrangement and source-qualified bibliographic context recorded alongside source metadata. Unknown or disputed values remain qualified.", "fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/23395654", "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Automated file checksum and PDF inspection", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Digital reading copy verified", "note": "Downloaded access-copy MD5 matched the source checksum; local SHA-256 and PDF file-page count are recorded in the file manifest. This event does not describe transfer of custody.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/api/records/23395654/files/Threads%20of%20Sand,%20Scar%20&%20Scripture.pdf/content" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Description policy and provenance context adopted", "note": "Responsible service, source repository, local access-copy role, unknown custody and original order, correction route and dated description history made explicit under moo-description-policy-1.0.", "sources": [ "policies.html" ] }, { "event_id": "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Unify graph identities and qualify exported relationships and citations", "note": "Local graph projection now uses one contextual identity per entity, distinguishes work-level institutional matches from selected-edition links, retains title-level ISBN uncertainty, and derives citations from the source title. Typed relation assertions and a versioned validation profile are introduced. No publication date, original source snapshot or PDF changed.", "fields": [ "metadata_profile", "relationship_assertions", "identity", "institutional_match_scope", "citation_projection" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Source-based metadata implementation and regression validation", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication, source review or acquisition date", "sources": [ "metadata/metadata-profile.json" ] }, { "event_id": "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Record inspected public ORCID profile evidence", "note": "The official ORCID public person API returned the credited name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website. This confirms a matching public profile, not independently verified biographical or affiliation claims. Original creator arrays and source snapshots are unchanged.", "fields": [ "orcid_authority" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Read-only official public API inspection", "date_kind": "Local authority review and catalogue description event; not a publication or original creation date", "sources": [ "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ] } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Catalogue description events; these are not work publication dates or acquisition dates." }, { "field": "pirr_references", "value": [ { "programme_key": "research-witness-material-memory", "programme_title": "Witness, Material Presence, and Cultural Memory", "programme_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/", "programme_stage": "Continuing research", "registry_url": "research-registry.html#research-witness-material-memory", "identifiers": [ { "scheme": "PIRR project ID", "value": "pir-prj-dd7kt5rw", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/#programme-record" } ], "relation": "Published study associated with the continuing inquiry.", "relation_note": "Published study associated with the continuing inquiry.", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/" }, { "programme_key": "arabic-translation-threads-of-sand", "programme_title": "Threads of Sand: Arabic Translation", "programme_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/arabic-translation-threads-of-sand/", "programme_stage": "In development", "registry_url": "research-registry.html#arabic-translation-threads-of-sand", "identifiers": [ { "scheme": "PIRR programme reference", "value": "moo-program-ccb726880981ccbeb400023c", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/arabic-translation-threads-of-sand/#programme-record" } ], "relation": "Published English-language source edition for translation.", "relation_note": "Published English-language source edition for translation.", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/" }, { "programme_key": "sudanese-art-and-aesthetics", "programme_title": "Sudanese Art and Aesthetics", "programme_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/sudanese-art-and-aesthetics/", "programme_stage": "Continuing research", "registry_url": "research-registry.html#sudanese-art-and-aesthetics", "identifiers": [], "relation": "Published study within the continuing programme.", "relation_note": "Published study within the continuing programme.", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/" } ], "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "PIRR project IDs and programme references identify research records, not publication versions or independent chapter deposits." }, { "field": "relationship_assertions", "value": [ { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:7d3ccaa4c0544d3c1f50c8948b752a948c61106ed585e203f288e66163e37f2e", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23395654.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:9f3c72a22524892c4d67a948806c261493664e751f69e997bc44d64aa3b213f3", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23395654.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:21f8a54f7d71b29119651918cb96280fd57e8ddd819b7bfda3a320d703d57889", "subject": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#describes", "object": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "scope": "exact_edition", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "source_location": { "kind": "metadata_field", "field": "linked_zenodo_dois", "values": [ "10.5281/zenodo.23395654" ] }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "Exact-edition matching requires the selected DOI in the reviewed page metadata; other matches retain their wider scope." } ], "status": "typed_evidence_projection", "note": "Stable, typed assertions retain source scope and explicit unknown review metadata." }, { "field": "reading_copy", "value": { "id": "23395654", "title": "Threads of Sand, Scar & Scripture: Sudanese Art and the Ethics of Witnessing (A Post-Interpretive Study)", "accession": "MOO-CAT-003", "pdf_url": "../assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/23395654/files/Threads%20of%20Sand,%20Scar%20&%20Scripture.pdf/content", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23395654", "source_filename": "Threads of Sand, Scar & Scripture.pdf", "checksum": "md5:46a6f18c00b10acb6753fcda97d91cd8", "sha256": "314714912e2fef212ea2960c105309c422b13a7d14a2ff2ec350c938c13a31c6", "bytes": 1285819, "page_count": 226, "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "checksum_match": true, "rights": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "role": "Local reading copy; original repository file retained unchanged" }, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/23395654/files/Threads%20of%20Sand,%20Scar%20&%20Scripture.pdf/content", "status": "derived_file_inspection", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "note": "Byte-identical local access copy. Source MD5 was recomputed and matched; SHA-256 and page count were measured from the downloaded PDF. This is not a preservation-deposit claim." }, { "field": "page_count", "value": 226, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/23395654/files/Threads%20of%20Sand,%20Scar%20&%20Scripture.pdf/content", "status": "derived_file_inspection", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "note": "Total PDF file pages measured from the deposited file, including cover and unnumbered pages. Not a claim about printed pagination." } ], "entity_links": [ { "id": "dorian-vale", "label": "Dorian Vale", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "author", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author.", "variants": [ "Vale, Dorian" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "museum-of-one", "label": "Museum of One", "entity_type": "Organization", "relation": "publisher", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record.", "variants": [ "MuseumofOne", "MUSEUM OF ONE" ], "evidence_scope": "work" } ], "contents": [ { "title": "Preface", "type": "Preface", "pdf_start": 7, "pdf_end": 10, "printed_start": "v", "printed_end": "viii", "id": "c001", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 7, 10 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 7; contents pages 5–6", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "23395654", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "reference": "MOO-CAT-003/C001", "url": "parts/23395654-c001.html", "reader_url": "read/23395654.html#page=7", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "page_count": 226, "pdf_pages": [ 5, 6 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 1, "title": "The Lens of Origin: The Unwritten Archive, Before Islam, Before Labels", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 11, "printed_start": "1", "id": "c002", "pdf_end": 27, "printed_end": "17", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 11, 27 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 11; contents pages 5–6", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "23395654", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "reference": "MOO-CAT-003/C002", "url": "parts/23395654-c002.html", "reader_url": "read/23395654.html#page=11", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "page_count": 226, "pdf_pages": [ 5, 6 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 2, "title": "The Lens of the Land: River-Cosmology and Desert Intelligence", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 28, "printed_start": "18", "id": "c003", "pdf_end": 47, "printed_end": "37", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 28, 47 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 28; contents pages 5–6", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "23395654", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "reference": "MOO-CAT-003/C003", "url": "parts/23395654-c003.html", "reader_url": "read/23395654.html#page=28", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "page_count": 226, "pdf_pages": [ 5, 6 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 3, "title": "The Lens of the Body: Scar, Pattern, and Totem", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 48, "printed_start": "38", "id": "c004", "pdf_end": 62, "printed_end": "52", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 48, 62 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 48; contents pages 5–6", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "23395654", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "reference": "MOO-CAT-003/C004", "url": "parts/23395654-c004.html", "reader_url": "read/23395654.html#page=48", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "page_count": 226, "pdf_pages": [ 5, 6 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 4, "title": "The Lens of Aftermath: Art After the Border Was Drawn", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 63, "printed_start": "53", "id": "c005", "pdf_end": 78, "printed_end": "68", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 63, 78 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 63; contents pages 5–6", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "23395654", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "reference": "MOO-CAT-003/C005", "url": "parts/23395654-c005.html", "reader_url": "read/23395654.html#page=63", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "page_count": 226, "pdf_pages": [ 5, 6 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 5, "title": "The Lens of Erasure: When Civilizing Became a Curriculum", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 79, "printed_start": "69", "id": "c006", "pdf_end": 95, "printed_end": "85", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 79, 95 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 79; contents pages 5–6", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "23395654", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "reference": "MOO-CAT-003/C006", "url": "parts/23395654-c006.html", "reader_url": "read/23395654.html#page=79", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "page_count": 226, "pdf_pages": [ 5, 6 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 6, "title": "The Lens of Resistance: When Beauty Became a Code", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 96, "printed_start": "86", "id": "c007", "pdf_end": 109, "printed_end": "99", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 96, 109 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 96; contents pages 5–6", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "23395654", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "reference": "MOO-CAT-003/C007", "url": "parts/23395654-c007.html", "reader_url": "read/23395654.html#page=96", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "page_count": 226, "pdf_pages": [ 5, 6 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 7, "title": "The Lens of the Sacred: The Theology of Repetition", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 110, "printed_start": "100", "id": "c008", "pdf_end": 118, "printed_end": "108", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 110, 118 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 110; contents pages 5–6", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "23395654", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "reference": "MOO-CAT-003/C008", "url": "parts/23395654-c008.html", "reader_url": "read/23395654.html#page=110", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "page_count": 226, "pdf_pages": [ 5, 6 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 8, "title": "The Lens of Sand & Scripture: Aesthetic Islam in Sudan", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 119, "printed_start": "109", "id": "c009", "pdf_end": 133, "printed_end": "123", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 119, 133 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 119; contents pages 5–6", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "23395654", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "reference": "MOO-CAT-003/C009", "url": "parts/23395654-c009.html", "reader_url": "read/23395654.html#page=119", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "page_count": 226, "pdf_pages": [ 5, 6 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 9, "title": "The Lens of Oral Memory: The Artwork That Walks Before the Pen", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 134, "printed_start": "124", "id": "c010", "pdf_end": 143, "printed_end": "133", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 134, 143 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 134; contents pages 5–6", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "23395654", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "reference": "MOO-CAT-003/C010", "url": "parts/23395654-c010.html", "reader_url": "read/23395654.html#page=134", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "page_count": 226, "pdf_pages": [ 5, 6 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 10, "title": "The Lens of Architecture: Sudanese Space as Moral Instruction", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 144, "printed_start": "134", "id": "c011", "pdf_end": 153, "printed_end": "143", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 144, 153 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 144; contents pages 5–6", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "23395654", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "reference": "MOO-CAT-003/C011", "url": "parts/23395654-c011.html", "reader_url": "read/23395654.html#page=144", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "page_count": 226, "pdf_pages": [ 5, 6 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 11, "title": "The Lens of Craft: Inheritance in the Hands", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 154, "printed_start": "144", "id": "c012", "pdf_end": 165, "printed_end": "155", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 154, 165 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 154; contents pages 5–6", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "23395654", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "reference": "MOO-CAT-003/C012", "url": "parts/23395654-c012.html", "reader_url": "read/23395654.html#page=154", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "page_count": 226, "pdf_pages": [ 5, 6 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 12, "title": "The Lens of Migration: The Shadow Canon of Diaspora", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 166, "printed_start": "156", "id": "c013", "pdf_end": 179, "printed_end": "169", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 166, 179 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 166; contents pages 5–6", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "23395654", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "reference": "MOO-CAT-003/C013", "url": "parts/23395654-c013.html", "reader_url": "read/23395654.html#page=166", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "page_count": 226, "pdf_pages": [ 5, 6 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 13, "title": "The Lens of Rupture: The Hand Continues", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 180, "printed_start": "170", "id": "c014", "pdf_end": 193, "printed_end": "183", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 180, 193 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 180; contents pages 5–6", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "23395654", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "reference": "MOO-CAT-003/C014", "url": "parts/23395654-c014.html", "reader_url": "read/23395654.html#page=180", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "page_count": 226, "pdf_pages": [ 5, 6 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 14, "title": "The Lens of Silence: Withheld Testimony as Strategy", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 194, "printed_start": "184", "id": "c015", "pdf_end": 206, "printed_end": "196", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 194, 206 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 194; contents pages 5–6", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "23395654", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "reference": "MOO-CAT-003/C015", "url": "parts/23395654-c015.html", "reader_url": "read/23395654.html#page=194", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "page_count": 226, "pdf_pages": [ 5, 6 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 15, "title": "The Lens of the Ghost: What Sudan Tried to Forget", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 207, "printed_start": "197", "id": "c016", "pdf_end": 223, "printed_end": "213", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 207, 223 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 207; contents pages 5–6", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "23395654", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "reference": "MOO-CAT-003/C016", "url": "parts/23395654-c016.html", "reader_url": "read/23395654.html#page=207", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "page_count": 226, "pdf_pages": [ 5, 6 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 16, "title": "Epilogue: The Custodian’s Oath", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 224, "printed_start": "214", "id": "c017", "pdf_end": 225, "printed_end": "215", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 224, 225 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 224; contents pages 5–6", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "23395654", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "reference": "MOO-CAT-003/C017", "url": "parts/23395654-c017.html", "reader_url": "read/23395654.html#page=224", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "page_count": 226, "pdf_pages": [ 5, 6 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "controlled_subjects": [ { "id": "sudanese-art", "label": "Sudanese art", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#sudanese-art", "url": "vocabulary.html#sudanese-art", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:sudanese-art", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Art discussed in relation to Sudan and Sudanese histories or experiences.", "scope_note": "A contextual subject heading, not a statement about any individual’s citizenship or an external geographic authority assignment.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "displacement", "label": "Displacement", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#displacement", "url": "vocabulary.html#displacement", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:displacement", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Dislocation from place or context as a subject of art and critical writing.", "scope_note": "In the current assignment, refers to displacement in the Sudanese art study; do not merge with the author’s named Aesthetic Displacement Theory.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "ethics-of-witnessing", "label": "Ethics of witnessing", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#ethics-of-witnessing", "url": "vocabulary.html#ethics-of-witnessing", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:ethics-of-witnessing", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "ethics of witnessing" ], "definition": "Ethical responsibility in attending to artworks and the histories they engage.", "scope_note": "Local access term used for the Museum of One corpus. Preserve the author’s framework attribution; no equivalence with an external philosophical school is asserted.", "kind": "local-framework-concept", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "post-interpretive-criticism", "witnessing" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "post-interpretive-criticism", "label": "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#post-interpretive-criticism", "url": "vocabulary.html#post-interpretive-criticism", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:post-interpretive-criticism", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "PIC", "Post Interpretive Criticism" ], "definition": "The critical framework named and developed in the Museum of One publications.", "scope_note": "Local named intellectual framework. Used for records explicitly concerned with it; no Getty, Library of Congress, or other external equivalence is asserted.", "kind": "local-framework-concept", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "custodianship", "ethics-of-witnessing", "foundational-writings", "moral-proximity" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "genre_terms": [ { "id": "genre-book", "label": "Book", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#genre-book", "url": "vocabulary.html#genre-book", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:genre-book", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Books", "Digital book" ], "definition": "Book-length publication represented by a deposited digital edition.", "scope_note": "Describes publication genre. The local PDF is not being described as a physical bound volume.", "kind": "genre", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "verified_mapping", "external_mappings": [ { "vocabulary": "Getty Art & Architecture Thesaurus", "label": "books", "uri": "http://vocab.getty.edu/aat/300028051", "source_url": "https://vocab.getty.edu/page/aat/300028051", "relation": "relatedMatch", "status": "verified", "verified_on": "2026-11-04", "note": "Getty’s concept concerns bound physical volumes. It is a related form reference for this digital-publication genre, not an exact equivalence or physical-holdings assertion." } ], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "type", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "vocabulary_version": 4, "description_history": [ { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Source-based catalogue description", "note": "Local description assembled from the identified public repository record and available institutional work record. Source metadata remains separately identifiable.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/23395654", "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Qualified descriptive enrichment", "note": "Local editorial description, arrangement and source-qualified bibliographic context recorded alongside source metadata. Unknown or disputed values remain qualified.", "fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/23395654", "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Automated file checksum and PDF inspection", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Digital reading copy verified", "note": "Downloaded access-copy MD5 matched the source checksum; local SHA-256 and PDF file-page count are recorded in the file manifest. This event does not describe transfer of custody.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/api/records/23395654/files/Threads%20of%20Sand,%20Scar%20&%20Scripture.pdf/content" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Description policy and provenance context adopted", "note": "Responsible service, source repository, local access-copy role, unknown custody and original order, correction route and dated description history made explicit under moo-description-policy-1.0.", "sources": [ "policies.html" ] }, { "event_id": "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Unify graph identities and qualify exported relationships and citations", "note": "Local graph projection now uses one contextual identity per entity, distinguishes work-level institutional matches from selected-edition links, retains title-level ISBN uncertainty, and derives citations from the source title. Typed relation assertions and a versioned validation profile are introduced. No publication date, original source snapshot or PDF changed.", "fields": [ "metadata_profile", "relationship_assertions", "identity", "institutional_match_scope", "citation_projection" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Source-based metadata implementation and regression validation", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication, source review or acquisition date", "sources": [ "metadata/metadata-profile.json" ] }, { "event_id": "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Record inspected public ORCID profile evidence", "note": "The official ORCID public person API returned the credited name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website. This confirms a matching public profile, not independently verified biographical or affiliation claims. Original creator arrays and source snapshots are unchanged.", "fields": [ "orcid_authority" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Read-only official public API inspection", "date_kind": "Local authority review and catalogue description event; not a publication or original creation date", "sources": [ "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ] } ], "record_modified": "2026-11-04", "record_modified_provenance": { "status": "derived_from_description_history", "event_ids": [ "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04" ], "note": "Latest documented local description event; not a publication, repository or source-review date." }, "archival_context": { "description_profile": "moo-description-policy-1.0", "catalogue_snapshot_date": "2026-11-04", "snapshot_note": "Selected catalogue snapshot; not a live repository synchronisation.", "record_category": "Published library and repository material", "reference_code_status": "Stable local catalogue reference; not evidence of an archival acquisition or a previous catalogue accession.", "source_repository": { "name": "Zenodo", "record_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23395654" }, "institutional_context_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "source_metadata_retrieved": "2026-11-04", "source_metadata_retrieval_status": "Documented in catalogue source provenance", "source_snapshot": "source/23395654.json", "source_filenames": [ "Threads of Sand, Scar & Scripture.pdf" ], "selection_basis": "Local descriptive selection of publicly published material; public availability does not establish ownership of originals.", "custodial_history": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No donation, physical transfer, acquisition agreement or chain of custody is documented by this catalogue. Zenodo remains the source repository for the deposited version." }, "original_order": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No original archival order is asserted. Current browsing groupings are local editorial arrangement." }, "arrangement": { "status": "local_editorial", "grouping": "Books & volumes", "statement": "A browsing grouping, not an original fonds or archival series." }, "responsible_service": { "name": "Museum of One", "service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "website": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "email": "research@museumofone.art" }, "description_method": "Source-based description with automated drafting and metadata assistance. Responsibility for the public catalogue rests with Museum of One; automated assistance does not constitute independent scholarly or curatorial review.", "policy_url": "policies.html", "correction_email": "research@museumofone.art", "access_copy": { "role": "Local digital reading copy of the deposited file", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/23395654/files/Threads%20of%20Sand,%20Scar%20&%20Scripture.pdf/content", "source_filename": "Threads of Sand, Scar & Scripture.pdf", "local_path": "assets/documents/23395654.pdf", "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "source_checksum_match": true, "sha256": "314714912e2fef212ea2960c105309c422b13a7d14a2ff2ec350c938c13a31c6", "statement": "Access copy only; no ownership or physical custody transfer is implied." } }, "description_policy_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "pirr_references": [ { "programme_key": "research-witness-material-memory", "programme_title": "Witness, Material Presence, and Cultural Memory", "programme_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/", "programme_stage": "Continuing research", "registry_url": "research-registry.html#research-witness-material-memory", "identifiers": [ { "scheme": "PIRR project ID", "value": "pir-prj-dd7kt5rw", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/#programme-record" } ], "relation": "Published study associated with the continuing inquiry.", "relation_note": "Published study associated with the continuing inquiry.", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/" }, { "programme_key": "arabic-translation-threads-of-sand", "programme_title": "Threads of Sand: Arabic Translation", "programme_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/arabic-translation-threads-of-sand/", "programme_stage": "In development", "registry_url": "research-registry.html#arabic-translation-threads-of-sand", "identifiers": [ { "scheme": "PIRR programme reference", "value": "moo-program-ccb726880981ccbeb400023c", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/arabic-translation-threads-of-sand/#programme-record" } ], "relation": "Published English-language source edition for translation.", "relation_note": "Published English-language source edition for translation.", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/" }, { "programme_key": "sudanese-art-and-aesthetics", "programme_title": "Sudanese Art and Aesthetics", "programme_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/sudanese-art-and-aesthetics/", "programme_stage": "Continuing research", "registry_url": "research-registry.html#sudanese-art-and-aesthetics", "identifiers": [], "relation": "Published study within the continuing programme.", "relation_note": "Published study within the continuing programme.", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/" } ], "pirr_work_identity": { "archive_reference": "MOO-CAT-003", "edition_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "zenodo_record_id": "23395654", "identifier_scope": "Publication identity; PIRR identifiers in programme relationships identify research records, not this publication." }, "metadata_origin": "https://archive.museumofone.art", "identity": { "work": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23395654.html#work", "edition": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "version_family": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19207069", "catalogue_record": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23395654.html#catalogue-record" }, "institutional_match_scope": "exact_edition", "relationship_assertions": [ { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:7d3ccaa4c0544d3c1f50c8948b752a948c61106ed585e203f288e66163e37f2e", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23395654.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:9f3c72a22524892c4d67a948806c261493664e751f69e997bc44d64aa3b213f3", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23395654.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:21f8a54f7d71b29119651918cb96280fd57e8ddd819b7bfda3a320d703d57889", "subject": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#describes", "object": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23395654", "scope": "exact_edition", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-threads-of-sand/", "source_location": { "kind": "metadata_field", "field": "linked_zenodo_dois", "values": [ "10.5281/zenodo.23395654" ] }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "Exact-edition matching requires the selected DOI in the reviewed page metadata; other matches retain their wider scope." } ], "orcid_authority": { "scheme": "ORCID", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "evidence_urls": [ "https://www.museumofone.art/archives-scholarly-infrastructure/", "https://eprints.rclis.org/47182/", "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ], "access_note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "evidence_receipt": "data/source/authority-review-2026-11-04.json" } }, { "id": "20383926", "accession": "MOO-CAT-004", "title": "The Moral Evidence of Space: Architecture, Power, and the Ethics of Witnessing (A Post-Interpretive Study)", "source_title": "The Moral Evidence of Space: Architecture, Power, and the Ethics of Witnessing (A Post-Interpretive Study)", "short_title": "The Moral Evidence of Space", "author": "Dorian Vale", "creators": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "affiliation": "Museum of One", "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094" } ], "doi": "10.5281/zenodo.20383926", "conceptdoi": "10.5281/zenodo.20095467", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20383926", "date": "2026-05-09", "type": "Book", "source_resource_type": { "title": "Book", "type": "publication", "subtype": "book" }, "version": "", "collection": "Books & volumes", "summary": "A book-length study of architecture as a condition of bodily experience, authority, and ethical encounter. It extends Post-Interpretive Criticism to scale, light, thresholds, surveillance, and access.", "subjects": [ "Architecture", "Spatial experience", "Power and institutions", "Ethics of witnessing" ], "keywords": [ "architecture", "spatial ethics", "phenomenology", "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "ethics of witnessing", "built environment" ], "license": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "files": [ { "name": "The Moral Evidance of Space.pdf", "url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/20383926/files/The%20Moral%20Evidance%20of%20Space.pdf/content", "size": 2713642, "size_label": "2650 KB", "checksum": "md5:23cdeec1af0577374dc9b05cb22a8f2e", "mimetype": "application/pdf" } ], "institutional_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "corroboration": "Museum of One’s matching publication page confirms Dorian Vale’s authorship and the work’s institutional context. It links the selected Zenodo edition DOI. Web-record dates are not treated as dates of the deposited edition. Source review: 4 November 2026.", "discrepancies": [ "The institutional publication register may cite the version-family DOI. This record cites the selected deposited edition DOI and identifies the concept DOI separately." ], "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "publisher": "Museum of One", "language": null, "isbn": "978-1-06-982034-1", "related_identifiers": [], "alternate_identifiers": [ { "identifier": "978-1-06-982034-1" } ], "source_references": [], "source_journal": null, "source_imprint": null, "source_contributors": [ { "name": "Museum of One", "affiliation": null, "type": "HostingInstitution" } ], "source_created": "2026-05-25T17:57:02.477362+00:00", "source_modified": "2026-10-15T23:24:10.711327+00:00", "source_description_html": "

The Moral Evidence of Space: Architecture, Power, and the Ethics of Witnessing by Dorian Vale is a major philosophical and architectural treatise that expands the framework of Post-Interpretive Criticism into the spatial domain, arguing that architecture must be understood not merely as aesthetic production or functional design, but as a system of moral choreography acting directly upon the human body. Drawing from architectural history, phenomenology, spatial theory, ethics, theology, and critical aesthetics, the book proposes that built environments do not simply contain human life; they actively shape posture, perception, obedience, dignity, and emotional possibility.

\n

Rejecting the interpretive traditions that reduce architecture to symbolism, style, or semiotic analysis, Vale develops a witness-based methodology centered on bodily testimony and spatial encounter. The text argues that space operates prior to language and often beyond conscious interpretation, producing ethical and psychological effects before the inhabitant can conceptualize them. From Paleolithic caves and Mesopotamian ziggurats to Gothic cathedrals, imperial complexes, corporate glass towers, hospitals, prisons, welfare offices, and public housing projects, the book traces an unbroken lineage of spatial systems that choreograph human behavior through scale, light, threshold, surveillance, circulation, elevation, enclosure, and access.

\n

Central to the work is the claim that architecture is the oldest technology of moral formation. The text reframes buildings not as neutral containers but as active ethical agents that distribute visibility, shame, reverence, exclusion, and belonging through material conditions. Vale introduces concepts such as “moral choreography,” “custodial space,” “architectures of obedience,” and “space as moral evidence,” arguing that the body itself functions as the primary archive of architectural truth. Against traditions of detached architectural interpretation, the book positions testimony, presence, restraint, and witness as the proper ethical stance of criticism.

\n

The work also critiques the modern fiction of neutral design, exposing how institutional and bureaucratic architectures frequently disguise systems of behavioral control beneath the language of efficiency, transparency, optimization, and functionality. By examining how spatial arrangements condition emotional and social realities, the book situates architecture within broader questions of governance, hierarchy, surveillance, ritual, and power. Simultaneously, it identifies counter-traditions of custodial architecture—spaces designed not to dominate the body but to shelter dignity, contemplation, and human presence.

\n

Blending philosophical inquiry with literary prose, The Moral Evidence of Space establishes a new branch of Post-Interpretive Criticism focused on spatial ethics and the phenomenology of built environments. It positions architecture not as a passive backdrop to history but as one of the primary forces through which civilizations produce forms of subjectivity, obedience, exclusion, and transcendence. The book contributes to contemporary debates in architecture, critical theory, aesthetics, urban studies, museum studies, phenomenology, and ethics by proposing a new framework for understanding how space acts upon human beings before interpretation begins.

\n

First published by Museum of One in 2026. Stable work DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.20095467

", "provenance": { "repository": "Zenodo REST API response supplied in query.json", "retrieved": "2026-11-04", "editorial_fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "source_snapshot": "source/20383926.json", "institutional_review": "Reviewed page-level title, author and repository links in saved public institutional HTML, 2026-11-04." }, "cover": "assets/moral-evidence-space.jpg", "cover_alt": "Published cover of The Moral Evidence of Space: Architecture, Power, and the Ethics of Witnessing (A Post-Interpretive Study)", "cover_source": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "source_review": "2026-11-04", "relations": [], "first_edition": "First edition; institutional publication date 2026-05-09", "institutional_metadata": { "title": "The Moral Evidence of Space", "author": "Dorian Vale", "web_publication": "2026-10-14T00:00:00.000Z", "web_updated": "2026-10-17T16:53:59.000Z", "linked_zenodo_dois": [ "10.5281/zenodo.20383926" ], "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "publication_title": "The Moral Evidence of Space", "publication_status": "Published book; first-edition PDF, 9 May 2026", "publication_date": "2026-05-09", "edition": "First edition" }, "research_programmes": [ { "title": "Witness, Material Presence, and Cultural Memory", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/", "status": "Continuing research", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "relation": "Published study associated with the continuing inquiry.", "relation_label": "Published study associated with the continuing inquiry." } ], "edition_statement": "First-edition PDF, first published 9 May 2026 (Museum of One publication record)", "record_level": "Item", "record_status": "Published source; selected catalogue record", "digital_formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "extent": "1 digital file; 2713642 bytes", "medium": "Digital document", "record_reviewed": "2026-11-04", "date_precision": "day", "alternate_titles": [ { "title": "The Moral Evidence of Space", "kind": "institutional_web_record_title", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/" } ], "digital_extent": { "file_count": 1, "total_bytes": 2713642, "formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "checksums": [ { "filename": "The Moral Evidance of Space.pdf", "algorithm": "md5", "value": "23cdeec1af0577374dc9b05cb22a8f2e", "syntax_valid": true, "verification": "source_checksum_transcription; bytes not independently recomputed" } ], "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20383926", "derivation": "File count and total bytes calculated from repository file metadata; MIME inferred from filename when absent." }, "identifier_validation": { "orcid": { "source_value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "ISO 7064 MOD 11-2 checksum only; this is not a live registry verification." }, "isbn": [ { "source_value": "978-1-06-982034-1", "normalized": "9781069820341", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "Checksum validation tests the identifier syntax only; it does not verify assignment, format or edition applicability.", "scope": "title_level_book_identifier; format applicability follows edition source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20383926" } ], "doi": { "source_value": "10.5281/zenodo.20383926", "syntax_valid": true, "note": "Syntax check only; repository snapshot supplies the identifier." } }, "isbn_applicability": "title_level_book_identifier", "serial": null, "contributor_roles": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": "Museum of One", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20383926" }, { "name": "Museum of One", "source_category": "contributor", "source_role": "HostingInstitution", "role_label": "HostingInstitution", "affiliation_as_supplied": null, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20383926" } ], "authority_links": [ { "title": "BiblioBoard catalogue access", "url": "https://library.biblioboard.com/content/fca202e1-3b5b-4ef4-a29c-00127b2bda84", "kind": "catalogue_access", "status": "institutional_link_access_restricted", "evidence_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-discovery-and-archive-sources/", "note": "Format, edition and ISBN not independently inspectable.", "scope": "Bibliographic context; inspect source for edition applicability", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-discovery-and-archive-sources/" }, { "title": "PhilArchive bibliographic record", "url": "https://philarchive.org/rec/VALTME-3", "kind": "repository_record", "status": "record_metadata_observed_in_search_index", "scope": "Bibliographic context; inspect source for edition applicability", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/" } ], "metadata_profile": { "name": "Museum of One source-qualified catalogue profile", "version": "3.0.0", "url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/metadata-profile.json", "source_snapshot_preserved": true }, "reading_copy": { "id": "20383926", "title": "The Moral Evidence of Space: Architecture, Power, and the Ethics of Witnessing (A Post-Interpretive Study)", "accession": "MOO-CAT-004", "pdf_url": "../assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/20383926/files/The%20Moral%20Evidance%20of%20Space.pdf/content", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20383926", "source_filename": "The Moral Evidance of Space.pdf", "checksum": "md5:23cdeec1af0577374dc9b05cb22a8f2e", "sha256": "49a76d86a81fc40c6baec3429cfb21c47582a35414f4715504d2c239b5fca5f7", "bytes": 2713642, "page_count": 196, "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "checksum_match": true, "rights": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "role": "Local reading copy; original repository file retained unchanged" }, "page_count": 196, "field_assertions": [ { "field": "title", "value": "The Moral Evidence of Space: Architecture, Power, and the Ethics of Witnessing (A Post-Interpretive Study)", "status": "catalogue_title", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "note": "Local display title; the deposited title is retained separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_title", "value": "The Moral Evidence of Space: Architecture, Power, and the Ethics of Witnessing (A Post-Interpretive Study)", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20383926", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "doi", "value": "10.5281/zenodo.20383926", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20383926", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "date", "value": "2026-05-09", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20383926", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "conceptdoi", "value": "10.5281/zenodo.20095467", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20383926", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "creators", "value": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "affiliation": "Museum of One", "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20383926", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "keywords", "value": [ "architecture", "spatial ethics", "phenomenology", "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "ethics of witnessing", "built environment" ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20383926", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "license", "value": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20383926", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "files", "value": [ { "name": "The Moral Evidance of Space.pdf", "url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/20383926/files/The%20Moral%20Evidance%20of%20Space.pdf/content", "size": 2713642, "size_label": "2650 KB", "checksum": "md5:23cdeec1af0577374dc9b05cb22a8f2e", "mimetype": "application/pdf" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20383926", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_created", "value": "2026-05-25T17:57:02.477362+00:00", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20383926", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_modified", "value": "2026-10-15T23:24:10.711327+00:00", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20383926", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "record_modified", "value": "2026-11-04", "status": "derived_from_description_history", "note": "Latest documented local description event; not a publication, repository or source-review date.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_review", "value": "2026-11-04", "status": "catalogue_source_review", "note": "Review of descriptive sources; not the creation or modification date of the work or repository record.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "author", "value": "Dorian Vale", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "note": "Institutional responsibility statement; original repository creator roles remain separate.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "publisher", "value": "Museum of One", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "note": "Institutional responsibility statement; original repository creator roles remain separate.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "first_edition", "value": "First edition; institutional publication date 2026-05-09", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "note": "Consult the linked edition record; a repository version is not a new book edition.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "edition_statement", "value": "First-edition PDF, first published 9 May 2026 (Museum of One publication record)", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "note": "Consult the linked edition record; a repository version is not a new book edition.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "isbn", "value": "978-1-06-982034-1", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "note": "Consult the linked edition record; a repository version is not a new book edition.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "orcid", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "source_linked_identifier", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "note": "Creator identifier supplied by the linked sources; no affiliation or endorsement is inferred.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "orcid_authority", "value": { "scheme": "ORCID", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "evidence_urls": [ "https://www.museumofone.art/archives-scholarly-infrastructure/", "https://eprints.rclis.org/47182/", "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ], "access_note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "evidence_receipt": "data/source/authority-review-2026-11-04.json" }, "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "source_url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "summary", "value": "A book-length study of architecture as a condition of bodily experience, authority, and ethical encounter. It extends Post-Interpretive Criticism to scale, light, thresholds, surveillance, and access.", "status": "editorial_enrichment", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "note": "Catalogue-editor summary based on the linked work; not an original publisher abstract.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "subjects", "value": [ "Architecture", "Spatial experience", "Power and institutions", "Ethics of witnessing" ], "status": "editorial_enrichment", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "note": "Local discovery terms; no controlled-vocabulary assignment is claimed.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "collection", "value": "Books & volumes", "status": "editorial_grouping", "note": "A local browsing collection, not an original repository collection.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "corroboration", "value": "Museum of One’s matching publication page confirms Dorian Vale’s authorship and the work’s institutional context. It links the selected Zenodo edition DOI. Web-record dates are not treated as dates of the deposited edition. Source review: 4 November 2026.", "status": "catalogue_review_note", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "discrepancies", "value": [ "The institutional publication register may cite the version-family DOI. This record cites the selected deposited edition DOI and identifies the concept DOI separately." ], "status": "catalogue_review_note", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "alternate_titles", "value": [ { "title": "The Moral Evidence of Space", "kind": "institutional_web_record_title", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/" } ], "status": "source_qualified_title_variants", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "note": "Each variant retains its own source and scope; a web page title is not a title-page transcription.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "date_precision", "value": "day", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20383926", "note": "Precision reported exactly as supplied; missing month or day is not filled.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "medium", "value": "Digital document", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20383926", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "digital_formats", "value": [ "application/pdf" ], "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20383926", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "extent", "value": "1 digital file; 2713642 bytes", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20383926", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "digital_extent", "value": { "file_count": 1, "total_bytes": 2713642, "formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "checksums": [ { "filename": "The Moral Evidance of Space.pdf", "algorithm": "md5", "value": "23cdeec1af0577374dc9b05cb22a8f2e", "syntax_valid": true, "verification": "source_checksum_transcription; bytes not independently recomputed" } ], "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20383926", "derivation": "File count and total bytes calculated from repository file metadata; MIME inferred from filename when absent." }, "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20383926", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "identifier_validation", "value": { "orcid": { "source_value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "ISO 7064 MOD 11-2 checksum only; this is not a live registry verification." }, "isbn": [ { "source_value": "978-1-06-982034-1", "normalized": "9781069820341", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "Checksum validation tests the identifier syntax only; it does not verify assignment, format or edition applicability.", "scope": "title_level_book_identifier; format applicability follows edition source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20383926" } ], "doi": { "source_value": "10.5281/zenodo.20383926", "syntax_valid": true, "note": "Syntax check only; repository snapshot supplies the identifier." } }, "status": "local_syntax_validation", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20383926", "note": "Checksum/syntax validation does not verify registration, assignment or edition applicability.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "contributor_roles", "value": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": "Museum of One", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20383926" }, { "name": "Museum of One", "source_category": "contributor", "source_role": "HostingInstitution", "role_label": "HostingInstitution", "affiliation_as_supplied": null, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20383926" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20383926", "note": "Creator and contributor roles are transcribed, not inferred from names or affiliations.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "authority_links", "value": [ { "title": "BiblioBoard catalogue access", "url": "https://library.biblioboard.com/content/fca202e1-3b5b-4ef4-a29c-00127b2bda84", "kind": "catalogue_access", "status": "institutional_link_access_restricted", "evidence_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-discovery-and-archive-sources/", "note": "Format, edition and ISBN not independently inspectable.", "scope": "Bibliographic context; inspect source for edition applicability", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-discovery-and-archive-sources/" }, { "title": "PhilArchive bibliographic record", "url": "https://philarchive.org/rec/VALTME-3", "kind": "repository_record", "status": "record_metadata_observed_in_search_index", "scope": "Bibliographic context; inspect source for edition applicability", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/" } ], "status": "source_qualified_external_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "note": "External records have separate status and edition scope; links are not endorsements or equivalence assertions.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "research_programme:https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/", "value": { "title": "Witness, Material Presence, and Cultural Memory", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/", "status": "Continuing research", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "relation": "Published study associated with the continuing inquiry.", "relation_label": "Published study associated with the continuing inquiry." }, "status": "institutional_work_relationship", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "note": "Programme relationship and stage follow the work-specific institutional badge; publication does not imply a completed programme or collaboration.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "entity_link:dorian-vale:author", "value": { "id": "dorian-vale", "label": "Dorian Vale", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "author", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author.", "variants": [ "Vale, Dorian" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:7515d7cd47fee770bc43022acc8ce8fc3d252885b11eedf418a0b962d85dd00c", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/20383926.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." } }, { "field": "entity_link:museum-of-one:publisher", "value": { "id": "museum-of-one", "label": "Museum of One", "entity_type": "Organization", "relation": "publisher", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record.", "variants": [ "MuseumofOne", "MUSEUM OF ONE" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:c50559322dabd2b8ca28f9d0284f0ffa3c93ff5a1025c6552cf7faa81737504e", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/20383926.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." } }, { "field": "contents", "value": [ { "title": "Preface", "type": "Preface", "pdf_start": 6, "pdf_end": 8, "printed_start": "iv", "printed_end": "vi", "id": "c001", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 6, 8 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 6; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "20383926", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.20383926", "reference": "MOO-CAT-004/C001", "url": "parts/20383926-c001.html", "reader_url": "read/20383926.html#page=6", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "page_count": 196, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 1, "title": "Introduction", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 9, "printed_start": "1", "id": "c002", "pdf_end": 22, "printed_end": "14", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 9, 22 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 9; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "20383926", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.20383926", "reference": "MOO-CAT-004/C002", "url": "parts/20383926-c002.html", "reader_url": "read/20383926.html#page=9", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "page_count": 196, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 2, "title": "The Moral Birth of Spaces", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 23, "printed_start": "15", "id": "c003", "pdf_end": 36, "printed_end": "28", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 23, 36 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 23; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "20383926", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.20383926", "reference": "MOO-CAT-004/C003", "url": "parts/20383926-c003.html", "reader_url": "read/20383926.html#page=23", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "page_count": 196, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 3, "title": "The Choreographers: A Lineage of Power", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 37, "printed_start": "29", "id": "c004", "pdf_end": 51, "printed_end": "43", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 37, 51 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 37; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "20383926", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.20383926", "reference": "MOO-CAT-004/C004", "url": "parts/20383926-c004.html", "reader_url": "read/20383926.html#page=37", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "page_count": 196, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 4, "title": "The Body as the First Blueprint", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 52, "printed_start": "44", "id": "c005", "pdf_end": 66, "printed_end": "58", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 52, 66 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 52; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "20383926", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.20383926", "reference": "MOO-CAT-004/C005", "url": "parts/20383926-c005.html", "reader_url": "read/20383926.html#page=52", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "page_count": 196, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 5, "title": "The Architecture of Shame", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 67, "printed_start": "59", "id": "c006", "pdf_end": 81, "printed_end": "73", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 67, 81 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 67; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "20383926", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.20383926", "reference": "MOO-CAT-004/C006", "url": "parts/20383926-c006.html", "reader_url": "read/20383926.html#page=67", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "page_count": 196, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 6, "title": "The Architecture of Obedience", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 82, "printed_start": "74", "id": "c007", "pdf_end": 97, "printed_end": "89", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 82, 97 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 82; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "20383926", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.20383926", "reference": "MOO-CAT-004/C007", "url": "parts/20383926-c007.html", "reader_url": "read/20383926.html#page=82", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "page_count": 196, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 7, "title": "The Architecture of Awe", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 98, "printed_start": "90", "id": "c008", "pdf_end": 112, "printed_end": "104", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 98, 112 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 98; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "20383926", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.20383926", "reference": "MOO-CAT-004/C008", "url": "parts/20383926-c008.html", "reader_url": "read/20383926.html#page=98", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "page_count": 196, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 8, "title": "Space as Moral Evidence", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 113, "printed_start": "105", "id": "c009", "pdf_end": 129, "printed_end": "121", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 113, 129 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 113; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "20383926", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.20383926", "reference": "MOO-CAT-004/C009", "url": "parts/20383926-c009.html", "reader_url": "read/20383926.html#page=113", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "page_count": 196, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 9, "title": "Against Interpretation: The Ethical Stance", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 130, "printed_start": "122", "id": "c010", "pdf_end": 147, "printed_end": "139", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 130, 147 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 130; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "20383926", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.20383926", "reference": "MOO-CAT-004/C010", "url": "parts/20383926-c010.html", "reader_url": "read/20383926.html#page=130", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "page_count": 196, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 10, "title": "The Ethics of Custodial Space", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 148, "printed_start": "140", "id": "c011", "pdf_end": 162, "printed_end": "154", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 148, 162 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 148; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "20383926", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.20383926", "reference": "MOO-CAT-004/C011", "url": "parts/20383926-c011.html", "reader_url": "read/20383926.html#page=148", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "page_count": 196, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 11, "title": "The Critic as Witness", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 163, "printed_start": "155", "id": "c012", "pdf_end": 175, "printed_end": "167", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 163, 175 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 163; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "20383926", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.20383926", "reference": "MOO-CAT-004/C012", "url": "parts/20383926-c012.html", "reader_url": "read/20383926.html#page=163", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "page_count": 196, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 12, "title": "The Post-Interpretive Doctrine", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 176, "printed_start": "168", "id": "c013", "pdf_end": 189, "printed_end": "181", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 176, 189 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 176; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "20383926", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.20383926", "reference": "MOO-CAT-004/C013", "url": "parts/20383926-c013.html", "reader_url": "read/20383926.html#page=176", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "page_count": 196, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 13, "title": "The Benedict", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 190, "printed_start": "182", "id": "c014", "pdf_end": 196, "printed_end": "188", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 190, 196 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 190; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "20383926", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.20383926", "reference": "MOO-CAT-004/C014", "url": "parts/20383926-c014.html", "reader_url": "read/20383926.html#page=190", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "page_count": 196, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/20383926/files/The%20Moral%20Evidance%20of%20Space.pdf/content", "status": "derived_file_inspection", "note": "Analytic descriptions were checked against headings and pagination in the deposited PDF. Component records do not have independent deposits or DOIs." }, { "field": "controlled_subjects", "value": [ { "id": "architecture", "label": "Architecture", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#architecture", "url": "vocabulary.html#architecture", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:architecture", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Buildings and the built environment as subjects of critical study.", "scope_note": "Use for the subject of a publication, not to classify the deposited document as a building.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "power-and-institutions", "spatial-experience" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "spatial-experience", "label": "Spatial experience", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#spatial-experience", "url": "vocabulary.html#spatial-experience", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:spatial-experience", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Bodily and perceptual experience of built or arranged space.", "scope_note": "Use for critical study of scale, light, thresholds, and access; related to Architecture and Exhibition design.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "architecture", "exhibition-design" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "power-and-institutions", "label": "Power and institutions", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#power-and-institutions", "url": "vocabulary.html#power-and-institutions", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:power-and-institutions", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Relations of authority as exercised through institutional structures and spaces.", "scope_note": "Use for inquiry into access, surveillance, ordering, and authority; not an institutional affiliation field.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "architecture" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "ethics-of-witnessing", "label": "Ethics of witnessing", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#ethics-of-witnessing", "url": "vocabulary.html#ethics-of-witnessing", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:ethics-of-witnessing", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "ethics of witnessing" ], "definition": "Ethical responsibility in attending to artworks and the histories they engage.", "scope_note": "Local access term used for the Museum of One corpus. Preserve the author’s framework attribution; no equivalence with an external philosophical school is asserted.", "kind": "local-framework-concept", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "post-interpretive-criticism", "witnessing" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Local preferred terms with definitions and synonyms. External alignment is scoped in the vocabulary register." }, { "field": "genre_terms", "value": [ { "id": "genre-book", "label": "Book", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#genre-book", "url": "vocabulary.html#genre-book", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:genre-book", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Books", "Digital book" ], "definition": "Book-length publication represented by a deposited digital edition.", "scope_note": "Describes publication genre. The local PDF is not being described as a physical bound volume.", "kind": "genre", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "verified_mapping", "external_mappings": [ { "vocabulary": "Getty Art & Architecture Thesaurus", "label": "books", "uri": "http://vocab.getty.edu/aat/300028051", "source_url": "https://vocab.getty.edu/page/aat/300028051", "relation": "relatedMatch", "status": "verified", "verified_on": "2026-11-04", "note": "Getty’s concept concerns bound physical volumes. It is a related form reference for this digital-publication genre, not an exact equivalence or physical-holdings assertion." } ], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "type", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Local resource-genre classification. Digital file format is recorded separately." }, { "field": "archival_context", "value": { "description_profile": "moo-description-policy-1.0", "catalogue_snapshot_date": "2026-11-04", "snapshot_note": "Selected catalogue snapshot; not a live repository synchronisation.", "record_category": "Published library and repository material", "reference_code_status": "Stable local catalogue reference; not evidence of an archival acquisition or a previous catalogue accession.", "source_repository": { "name": "Zenodo", "record_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20383926" }, "institutional_context_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "source_metadata_retrieved": "2026-11-04", "source_metadata_retrieval_status": "Documented in catalogue source provenance", "source_snapshot": "source/20383926.json", "source_filenames": [ "The Moral Evidance of Space.pdf" ], "selection_basis": "Local descriptive selection of publicly published material; public availability does not establish ownership of originals.", "custodial_history": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No donation, physical transfer, acquisition agreement or chain of custody is documented by this catalogue. Zenodo remains the source repository for the deposited version." }, "original_order": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No original archival order is asserted. Current browsing groupings are local editorial arrangement." }, "arrangement": { "status": "local_editorial", "grouping": "Books & volumes", "statement": "A browsing grouping, not an original fonds or archival series." }, "responsible_service": { "name": "Museum of One", "service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "website": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "email": "research@museumofone.art" }, "description_method": "Source-based description with automated drafting and metadata assistance. Responsibility for the public catalogue rests with Museum of One; automated assistance does not constitute independent scholarly or curatorial review.", "policy_url": "policies.html", "correction_email": "research@museumofone.art", "access_copy": { "role": "Local digital reading copy of the deposited file", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/20383926/files/The%20Moral%20Evidance%20of%20Space.pdf/content", "source_filename": "The Moral Evidance of Space.pdf", "local_path": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "source_checksum_match": true, "sha256": "49a76d86a81fc40c6baec3429cfb21c47582a35414f4715504d2c239b5fca5f7", "statement": "Access copy only; no ownership or physical custody transfer is implied." } }, "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Provenance records what is documented and leaves unknown custody and original order explicit." }, { "field": "description_history", "value": [ { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Source-based catalogue description", "note": "Local description assembled from the identified public repository record and available institutional work record. Source metadata remains separately identifiable.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/20383926", "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Qualified descriptive enrichment", "note": "Local editorial description, arrangement and source-qualified bibliographic context recorded alongside source metadata. Unknown or disputed values remain qualified.", "fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/20383926", "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Automated file checksum and PDF inspection", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Digital reading copy verified", "note": "Downloaded access-copy MD5 matched the source checksum; local SHA-256 and PDF file-page count are recorded in the file manifest. This event does not describe transfer of custody.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/api/records/20383926/files/The%20Moral%20Evidance%20of%20Space.pdf/content" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Description policy and provenance context adopted", "note": "Responsible service, source repository, local access-copy role, unknown custody and original order, correction route and dated description history made explicit under moo-description-policy-1.0.", "sources": [ "policies.html" ] }, { "event_id": "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Unify graph identities and qualify exported relationships and citations", "note": "Local graph projection now uses one contextual identity per entity, distinguishes work-level institutional matches from selected-edition links, retains title-level ISBN uncertainty, and derives citations from the source title. Typed relation assertions and a versioned validation profile are introduced. No publication date, original source snapshot or PDF changed.", "fields": [ "metadata_profile", "relationship_assertions", "identity", "institutional_match_scope", "citation_projection" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Source-based metadata implementation and regression validation", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication, source review or acquisition date", "sources": [ "metadata/metadata-profile.json" ] }, { "event_id": "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Record inspected public ORCID profile evidence", "note": "The official ORCID public person API returned the credited name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website. This confirms a matching public profile, not independently verified biographical or affiliation claims. Original creator arrays and source snapshots are unchanged.", "fields": [ "orcid_authority" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Read-only official public API inspection", "date_kind": "Local authority review and catalogue description event; not a publication or original creation date", "sources": [ "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ] } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Catalogue description events; these are not work publication dates or acquisition dates." }, { "field": "pirr_references", "value": [ { "programme_key": "research-witness-material-memory", "programme_title": "Witness, Material Presence, and Cultural Memory", "programme_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/", "programme_stage": "Continuing research", "registry_url": "research-registry.html#research-witness-material-memory", "identifiers": [ { "scheme": "PIRR project ID", "value": "pir-prj-dd7kt5rw", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/#programme-record" } ], "relation": "Published study associated with the continuing inquiry.", "relation_note": "Published study associated with the continuing inquiry.", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/" } ], "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "PIRR project IDs and programme references identify research records, not publication versions or independent chapter deposits." }, { "field": "relationship_assertions", "value": [ { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:7515d7cd47fee770bc43022acc8ce8fc3d252885b11eedf418a0b962d85dd00c", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/20383926.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:c50559322dabd2b8ca28f9d0284f0ffa3c93ff5a1025c6552cf7faa81737504e", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/20383926.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:67fe5f9df7dc5028e835bb11f9eebbc1977bd7145ef2c2ccab6186b95fed5e00", "subject": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#describes", "object": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20383926", "scope": "exact_edition", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "source_location": { "kind": "metadata_field", "field": "linked_zenodo_dois", "values": [ "10.5281/zenodo.20383926" ] }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "Exact-edition matching requires the selected DOI in the reviewed page metadata; other matches retain their wider scope." } ], "status": "typed_evidence_projection", "note": "Stable, typed assertions retain source scope and explicit unknown review metadata." }, { "field": "reading_copy", "value": { "id": "20383926", "title": "The Moral Evidence of Space: Architecture, Power, and the Ethics of Witnessing (A Post-Interpretive Study)", "accession": "MOO-CAT-004", "pdf_url": "../assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/20383926/files/The%20Moral%20Evidance%20of%20Space.pdf/content", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20383926", "source_filename": "The Moral Evidance of Space.pdf", "checksum": "md5:23cdeec1af0577374dc9b05cb22a8f2e", "sha256": "49a76d86a81fc40c6baec3429cfb21c47582a35414f4715504d2c239b5fca5f7", "bytes": 2713642, "page_count": 196, "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "checksum_match": true, "rights": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "role": "Local reading copy; original repository file retained unchanged" }, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/20383926/files/The%20Moral%20Evidance%20of%20Space.pdf/content", "status": "derived_file_inspection", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "note": "Byte-identical local access copy. Source MD5 was recomputed and matched; SHA-256 and page count were measured from the downloaded PDF. This is not a preservation-deposit claim." }, { "field": "page_count", "value": 196, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/20383926/files/The%20Moral%20Evidance%20of%20Space.pdf/content", "status": "derived_file_inspection", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "note": "Total PDF file pages measured from the deposited file, including cover and unnumbered pages. Not a claim about printed pagination." } ], "entity_links": [ { "id": "dorian-vale", "label": "Dorian Vale", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "author", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author.", "variants": [ "Vale, Dorian" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "museum-of-one", "label": "Museum of One", "entity_type": "Organization", "relation": "publisher", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record.", "variants": [ "MuseumofOne", "MUSEUM OF ONE" ], "evidence_scope": "work" } ], "contents": [ { "title": "Preface", "type": "Preface", "pdf_start": 6, "pdf_end": 8, "printed_start": "iv", "printed_end": "vi", "id": "c001", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 6, 8 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 6; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "20383926", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.20383926", "reference": "MOO-CAT-004/C001", "url": "parts/20383926-c001.html", "reader_url": "read/20383926.html#page=6", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "page_count": 196, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 1, "title": "Introduction", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 9, "printed_start": "1", "id": "c002", "pdf_end": 22, "printed_end": "14", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 9, 22 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 9; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "20383926", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.20383926", "reference": "MOO-CAT-004/C002", "url": "parts/20383926-c002.html", "reader_url": "read/20383926.html#page=9", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "page_count": 196, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 2, "title": "The Moral Birth of Spaces", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 23, "printed_start": "15", "id": "c003", "pdf_end": 36, "printed_end": "28", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 23, 36 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 23; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "20383926", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.20383926", "reference": "MOO-CAT-004/C003", "url": "parts/20383926-c003.html", "reader_url": "read/20383926.html#page=23", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "page_count": 196, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 3, "title": "The Choreographers: A Lineage of Power", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 37, "printed_start": "29", "id": "c004", "pdf_end": 51, "printed_end": "43", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 37, 51 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 37; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "20383926", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.20383926", "reference": "MOO-CAT-004/C004", "url": "parts/20383926-c004.html", "reader_url": "read/20383926.html#page=37", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "page_count": 196, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 4, "title": "The Body as the First Blueprint", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 52, "printed_start": "44", "id": "c005", "pdf_end": 66, "printed_end": "58", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 52, 66 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 52; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "20383926", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.20383926", "reference": "MOO-CAT-004/C005", "url": "parts/20383926-c005.html", "reader_url": "read/20383926.html#page=52", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "page_count": 196, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 5, "title": "The Architecture of Shame", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 67, "printed_start": "59", "id": "c006", "pdf_end": 81, "printed_end": "73", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 67, 81 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 67; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "20383926", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.20383926", "reference": "MOO-CAT-004/C006", "url": "parts/20383926-c006.html", "reader_url": "read/20383926.html#page=67", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "page_count": 196, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 6, "title": "The Architecture of Obedience", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 82, "printed_start": "74", "id": "c007", "pdf_end": 97, "printed_end": "89", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 82, 97 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 82; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "20383926", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.20383926", "reference": "MOO-CAT-004/C007", "url": "parts/20383926-c007.html", "reader_url": "read/20383926.html#page=82", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "page_count": 196, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 7, "title": "The Architecture of Awe", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 98, "printed_start": "90", "id": "c008", "pdf_end": 112, "printed_end": "104", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 98, 112 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 98; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "20383926", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.20383926", "reference": "MOO-CAT-004/C008", "url": "parts/20383926-c008.html", "reader_url": "read/20383926.html#page=98", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "page_count": 196, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 8, "title": "Space as Moral Evidence", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 113, "printed_start": "105", "id": "c009", "pdf_end": 129, "printed_end": "121", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 113, 129 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 113; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "20383926", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.20383926", "reference": "MOO-CAT-004/C009", "url": "parts/20383926-c009.html", "reader_url": "read/20383926.html#page=113", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "page_count": 196, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 9, "title": "Against Interpretation: The Ethical Stance", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 130, "printed_start": "122", "id": "c010", "pdf_end": 147, "printed_end": "139", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 130, 147 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 130; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "20383926", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.20383926", "reference": "MOO-CAT-004/C010", "url": "parts/20383926-c010.html", "reader_url": "read/20383926.html#page=130", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "page_count": 196, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 10, "title": "The Ethics of Custodial Space", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 148, "printed_start": "140", "id": "c011", "pdf_end": 162, "printed_end": "154", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 148, 162 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 148; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "20383926", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.20383926", "reference": "MOO-CAT-004/C011", "url": "parts/20383926-c011.html", "reader_url": "read/20383926.html#page=148", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "page_count": 196, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 11, "title": "The Critic as Witness", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 163, "printed_start": "155", "id": "c012", "pdf_end": 175, "printed_end": "167", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 163, 175 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 163; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "20383926", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.20383926", "reference": "MOO-CAT-004/C012", "url": "parts/20383926-c012.html", "reader_url": "read/20383926.html#page=163", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "page_count": 196, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 12, "title": "The Post-Interpretive Doctrine", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 176, "printed_start": "168", "id": "c013", "pdf_end": 189, "printed_end": "181", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 176, 189 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 176; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "20383926", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.20383926", "reference": "MOO-CAT-004/C013", "url": "parts/20383926-c013.html", "reader_url": "read/20383926.html#page=176", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "page_count": 196, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "number": 13, "title": "The Benedict", "type": "Chapter", "pdf_start": 190, "printed_start": "182", "id": "c014", "pdf_end": 196, "printed_end": "188", "evidence": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "pdf_pages": [ 190, 196 ], "title_source": "Full heading on PDF file page 190; contents page 5", "method": "Checked numbered opening headings, consecutive chapter boundaries, final text pages and printed page labels in the deposited PDF text layer. Line breaks joined and discretionary hyphens displayed as hyphens. Blank leaves excluded from terminal extents.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, "parent_id": "20383926", "parent_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.20383926", "reference": "MOO-CAT-004/C014", "url": "parts/20383926-c014.html", "reader_url": "read/20383926.html#page=190", "description_level": "Local analytic description of a publication component", "creator": "Dorian Vale", "creator_inheritance": "Responsibility inherited from the parent publication; no separate chapter-level deposit or independent authorship claim is made.", "source": { "file": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "page_count": 196, "pdf_pages": [ 5 ], "title_source": "Contents list corroborated against full chapter headings in the same deposited PDF.", "method": "PDF text-layer review; full heading titles take precedence over abbreviated contents entries. Extents end immediately before the next numbered opening or at the final text page. Prefaces are separately paginated.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "controlled_subjects": [ { "id": "architecture", "label": "Architecture", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#architecture", "url": "vocabulary.html#architecture", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:architecture", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Buildings and the built environment as subjects of critical study.", "scope_note": "Use for the subject of a publication, not to classify the deposited document as a building.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "power-and-institutions", "spatial-experience" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "spatial-experience", "label": "Spatial experience", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#spatial-experience", "url": "vocabulary.html#spatial-experience", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:spatial-experience", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Bodily and perceptual experience of built or arranged space.", "scope_note": "Use for critical study of scale, light, thresholds, and access; related to Architecture and Exhibition design.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "architecture", "exhibition-design" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "power-and-institutions", "label": "Power and institutions", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#power-and-institutions", "url": "vocabulary.html#power-and-institutions", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:power-and-institutions", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Relations of authority as exercised through institutional structures and spaces.", "scope_note": "Use for inquiry into access, surveillance, ordering, and authority; not an institutional affiliation field.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "architecture" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "ethics-of-witnessing", "label": "Ethics of witnessing", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#ethics-of-witnessing", "url": "vocabulary.html#ethics-of-witnessing", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:ethics-of-witnessing", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "ethics of witnessing" ], "definition": "Ethical responsibility in attending to artworks and the histories they engage.", "scope_note": "Local access term used for the Museum of One corpus. Preserve the author’s framework attribution; no equivalence with an external philosophical school is asserted.", "kind": "local-framework-concept", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "post-interpretive-criticism", "witnessing" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "genre_terms": [ { "id": "genre-book", "label": "Book", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#genre-book", "url": "vocabulary.html#genre-book", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:genre-book", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Books", "Digital book" ], "definition": "Book-length publication represented by a deposited digital edition.", "scope_note": "Describes publication genre. The local PDF is not being described as a physical bound volume.", "kind": "genre", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "verified_mapping", "external_mappings": [ { "vocabulary": "Getty Art & Architecture Thesaurus", "label": "books", "uri": "http://vocab.getty.edu/aat/300028051", "source_url": "https://vocab.getty.edu/page/aat/300028051", "relation": "relatedMatch", "status": "verified", "verified_on": "2026-11-04", "note": "Getty’s concept concerns bound physical volumes. It is a related form reference for this digital-publication genre, not an exact equivalence or physical-holdings assertion." } ], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "type", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "vocabulary_version": 4, "description_history": [ { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Source-based catalogue description", "note": "Local description assembled from the identified public repository record and available institutional work record. Source metadata remains separately identifiable.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/20383926", "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Qualified descriptive enrichment", "note": "Local editorial description, arrangement and source-qualified bibliographic context recorded alongside source metadata. Unknown or disputed values remain qualified.", "fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/20383926", "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Automated file checksum and PDF inspection", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Digital reading copy verified", "note": "Downloaded access-copy MD5 matched the source checksum; local SHA-256 and PDF file-page count are recorded in the file manifest. This event does not describe transfer of custody.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/api/records/20383926/files/The%20Moral%20Evidance%20of%20Space.pdf/content" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Description policy and provenance context adopted", "note": "Responsible service, source repository, local access-copy role, unknown custody and original order, correction route and dated description history made explicit under moo-description-policy-1.0.", "sources": [ "policies.html" ] }, { "event_id": "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Unify graph identities and qualify exported relationships and citations", "note": "Local graph projection now uses one contextual identity per entity, distinguishes work-level institutional matches from selected-edition links, retains title-level ISBN uncertainty, and derives citations from the source title. Typed relation assertions and a versioned validation profile are introduced. No publication date, original source snapshot or PDF changed.", "fields": [ "metadata_profile", "relationship_assertions", "identity", "institutional_match_scope", "citation_projection" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Source-based metadata implementation and regression validation", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication, source review or acquisition date", "sources": [ "metadata/metadata-profile.json" ] }, { "event_id": "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Record inspected public ORCID profile evidence", "note": "The official ORCID public person API returned the credited name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website. This confirms a matching public profile, not independently verified biographical or affiliation claims. Original creator arrays and source snapshots are unchanged.", "fields": [ "orcid_authority" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Read-only official public API inspection", "date_kind": "Local authority review and catalogue description event; not a publication or original creation date", "sources": [ "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ] } ], "record_modified": "2026-11-04", "record_modified_provenance": { "status": "derived_from_description_history", "event_ids": [ "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04" ], "note": "Latest documented local description event; not a publication, repository or source-review date." }, "archival_context": { "description_profile": "moo-description-policy-1.0", "catalogue_snapshot_date": "2026-11-04", "snapshot_note": "Selected catalogue snapshot; not a live repository synchronisation.", "record_category": "Published library and repository material", "reference_code_status": "Stable local catalogue reference; not evidence of an archival acquisition or a previous catalogue accession.", "source_repository": { "name": "Zenodo", "record_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20383926" }, "institutional_context_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "source_metadata_retrieved": "2026-11-04", "source_metadata_retrieval_status": "Documented in catalogue source provenance", "source_snapshot": "source/20383926.json", "source_filenames": [ "The Moral Evidance of Space.pdf" ], "selection_basis": "Local descriptive selection of publicly published material; public availability does not establish ownership of originals.", "custodial_history": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No donation, physical transfer, acquisition agreement or chain of custody is documented by this catalogue. Zenodo remains the source repository for the deposited version." }, "original_order": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No original archival order is asserted. Current browsing groupings are local editorial arrangement." }, "arrangement": { "status": "local_editorial", "grouping": "Books & volumes", "statement": "A browsing grouping, not an original fonds or archival series." }, "responsible_service": { "name": "Museum of One", "service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "website": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "email": "research@museumofone.art" }, "description_method": "Source-based description with automated drafting and metadata assistance. Responsibility for the public catalogue rests with Museum of One; automated assistance does not constitute independent scholarly or curatorial review.", "policy_url": "policies.html", "correction_email": "research@museumofone.art", "access_copy": { "role": "Local digital reading copy of the deposited file", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/20383926/files/The%20Moral%20Evidance%20of%20Space.pdf/content", "source_filename": "The Moral Evidance of Space.pdf", "local_path": "assets/documents/20383926.pdf", "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "source_checksum_match": true, "sha256": "49a76d86a81fc40c6baec3429cfb21c47582a35414f4715504d2c239b5fca5f7", "statement": "Access copy only; no ownership or physical custody transfer is implied." } }, "description_policy_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "pirr_references": [ { "programme_key": "research-witness-material-memory", "programme_title": "Witness, Material Presence, and Cultural Memory", "programme_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/", "programme_stage": "Continuing research", "registry_url": "research-registry.html#research-witness-material-memory", "identifiers": [ { "scheme": "PIRR project ID", "value": "pir-prj-dd7kt5rw", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/#programme-record" } ], "relation": "Published study associated with the continuing inquiry.", "relation_note": "Published study associated with the continuing inquiry.", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/" } ], "pirr_work_identity": { "archive_reference": "MOO-CAT-004", "edition_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.20383926", "zenodo_record_id": "20383926", "identifier_scope": "Publication identity; PIRR identifiers in programme relationships identify research records, not this publication." }, "metadata_origin": "https://archive.museumofone.art", "identity": { "work": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/20383926.html#work", "edition": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20383926", "version_family": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20095467", "catalogue_record": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/20383926.html#catalogue-record" }, "institutional_match_scope": "exact_edition", "relationship_assertions": [ { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:7515d7cd47fee770bc43022acc8ce8fc3d252885b11eedf418a0b962d85dd00c", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/20383926.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:c50559322dabd2b8ca28f9d0284f0ffa3c93ff5a1025c6552cf7faa81737504e", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/20383926.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:67fe5f9df7dc5028e835bb11f9eebbc1977bd7145ef2c2ccab6186b95fed5e00", "subject": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#describes", "object": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20383926", "scope": "exact_edition", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/publication-moral-evidence-of-space/", "source_location": { "kind": "metadata_field", "field": "linked_zenodo_dois", "values": [ "10.5281/zenodo.20383926" ] }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "Exact-edition matching requires the selected DOI in the reviewed page metadata; other matches retain their wider scope." } ], "orcid_authority": { "scheme": "ORCID", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "evidence_urls": [ "https://www.museumofone.art/archives-scholarly-infrastructure/", "https://eprints.rclis.org/47182/", "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ], "access_note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "evidence_receipt": "data/source/authority-review-2026-11-04.json" } }, { "id": "23430200", "accession": "MOO-CAT-005", "title": "After the Interpretation Changes: Correction, Completion, and the Circulation of Museum Titles", "source_title": "After the Interpretation Changes: Correction, Completion, and the Circulation of Museum Titles", "short_title": "After the Interpretation Changes", "author": "Dorian Vale", "creators": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "affiliation": "Museum of One", "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094" } ], "doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23430200", "conceptdoi": "10.5281/zenodo.23430199", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23430200", "date": "2026-10-17", "type": "Working paper", "source_resource_type": { "title": "Working paper", "type": "publication", "subtype": "workingpaper" }, "version": "1.0", "collection": "Essays & research", "summary": "Research Working Paper No. 2 distinguishes title correction, later identification, and the circulation of catalogue descriptions through a study of Simon Maris’s portrait Isabella and its repository records.", "subjects": [ "Museum cataloguing", "Critical language", "Documentary evidence", "Title correction" ], "keywords": [ "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Museum of One", "Dorian Vale", "Alexander Viktorovich Markov", "Museum titles", "Museum cataloguing", "Correction", "Completion", "Circulation", "Interpretive authority", "Rijksmuseum", "Simon Maris", "Isabella", "Europeana", "Wikimedia Commons", "Collection records", "Cultural heritage metadata", "Documentary research", "Provenance", "Historical evidence", "Art historiography", "Documentation", "Deactivation", "Contestability", "Semantic persistence", "Reauthorization", "Successional authority", "Museum terminology", "Dutch art", "Aesthetics", "Philosophy of Art", "Art Criticism", "Art Theory", "Visual Culture Studies", "Ethics in Art Criticism", "Interpretation and Meaning", "Interpretive Restraint", "Criticism and Reception Theory", "Epistemology of Art" ], "license": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution–NonCommercial–NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/" }, "files": [ { "name": "After_the_Interpretation_Changes_Working_Paper_2_v1.0.pdf", "url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/23430200/files/After_the_Interpretation_Changes_Working_Paper_2_v1.0.pdf/content", "size": 180105, "size_label": "176 KB", "checksum": "md5:aa7d5753758bf6e178342117ef9ad3db", "mimetype": "application/pdf" } ], "institutional_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "corroboration": "Museum of One’s matching publication page confirms Dorian Vale’s authorship and the work’s institutional context. It links the selected Zenodo edition DOI. Web-record dates are not treated as dates of the deposited edition. Source review: 4 November 2026.", "discrepancies": [], "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "publisher": "Museum of One", "language": "eng", "isbn": null, "related_identifiers": [ { "identifier": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-critical-language/", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "10.22501/rc.4965790", "relation": "isVariantFormOf", "resource_type": "publication-workingpaper", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-working-papers/", "relation": "isPartOf", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://id.rijksmuseum.nl/200109696", "relation": "references", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.rijksmuseum.nl/en/research/our-research/overarching/terminology", "relation": "references", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "10.52476/trb.9685", "relation": "references", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "https://id.rijksmuseum.nl/300304730", "relation": "references", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://nltimes.nl/2015/12/09/rijksmuseum-stripping-insensitive-words-artwork-titles-descriptions", "relation": "references", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.theguardian.com/artanddesign/jonathanjonesblog/2015/dec/15/artworks-racist-titles-rijksmuseum-amsterdam", "relation": "references", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://id.rijksmuseum.nl/200839673", "relation": "references", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.leidenarthistoryblog.nl/articles/presenting-the-colonial-past-in-the-museum", "relation": "references", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.europeana.eu/nl/item/90402/SK_A_2931", "relation": "references", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Jonge_vrouw_met_waaier,_SK-A-2931.jpg", "relation": "references", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "url" } ], "alternate_identifiers": [], "source_references": [ "Rijksmuseum. Isabella. Collection no. SK-A-2931. Consulted 7-9 October 2026; cited passages checked 17 October 2026. https://www.rijksmuseum.nl/en/collection/object/Isabella--ead5f623d828c7250ce5413e809b3551", "Rijksmuseum. Terminology. Consulted during the original research; cited passages checked 17 October 2026. https://www.rijksmuseum.nl/en/research/our-research/overarching/terminology", "Lambrechts, Lisa. 2020. From Young Woman with a Fan to Isabella: A Rediscovered Identity. The Rijksmuseum Bulletin 68(2): 157-165. https://doi.org/10.52476/trb.9685", "Rijksmuseum Research Library. Bibliographic entry for Lisa Lambrechts, From Young Woman with a Fan to Isabella: A Rediscovered Identity. Recorded 7 October 2026; the library link could not be reopened during the final source check.", "NL Times. 2015. Rijksmuseum stripping insensitive words from artwork titles, descriptions. 9 December. https://nltimes.nl/2015/12/09/rijksmuseum-stripping-insensitive-words-artwork-titles-descriptions", "Jones, Jonathan. 2015. Young Negro Girl: should artworks with offensive names get an update? The Guardian, 15 December. Historical wording retained only to identify the cited publication. https://www.theguardian.com/artanddesign/jonathanjonesblog/2015/dec/15/artworks-racist-titles-rijksmuseum-amsterdam", "Rijksmuseum. Portret van model, getiteld Isabella. Collection no. SK-A-5103. Checked 17 October 2026. https://www.rijksmuseum.nl/en/collection/object/Portret-van-model-getiteld-Isabella--7bb631ae77f2a0287156185a2f062092", "Leiden Art History Blog. 2019. Presenting the Colonial Past in the Museum. 27 September. https://www.leidenarthistoryblog.nl/articles/presenting-the-colonial-past-in-the-museum", "Europeana. Jonge vrouw met waaier. Dutch record for Rijksmuseum SK-A-2931. Consulted 9 October and checked 17 October 2026. https://www.europeana.eu/nl/item/90402/SK_A_2931", "Wikimedia Commons. File:Jonge vrouw met waaier, SK-A-2931.jpg. Search-service copy consulted 9 October and checked 17 October 2026; direct access failed. https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Jonge_vrouw_met_waaier,_SK-A-2931.jpg", "Vale, Dorian, and Alexander V. Markov. Correspondence, 4-24 September 2026, with Markov's subsequent response in October 2026. Museum of One research archive, Post-interpretive criticism, The unstable sign and the afterlife of interpretation. Intellectual provenance only; the full private exchange is not part of this publication." ], "source_journal": null, "source_imprint": {}, "source_contributors": [], "source_created": "2026-10-17T04:35:17.777799+00:00", "source_modified": "2026-10-17T06:42:45.273937+00:00", "source_description_html": "

This study distinguishes two changes in the Rijksmuseum’s presentation of Simon Maris’s portrait now titled Isabella: the withdrawal of a racialized catalogue title in 2015, and the fulfilment in 2020 of an announced intention to adopt a name when one became known. The second change does not, by itself, demonstrate revision of the rule governing the first. The records examined at Europeana and Wikimedia Commons reveal different afterlives of the later decision. Europeana retains the descriptive title and an account in which identification remains unfinished. Commons preserves the older wording in the name of its image file while identifying the work as Isabella in the accompanying description. Drawing on my correspondence with Alexander V. Markov, the study follows what these descriptions do, rather than treating their survival as evidence of continuing authority. It finds uneven presentation of the later naming decision, not a demonstrated restoration of the rejected title. Its contribution to Post-Interpretive Criticism is a documentary distinction among correction, completion and circulation.

\n

Independently authored by Dorian Vale and published by Museum of One as Research Working Paper No. 2, version 1.0. Developed through scholarly correspondence with Alexander Viktorovich Markov and his subsequent critical response to the documentary study. Selected passages and summaries are reproduced with his permission. Markov is not a coauthor, and the study is not a record of formal peer review or agreement with every proposal. The full private correspondence is not published.

\n

© 2026 Dorian Vale · Museum of One. CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 applies to the author's original contribution. Rights in third-party material and the original correspondence remain with their respective holders. Permission for selected correspondence material does not extend to reproduction of the full exchange.

\n

Research programme: https://www.museumofone.art/research-critical-language/
PIRR programme reference: moo-program-2b3ad664cbd92f69b862db8c

", "provenance": { "repository": "Zenodo REST API response supplied in query.json", "retrieved": "2026-11-04", "editorial_fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "source_snapshot": "source/23430200.json", "institutional_review": "Reviewed page-level title, author and repository links in saved public institutional HTML, 2026-11-04." }, "source_review": "2026-11-04", "relations": [ { "identifier": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-critical-language/", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "10.22501/rc.4965790", "relation": "isVariantFormOf", "resource_type": "publication-workingpaper", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-working-papers/", "relation": "isPartOf", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://id.rijksmuseum.nl/200109696", "relation": "references", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.rijksmuseum.nl/en/research/our-research/overarching/terminology", "relation": "references", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "10.52476/trb.9685", "relation": "references", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "https://id.rijksmuseum.nl/300304730", "relation": "references", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://nltimes.nl/2015/12/09/rijksmuseum-stripping-insensitive-words-artwork-titles-descriptions", "relation": "references", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.theguardian.com/artanddesign/jonathanjonesblog/2015/dec/15/artworks-racist-titles-rijksmuseum-amsterdam", "relation": "references", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://id.rijksmuseum.nl/200839673", "relation": "references", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.leidenarthistoryblog.nl/articles/presenting-the-colonial-past-in-the-museum", "relation": "references", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.europeana.eu/nl/item/90402/SK_A_2931", "relation": "references", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Jonge_vrouw_met_waaier,_SK-A-2931.jpg", "relation": "references", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "url" } ], "institutional_metadata": { "title": "After the Interpretation Changes: Correction, Completion, and the Circulation of Museum Titles", "author": "Dorian Vale", "web_publication": "2026-10-17T05:28:12.000Z", "web_updated": "2026-11-02T20:38:02.000Z", "linked_zenodo_dois": [ "10.5281/zenodo.23430200" ], "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/" }, "research_programmes": [ { "title": "Alexander Viktorovich Markov: Critical Language and Lasting Correction", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-critical-language/", "status": "In development", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "relation": "Published working paper within a developing inquiry", "relation_label": "Published working paper within a developing inquiry" } ], "citation": "Vale, Dorian. 2026. After the Interpretation Changes: Correction, Completion, and the Circulation of Museum Titles. Museum of One Research Working Paper No. 2, version 1.0. Museum of One. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23430200.", "record_level": "Item", "record_status": "Published source; selected catalogue record", "digital_formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "extent": "1 digital file; 180105 bytes", "medium": "Digital document", "record_reviewed": "2026-11-04", "date_precision": "day", "alternate_titles": [], "digital_extent": { "file_count": 1, "total_bytes": 180105, "formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "checksums": [ { "filename": "After_the_Interpretation_Changes_Working_Paper_2_v1.0.pdf", "algorithm": "md5", "value": "aa7d5753758bf6e178342117ef9ad3db", "syntax_valid": true, "verification": "source_checksum_transcription; bytes not independently recomputed" } ], "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23430200", "derivation": "File count and total bytes calculated from repository file metadata; MIME inferred from filename when absent." }, "identifier_validation": { "orcid": { "source_value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "ISO 7064 MOD 11-2 checksum only; this is not a live registry verification." }, "isbn": [], "doi": { "source_value": "10.5281/zenodo.23430200", "syntax_valid": true, "note": "Syntax check only; repository snapshot supplies the identifier." } }, "isbn_applicability": "not_supplied", "serial": null, "contributor_roles": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": "Museum of One", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23430200" } ], "authority_links": [], "metadata_profile": { "name": "Museum of One source-qualified catalogue profile", "version": "3.0.0", "url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/metadata-profile.json", "source_snapshot_preserved": true }, "reading_copy": { "id": "23430200", "title": "After the Interpretation Changes: Correction, Completion, and the Circulation of Museum Titles", "accession": "MOO-CAT-005", "pdf_url": "../assets/documents/23430200.pdf", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/23430200/files/After_the_Interpretation_Changes_Working_Paper_2_v1.0.pdf/content", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23430200", "source_filename": "After_the_Interpretation_Changes_Working_Paper_2_v1.0.pdf", "checksum": "md5:aa7d5753758bf6e178342117ef9ad3db", "sha256": "272b077f00db6a02d04c03b87608a0ab8cc34972b11759e51b7ece3890228716", "bytes": 180105, "page_count": 10, "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "checksum_match": true, "rights": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution–NonCommercial–NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/" }, "role": "Local reading copy; original repository file retained unchanged" }, "page_count": 10, "field_assertions": [ { "field": "title", "value": "After the Interpretation Changes: Correction, Completion, and the Circulation of Museum Titles", "status": "catalogue_title", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "note": "Local display title; the deposited title is retained separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_title", "value": "After the Interpretation Changes: Correction, Completion, and the Circulation of Museum Titles", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23430200", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "doi", "value": "10.5281/zenodo.23430200", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23430200", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "date", "value": "2026-10-17", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23430200", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "version", "value": "1.0", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23430200", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "conceptdoi", "value": "10.5281/zenodo.23430199", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23430200", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "creators", "value": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "affiliation": "Museum of One", "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23430200", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "keywords", "value": [ "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Museum of One", "Dorian Vale", "Alexander Viktorovich Markov", "Museum titles", "Museum cataloguing", "Correction", "Completion", "Circulation", "Interpretive authority", "Rijksmuseum", "Simon Maris", "Isabella", "Europeana", "Wikimedia Commons", "Collection records", "Cultural heritage metadata", "Documentary research", "Provenance", "Historical evidence", "Art historiography", "Documentation", "Deactivation", "Contestability", "Semantic persistence", "Reauthorization", "Successional authority", "Museum terminology", "Dutch art", "Aesthetics", "Philosophy of Art", "Art Criticism", "Art Theory", "Visual Culture Studies", "Ethics in Art Criticism", "Interpretation and Meaning", "Interpretive Restraint", "Criticism and Reception Theory", "Epistemology of Art" ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23430200", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "language", "value": "eng", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23430200", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "license", "value": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution–NonCommercial–NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/" }, "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23430200", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "files", "value": [ { "name": "After_the_Interpretation_Changes_Working_Paper_2_v1.0.pdf", "url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/23430200/files/After_the_Interpretation_Changes_Working_Paper_2_v1.0.pdf/content", "size": 180105, "size_label": "176 KB", "checksum": "md5:aa7d5753758bf6e178342117ef9ad3db", "mimetype": "application/pdf" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23430200", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_created", "value": "2026-10-17T04:35:17.777799+00:00", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23430200", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_modified", "value": "2026-10-17T06:42:45.273937+00:00", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23430200", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "record_modified", "value": "2026-11-04", "status": "derived_from_description_history", "note": "Latest documented local description event; not a publication, repository or source-review date.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_review", "value": "2026-11-04", "status": "catalogue_source_review", "note": "Review of descriptive sources; not the creation or modification date of the work or repository record.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "author", "value": "Dorian Vale", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "note": "Institutional responsibility statement; original repository creator roles remain separate.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "publisher", "value": "Museum of One", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "note": "Institutional responsibility statement; original repository creator roles remain separate.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "orcid", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "source_linked_identifier", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "note": "Creator identifier supplied by the linked sources; no affiliation or endorsement is inferred.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "orcid_authority", "value": { "scheme": "ORCID", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "evidence_urls": [ "https://www.museumofone.art/archives-scholarly-infrastructure/", "https://eprints.rclis.org/47182/", "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ], "access_note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "evidence_receipt": "data/source/authority-review-2026-11-04.json" }, "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "source_url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "summary", "value": "Research Working Paper No. 2 distinguishes title correction, later identification, and the circulation of catalogue descriptions through a study of Simon Maris’s portrait Isabella and its repository records.", "status": "editorial_enrichment", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "note": "Catalogue-editor summary based on the linked work; not an original publisher abstract.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "subjects", "value": [ "Museum cataloguing", "Critical language", "Documentary evidence", "Title correction" ], "status": "editorial_enrichment", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "note": "Local discovery terms; no controlled-vocabulary assignment is claimed.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "collection", "value": "Essays & research", "status": "editorial_grouping", "note": "A local browsing collection, not an original repository collection.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "corroboration", "value": "Museum of One’s matching publication page confirms Dorian Vale’s authorship and the work’s institutional context. It links the selected Zenodo edition DOI. Web-record dates are not treated as dates of the deposited edition. Source review: 4 November 2026.", "status": "catalogue_review_note", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "date_precision", "value": "day", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23430200", "note": "Precision reported exactly as supplied; missing month or day is not filled.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "medium", "value": "Digital document", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23430200", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "digital_formats", "value": [ "application/pdf" ], "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23430200", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "extent", "value": "1 digital file; 180105 bytes", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23430200", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "digital_extent", "value": { "file_count": 1, "total_bytes": 180105, "formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "checksums": [ { "filename": "After_the_Interpretation_Changes_Working_Paper_2_v1.0.pdf", "algorithm": "md5", "value": "aa7d5753758bf6e178342117ef9ad3db", "syntax_valid": true, "verification": "source_checksum_transcription; bytes not independently recomputed" } ], "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23430200", "derivation": "File count and total bytes calculated from repository file metadata; MIME inferred from filename when absent." }, "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23430200", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "identifier_validation", "value": { "orcid": { "source_value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "ISO 7064 MOD 11-2 checksum only; this is not a live registry verification." }, "isbn": [], "doi": { "source_value": "10.5281/zenodo.23430200", "syntax_valid": true, "note": "Syntax check only; repository snapshot supplies the identifier." } }, "status": "local_syntax_validation", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23430200", "note": "Checksum/syntax validation does not verify registration, assignment or edition applicability.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "contributor_roles", "value": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": "Museum of One", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23430200" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23430200", "note": "Creator and contributor roles are transcribed, not inferred from names or affiliations.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "research_programme:https://www.museumofone.art/research-critical-language/", "value": { "title": "Alexander Viktorovich Markov: Critical Language and Lasting Correction", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-critical-language/", "status": "In development", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "relation": "Published working paper within a developing inquiry", "relation_label": "Published working paper within a developing inquiry" }, "status": "institutional_work_relationship", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "note": "Programme relationship and stage follow the work-specific institutional badge; publication does not imply a completed programme or collaboration.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "entity_link:dorian-vale:author", "value": { "id": "dorian-vale", "label": "Dorian Vale", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "author", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author.", "variants": [ "Vale, Dorian" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:f4caf8eb7846f4233360058d01fb0f6bef64c0d5367b8dfe2a8e0091bf51aeb9", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23430200.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." } }, { "field": "entity_link:museum-of-one:publisher", "value": { "id": "museum-of-one", "label": "Museum of One", "entity_type": "Organization", "relation": "publisher", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record.", "variants": [ "MuseumofOne", "MUSEUM OF ONE" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:594393ee5ef8bcd2501a4c5b004d168d9f679feefbfb579c0845f43ec2bcaa6f", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23430200.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." } }, { "field": "entity_link:simon-maris:artist discussed", "value": { "id": "simon-maris", "label": "Simon Maris", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "artist discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "note": "The abstract identifies Simon Maris as the artist of the portrait now titled Isabella.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:89abb4856a48db487c8e3fde3bfd3e547d4828f01b2a9f6559effd263165dd19", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23430200.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/simon-maris.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The abstract identifies Simon Maris as the artist of the portrait now titled Isabella." } }, { "field": "entity_link:alexander-viktorovich-markov:scholarly correspondent", "value": { "id": "alexander-viktorovich-markov", "label": "Alexander Viktorovich Markov", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "scholarly correspondent", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "note": "The source records scholarly correspondence and a critical response. It explicitly states that Markov is not a coauthor and that this is not formal peer review or agreement with every proposal.", "variants": [ "Alexander V. Markov" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:8ab286bbc76d19e318848536592a0a311ce1019bffbe2b8b17f6ec0276459c76", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23430200.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#has-scholarly-correspondent", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/alexander-viktorovich-markov.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The source records scholarly correspondence and a critical response. It explicitly states that Markov is not a coauthor and that this is not formal peer review or agreement with every proposal." } }, { "field": "entity_link:isabella:artwork discussed", "value": { "id": "isabella", "label": "Isabella", "entity_type": "Artwork", "relation": "artwork discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "note": "The abstract identifies the current title and artist. The changing catalogue title is the subject of the paper; historic terminology is not adopted as the preferred label.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:9b9176ac726ef49049a1bccf3023ff91c38c448b619716b73640f73063441e39", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23430200.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/isabella.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The abstract identifies the current title and artist. The changing catalogue title is the subject of the paper; historic terminology is not adopted as the preferred label." } }, { "field": "controlled_subjects", "value": [ { "id": "museum-cataloguing", "label": "Museum cataloguing", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#museum-cataloguing", "url": "vocabulary.html#museum-cataloguing", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:museum-cataloguing", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Museum cataloging" ], "definition": "The creation, revision, and circulation of descriptive records for museum objects.", "scope_note": "Use when catalogue titles, descriptions, or metadata are subjects of research; distinguish this from the archive’s own cataloguing activity.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [ "title-correction" ], "related": [ "critical-language" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "critical-language", "label": "Critical language", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#critical-language", "url": "vocabulary.html#critical-language", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:critical-language", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "The terms and linguistic choices through which critical claims are made.", "scope_note": "Use for publications examining wording, descriptive authority, restraint, or the circulation of interpretation.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "art-writing", "museum-cataloguing" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "documentary-evidence", "label": "Documentary evidence", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#documentary-evidence", "url": "vocabulary.html#documentary-evidence", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:documentary-evidence", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Documents considered as support for an interpretive or historical claim.", "scope_note": "Use when the evidentiary function of records is central, rather than the production of documentation alone.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "documentation", "historical-evidence" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "title-correction", "label": "Title correction", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#title-correction", "url": "vocabulary.html#title-correction", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:title-correction", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Revision of an object title or identification in a descriptive record.", "scope_note": "Use for research on corrections and their subsequent circulation; assignment does not state that every cited institution has adopted a correction.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [ "museum-cataloguing" ], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Local preferred terms with definitions and synonyms. External alignment is scoped in the vocabulary register." }, { "field": "genre_terms", "value": [ { "id": "genre-working-paper", "label": "Working paper", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#genre-working-paper", "url": "vocabulary.html#genre-working-paper", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:genre-working-paper", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Working papers" ], "definition": "A research publication presented as a working or operational paper.", "scope_note": "Preserve source version and programme stage. This genre does not imply peer review or final publication status.", "kind": "genre", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "type", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Local resource-genre classification. Digital file format is recorded separately." }, { "field": "archival_context", "value": { "description_profile": "moo-description-policy-1.0", "catalogue_snapshot_date": "2026-11-04", "snapshot_note": "Selected catalogue snapshot; not a live repository synchronisation.", "record_category": "Published library and repository material", "reference_code_status": "Stable local catalogue reference; not evidence of an archival acquisition or a previous catalogue accession.", "source_repository": { "name": "Zenodo", "record_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23430200" }, "institutional_context_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "source_metadata_retrieved": "2026-11-04", "source_metadata_retrieval_status": "Documented in catalogue source provenance", "source_snapshot": "source/23430200.json", "source_filenames": [ "After_the_Interpretation_Changes_Working_Paper_2_v1.0.pdf" ], "selection_basis": "Local descriptive selection of publicly published material; public availability does not establish ownership of originals.", "custodial_history": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No donation, physical transfer, acquisition agreement or chain of custody is documented by this catalogue. Zenodo remains the source repository for the deposited version." }, "original_order": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No original archival order is asserted. Current browsing groupings are local editorial arrangement." }, "arrangement": { "status": "local_editorial", "grouping": "Essays & research", "statement": "A browsing grouping, not an original fonds or archival series." }, "responsible_service": { "name": "Museum of One", "service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "website": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "email": "research@museumofone.art" }, "description_method": "Source-based description with automated drafting and metadata assistance. Responsibility for the public catalogue rests with Museum of One; automated assistance does not constitute independent scholarly or curatorial review.", "policy_url": "policies.html", "correction_email": "research@museumofone.art", "access_copy": { "role": "Local digital reading copy of the deposited file", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/23430200/files/After_the_Interpretation_Changes_Working_Paper_2_v1.0.pdf/content", "source_filename": "After_the_Interpretation_Changes_Working_Paper_2_v1.0.pdf", "local_path": "assets/documents/23430200.pdf", "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "source_checksum_match": true, "sha256": "272b077f00db6a02d04c03b87608a0ab8cc34972b11759e51b7ece3890228716", "statement": "Access copy only; no ownership or physical custody transfer is implied." } }, "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Provenance records what is documented and leaves unknown custody and original order explicit." }, { "field": "description_history", "value": [ { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Source-based catalogue description", "note": "Local description assembled from the identified public repository record and available institutional work record. Source metadata remains separately identifiable.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/23430200", "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Qualified descriptive enrichment", "note": "Local editorial description, arrangement and source-qualified bibliographic context recorded alongside source metadata. Unknown or disputed values remain qualified.", "fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/23430200", "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Automated file checksum and PDF inspection", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Digital reading copy verified", "note": "Downloaded access-copy MD5 matched the source checksum; local SHA-256 and PDF file-page count are recorded in the file manifest. This event does not describe transfer of custody.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/api/records/23430200/files/After_the_Interpretation_Changes_Working_Paper_2_v1.0.pdf/content" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Description policy and provenance context adopted", "note": "Responsible service, source repository, local access-copy role, unknown custody and original order, correction route and dated description history made explicit under moo-description-policy-1.0.", "sources": [ "policies.html" ] }, { "event_id": "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Unify graph identities and qualify exported relationships and citations", "note": "Local graph projection now uses one contextual identity per entity, distinguishes work-level institutional matches from selected-edition links, retains title-level ISBN uncertainty, and derives citations from the source title. Typed relation assertions and a versioned validation profile are introduced. No publication date, original source snapshot or PDF changed.", "fields": [ "metadata_profile", "relationship_assertions", "identity", "institutional_match_scope", "citation_projection" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Source-based metadata implementation and regression validation", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication, source review or acquisition date", "sources": [ "metadata/metadata-profile.json" ] }, { "event_id": "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Record inspected public ORCID profile evidence", "note": "The official ORCID public person API returned the credited name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website. This confirms a matching public profile, not independently verified biographical or affiliation claims. Original creator arrays and source snapshots are unchanged.", "fields": [ "orcid_authority" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Read-only official public API inspection", "date_kind": "Local authority review and catalogue description event; not a publication or original creation date", "sources": [ "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ] } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Catalogue description events; these are not work publication dates or acquisition dates." }, { "field": "pirr_references", "value": [ { "programme_key": "research-critical-language", "programme_title": "Alexander Viktorovich Markov: Critical Language and Lasting Correction", "programme_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-critical-language/", "programme_stage": "In development", "registry_url": "research-registry.html#research-critical-language", "identifiers": [ { "scheme": "PIRR programme reference", "value": "moo-program-2b3ad664cbd92f69b862db8c", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-critical-language/#programme-record" } ], "relation": "Published working paper within a developing inquiry", "relation_note": "Published working paper within a developing inquiry", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/" } ], "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "PIRR project IDs and programme references identify research records, not publication versions or independent chapter deposits." }, { "field": "relationship_assertions", "value": [ { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:f4caf8eb7846f4233360058d01fb0f6bef64c0d5367b8dfe2a8e0091bf51aeb9", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23430200.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:594393ee5ef8bcd2501a4c5b004d168d9f679feefbfb579c0845f43ec2bcaa6f", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23430200.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:89abb4856a48db487c8e3fde3bfd3e547d4828f01b2a9f6559effd263165dd19", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23430200.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/simon-maris.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The abstract identifies Simon Maris as the artist of the portrait now titled Isabella." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:8ab286bbc76d19e318848536592a0a311ce1019bffbe2b8b17f6ec0276459c76", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23430200.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#has-scholarly-correspondent", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/alexander-viktorovich-markov.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The source records scholarly correspondence and a critical response. It explicitly states that Markov is not a coauthor and that this is not formal peer review or agreement with every proposal." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:9b9176ac726ef49049a1bccf3023ff91c38c448b619716b73640f73063441e39", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23430200.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/isabella.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The abstract identifies the current title and artist. The changing catalogue title is the subject of the paper; historic terminology is not adopted as the preferred label." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:7ec2ee6922fd8dd376d1803ca0f62f1b2cced87b3e7ad2cc7643e221c040485d", "subject": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#describes", "object": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23430200", "scope": "exact_edition", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "source_location": { "kind": "metadata_field", "field": "linked_zenodo_dois", "values": [ "10.5281/zenodo.23430200" ] }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "Exact-edition matching requires the selected DOI in the reviewed page metadata; other matches retain their wider scope." } ], "status": "typed_evidence_projection", "note": "Stable, typed assertions retain source scope and explicit unknown review metadata." }, { "field": "reading_copy", "value": { "id": "23430200", "title": "After the Interpretation Changes: Correction, Completion, and the Circulation of Museum Titles", "accession": "MOO-CAT-005", "pdf_url": "../assets/documents/23430200.pdf", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/23430200/files/After_the_Interpretation_Changes_Working_Paper_2_v1.0.pdf/content", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23430200", "source_filename": "After_the_Interpretation_Changes_Working_Paper_2_v1.0.pdf", "checksum": "md5:aa7d5753758bf6e178342117ef9ad3db", "sha256": "272b077f00db6a02d04c03b87608a0ab8cc34972b11759e51b7ece3890228716", "bytes": 180105, "page_count": 10, "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "checksum_match": true, "rights": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution–NonCommercial–NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/" }, "role": "Local reading copy; original repository file retained unchanged" }, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/23430200/files/After_the_Interpretation_Changes_Working_Paper_2_v1.0.pdf/content", "status": "derived_file_inspection", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "note": "Byte-identical local access copy. Source MD5 was recomputed and matched; SHA-256 and page count were measured from the downloaded PDF. This is not a preservation-deposit claim." }, { "field": "page_count", "value": 10, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/23430200/files/After_the_Interpretation_Changes_Working_Paper_2_v1.0.pdf/content", "status": "derived_file_inspection", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "note": "Total PDF file pages measured from the deposited file, including cover and unnumbered pages. Not a claim about printed pagination." } ], "entity_links": [ { "id": "dorian-vale", "label": "Dorian Vale", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "author", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author.", "variants": [ "Vale, Dorian" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "museum-of-one", "label": "Museum of One", "entity_type": "Organization", "relation": "publisher", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record.", "variants": [ "MuseumofOne", "MUSEUM OF ONE" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "simon-maris", "label": "Simon Maris", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "artist discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "note": "The abstract identifies Simon Maris as the artist of the portrait now titled Isabella.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "alexander-viktorovich-markov", "label": "Alexander Viktorovich Markov", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "scholarly correspondent", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "note": "The source records scholarly correspondence and a critical response. It explicitly states that Markov is not a coauthor and that this is not formal peer review or agreement with every proposal.", "variants": [ "Alexander V. Markov" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "isabella", "label": "Isabella", "entity_type": "Artwork", "relation": "artwork discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "note": "The abstract identifies the current title and artist. The changing catalogue title is the subject of the paper; historic terminology is not adopted as the preferred label.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" } ], "contents": [], "controlled_subjects": [ { "id": "museum-cataloguing", "label": "Museum cataloguing", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#museum-cataloguing", "url": "vocabulary.html#museum-cataloguing", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:museum-cataloguing", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Museum cataloging" ], "definition": "The creation, revision, and circulation of descriptive records for museum objects.", "scope_note": "Use when catalogue titles, descriptions, or metadata are subjects of research; distinguish this from the archive’s own cataloguing activity.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [ "title-correction" ], "related": [ "critical-language" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "critical-language", "label": "Critical language", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#critical-language", "url": "vocabulary.html#critical-language", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:critical-language", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "The terms and linguistic choices through which critical claims are made.", "scope_note": "Use for publications examining wording, descriptive authority, restraint, or the circulation of interpretation.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "art-writing", "museum-cataloguing" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "documentary-evidence", "label": "Documentary evidence", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#documentary-evidence", "url": "vocabulary.html#documentary-evidence", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:documentary-evidence", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Documents considered as support for an interpretive or historical claim.", "scope_note": "Use when the evidentiary function of records is central, rather than the production of documentation alone.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "documentation", "historical-evidence" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "title-correction", "label": "Title correction", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#title-correction", "url": "vocabulary.html#title-correction", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:title-correction", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Revision of an object title or identification in a descriptive record.", "scope_note": "Use for research on corrections and their subsequent circulation; assignment does not state that every cited institution has adopted a correction.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [ "museum-cataloguing" ], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "genre_terms": [ { "id": "genre-working-paper", "label": "Working paper", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#genre-working-paper", "url": "vocabulary.html#genre-working-paper", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:genre-working-paper", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Working papers" ], "definition": "A research publication presented as a working or operational paper.", "scope_note": "Preserve source version and programme stage. This genre does not imply peer review or final publication status.", "kind": "genre", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "type", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "vocabulary_version": 4, "description_history": [ { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Source-based catalogue description", "note": "Local description assembled from the identified public repository record and available institutional work record. Source metadata remains separately identifiable.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/23430200", "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Qualified descriptive enrichment", "note": "Local editorial description, arrangement and source-qualified bibliographic context recorded alongside source metadata. Unknown or disputed values remain qualified.", "fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/23430200", "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Automated file checksum and PDF inspection", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Digital reading copy verified", "note": "Downloaded access-copy MD5 matched the source checksum; local SHA-256 and PDF file-page count are recorded in the file manifest. This event does not describe transfer of custody.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/api/records/23430200/files/After_the_Interpretation_Changes_Working_Paper_2_v1.0.pdf/content" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Description policy and provenance context adopted", "note": "Responsible service, source repository, local access-copy role, unknown custody and original order, correction route and dated description history made explicit under moo-description-policy-1.0.", "sources": [ "policies.html" ] }, { "event_id": "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Unify graph identities and qualify exported relationships and citations", "note": "Local graph projection now uses one contextual identity per entity, distinguishes work-level institutional matches from selected-edition links, retains title-level ISBN uncertainty, and derives citations from the source title. Typed relation assertions and a versioned validation profile are introduced. No publication date, original source snapshot or PDF changed.", "fields": [ "metadata_profile", "relationship_assertions", "identity", "institutional_match_scope", "citation_projection" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Source-based metadata implementation and regression validation", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication, source review or acquisition date", "sources": [ "metadata/metadata-profile.json" ] }, { "event_id": "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Record inspected public ORCID profile evidence", "note": "The official ORCID public person API returned the credited name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website. This confirms a matching public profile, not independently verified biographical or affiliation claims. Original creator arrays and source snapshots are unchanged.", "fields": [ "orcid_authority" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Read-only official public API inspection", "date_kind": "Local authority review and catalogue description event; not a publication or original creation date", "sources": [ "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ] } ], "record_modified": "2026-11-04", "record_modified_provenance": { "status": "derived_from_description_history", "event_ids": [ "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04" ], "note": "Latest documented local description event; not a publication, repository or source-review date." }, "archival_context": { "description_profile": "moo-description-policy-1.0", "catalogue_snapshot_date": "2026-11-04", "snapshot_note": "Selected catalogue snapshot; not a live repository synchronisation.", "record_category": "Published library and repository material", "reference_code_status": "Stable local catalogue reference; not evidence of an archival acquisition or a previous catalogue accession.", "source_repository": { "name": "Zenodo", "record_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23430200" }, "institutional_context_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "source_metadata_retrieved": "2026-11-04", "source_metadata_retrieval_status": "Documented in catalogue source provenance", "source_snapshot": "source/23430200.json", "source_filenames": [ "After_the_Interpretation_Changes_Working_Paper_2_v1.0.pdf" ], "selection_basis": "Local descriptive selection of publicly published material; public availability does not establish ownership of originals.", "custodial_history": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No donation, physical transfer, acquisition agreement or chain of custody is documented by this catalogue. Zenodo remains the source repository for the deposited version." }, "original_order": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No original archival order is asserted. Current browsing groupings are local editorial arrangement." }, "arrangement": { "status": "local_editorial", "grouping": "Essays & research", "statement": "A browsing grouping, not an original fonds or archival series." }, "responsible_service": { "name": "Museum of One", "service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "website": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "email": "research@museumofone.art" }, "description_method": "Source-based description with automated drafting and metadata assistance. Responsibility for the public catalogue rests with Museum of One; automated assistance does not constitute independent scholarly or curatorial review.", "policy_url": "policies.html", "correction_email": "research@museumofone.art", "access_copy": { "role": "Local digital reading copy of the deposited file", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/23430200/files/After_the_Interpretation_Changes_Working_Paper_2_v1.0.pdf/content", "source_filename": "After_the_Interpretation_Changes_Working_Paper_2_v1.0.pdf", "local_path": "assets/documents/23430200.pdf", "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "source_checksum_match": true, "sha256": "272b077f00db6a02d04c03b87608a0ab8cc34972b11759e51b7ece3890228716", "statement": "Access copy only; no ownership or physical custody transfer is implied." } }, "description_policy_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "pirr_references": [ { "programme_key": "research-critical-language", "programme_title": "Alexander Viktorovich Markov: Critical Language and Lasting Correction", "programme_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-critical-language/", "programme_stage": "In development", "registry_url": "research-registry.html#research-critical-language", "identifiers": [ { "scheme": "PIRR programme reference", "value": "moo-program-2b3ad664cbd92f69b862db8c", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-critical-language/#programme-record" } ], "relation": "Published working paper within a developing inquiry", "relation_note": "Published working paper within a developing inquiry", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/" } ], "pirr_work_identity": { "archive_reference": "MOO-CAT-005", "edition_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23430200", "zenodo_record_id": "23430200", "identifier_scope": "Publication identity; PIRR identifiers in programme relationships identify research records, not this publication." }, "metadata_origin": "https://archive.museumofone.art", "identity": { "work": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23430200.html#work", "edition": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23430200", "version_family": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23430199", "catalogue_record": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23430200.html#catalogue-record" }, "institutional_match_scope": "exact_edition", "relationship_assertions": [ { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:f4caf8eb7846f4233360058d01fb0f6bef64c0d5367b8dfe2a8e0091bf51aeb9", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23430200.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:594393ee5ef8bcd2501a4c5b004d168d9f679feefbfb579c0845f43ec2bcaa6f", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23430200.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:89abb4856a48db487c8e3fde3bfd3e547d4828f01b2a9f6559effd263165dd19", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23430200.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/simon-maris.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The abstract identifies Simon Maris as the artist of the portrait now titled Isabella." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:8ab286bbc76d19e318848536592a0a311ce1019bffbe2b8b17f6ec0276459c76", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23430200.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#has-scholarly-correspondent", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/alexander-viktorovich-markov.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The source records scholarly correspondence and a critical response. It explicitly states that Markov is not a coauthor and that this is not formal peer review or agreement with every proposal." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:9b9176ac726ef49049a1bccf3023ff91c38c448b619716b73640f73063441e39", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23430200.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/isabella.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The abstract identifies the current title and artist. The changing catalogue title is the subject of the paper; historic terminology is not adopted as the preferred label." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:7ec2ee6922fd8dd376d1803ca0f62f1b2cced87b3e7ad2cc7643e221c040485d", "subject": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#describes", "object": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23430200", "scope": "exact_edition", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/after-the-interpretation-changes/", "source_location": { "kind": "metadata_field", "field": "linked_zenodo_dois", "values": [ "10.5281/zenodo.23430200" ] }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "Exact-edition matching requires the selected DOI in the reviewed page metadata; other matches retain their wider scope." } ], "orcid_authority": { "scheme": "ORCID", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "evidence_urls": [ "https://www.museumofone.art/archives-scholarly-infrastructure/", "https://eprints.rclis.org/47182/", "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ], "access_note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "evidence_receipt": "data/source/authority-review-2026-11-04.json" } }, { "id": "23428974", "accession": "MOO-CAT-006", "title": "Answerability: Exhibition, Documentation, and Historical Evidence in Postwar Japanese Art", "source_title": "Answerability: Exhibition, Documentation, and Historical Evidence in Postwar Japanese Art", "short_title": "Answerability", "author": "Dorian Vale", "creators": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "affiliation": "Museum of One", "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094" } ], "doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23428974", "conceptdoi": "10.5281/zenodo.23428973", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23428974", "date": "2026-10-17", "type": "Working paper", "source_resource_type": { "title": "Working paper", "type": "publication", "subtype": "workingpaper" }, "version": "1.0", "collection": "Essays & research", "summary": "Research Working Paper No. 1 examines when exhibition and documentary evidence requires an art-historical account to limit or revise its claims, with particular attention to postwar Japanese art and Shiraga Kazuo.", "subjects": [ "Postwar Japanese art", "Historical evidence", "Exhibition histories", "Documentation" ], "keywords": [ "Historical answerability", "Art historiography", "Postwar Japanese art", "Exhibition history", "Documentation", "Historical evidence", "Artistic operation", "Interpretation", "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Shiraga Kazuo", "Challenging Mud", "Reiko Tomii", "Namiko Kunimoto", "Hi Red Center", "GUN", "Aesthetics", "Museum of One", "Dorian Vale", "Philosophy of Art", "Art Criticism", "Art Theory", "Visual Culture Studies", "Ethics in Art Criticism", "Interpretation and Meaning", "Interpretive Restraint", "Criticism and Reception Theory", "Epistemology of Art", "Gutai", "Japanese avant-garde art", "Postwar Japanese art history", "Art collectives in Japan", "Performance art in Japan", "Photographic documentation", "Art-historical methodology" ], "license": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution–NonCommercial–NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/" }, "files": [ { "name": "Answerability_Working_Paper_01_v1_0.pdf", "url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/23428974/files/Answerability_Working_Paper_01_v1_0.pdf/content", "size": 208809, "size_label": "204 KB", "checksum": "md5:908dc7989ef983324ddcba78684aee12", "mimetype": "application/pdf" } ], "institutional_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "corroboration": "Museum of One’s matching publication page confirms Dorian Vale’s authorship and the work’s institutional context. It links the selected Zenodo edition DOI. Web-record dates are not treated as dates of the deposited edition. Source review: 4 November 2026.", "discrepancies": [], "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "publisher": "Museum of One", "language": "eng", "isbn": null, "related_identifiers": [ { "identifier": "https://www.museumofone.art/reiko-tomii/", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-working-papers/", "relation": "isPartOf", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "10.22501/rc.4965738", "relation": "isVariantFormOf", "resource_type": "publication-workingpaper", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "https://www.historians.org/resource/statement-on-standards-of-professional-conduct/", "relation": "references", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "10.1111/j.1467-8365.2012.00951.x", "relation": "references", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "https://www.moma.org/collection/works/127373", "relation": "references", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.aaa-a.org/programs/conversation-with-reiko-tomii", "relation": "references", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.aaa-a.org/programs/i-challenged-mud-after", "relation": "references", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://field-journal.com/issue-7/localizing-socially-engaged-art-some-observations-on-collective-operations-in-prewar-and-postwar-japan/", "relation": "references", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "10.37050/wpc-co-01_05", "relation": "references", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "10.1017/CBO9780511498381", "relation": "references", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "10.5281/zenodo.18104019", "relation": "references", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "doi" } ], "alternate_identifiers": [], "source_references": [ "American Historical Association. Statement on Standards of Professional Conduct. Revised 2005; amended January 2023. Sections 2–3. Accessed 17 October 2026.", "Kunimoto, Namiko. 2013. Shiraga Kazuo: The Hero and Concrete Violence. Art History 36(1): 154–179. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-8365.2012.00951.x", "Museum of Modern Art. Street Cleaning Event (1964), performed during Fluxfest Presents Hi Red Center Street Cleaning Event, Grand Army Plaza, New York, June 11, 1966. Hi Red Center. Gelatin silver print, 1966. Collection record 2224.2008.1x1–x4. Accessed 17 October 2026.", "Tomii, Reiko. 2011. Conversation with Reiko Tomii. Conversation with Jane DeBevoise. Asia Art Archive in America, 6 September 2011. Accessed 17 October 2026.", "Tomii, Reiko. 2011. I challenged mud, after… Asia Art Archive in America. Account of the historical investigation at the Museum of Modern Art on 23 July 2011. Accessed 17 October 2026.", "Tomii, Reiko. 2017. Localizing Socially Engaged Art: Some Observations on Collective Operations in Prewar and Postwar Japan. FIELD 7 (Spring). Accessed 17 October 2026.", "Tomii, Reiko. 2025. Thinking Operationally: Collectivism in Modern Japan and Its Contemporary Evolution. In Thinking Collectives / Collective Thinking, edited by Eva Bentcheva, Annie Jael Kwan, and Ming Tiampo, 59–76. Berlin: ICI Berlin Press. https://doi.org/10.37050/wpc-co-01_05", "Tucker, Aviezer. 2004. Our Knowledge of the Past: A Philosophy of Historiography. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Introduction, 1–10. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511498381", "Vale, Dorian. 2025. Interpretation at Risk: Post-Interpretive Criticism After the 20th Century. Museum of One. Six-page PDF edition. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.18104019" ], "source_journal": null, "source_imprint": {}, "source_contributors": [], "source_created": "2026-10-17T02:14:15.319009+00:00", "source_modified": "2026-10-17T06:40:32.872759+00:00", "source_description_html": "

This working paper develops a claim-specific criterion of historical answerability through engagement with Reiko Tomii’s scholarship on operation in postwar Japanese art. It asks when evidence concerning exhibition, documentation, and artistic organization requires an art-historical account to reconsider the boundary of the work it claims to explain.

\n

The principal case is Shiraga Kazuo’s Challenging Mud. Tomii’s accounts of material preparation and anticipated display are read beside Namiko Kunimoto’s analysis of action, object, agency, and selfhood. Further investigations address press presentation and photographic selection, Hi Red Center and GUN, conditions of authorization, and the differentiation of events and photographic records in museum cataloguing. The comparison does not presume a disagreement between Tomii and Kunimoto or equate evidence of preparation with complete predetermination.

\n

The method distinguishes attribution, justification, and historical accuracy. Before evaluating a challenge, it fixes a proposition’s referent, meaning, scope, certainty, and evidential basis. Retention, limitation, revision, and suspension identify possible consequences of evidence without becoming compulsory stages or an aesthetic scoring system. The analysis separates a supported preparation-display relation from stronger claims about intention and distinguishes documentation’s original public operation from the reach of its later historical testimony.

\n

The contribution is a disciplined account of inferential reach within the historical problems Tomii’s research makes visible. It also refines the application of restraint in Post-Interpretive Criticism: the amount of explanation cannot be prescribed before its evidential function is examined. This is a source-critical study of published arguments, not an independently inspected archival reconstruction or an empirical study of museum audiences. The criterion remains open to further cases and scholarly revision.

\n

Research Working Paper No. 1. Version 1.0. 10 pages.

\n

Independent working paper by Dorian Vale, developed following discussion and feedback from Reiko Tomii. Tomii is not a coauthor. Her feedback is not represented as endorsement or formal peer review. Private correspondence and meeting records are not reproduced.

\n

Research programme and detailed study overview: https://www.museumofone.art/reiko-tomii/ 

", "provenance": { "repository": "Zenodo REST API response supplied in query.json", "retrieved": "2026-11-04", "editorial_fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "source_snapshot": "source/23428974.json", "institutional_review": "Reviewed page-level title, author and repository links in saved public institutional HTML, 2026-11-04." }, "source_review": "2026-11-04", "relations": [ { "identifier": "https://www.museumofone.art/reiko-tomii/", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-working-papers/", "relation": "isPartOf", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "10.22501/rc.4965738", "relation": "isVariantFormOf", "resource_type": "publication-workingpaper", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "https://www.historians.org/resource/statement-on-standards-of-professional-conduct/", "relation": "references", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "10.1111/j.1467-8365.2012.00951.x", "relation": "references", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "https://www.moma.org/collection/works/127373", "relation": "references", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.aaa-a.org/programs/conversation-with-reiko-tomii", "relation": "references", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.aaa-a.org/programs/i-challenged-mud-after", "relation": "references", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://field-journal.com/issue-7/localizing-socially-engaged-art-some-observations-on-collective-operations-in-prewar-and-postwar-japan/", "relation": "references", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "10.37050/wpc-co-01_05", "relation": "references", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "10.1017/CBO9780511498381", "relation": "references", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "10.5281/zenodo.18104019", "relation": "references", "resource_type": "other", "scheme": "doi" } ], "institutional_metadata": { "title": "Answerability: Exhibition, Documentation, and Historical Evidence in Postwar Japanese Art", "author": "Dorian Vale", "web_publication": "2026-10-17T05:27:38.000Z", "web_updated": "2026-11-02T20:40:46.000Z", "linked_zenodo_dois": [ "10.5281/zenodo.23428974" ], "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/" }, "research_programmes": [ { "title": "Reiko Tomii: Operation and Historical Answerability", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/reiko-tomii/", "status": "In development", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "relation": "Published working paper within a developing inquiry", "relation_label": "Published working paper within a developing inquiry" } ], "citation": "Vale, Dorian. 2026. Answerability: Exhibition, Documentation, and Historical Evidence in Postwar Japanese Art. Museum of One Research Working Paper No. 1, version 1.0. Museum of One. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23428974.", "record_level": "Item", "record_status": "Published source; selected catalogue record", "digital_formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "extent": "1 digital file; 208809 bytes", "medium": "Digital document", "record_reviewed": "2026-11-04", "date_precision": "day", "alternate_titles": [], "digital_extent": { "file_count": 1, "total_bytes": 208809, "formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "checksums": [ { "filename": "Answerability_Working_Paper_01_v1_0.pdf", "algorithm": "md5", "value": "908dc7989ef983324ddcba78684aee12", "syntax_valid": true, "verification": "source_checksum_transcription; bytes not independently recomputed" } ], "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23428974", "derivation": "File count and total bytes calculated from repository file metadata; MIME inferred from filename when absent." }, "identifier_validation": { "orcid": { "source_value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "ISO 7064 MOD 11-2 checksum only; this is not a live registry verification." }, "isbn": [], "doi": { "source_value": "10.5281/zenodo.23428974", "syntax_valid": true, "note": "Syntax check only; repository snapshot supplies the identifier." } }, "isbn_applicability": "not_supplied", "serial": null, "contributor_roles": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": "Museum of One", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23428974" } ], "authority_links": [], "metadata_profile": { "name": "Museum of One source-qualified catalogue profile", "version": "3.0.0", "url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/metadata-profile.json", "source_snapshot_preserved": true }, "reading_copy": { "id": "23428974", "title": "Answerability: Exhibition, Documentation, and Historical Evidence in Postwar Japanese Art", "accession": "MOO-CAT-006", "pdf_url": "../assets/documents/23428974.pdf", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/23428974/files/Answerability_Working_Paper_01_v1_0.pdf/content", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23428974", "source_filename": "Answerability_Working_Paper_01_v1_0.pdf", "checksum": "md5:908dc7989ef983324ddcba78684aee12", "sha256": "079dcc91558e146ca7f9c204d5441c3fe6f9958ca4668700bcc0016766c75ad9", "bytes": 208809, "page_count": 10, "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "checksum_match": true, "rights": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution–NonCommercial–NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/" }, "role": "Local reading copy; original repository file retained unchanged" }, "page_count": 10, "field_assertions": [ { "field": "title", "value": "Answerability: Exhibition, Documentation, and Historical Evidence in Postwar Japanese Art", "status": "catalogue_title", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "note": "Local display title; the deposited title is retained separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_title", "value": "Answerability: Exhibition, Documentation, and Historical Evidence in Postwar Japanese Art", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23428974", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "doi", "value": "10.5281/zenodo.23428974", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23428974", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "date", "value": "2026-10-17", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23428974", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "version", "value": "1.0", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23428974", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "conceptdoi", "value": "10.5281/zenodo.23428973", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23428974", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "creators", "value": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "affiliation": "Museum of One", "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23428974", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "keywords", "value": [ "Historical answerability", "Art historiography", "Postwar Japanese art", "Exhibition history", "Documentation", "Historical evidence", "Artistic operation", "Interpretation", "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Shiraga Kazuo", "Challenging Mud", "Reiko Tomii", "Namiko Kunimoto", "Hi Red Center", "GUN", "Aesthetics", "Museum of One", "Dorian Vale", "Philosophy of Art", "Art Criticism", "Art Theory", "Visual Culture Studies", "Ethics in Art Criticism", "Interpretation and Meaning", "Interpretive Restraint", "Criticism and Reception Theory", "Epistemology of Art", "Gutai", "Japanese avant-garde art", "Postwar Japanese art history", "Art collectives in Japan", "Performance art in Japan", "Photographic documentation", "Art-historical methodology" ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23428974", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "language", "value": "eng", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23428974", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "license", "value": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution–NonCommercial–NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/" }, "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23428974", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "files", "value": [ { "name": "Answerability_Working_Paper_01_v1_0.pdf", "url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/23428974/files/Answerability_Working_Paper_01_v1_0.pdf/content", "size": 208809, "size_label": "204 KB", "checksum": "md5:908dc7989ef983324ddcba78684aee12", "mimetype": "application/pdf" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23428974", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_created", "value": "2026-10-17T02:14:15.319009+00:00", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23428974", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_modified", "value": "2026-10-17T06:40:32.872759+00:00", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23428974", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "record_modified", "value": "2026-11-04", "status": "derived_from_description_history", "note": "Latest documented local description event; not a publication, repository or source-review date.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_review", "value": "2026-11-04", "status": "catalogue_source_review", "note": "Review of descriptive sources; not the creation or modification date of the work or repository record.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "author", "value": "Dorian Vale", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "note": "Institutional responsibility statement; original repository creator roles remain separate.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "publisher", "value": "Museum of One", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "note": "Institutional responsibility statement; original repository creator roles remain separate.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "orcid", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "source_linked_identifier", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "note": "Creator identifier supplied by the linked sources; no affiliation or endorsement is inferred.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "orcid_authority", "value": { "scheme": "ORCID", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "evidence_urls": [ "https://www.museumofone.art/archives-scholarly-infrastructure/", "https://eprints.rclis.org/47182/", "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ], "access_note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "evidence_receipt": "data/source/authority-review-2026-11-04.json" }, "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "source_url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "summary", "value": "Research Working Paper No. 1 examines when exhibition and documentary evidence requires an art-historical account to limit or revise its claims, with particular attention to postwar Japanese art and Shiraga Kazuo.", "status": "editorial_enrichment", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "note": "Catalogue-editor summary based on the linked work; not an original publisher abstract.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "subjects", "value": [ "Postwar Japanese art", "Historical evidence", "Exhibition histories", "Documentation" ], "status": "editorial_enrichment", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "note": "Local discovery terms; no controlled-vocabulary assignment is claimed.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "collection", "value": "Essays & research", "status": "editorial_grouping", "note": "A local browsing collection, not an original repository collection.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "corroboration", "value": "Museum of One’s matching publication page confirms Dorian Vale’s authorship and the work’s institutional context. It links the selected Zenodo edition DOI. Web-record dates are not treated as dates of the deposited edition. Source review: 4 November 2026.", "status": "catalogue_review_note", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "date_precision", "value": "day", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23428974", "note": "Precision reported exactly as supplied; missing month or day is not filled.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "medium", "value": "Digital document", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23428974", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "digital_formats", "value": [ "application/pdf" ], "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23428974", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "extent", "value": "1 digital file; 208809 bytes", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23428974", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "digital_extent", "value": { "file_count": 1, "total_bytes": 208809, "formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "checksums": [ { "filename": "Answerability_Working_Paper_01_v1_0.pdf", "algorithm": "md5", "value": "908dc7989ef983324ddcba78684aee12", "syntax_valid": true, "verification": "source_checksum_transcription; bytes not independently recomputed" } ], "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23428974", "derivation": "File count and total bytes calculated from repository file metadata; MIME inferred from filename when absent." }, "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23428974", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "identifier_validation", "value": { "orcid": { "source_value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "ISO 7064 MOD 11-2 checksum only; this is not a live registry verification." }, "isbn": [], "doi": { "source_value": "10.5281/zenodo.23428974", "syntax_valid": true, "note": "Syntax check only; repository snapshot supplies the identifier." } }, "status": "local_syntax_validation", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23428974", "note": "Checksum/syntax validation does not verify registration, assignment or edition applicability.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "contributor_roles", "value": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": "Museum of One", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23428974" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23428974", "note": "Creator and contributor roles are transcribed, not inferred from names or affiliations.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "research_programme:https://www.museumofone.art/reiko-tomii/", "value": { "title": "Reiko Tomii: Operation and Historical Answerability", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/reiko-tomii/", "status": "In development", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "relation": "Published working paper within a developing inquiry", "relation_label": "Published working paper within a developing inquiry" }, "status": "institutional_work_relationship", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "note": "Programme relationship and stage follow the work-specific institutional badge; publication does not imply a completed programme or collaboration.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "entity_link:dorian-vale:author", "value": { "id": "dorian-vale", "label": "Dorian Vale", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "author", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author.", "variants": [ "Vale, Dorian" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:3bb842dc4e6d87f2c3b561cb44e66295baee0bb11f9e9a8bb69997a24e4c619e", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23428974.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." } }, { "field": "entity_link:museum-of-one:publisher", "value": { "id": "museum-of-one", "label": "Museum of One", "entity_type": "Organization", "relation": "publisher", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record.", "variants": [ "MuseumofOne", "MUSEUM OF ONE" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:d1ae13882f6c84e7ca8bfcd3f7f77f96624e3bccf4eeeb4da53840ed7ee75136", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23428974.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." } }, { "field": "entity_link:shiraga-kazuo:artist discussed", "value": { "id": "shiraga-kazuo", "label": "Shiraga Kazuo", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "artist discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "note": "The abstract identifies Shiraga Kazuo’s Challenging Mud as the principal case.", "variants": [ "Kazuo Shiraga" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:6ca1a3a0666273553ef0227dc69fde02894c77444137621706db775571d472c2", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23428974.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/shiraga-kazuo.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The abstract identifies Shiraga Kazuo’s Challenging Mud as the principal case." } }, { "field": "entity_link:reiko-tomii:scholar discussed", "value": { "id": "reiko-tomii", "label": "Reiko Tomii", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "scholar discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "note": "The paper engages Tomii’s scholarship and records discussion and feedback. The source explicitly states that Tomii is not a coauthor and that no blanket endorsement or formal peer review is implied.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:123ccae55316d10562e27370749c1e5eab46dfcf736a7837c028b0a0b4954206", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23428974.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-scholar", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/reiko-tomii.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The paper engages Tomii’s scholarship and records discussion and feedback. The source explicitly states that Tomii is not a coauthor and that no blanket endorsement or formal peer review is implied." } }, { "field": "entity_link:namiko-kunimoto:scholar discussed", "value": { "id": "namiko-kunimoto", "label": "Namiko Kunimoto", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "scholar discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "note": "The abstract identifies Kunimoto’s analysis as scholarship read alongside Tomii’s work; no coauthorship is asserted.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:489656dbd2f936567e14d946b22c352642e2de94ce1ef6865f04de5ec30b0186", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23428974.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-scholar", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/namiko-kunimoto.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The abstract identifies Kunimoto’s analysis as scholarship read alongside Tomii’s work; no coauthorship is asserted." } }, { "field": "entity_link:challenging-mud:artwork discussed", "value": { "id": "challenging-mud", "label": "Challenging Mud", "entity_type": "Artwork", "relation": "artwork discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "note": "The abstract identifies the title and artist. Different executions and the relationship between action and displayed result are examined in the paper; this record does not merge those events into a single documented object.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:921bc94da701d09e6a5715e70509b7ea43b98bfcf3067762ba549ee2116947da", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23428974.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/challenging-mud.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The abstract identifies the title and artist. Different executions and the relationship between action and displayed result are examined in the paper; this record does not merge those events into a single documented object." } }, { "field": "controlled_subjects", "value": [ { "id": "postwar-japanese-art", "label": "Postwar Japanese art", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#postwar-japanese-art", "url": "vocabulary.html#postwar-japanese-art", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:postwar-japanese-art", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Art in Japan considered in relation to the period after the Second World War.", "scope_note": "A contextual historical access point. The item description identifies the practices and dates actually discussed.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "historical-evidence", "label": "Historical evidence", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#historical-evidence", "url": "vocabulary.html#historical-evidence", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:historical-evidence", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Evidence used to support or constrain accounts of past artistic activity.", "scope_note": "Use for methodological discussion of what an art-historical claim can substantiate.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "documentary-evidence" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "exhibition-histories", "label": "Exhibition histories", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#exhibition-histories", "url": "vocabulary.html#exhibition-histories", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:exhibition-histories", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Exhibition history" ], "definition": "Historical study of exhibitions, their events, and their documentary traces.", "scope_note": "Use for publications examining what exhibition records allow a historical account to claim.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "documentation" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "documentation", "label": "Documentation", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#documentation", "url": "vocabulary.html#documentation", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:documentation", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "The recording and preservation of information about art, events, or practices.", "scope_note": "Use for discussion of documentary processes and their limitations; related to Documentary evidence.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "documentary-evidence", "exhibition-histories" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Local preferred terms with definitions and synonyms. External alignment is scoped in the vocabulary register." }, { "field": "genre_terms", "value": [ { "id": "genre-working-paper", "label": "Working paper", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#genre-working-paper", "url": "vocabulary.html#genre-working-paper", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:genre-working-paper", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Working papers" ], "definition": "A research publication presented as a working or operational paper.", "scope_note": "Preserve source version and programme stage. This genre does not imply peer review or final publication status.", "kind": "genre", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "type", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Local resource-genre classification. Digital file format is recorded separately." }, { "field": "archival_context", "value": { "description_profile": "moo-description-policy-1.0", "catalogue_snapshot_date": "2026-11-04", "snapshot_note": "Selected catalogue snapshot; not a live repository synchronisation.", "record_category": "Published library and repository material", "reference_code_status": "Stable local catalogue reference; not evidence of an archival acquisition or a previous catalogue accession.", "source_repository": { "name": "Zenodo", "record_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23428974" }, "institutional_context_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "source_metadata_retrieved": "2026-11-04", "source_metadata_retrieval_status": "Documented in catalogue source provenance", "source_snapshot": "source/23428974.json", "source_filenames": [ "Answerability_Working_Paper_01_v1_0.pdf" ], "selection_basis": "Local descriptive selection of publicly published material; public availability does not establish ownership of originals.", "custodial_history": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No donation, physical transfer, acquisition agreement or chain of custody is documented by this catalogue. Zenodo remains the source repository for the deposited version." }, "original_order": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No original archival order is asserted. Current browsing groupings are local editorial arrangement." }, "arrangement": { "status": "local_editorial", "grouping": "Essays & research", "statement": "A browsing grouping, not an original fonds or archival series." }, "responsible_service": { "name": "Museum of One", "service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "website": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "email": "research@museumofone.art" }, "description_method": "Source-based description with automated drafting and metadata assistance. Responsibility for the public catalogue rests with Museum of One; automated assistance does not constitute independent scholarly or curatorial review.", "policy_url": "policies.html", "correction_email": "research@museumofone.art", "access_copy": { "role": "Local digital reading copy of the deposited file", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/23428974/files/Answerability_Working_Paper_01_v1_0.pdf/content", "source_filename": "Answerability_Working_Paper_01_v1_0.pdf", "local_path": "assets/documents/23428974.pdf", "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "source_checksum_match": true, "sha256": "079dcc91558e146ca7f9c204d5441c3fe6f9958ca4668700bcc0016766c75ad9", "statement": "Access copy only; no ownership or physical custody transfer is implied." } }, "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Provenance records what is documented and leaves unknown custody and original order explicit." }, { "field": "description_history", "value": [ { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Source-based catalogue description", "note": "Local description assembled from the identified public repository record and available institutional work record. Source metadata remains separately identifiable.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/23428974", "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Qualified descriptive enrichment", "note": "Local editorial description, arrangement and source-qualified bibliographic context recorded alongside source metadata. Unknown or disputed values remain qualified.", "fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/23428974", "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Automated file checksum and PDF inspection", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Digital reading copy verified", "note": "Downloaded access-copy MD5 matched the source checksum; local SHA-256 and PDF file-page count are recorded in the file manifest. This event does not describe transfer of custody.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/api/records/23428974/files/Answerability_Working_Paper_01_v1_0.pdf/content" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Description policy and provenance context adopted", "note": "Responsible service, source repository, local access-copy role, unknown custody and original order, correction route and dated description history made explicit under moo-description-policy-1.0.", "sources": [ "policies.html" ] }, { "event_id": "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Unify graph identities and qualify exported relationships and citations", "note": "Local graph projection now uses one contextual identity per entity, distinguishes work-level institutional matches from selected-edition links, retains title-level ISBN uncertainty, and derives citations from the source title. Typed relation assertions and a versioned validation profile are introduced. No publication date, original source snapshot or PDF changed.", "fields": [ "metadata_profile", "relationship_assertions", "identity", "institutional_match_scope", "citation_projection" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Source-based metadata implementation and regression validation", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication, source review or acquisition date", "sources": [ "metadata/metadata-profile.json" ] }, { "event_id": "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Record inspected public ORCID profile evidence", "note": "The official ORCID public person API returned the credited name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website. This confirms a matching public profile, not independently verified biographical or affiliation claims. Original creator arrays and source snapshots are unchanged.", "fields": [ "orcid_authority" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Read-only official public API inspection", "date_kind": "Local authority review and catalogue description event; not a publication or original creation date", "sources": [ "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ] } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Catalogue description events; these are not work publication dates or acquisition dates." }, { "field": "pirr_references", "value": [ { "programme_key": "reiko-tomii", "programme_title": "Reiko Tomii: Operation and Historical Answerability", "programme_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/reiko-tomii/", "programme_stage": "In development", "registry_url": "research-registry.html#reiko-tomii", "identifiers": [ { "scheme": "PIRR programme reference", "value": "moo-program-fc96d462c463652ce260cd27", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/reiko-tomii/#programme-record" } ], "relation": "Published working paper within a developing inquiry", "relation_note": "Published working paper within a developing inquiry", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/" } ], "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "PIRR project IDs and programme references identify research records, not publication versions or independent chapter deposits." }, { "field": "relationship_assertions", "value": [ { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:3bb842dc4e6d87f2c3b561cb44e66295baee0bb11f9e9a8bb69997a24e4c619e", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23428974.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:d1ae13882f6c84e7ca8bfcd3f7f77f96624e3bccf4eeeb4da53840ed7ee75136", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23428974.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:6ca1a3a0666273553ef0227dc69fde02894c77444137621706db775571d472c2", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23428974.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/shiraga-kazuo.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The abstract identifies Shiraga Kazuo’s Challenging Mud as the principal case." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:123ccae55316d10562e27370749c1e5eab46dfcf736a7837c028b0a0b4954206", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23428974.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-scholar", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/reiko-tomii.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The paper engages Tomii’s scholarship and records discussion and feedback. The source explicitly states that Tomii is not a coauthor and that no blanket endorsement or formal peer review is implied." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:489656dbd2f936567e14d946b22c352642e2de94ce1ef6865f04de5ec30b0186", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23428974.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-scholar", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/namiko-kunimoto.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The abstract identifies Kunimoto’s analysis as scholarship read alongside Tomii’s work; no coauthorship is asserted." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:921bc94da701d09e6a5715e70509b7ea43b98bfcf3067762ba549ee2116947da", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23428974.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/challenging-mud.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The abstract identifies the title and artist. Different executions and the relationship between action and displayed result are examined in the paper; this record does not merge those events into a single documented object." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:69559507ffddbc0dbba409ee6ba7cd60eed421cdb5880152dafddf81194e21b0", "subject": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#describes", "object": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23428974", "scope": "exact_edition", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "source_location": { "kind": "metadata_field", "field": "linked_zenodo_dois", "values": [ "10.5281/zenodo.23428974" ] }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "Exact-edition matching requires the selected DOI in the reviewed page metadata; other matches retain their wider scope." } ], "status": "typed_evidence_projection", "note": "Stable, typed assertions retain source scope and explicit unknown review metadata." }, { "field": "reading_copy", "value": { "id": "23428974", "title": "Answerability: Exhibition, Documentation, and Historical Evidence in Postwar Japanese Art", "accession": "MOO-CAT-006", "pdf_url": "../assets/documents/23428974.pdf", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/23428974/files/Answerability_Working_Paper_01_v1_0.pdf/content", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23428974", "source_filename": "Answerability_Working_Paper_01_v1_0.pdf", "checksum": "md5:908dc7989ef983324ddcba78684aee12", "sha256": "079dcc91558e146ca7f9c204d5441c3fe6f9958ca4668700bcc0016766c75ad9", "bytes": 208809, "page_count": 10, "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "checksum_match": true, "rights": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution–NonCommercial–NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/" }, "role": "Local reading copy; original repository file retained unchanged" }, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/23428974/files/Answerability_Working_Paper_01_v1_0.pdf/content", "status": "derived_file_inspection", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "note": "Byte-identical local access copy. Source MD5 was recomputed and matched; SHA-256 and page count were measured from the downloaded PDF. This is not a preservation-deposit claim." }, { "field": "page_count", "value": 10, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/23428974/files/Answerability_Working_Paper_01_v1_0.pdf/content", "status": "derived_file_inspection", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "note": "Total PDF file pages measured from the deposited file, including cover and unnumbered pages. Not a claim about printed pagination." } ], "entity_links": [ { "id": "dorian-vale", "label": "Dorian Vale", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "author", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author.", "variants": [ "Vale, Dorian" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "museum-of-one", "label": "Museum of One", "entity_type": "Organization", "relation": "publisher", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record.", "variants": [ "MuseumofOne", "MUSEUM OF ONE" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "shiraga-kazuo", "label": "Shiraga Kazuo", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "artist discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "note": "The abstract identifies Shiraga Kazuo’s Challenging Mud as the principal case.", "variants": [ "Kazuo Shiraga" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "reiko-tomii", "label": "Reiko Tomii", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "scholar discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "note": "The paper engages Tomii’s scholarship and records discussion and feedback. The source explicitly states that Tomii is not a coauthor and that no blanket endorsement or formal peer review is implied.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "namiko-kunimoto", "label": "Namiko Kunimoto", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "scholar discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "note": "The abstract identifies Kunimoto’s analysis as scholarship read alongside Tomii’s work; no coauthorship is asserted.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "challenging-mud", "label": "Challenging Mud", "entity_type": "Artwork", "relation": "artwork discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "note": "The abstract identifies the title and artist. Different executions and the relationship between action and displayed result are examined in the paper; this record does not merge those events into a single documented object.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" } ], "contents": [], "controlled_subjects": [ { "id": "postwar-japanese-art", "label": "Postwar Japanese art", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#postwar-japanese-art", "url": "vocabulary.html#postwar-japanese-art", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:postwar-japanese-art", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Art in Japan considered in relation to the period after the Second World War.", "scope_note": "A contextual historical access point. The item description identifies the practices and dates actually discussed.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "historical-evidence", "label": "Historical evidence", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#historical-evidence", "url": "vocabulary.html#historical-evidence", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:historical-evidence", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Evidence used to support or constrain accounts of past artistic activity.", "scope_note": "Use for methodological discussion of what an art-historical claim can substantiate.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "documentary-evidence" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "exhibition-histories", "label": "Exhibition histories", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#exhibition-histories", "url": "vocabulary.html#exhibition-histories", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:exhibition-histories", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Exhibition history" ], "definition": "Historical study of exhibitions, their events, and their documentary traces.", "scope_note": "Use for publications examining what exhibition records allow a historical account to claim.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "documentation" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "documentation", "label": "Documentation", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#documentation", "url": "vocabulary.html#documentation", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:documentation", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "The recording and preservation of information about art, events, or practices.", "scope_note": "Use for discussion of documentary processes and their limitations; related to Documentary evidence.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "documentary-evidence", "exhibition-histories" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "genre_terms": [ { "id": "genre-working-paper", "label": "Working paper", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#genre-working-paper", "url": "vocabulary.html#genre-working-paper", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:genre-working-paper", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Working papers" ], "definition": "A research publication presented as a working or operational paper.", "scope_note": "Preserve source version and programme stage. This genre does not imply peer review or final publication status.", "kind": "genre", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "type", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "vocabulary_version": 4, "description_history": [ { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Source-based catalogue description", "note": "Local description assembled from the identified public repository record and available institutional work record. Source metadata remains separately identifiable.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/23428974", "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Qualified descriptive enrichment", "note": "Local editorial description, arrangement and source-qualified bibliographic context recorded alongside source metadata. Unknown or disputed values remain qualified.", "fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/23428974", "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Automated file checksum and PDF inspection", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Digital reading copy verified", "note": "Downloaded access-copy MD5 matched the source checksum; local SHA-256 and PDF file-page count are recorded in the file manifest. This event does not describe transfer of custody.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/api/records/23428974/files/Answerability_Working_Paper_01_v1_0.pdf/content" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Description policy and provenance context adopted", "note": "Responsible service, source repository, local access-copy role, unknown custody and original order, correction route and dated description history made explicit under moo-description-policy-1.0.", "sources": [ "policies.html" ] }, { "event_id": "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Unify graph identities and qualify exported relationships and citations", "note": "Local graph projection now uses one contextual identity per entity, distinguishes work-level institutional matches from selected-edition links, retains title-level ISBN uncertainty, and derives citations from the source title. Typed relation assertions and a versioned validation profile are introduced. No publication date, original source snapshot or PDF changed.", "fields": [ "metadata_profile", "relationship_assertions", "identity", "institutional_match_scope", "citation_projection" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Source-based metadata implementation and regression validation", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication, source review or acquisition date", "sources": [ "metadata/metadata-profile.json" ] }, { "event_id": "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Record inspected public ORCID profile evidence", "note": "The official ORCID public person API returned the credited name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website. This confirms a matching public profile, not independently verified biographical or affiliation claims. Original creator arrays and source snapshots are unchanged.", "fields": [ "orcid_authority" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Read-only official public API inspection", "date_kind": "Local authority review and catalogue description event; not a publication or original creation date", "sources": [ "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ] } ], "record_modified": "2026-11-04", "record_modified_provenance": { "status": "derived_from_description_history", "event_ids": [ "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04" ], "note": "Latest documented local description event; not a publication, repository or source-review date." }, "archival_context": { "description_profile": "moo-description-policy-1.0", "catalogue_snapshot_date": "2026-11-04", "snapshot_note": "Selected catalogue snapshot; not a live repository synchronisation.", "record_category": "Published library and repository material", "reference_code_status": "Stable local catalogue reference; not evidence of an archival acquisition or a previous catalogue accession.", "source_repository": { "name": "Zenodo", "record_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/23428974" }, "institutional_context_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "source_metadata_retrieved": "2026-11-04", "source_metadata_retrieval_status": "Documented in catalogue source provenance", "source_snapshot": "source/23428974.json", "source_filenames": [ "Answerability_Working_Paper_01_v1_0.pdf" ], "selection_basis": "Local descriptive selection of publicly published material; public availability does not establish ownership of originals.", "custodial_history": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No donation, physical transfer, acquisition agreement or chain of custody is documented by this catalogue. Zenodo remains the source repository for the deposited version." }, "original_order": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No original archival order is asserted. Current browsing groupings are local editorial arrangement." }, "arrangement": { "status": "local_editorial", "grouping": "Essays & research", "statement": "A browsing grouping, not an original fonds or archival series." }, "responsible_service": { "name": "Museum of One", "service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "website": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "email": "research@museumofone.art" }, "description_method": "Source-based description with automated drafting and metadata assistance. Responsibility for the public catalogue rests with Museum of One; automated assistance does not constitute independent scholarly or curatorial review.", "policy_url": "policies.html", "correction_email": "research@museumofone.art", "access_copy": { "role": "Local digital reading copy of the deposited file", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/23428974/files/Answerability_Working_Paper_01_v1_0.pdf/content", "source_filename": "Answerability_Working_Paper_01_v1_0.pdf", "local_path": "assets/documents/23428974.pdf", "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "source_checksum_match": true, "sha256": "079dcc91558e146ca7f9c204d5441c3fe6f9958ca4668700bcc0016766c75ad9", "statement": "Access copy only; no ownership or physical custody transfer is implied." } }, "description_policy_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "pirr_references": [ { "programme_key": "reiko-tomii", "programme_title": "Reiko Tomii: Operation and Historical Answerability", "programme_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/reiko-tomii/", "programme_stage": "In development", "registry_url": "research-registry.html#reiko-tomii", "identifiers": [ { "scheme": "PIRR programme reference", "value": "moo-program-fc96d462c463652ce260cd27", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/reiko-tomii/#programme-record" } ], "relation": "Published working paper within a developing inquiry", "relation_note": "Published working paper within a developing inquiry", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/" } ], "pirr_work_identity": { "archive_reference": "MOO-CAT-006", "edition_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23428974", "zenodo_record_id": "23428974", "identifier_scope": "Publication identity; PIRR identifiers in programme relationships identify research records, not this publication." }, "metadata_origin": "https://archive.museumofone.art", "identity": { "work": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23428974.html#work", "edition": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23428974", "version_family": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23428973", "catalogue_record": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23428974.html#catalogue-record" }, "institutional_match_scope": "exact_edition", "relationship_assertions": [ { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:3bb842dc4e6d87f2c3b561cb44e66295baee0bb11f9e9a8bb69997a24e4c619e", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23428974.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:d1ae13882f6c84e7ca8bfcd3f7f77f96624e3bccf4eeeb4da53840ed7ee75136", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23428974.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:6ca1a3a0666273553ef0227dc69fde02894c77444137621706db775571d472c2", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23428974.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/shiraga-kazuo.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The abstract identifies Shiraga Kazuo’s Challenging Mud as the principal case." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:123ccae55316d10562e27370749c1e5eab46dfcf736a7837c028b0a0b4954206", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23428974.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-scholar", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/reiko-tomii.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The paper engages Tomii’s scholarship and records discussion and feedback. The source explicitly states that Tomii is not a coauthor and that no blanket endorsement or formal peer review is implied." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:489656dbd2f936567e14d946b22c352642e2de94ce1ef6865f04de5ec30b0186", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23428974.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-scholar", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/namiko-kunimoto.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The abstract identifies Kunimoto’s analysis as scholarship read alongside Tomii’s work; no coauthorship is asserted." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:921bc94da701d09e6a5715e70509b7ea43b98bfcf3067762ba549ee2116947da", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/23428974.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/challenging-mud.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The abstract identifies the title and artist. Different executions and the relationship between action and displayed result are examined in the paper; this record does not merge those events into a single documented object." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:69559507ffddbc0dbba409ee6ba7cd60eed421cdb5880152dafddf81194e21b0", "subject": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#describes", "object": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23428974", "scope": "exact_edition", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/answerability/", "source_location": { "kind": "metadata_field", "field": "linked_zenodo_dois", "values": [ "10.5281/zenodo.23428974" ] }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "Exact-edition matching requires the selected DOI in the reviewed page metadata; other matches retain their wider scope." } ], "orcid_authority": { "scheme": "ORCID", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "evidence_urls": [ "https://www.museumofone.art/archives-scholarly-infrastructure/", "https://eprints.rclis.org/47182/", "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ], "access_note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "evidence_receipt": "data/source/authority-review-2026-11-04.json" } }, { "id": "21715085", "accession": "MOO-CAT-007", "title": "Art That Falls Apart: Material Fatigue as Moral Statement", "source_title": "Art That Falls Apart: Material Fatigue as Moral Statement", "short_title": "Art That Falls Apart", "author": "Dorian Vale", "creators": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "affiliation": null, "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094" }, { "name": "Museum of One", "affiliation": null } ], "doi": "10.5281/zenodo.21715085", "conceptdoi": "10.5281/zenodo.21715084", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21715085", "date": "2026-07-31", "type": "Journal article", "source_resource_type": { "title": "Journal article", "type": "publication", "subtype": "article" }, "version": "", "collection": "Essays & research", "summary": "An essay considering unstable materials, deterioration, and the tension between conservation and artistic impermanence. It reads material fatigue through the ethics of witnessing.", "subjects": [ "Contemporary art", "Material deterioration", "Conservation ethics", "Impermanence" ], "keywords": [ "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Stillmark Theory", "Message-Transfer Theory", "MTT", "Misplacement", "Displacement", "Aesthetic Displacement Theory", "Theory of Misplacement", "Absential Aesthetics", "Witness Aesthetics", "Hauntmark Theory", "Presence-Based Criticism", "Custodianship of Art", "Art as Ontology", "Aesthetic Recursion", "Aesthetic Recursion Theory", "Viewer as Evidence Theory", "Interpretive Load Index (ILI)", "Viewer Displacement Ratio (VDR)", "Ethical Proximity Score (EPS)", "Institutional Alignment Indicator (IAI)", "Epoché Fidelity Index (EFI)", "Phenomenological Phase Alignment Score (PPAS)", "Residue Engagement Restraint Ratio (RERR)", "Quasi-Subject Agency Recognition Index (QSARI)", "Dialectical Circulation Index (DCI)", "Restraint in front of art", "Moral proximity", "Interpretive silence", "Erasure as ethics", "Temporal scarcity", "Silence as method", "Ontology of beauty", "Language as violence", "Aesthetic mercy", "Art encounter ethics", "Epistemology of witness", "Philosophy of Art", "Aesthetics", "Art Theory", "Contemporary Aesthetics", "Comparative Aesthetics", "Phenomenology and Art", "Phenomenology", "Aesthetic Phenomenology", "Phenomenology of Aesthetic", "post-hermeneutics phenomenology", "Ethics in Art Criticism", "Interpretation and Meaning", "Criticism and Reception Theory", "Epistemology of Art", "Visual Culture Studies", "Dorian Vale", "Founder of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Post-Aesthetic Critic", "Independent Philosopher of Art", "Museum of One", "Art Writer and Theorist", "Aesthetic Philosopher", "Custodian of Witness Aesthetics", "The Doctrine of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "The Custodian's Oath", "The Canon of Witnesses", "Art as Truth", "Art as Presence", "The Viewer as Evidence", "Interpretation vs. Witnessing", "Language as Custody", "Erasure as Afterlife", "Museum of One Manifesto", "Post-Interpretive Lexicon", "Alternative art criticism", "New art criticism movement", "Ethical art theory", "Criticism beyond interpretation", "Slow looking philosophy", "Contemporary sacred aesthetics", "Quiet philosophy of art", "Radical art restraint", "Witness over interpretation", "Interpretive Restraint" ], "license": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "files": [ { "name": "Art That Falls Apart — material fatigue as moral statement.pdf", "url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/21715085/files/Art%20That%20Falls%20Apart%20%E2%80%94%20material%20fatigue%20as%20moral%20statement.pdf/content", "size": 880295, "size_label": "860 KB", "checksum": "md5:9865b03866bdebb2458da23c34d23c07", "mimetype": "application/pdf" } ], "institutional_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "corroboration": "Museum of One’s matching publication page confirms Dorian Vale’s authorship and the work’s institutional context. Its repository links and publication dates are retained separately from this selected Zenodo edition. Web-record dates are not treated as dates of the deposited edition. Source review: 4 November 2026.", "discrepancies": [ "The repository also lists organizational or URL-form creator entries. The catalogue displays Dorian Vale as bibliographic author while retaining the deposited creator list separately.", "The Museum of One web record is dated 29 July 2026; this selected Zenodo edition gives 31 July 2026. These describe separate publication records." ], "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "publisher": "Museum of One", "language": null, "isbn": null, "related_identifiers": [ { "identifier": "978-1-06-982030-3", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "isbn" }, { "identifier": "978-1-06-982031-0", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "isbn" }, { "identifier": "978-1-06-982032-7", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "isbn" }, { "identifier": "978-1-06-982033-4", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "isbn" }, { "identifier": "978-1-06-982034-1", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "isbn" }, { "identifier": "https://www.museumofone.art", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://zenodo.org/communities/post-interpretive-criticism", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://osf.io/zhnre/", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://works.hcommons.org/records/xv2j2-g6927", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://philpapers.org/rec/VALPCF-2", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.semanticscholar.org/author/Dorian-Vale/2380743266", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.researchcatalogue.net/profile", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://archive.org/details/the-journal-of-post-interpretive-criticism-vi", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=15tvhjAAAAAJ", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://independent.academia.edu/DorianVale", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://core.ac.uk/search/?q=post-interpretive+criticism+dorian+vale", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.base-search.net/Search/Results?lookfor=Post-Interpretive+Criticism", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://commons.datacite.org/?query=Post-Interpretive+Criticism", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://openalex.org/works?filter=title_and_abstract.search:Post-Interpretive+Criticism+Dorian+Vale", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://webarchiveweb.wayback.bac-lac.canada.ca/web/*/https://www.museumofone.art", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" } ], "alternate_identifiers": [ { "identifier": "2819-7232" }, { "identifier": "0000000528819728" }, { "identifier": "0000000528819787" }, { "identifier": "0000000528819744" } ], "source_references": [ "https://www.museumofone.art" ], "source_journal": { "title": "Journal of Post-Interpretive Criticism" }, "source_imprint": null, "source_contributors": [], "source_created": "2026-07-31T06:35:35.777378+00:00", "source_modified": "2026-07-31T06:35:36.092919+00:00", "source_description_html": "

Abstract

\n

This essay examines material deterioration in contemporary art as an ethical and aesthetic condition rather than a conservation problem. Challenging the museum’s traditional commitment to permanence, it argues that entropy, material fatigue, and physical decay can function as intrinsic components of artistic meaning rather than accidental losses requiring restoration. Drawing upon principles of Post-Interpretive Criticism, the essay proposes that deterioration constitutes evidence of an artwork’s temporal existence and should be approached through witnessing rather than interpretive recovery.

\n

Through discussions of works by Eva Hesse, Gordon Matta-Clark, Joseph Beuys, Anselm Kiefer, Dieter Roth, Anya Gallaccio, Felix Gonzalez-Torres, and Zoe Leonard, the essay explores how unstable materials—including latex, fat, organic matter, flowers, candy, and architectural interventions—redefine the relationship between object, institution, and viewer. It argues that museums often operate within a preservation paradigm that privileges permanence, stability, and market value, while overlooking the ethical significance of material transformation. Cases of conservation intervention further reveal the tension between institutional stewardship and artistic intentions that incorporate impermanence.

\n

Rather than treating physical degradation as damage or failure, the essay frames material fatigue as a visible record of time, encounter, and existence. It proposes that criticism should abandon the pursuit of hidden meanings in favor of attentive witnessing, where cracks, fading pigments, decomposition, and structural instability become legitimate aesthetic events. In this framework, decay functions not as the negation of the artwork but as part of its continuing presence.

\n

By repositioning entropy as an ethical condition of viewing, the essay contributes to contemporary debates in aesthetics, conservation ethics, museum studies, material culture, and conceptual art. It advances the view that the moral responsibility of both institutions and critics is not to deny mortality through preservation alone, but to recognize impermanence as an essential dimension of artistic experience.

\n\n
\n

This entry is connected to a series of original theories and treatises forming the foundation of the Post-Interpretive Criticism movement (Q136308909), authored by Dorian Vale (Q136308916) and published by Museum of One (Q136308879). These include: Stillmark Theory (Q136328254), Hauntmark Theory (Q136328273), Absential Aesthetic Theory (Q136328330), Viewer-as-Evidence Theory (Q136328828), Message-Transfer Theory (Q136329002), Aesthetic Displacement Theory (Q136329014), Theory of Misplacement (Q136329054), and Art as Truth: A Treatise (Q136329071), Aesthetic Recursion Theory (Q136339843), The Journal of Post-Interpretive Criticism (Q136530009), Canon of Witnesses (Q136565881),Interpretive Load Index (ILI) (Q137709526), Viewer Displacement Ratio (VDR) (Q137709583) , Ethical Proximity Score (EPS) (Q137709600) , Institutional Alignment Indicator (IAI) (Q137709608), Post-Hermeneutic Phenomenology (Q137711946)

\n
\n
 
\n
\n
\n

Dorian Vale is a chosen pseudonym, not to obscure identity, but to preserve clarity of voice and integrity of message. It creates distance between the writer and the work, allowing the philosophy to stand unclouded by biography. The name exists not to hide, but to honor the seriousness of the task: to speak without spectacle, and to build without needing to be seen.

\n
\n
\n

 

\n
\n
", "provenance": { "repository": "Zenodo REST API response supplied in query.json", "retrieved": "2026-11-04", "editorial_fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "source_snapshot": "source/21715085.json", "institutional_review": "Reviewed page-level title, author and repository links in saved public institutional HTML, 2026-11-04." }, "source_review": "2026-11-04", "relations": [ { "identifier": "978-1-06-982030-3", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "isbn" }, { "identifier": "978-1-06-982031-0", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "isbn" }, { "identifier": "978-1-06-982032-7", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "isbn" }, { "identifier": "978-1-06-982033-4", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "isbn" }, { "identifier": "978-1-06-982034-1", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "isbn" }, { "identifier": "https://www.museumofone.art", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://zenodo.org/communities/post-interpretive-criticism", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://osf.io/zhnre/", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://works.hcommons.org/records/xv2j2-g6927", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://philpapers.org/rec/VALPCF-2", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.semanticscholar.org/author/Dorian-Vale/2380743266", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.researchcatalogue.net/profile", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://archive.org/details/the-journal-of-post-interpretive-criticism-vi", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=15tvhjAAAAAJ", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://independent.academia.edu/DorianVale", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://core.ac.uk/search/?q=post-interpretive+criticism+dorian+vale", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.base-search.net/Search/Results?lookfor=Post-Interpretive+Criticism", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://commons.datacite.org/?query=Post-Interpretive+Criticism", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://openalex.org/works?filter=title_and_abstract.search:Post-Interpretive+Criticism+Dorian+Vale", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://webarchiveweb.wayback.bac-lac.canada.ca/web/*/https://www.museumofone.art", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" } ], "institutional_metadata": { "title": "Art That Falls Apart: Material Fatigue as Moral Statement", "author": "Dorian Vale", "web_publication": "2026-07-29T08:06:52.000Z", "web_updated": "2026-11-03T00:37:00.000Z", "linked_zenodo_dois": [ "10.5281/zenodo.21715084" ], "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "publication_title": "Art That Falls Apart: Material Fatigue as Moral Statement", "publication_status": "Published field essay", "publication_date": "2026-07-29", "edition": null }, "research_programmes": [ { "title": "Witness, Material Presence, and Cultural Memory", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/", "status": "Continuing research", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "relation": "Published field essay in this programme.", "relation_label": "Published field essay in this programme." } ], "record_level": "Item", "record_status": "Published source; selected catalogue record", "digital_formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "extent": "1 digital file; 880295 bytes", "medium": "Digital document", "record_reviewed": "2026-11-04", "date_precision": "day", "alternate_titles": [], "digital_extent": { "file_count": 1, "total_bytes": 880295, "formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "checksums": [ { "filename": "Art That Falls Apart — material fatigue as moral statement.pdf", "algorithm": "md5", "value": "9865b03866bdebb2458da23c34d23c07", "syntax_valid": true, "verification": "source_checksum_transcription; bytes not independently recomputed" } ], "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21715085", "derivation": "File count and total bytes calculated from repository file metadata; MIME inferred from filename when absent." }, "identifier_validation": { "orcid": { "source_value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "ISO 7064 MOD 11-2 checksum only; this is not a live registry verification." }, "isbn": [], "doi": { "source_value": "10.5281/zenodo.21715085", "syntax_valid": true, "note": "Syntax check only; repository snapshot supplies the identifier." } }, "isbn_applicability": "not_supplied", "serial": null, "contributor_roles": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": null, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21715085" }, { "name": "Museum of One", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": null, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21715085" } ], "authority_links": [], "metadata_profile": { "name": "Museum of One source-qualified catalogue profile", "version": "3.0.0", "url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/metadata-profile.json", "source_snapshot_preserved": true }, "reading_copy": { "id": "21715085", "title": "Art That Falls Apart: Material Fatigue as Moral Statement", "accession": "MOO-CAT-007", "pdf_url": "../assets/documents/21715085.pdf", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/21715085/files/Art%20That%20Falls%20Apart%20%E2%80%94%20material%20fatigue%20as%20moral%20statement.pdf/content", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21715085", "source_filename": "Art That Falls Apart — material fatigue as moral statement.pdf", "checksum": "md5:9865b03866bdebb2458da23c34d23c07", "sha256": "f43ae89bec1051c9a3d9ecd807bb473530ebad8a844194835713bb4caefb3e45", "bytes": 880295, "page_count": 5, "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "checksum_match": true, "rights": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "role": "Local reading copy; original repository file retained unchanged" }, "page_count": 5, "field_assertions": [ { "field": "title", "value": "Art That Falls Apart: Material Fatigue as Moral Statement", "status": "catalogue_title", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "note": "Local display title; the deposited title is retained separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_title", "value": "Art That Falls Apart: Material Fatigue as Moral Statement", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21715085", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "doi", "value": "10.5281/zenodo.21715085", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21715085", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "date", "value": "2026-07-31", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21715085", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "conceptdoi", "value": "10.5281/zenodo.21715084", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21715085", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "creators", "value": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "affiliation": null, "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094" }, { "name": "Museum of One", "affiliation": null } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21715085", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "keywords", "value": [ "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Stillmark Theory", "Message-Transfer Theory", "MTT", "Misplacement", "Displacement", "Aesthetic Displacement Theory", "Theory of Misplacement", "Absential Aesthetics", "Witness Aesthetics", "Hauntmark Theory", "Presence-Based Criticism", "Custodianship of Art", "Art as Ontology", "Aesthetic Recursion", "Aesthetic Recursion Theory", "Viewer as Evidence Theory", "Interpretive Load Index (ILI)", "Viewer Displacement Ratio (VDR)", "Ethical Proximity Score (EPS)", "Institutional Alignment Indicator (IAI)", "Epoché Fidelity Index (EFI)", "Phenomenological Phase Alignment Score (PPAS)", "Residue Engagement Restraint Ratio (RERR)", "Quasi-Subject Agency Recognition Index (QSARI)", "Dialectical Circulation Index (DCI)", "Restraint in front of art", "Moral proximity", "Interpretive silence", "Erasure as ethics", "Temporal scarcity", "Silence as method", "Ontology of beauty", "Language as violence", "Aesthetic mercy", "Art encounter ethics", "Epistemology of witness", "Philosophy of Art", "Aesthetics", "Art Theory", "Contemporary Aesthetics", "Comparative Aesthetics", "Phenomenology and Art", "Phenomenology", "Aesthetic Phenomenology", "Phenomenology of Aesthetic", "post-hermeneutics phenomenology", "Ethics in Art Criticism", "Interpretation and Meaning", "Criticism and Reception Theory", "Epistemology of Art", "Visual Culture Studies", "Dorian Vale", "Founder of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Post-Aesthetic Critic", "Independent Philosopher of Art", "Museum of One", "Art Writer and Theorist", "Aesthetic Philosopher", "Custodian of Witness Aesthetics", "The Doctrine of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "The Custodian's Oath", "The Canon of Witnesses", "Art as Truth", "Art as Presence", "The Viewer as Evidence", "Interpretation vs. Witnessing", "Language as Custody", "Erasure as Afterlife", "Museum of One Manifesto", "Post-Interpretive Lexicon", "Alternative art criticism", "New art criticism movement", "Ethical art theory", "Criticism beyond interpretation", "Slow looking philosophy", "Contemporary sacred aesthetics", "Quiet philosophy of art", "Radical art restraint", "Witness over interpretation", "Interpretive Restraint" ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21715085", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "license", "value": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21715085", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "files", "value": [ { "name": "Art That Falls Apart — material fatigue as moral statement.pdf", "url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/21715085/files/Art%20That%20Falls%20Apart%20%E2%80%94%20material%20fatigue%20as%20moral%20statement.pdf/content", "size": 880295, "size_label": "860 KB", "checksum": "md5:9865b03866bdebb2458da23c34d23c07", "mimetype": "application/pdf" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21715085", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_created", "value": "2026-07-31T06:35:35.777378+00:00", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21715085", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_modified", "value": "2026-07-31T06:35:36.092919+00:00", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21715085", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "record_modified", "value": "2026-11-04", "status": "derived_from_description_history", "note": "Latest documented local description event; not a publication, repository or source-review date.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_review", "value": "2026-11-04", "status": "catalogue_source_review", "note": "Review of descriptive sources; not the creation or modification date of the work or repository record.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "author", "value": "Dorian Vale", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "note": "Institutional responsibility statement; original repository creator roles remain separate.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "publisher", "value": "Museum of One", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "note": "Institutional responsibility statement; original repository creator roles remain separate.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "orcid", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "source_linked_identifier", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "note": "Creator identifier supplied by the linked sources; no affiliation or endorsement is inferred.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "orcid_authority", "value": { "scheme": "ORCID", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "evidence_urls": [ "https://www.museumofone.art/archives-scholarly-infrastructure/", "https://eprints.rclis.org/47182/", "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ], "access_note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "evidence_receipt": "data/source/authority-review-2026-11-04.json" }, "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "source_url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "summary", "value": "An essay considering unstable materials, deterioration, and the tension between conservation and artistic impermanence. It reads material fatigue through the ethics of witnessing.", "status": "editorial_enrichment", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "note": "Catalogue-editor summary based on the linked work; not an original publisher abstract.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "subjects", "value": [ "Contemporary art", "Material deterioration", "Conservation ethics", "Impermanence" ], "status": "editorial_enrichment", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "note": "Local discovery terms; no controlled-vocabulary assignment is claimed.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "collection", "value": "Essays & research", "status": "editorial_grouping", "note": "A local browsing collection, not an original repository collection.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "corroboration", "value": "Museum of One’s matching publication page confirms Dorian Vale’s authorship and the work’s institutional context. Its repository links and publication dates are retained separately from this selected Zenodo edition. Web-record dates are not treated as dates of the deposited edition. Source review: 4 November 2026.", "status": "catalogue_review_note", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "discrepancies", "value": [ "The repository also lists organizational or URL-form creator entries. The catalogue displays Dorian Vale as bibliographic author while retaining the deposited creator list separately.", "The Museum of One web record is dated 29 July 2026; this selected Zenodo edition gives 31 July 2026. These describe separate publication records." ], "status": "catalogue_review_note", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "date_precision", "value": "day", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21715085", "note": "Precision reported exactly as supplied; missing month or day is not filled.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "medium", "value": "Digital document", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21715085", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "digital_formats", "value": [ "application/pdf" ], "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21715085", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "extent", "value": "1 digital file; 880295 bytes", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21715085", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "digital_extent", "value": { "file_count": 1, "total_bytes": 880295, "formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "checksums": [ { "filename": "Art That Falls Apart — material fatigue as moral statement.pdf", "algorithm": "md5", "value": "9865b03866bdebb2458da23c34d23c07", "syntax_valid": true, "verification": "source_checksum_transcription; bytes not independently recomputed" } ], "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21715085", "derivation": "File count and total bytes calculated from repository file metadata; MIME inferred from filename when absent." }, "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21715085", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "identifier_validation", "value": { "orcid": { "source_value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "ISO 7064 MOD 11-2 checksum only; this is not a live registry verification." }, "isbn": [], "doi": { "source_value": "10.5281/zenodo.21715085", "syntax_valid": true, "note": "Syntax check only; repository snapshot supplies the identifier." } }, "status": "local_syntax_validation", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21715085", "note": "Checksum/syntax validation does not verify registration, assignment or edition applicability.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "contributor_roles", "value": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": null, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21715085" }, { "name": "Museum of One", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": null, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21715085" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21715085", "note": "Creator and contributor roles are transcribed, not inferred from names or affiliations.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "research_programme:https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/", "value": { "title": "Witness, Material Presence, and Cultural Memory", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/", "status": "Continuing research", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "relation": "Published field essay in this programme.", "relation_label": "Published field essay in this programme." }, "status": "institutional_work_relationship", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "note": "Programme relationship and stage follow the work-specific institutional badge; publication does not imply a completed programme or collaboration.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "entity_link:dorian-vale:author", "value": { "id": "dorian-vale", "label": "Dorian Vale", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "author", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author.", "variants": [ "Vale, Dorian" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:8197bdc0d1706a8341a1777519c687488dc0e7820bd099802a106bbec1a4356b", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21715085.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." } }, { "field": "entity_link:museum-of-one:publisher", "value": { "id": "museum-of-one", "label": "Museum of One", "entity_type": "Organization", "relation": "publisher", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record.", "variants": [ "MuseumofOne", "MUSEUM OF ONE" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:dcf065760a48ea6455e4dbe3367a61e0da8667b30fde87b0245df91b1ecac4d0", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21715085.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." } }, { "field": "entity_link:eva-hesse:artist discussed", "value": { "id": "eva-hesse", "label": "Eva Hesse", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "artist discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "note": "The essay explicitly names Expanded Expansion and its materials.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:eb00f75eccb675f312f70aae7148ef83836137de9a6ecf9ce19dbd713388d1ba", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21715085.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/eva-hesse.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay explicitly names Expanded Expansion and its materials." } }, { "field": "entity_link:felix-gonzalez-torres:artist discussed", "value": { "id": "felix-gonzalez-torres", "label": "Felix Gonzalez-Torres", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "artist discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "note": "The essay discusses “Untitled” (Portrait of Ross in L.A.).", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:bfd6f3019bb61fbe19437f74214e8a96dccb09e5a8da9899416caf1f78b47d23", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21715085.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/felix-gonzalez-torres.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay discusses “Untitled” (Portrait of Ross in L.A.)." } }, { "field": "entity_link:expanded-expansion:artwork discussed", "value": { "id": "expanded-expansion", "label": "Expanded Expansion", "entity_type": "Artwork", "relation": "artwork discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "note": "The essay explicitly attributes the work to Eva Hesse.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:907d06f553e3de9f5770c7b9d5934a73a6181eb1440f2997d0f10f65d634160a", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21715085.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/expanded-expansion.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay explicitly attributes the work to Eva Hesse." } }, { "field": "entity_link:untitled-portrait-of-ross-in-la:artwork discussed", "value": { "id": "untitled-portrait-of-ross-in-la", "label": "“Untitled” (Portrait of Ross in L.A.)", "entity_type": "Artwork", "relation": "artwork discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "note": "The essay explicitly attributes the work to Felix Gonzalez-Torres.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:96ad76d3ed73356e8b74c4134f397d8d89e7da9b94532070a108ffc5a5304d24", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21715085.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/untitled-portrait-of-ross-in-la.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay explicitly attributes the work to Felix Gonzalez-Torres." } }, { "field": "controlled_subjects", "value": [ { "id": "contemporary-art", "label": "Contemporary art", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#contemporary-art", "url": "vocabulary.html#contemporary-art", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:contemporary-art", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Art discussed within contemporary artistic and critical contexts.", "scope_note": "A broad local subject heading; specific chronology must be supplied in the item description.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "material-deterioration", "label": "Material deterioration", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#material-deterioration", "url": "vocabulary.html#material-deterioration", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:material-deterioration", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Physical alteration or weakening of materials over time.", "scope_note": "Use for discussion of material fatigue and decay in artworks; no condition assessment of a held object is implied.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "impermanence" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "conservation-ethics", "label": "Conservation ethics", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#conservation-ethics", "url": "vocabulary.html#conservation-ethics", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:conservation-ethics", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Ethical questions about caring for, stabilising, or allowing change in artworks.", "scope_note": "Use for discussion of conservation decisions and their relation to artistic impermanence.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "impermanence" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "impermanence", "label": "Impermanence", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#impermanence", "url": "vocabulary.html#impermanence", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:impermanence", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "The condition of change, transience, or non-endurance as an artistic concern.", "scope_note": "Use for critical discussion of impermanence; material deterioration identifies a particular physical process.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "conservation-ethics", "material-deterioration" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Local preferred terms with definitions and synonyms. External alignment is scoped in the vocabulary register." }, { "field": "genre_terms", "value": [ { "id": "genre-journal-article", "label": "Journal article", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#genre-journal-article", "url": "vocabulary.html#genre-journal-article", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:genre-journal-article", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Journal articles" ], "definition": "A contribution issued as part of a journal or periodical.", "scope_note": "Describes publication genre based on the catalogued source record; peer-review status is a separate question.", "kind": "genre", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "verified_mapping", "external_mappings": [ { "vocabulary": "Getty Art & Architecture Thesaurus", "label": "articles", "uri": "http://vocab.getty.edu/aat/300048715", "source_url": "https://www.getty.edu/vow/AATFullDisplay?find=&logic=AND¬e=&subjectid=300048715", "relation": "broadMatch", "status": "verified", "verified_on": "2026-11-04", "note": "Getty’s articles concept includes contributions to magazines, newspapers, encyclopedias, and other works; journal article is the narrower local genre." } ], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "type", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Local resource-genre classification. Digital file format is recorded separately." }, { "field": "archival_context", "value": { "description_profile": "moo-description-policy-1.0", "catalogue_snapshot_date": "2026-11-04", "snapshot_note": "Selected catalogue snapshot; not a live repository synchronisation.", "record_category": "Published library and repository material", "reference_code_status": "Stable local catalogue reference; not evidence of an archival acquisition or a previous catalogue accession.", "source_repository": { "name": "Zenodo", "record_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21715085" }, "institutional_context_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "source_metadata_retrieved": "2026-11-04", "source_metadata_retrieval_status": "Documented in catalogue source provenance", "source_snapshot": "source/21715085.json", "source_filenames": [ "Art That Falls Apart — material fatigue as moral statement.pdf" ], "selection_basis": "Local descriptive selection of publicly published material; public availability does not establish ownership of originals.", "custodial_history": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No donation, physical transfer, acquisition agreement or chain of custody is documented by this catalogue. Zenodo remains the source repository for the deposited version." }, "original_order": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No original archival order is asserted. Current browsing groupings are local editorial arrangement." }, "arrangement": { "status": "local_editorial", "grouping": "Essays & research", "statement": "A browsing grouping, not an original fonds or archival series." }, "responsible_service": { "name": "Museum of One", "service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "website": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "email": "research@museumofone.art" }, "description_method": "Source-based description with automated drafting and metadata assistance. Responsibility for the public catalogue rests with Museum of One; automated assistance does not constitute independent scholarly or curatorial review.", "policy_url": "policies.html", "correction_email": "research@museumofone.art", "access_copy": { "role": "Local digital reading copy of the deposited file", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/21715085/files/Art%20That%20Falls%20Apart%20%E2%80%94%20material%20fatigue%20as%20moral%20statement.pdf/content", "source_filename": "Art That Falls Apart — material fatigue as moral statement.pdf", "local_path": "assets/documents/21715085.pdf", "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "source_checksum_match": true, "sha256": "f43ae89bec1051c9a3d9ecd807bb473530ebad8a844194835713bb4caefb3e45", "statement": "Access copy only; no ownership or physical custody transfer is implied." } }, "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Provenance records what is documented and leaves unknown custody and original order explicit." }, { "field": "description_history", "value": [ { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Source-based catalogue description", "note": "Local description assembled from the identified public repository record and available institutional work record. Source metadata remains separately identifiable.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/21715085", "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Qualified descriptive enrichment", "note": "Local editorial description, arrangement and source-qualified bibliographic context recorded alongside source metadata. Unknown or disputed values remain qualified.", "fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/21715085", "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Automated file checksum and PDF inspection", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Digital reading copy verified", "note": "Downloaded access-copy MD5 matched the source checksum; local SHA-256 and PDF file-page count are recorded in the file manifest. This event does not describe transfer of custody.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/api/records/21715085/files/Art%20That%20Falls%20Apart%20%E2%80%94%20material%20fatigue%20as%20moral%20statement.pdf/content" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Description policy and provenance context adopted", "note": "Responsible service, source repository, local access-copy role, unknown custody and original order, correction route and dated description history made explicit under moo-description-policy-1.0.", "sources": [ "policies.html" ] }, { "event_id": "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Unify graph identities and qualify exported relationships and citations", "note": "Local graph projection now uses one contextual identity per entity, distinguishes work-level institutional matches from selected-edition links, retains title-level ISBN uncertainty, and derives citations from the source title. Typed relation assertions and a versioned validation profile are introduced. No publication date, original source snapshot or PDF changed.", "fields": [ "metadata_profile", "relationship_assertions", "identity", "institutional_match_scope", "citation_projection" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Source-based metadata implementation and regression validation", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication, source review or acquisition date", "sources": [ "metadata/metadata-profile.json" ] }, { "event_id": "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Record inspected public ORCID profile evidence", "note": "The official ORCID public person API returned the credited name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website. This confirms a matching public profile, not independently verified biographical or affiliation claims. Original creator arrays and source snapshots are unchanged.", "fields": [ "orcid_authority" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Read-only official public API inspection", "date_kind": "Local authority review and catalogue description event; not a publication or original creation date", "sources": [ "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ] } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Catalogue description events; these are not work publication dates or acquisition dates." }, { "field": "pirr_references", "value": [ { "programme_key": "research-witness-material-memory", "programme_title": "Witness, Material Presence, and Cultural Memory", "programme_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/", "programme_stage": "Continuing research", "registry_url": "research-registry.html#research-witness-material-memory", "identifiers": [ { "scheme": "PIRR project ID", "value": "pir-prj-dd7kt5rw", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/#programme-record" } ], "relation": "Published field essay in this programme.", "relation_note": "Published field essay in this programme.", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/" } ], "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "PIRR project IDs and programme references identify research records, not publication versions or independent chapter deposits." }, { "field": "relationship_assertions", "value": [ { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:8197bdc0d1706a8341a1777519c687488dc0e7820bd099802a106bbec1a4356b", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21715085.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:dcf065760a48ea6455e4dbe3367a61e0da8667b30fde87b0245df91b1ecac4d0", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21715085.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:eb00f75eccb675f312f70aae7148ef83836137de9a6ecf9ce19dbd713388d1ba", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21715085.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/eva-hesse.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay explicitly names Expanded Expansion and its materials." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:bfd6f3019bb61fbe19437f74214e8a96dccb09e5a8da9899416caf1f78b47d23", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21715085.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/felix-gonzalez-torres.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay discusses “Untitled” (Portrait of Ross in L.A.)." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:907d06f553e3de9f5770c7b9d5934a73a6181eb1440f2997d0f10f65d634160a", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21715085.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/expanded-expansion.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay explicitly attributes the work to Eva Hesse." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:96ad76d3ed73356e8b74c4134f397d8d89e7da9b94532070a108ffc5a5304d24", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21715085.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/untitled-portrait-of-ross-in-la.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay explicitly attributes the work to Felix Gonzalez-Torres." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:76f74d4ae6d398952cc13d89449fb2f673d1e6644eebb4f92c007c1e27e7971c", "subject": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#describes", "object": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21715084", "scope": "version_family", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "source_location": { "kind": "metadata_field", "field": "linked_zenodo_dois", "values": [ "10.5281/zenodo.21715084" ] }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "Exact-edition matching requires the selected DOI in the reviewed page metadata; other matches retain their wider scope." } ], "status": "typed_evidence_projection", "note": "Stable, typed assertions retain source scope and explicit unknown review metadata." }, { "field": "reading_copy", "value": { "id": "21715085", "title": "Art That Falls Apart: Material Fatigue as Moral Statement", "accession": "MOO-CAT-007", "pdf_url": "../assets/documents/21715085.pdf", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/21715085/files/Art%20That%20Falls%20Apart%20%E2%80%94%20material%20fatigue%20as%20moral%20statement.pdf/content", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21715085", "source_filename": "Art That Falls Apart — material fatigue as moral statement.pdf", "checksum": "md5:9865b03866bdebb2458da23c34d23c07", "sha256": "f43ae89bec1051c9a3d9ecd807bb473530ebad8a844194835713bb4caefb3e45", "bytes": 880295, "page_count": 5, "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "checksum_match": true, "rights": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "role": "Local reading copy; original repository file retained unchanged" }, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/21715085/files/Art%20That%20Falls%20Apart%20%E2%80%94%20material%20fatigue%20as%20moral%20statement.pdf/content", "status": "derived_file_inspection", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "note": "Byte-identical local access copy. Source MD5 was recomputed and matched; SHA-256 and page count were measured from the downloaded PDF. This is not a preservation-deposit claim." }, { "field": "page_count", "value": 5, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/21715085/files/Art%20That%20Falls%20Apart%20%E2%80%94%20material%20fatigue%20as%20moral%20statement.pdf/content", "status": "derived_file_inspection", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "note": "Total PDF file pages measured from the deposited file, including cover and unnumbered pages. Not a claim about printed pagination." } ], "entity_links": [ { "id": "dorian-vale", "label": "Dorian Vale", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "author", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author.", "variants": [ "Vale, Dorian" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "museum-of-one", "label": "Museum of One", "entity_type": "Organization", "relation": "publisher", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record.", "variants": [ "MuseumofOne", "MUSEUM OF ONE" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "eva-hesse", "label": "Eva Hesse", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "artist discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "note": "The essay explicitly names Expanded Expansion and its materials.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "felix-gonzalez-torres", "label": "Felix Gonzalez-Torres", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "artist discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "note": "The essay discusses “Untitled” (Portrait of Ross in L.A.).", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "expanded-expansion", "label": "Expanded Expansion", "entity_type": "Artwork", "relation": "artwork discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "note": "The essay explicitly attributes the work to Eva Hesse.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "untitled-portrait-of-ross-in-la", "label": "“Untitled” (Portrait of Ross in L.A.)", "entity_type": "Artwork", "relation": "artwork discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "note": "The essay explicitly attributes the work to Felix Gonzalez-Torres.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" } ], "contents": [], "controlled_subjects": [ { "id": "contemporary-art", "label": "Contemporary art", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#contemporary-art", "url": "vocabulary.html#contemporary-art", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:contemporary-art", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Art discussed within contemporary artistic and critical contexts.", "scope_note": "A broad local subject heading; specific chronology must be supplied in the item description.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "material-deterioration", "label": "Material deterioration", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#material-deterioration", "url": "vocabulary.html#material-deterioration", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:material-deterioration", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Physical alteration or weakening of materials over time.", "scope_note": "Use for discussion of material fatigue and decay in artworks; no condition assessment of a held object is implied.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "impermanence" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "conservation-ethics", "label": "Conservation ethics", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#conservation-ethics", "url": "vocabulary.html#conservation-ethics", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:conservation-ethics", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Ethical questions about caring for, stabilising, or allowing change in artworks.", "scope_note": "Use for discussion of conservation decisions and their relation to artistic impermanence.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "impermanence" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "impermanence", "label": "Impermanence", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#impermanence", "url": "vocabulary.html#impermanence", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:impermanence", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "The condition of change, transience, or non-endurance as an artistic concern.", "scope_note": "Use for critical discussion of impermanence; material deterioration identifies a particular physical process.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "conservation-ethics", "material-deterioration" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "genre_terms": [ { "id": "genre-journal-article", "label": "Journal article", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#genre-journal-article", "url": "vocabulary.html#genre-journal-article", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:genre-journal-article", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Journal articles" ], "definition": "A contribution issued as part of a journal or periodical.", "scope_note": "Describes publication genre based on the catalogued source record; peer-review status is a separate question.", "kind": "genre", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "verified_mapping", "external_mappings": [ { "vocabulary": "Getty Art & Architecture Thesaurus", "label": "articles", "uri": "http://vocab.getty.edu/aat/300048715", "source_url": "https://www.getty.edu/vow/AATFullDisplay?find=&logic=AND¬e=&subjectid=300048715", "relation": "broadMatch", "status": "verified", "verified_on": "2026-11-04", "note": "Getty’s articles concept includes contributions to magazines, newspapers, encyclopedias, and other works; journal article is the narrower local genre." } ], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "type", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "vocabulary_version": 4, "description_history": [ { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Source-based catalogue description", "note": "Local description assembled from the identified public repository record and available institutional work record. Source metadata remains separately identifiable.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/21715085", "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Qualified descriptive enrichment", "note": "Local editorial description, arrangement and source-qualified bibliographic context recorded alongside source metadata. Unknown or disputed values remain qualified.", "fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/21715085", "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Automated file checksum and PDF inspection", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Digital reading copy verified", "note": "Downloaded access-copy MD5 matched the source checksum; local SHA-256 and PDF file-page count are recorded in the file manifest. This event does not describe transfer of custody.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/api/records/21715085/files/Art%20That%20Falls%20Apart%20%E2%80%94%20material%20fatigue%20as%20moral%20statement.pdf/content" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Description policy and provenance context adopted", "note": "Responsible service, source repository, local access-copy role, unknown custody and original order, correction route and dated description history made explicit under moo-description-policy-1.0.", "sources": [ "policies.html" ] }, { "event_id": "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Unify graph identities and qualify exported relationships and citations", "note": "Local graph projection now uses one contextual identity per entity, distinguishes work-level institutional matches from selected-edition links, retains title-level ISBN uncertainty, and derives citations from the source title. Typed relation assertions and a versioned validation profile are introduced. No publication date, original source snapshot or PDF changed.", "fields": [ "metadata_profile", "relationship_assertions", "identity", "institutional_match_scope", "citation_projection" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Source-based metadata implementation and regression validation", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication, source review or acquisition date", "sources": [ "metadata/metadata-profile.json" ] }, { "event_id": "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Record inspected public ORCID profile evidence", "note": "The official ORCID public person API returned the credited name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website. This confirms a matching public profile, not independently verified biographical or affiliation claims. Original creator arrays and source snapshots are unchanged.", "fields": [ "orcid_authority" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Read-only official public API inspection", "date_kind": "Local authority review and catalogue description event; not a publication or original creation date", "sources": [ "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ] } ], "record_modified": "2026-11-04", "record_modified_provenance": { "status": "derived_from_description_history", "event_ids": [ "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04" ], "note": "Latest documented local description event; not a publication, repository or source-review date." }, "archival_context": { "description_profile": "moo-description-policy-1.0", "catalogue_snapshot_date": "2026-11-04", "snapshot_note": "Selected catalogue snapshot; not a live repository synchronisation.", "record_category": "Published library and repository material", "reference_code_status": "Stable local catalogue reference; not evidence of an archival acquisition or a previous catalogue accession.", "source_repository": { "name": "Zenodo", "record_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21715085" }, "institutional_context_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "source_metadata_retrieved": "2026-11-04", "source_metadata_retrieval_status": "Documented in catalogue source provenance", "source_snapshot": "source/21715085.json", "source_filenames": [ "Art That Falls Apart — material fatigue as moral statement.pdf" ], "selection_basis": "Local descriptive selection of publicly published material; public availability does not establish ownership of originals.", "custodial_history": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No donation, physical transfer, acquisition agreement or chain of custody is documented by this catalogue. Zenodo remains the source repository for the deposited version." }, "original_order": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No original archival order is asserted. Current browsing groupings are local editorial arrangement." }, "arrangement": { "status": "local_editorial", "grouping": "Essays & research", "statement": "A browsing grouping, not an original fonds or archival series." }, "responsible_service": { "name": "Museum of One", "service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "website": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "email": "research@museumofone.art" }, "description_method": "Source-based description with automated drafting and metadata assistance. Responsibility for the public catalogue rests with Museum of One; automated assistance does not constitute independent scholarly or curatorial review.", "policy_url": "policies.html", "correction_email": "research@museumofone.art", "access_copy": { "role": "Local digital reading copy of the deposited file", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/21715085/files/Art%20That%20Falls%20Apart%20%E2%80%94%20material%20fatigue%20as%20moral%20statement.pdf/content", "source_filename": "Art That Falls Apart — material fatigue as moral statement.pdf", "local_path": "assets/documents/21715085.pdf", "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "source_checksum_match": true, "sha256": "f43ae89bec1051c9a3d9ecd807bb473530ebad8a844194835713bb4caefb3e45", "statement": "Access copy only; no ownership or physical custody transfer is implied." } }, "description_policy_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "pirr_references": [ { "programme_key": "research-witness-material-memory", "programme_title": "Witness, Material Presence, and Cultural Memory", "programme_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/", "programme_stage": "Continuing research", "registry_url": "research-registry.html#research-witness-material-memory", "identifiers": [ { "scheme": "PIRR project ID", "value": "pir-prj-dd7kt5rw", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/#programme-record" } ], "relation": "Published field essay in this programme.", "relation_note": "Published field essay in this programme.", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/" } ], "pirr_work_identity": { "archive_reference": "MOO-CAT-007", "edition_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.21715085", "zenodo_record_id": "21715085", "identifier_scope": "Publication identity; PIRR identifiers in programme relationships identify research records, not this publication." }, "metadata_origin": "https://archive.museumofone.art", "identity": { "work": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21715085.html#work", "edition": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21715085", "version_family": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21715084", "catalogue_record": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21715085.html#catalogue-record" }, "institutional_match_scope": "version_family", "relationship_assertions": [ { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:8197bdc0d1706a8341a1777519c687488dc0e7820bd099802a106bbec1a4356b", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21715085.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:dcf065760a48ea6455e4dbe3367a61e0da8667b30fde87b0245df91b1ecac4d0", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21715085.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:eb00f75eccb675f312f70aae7148ef83836137de9a6ecf9ce19dbd713388d1ba", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21715085.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/eva-hesse.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay explicitly names Expanded Expansion and its materials." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:bfd6f3019bb61fbe19437f74214e8a96dccb09e5a8da9899416caf1f78b47d23", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21715085.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/felix-gonzalez-torres.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay discusses “Untitled” (Portrait of Ross in L.A.)." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:907d06f553e3de9f5770c7b9d5934a73a6181eb1440f2997d0f10f65d634160a", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21715085.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/expanded-expansion.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay explicitly attributes the work to Eva Hesse." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:96ad76d3ed73356e8b74c4134f397d8d89e7da9b94532070a108ffc5a5304d24", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21715085.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/untitled-portrait-of-ross-in-la.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay explicitly attributes the work to Felix Gonzalez-Torres." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:76f74d4ae6d398952cc13d89449fb2f673d1e6644eebb4f92c007c1e27e7971c", "subject": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#describes", "object": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21715084", "scope": "version_family", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/art-that-falls-apart-material-fatigue-as-moral-statement/", "source_location": { "kind": "metadata_field", "field": "linked_zenodo_dois", "values": [ "10.5281/zenodo.21715084" ] }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "Exact-edition matching requires the selected DOI in the reviewed page metadata; other matches retain their wider scope." } ], "orcid_authority": { "scheme": "ORCID", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "evidence_urls": [ "https://www.museumofone.art/archives-scholarly-infrastructure/", "https://eprints.rclis.org/47182/", "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ], "access_note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "evidence_receipt": "data/source/authority-review-2026-11-04.json" } }, { "id": "21241866", "accession": "MOO-CAT-008", "title": "Hassan Sharif's Objects: The Ascetic of the Everyday", "source_title": "Hassan Sharif's Objects: The Ascetic of the Everyday", "short_title": "Hassan Sharif’s Objects", "author": "Dorian Vale", "creators": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "affiliation": "Museum of One", "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094" } ], "doi": "10.5281/zenodo.21241866", "conceptdoi": "10.5281/zenodo.21241865", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21241866", "date": "2026-07-07", "type": "Journal article", "source_resource_type": { "title": "Journal article", "type": "publication", "subtype": "article" }, "version": "", "collection": "Essays & research", "summary": "An essay on Hassan Sharif’s handmade accumulations of ordinary materials, examining repetition, labour, consumption, and the ethical implications of material fragility.", "subjects": [ "Hassan Sharif", "Emirati art", "Repetition and labour", "Material practice" ], "keywords": [ "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Stillmark Theory", "Message-Transfer Theory", "Displacement", "Misplacement", "Aesthetic Displacement Theory", "Theory of Misplacement", "Absential Aesthetics", "Witness Aesthetics", "Hauntmark Theory", "Presence-Based Criticism", "Custodianship of Art", "Art as Ontology", "Aesthetic Recursion Theory", "Aesthetic Recursion", "Viewer as Evidence Theory", "Interpretive Load Index (ILI)", "Viewer Displacement Ratio (VDR)", "Ethical Proximity Score (EPS)", "Institutional Alignment Indicator (IAI)", "Epoché Fidelity Index (EFI)", "Phenomenological Phase Alignment Score (PPAS)", "Residue Engagement Restraint Ratio (RERR)", "Quasi-Subject Agency Recognition Index (QSARI)", "Dialectical Circulation Index (DCI)", "Restraint in front of art", "Moral proximity", "Interpretive silence", "Temporal scarcity", "Erasure as ethics", "Silence as method", "Ontology of beauty", "Aesthetic mercy", "Art encounter ethics", "Language as violence", "Epistemology of witness", "Philosophy of Art", "Aesthetics", "Art Theory", "Contemporary Aesthetics", "Comparative Aesthetics", "Phenomenology and Art", "Phenomenology", "Aesthetic Phenomenology", "Phenomenology of Aesthetic", "post-hermeneutics phenomenology", "Ethics in Art Criticism", "Interpretation and Meaning", "Criticism and Reception Theory", "Epistemology of Art", "Visual Culture Studies", "Dorian Vale", "Founder of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Post-Aesthetic Critic", "Independent Philosopher of Art", "Museum of One", "Art Writer and Theorist", "Aesthetic Philosopher", "Custodian of Witness Aesthetics", "Post-Interpretive Lexicon", "Museum of One Manifesto", "Erasure as Afterlife", "Language as Custody", "Interpretation vs. Witnessing", "The Viewer as Evidence", "Art as Presence", "Art as Truth", "The Canon of Witnesses", "The Custodian's Oath", "The Doctrine of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Interpretive Restraint", "Witness over interpretation", "Radical art restraint", "Quiet philosophy of art", "Slow looking philosophy", "Ethical art theory", "Criticism beyond interpretationNew art criticism movement", "Alternative art criticism", "Hassan Sharif", "Middle Eastern Modernism", "Conceptual Art", "Ethical Repetition", "Theology of the Banal", "Asceticism", "Anti-monumentality" ], "license": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "files": [ { "name": "Hassan Sharif’s Objects- The Ascetic of the Everyday .pdf", "url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/21241866/files/Hassan%20Sharif%E2%80%99s%20Objects-%20The%20Ascetic%20of%20the%20Everyday%20.pdf/content", "size": 1077820, "size_label": "1053 KB", "checksum": "md5:3e92afe450b57ddd845ec65ec3e2ab1b", "mimetype": "application/pdf" } ], "institutional_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "corroboration": "Museum of One’s matching publication page confirms Dorian Vale’s authorship and the work’s institutional context. Its repository links and publication dates are retained separately from this selected Zenodo edition. Web-record dates are not treated as dates of the deposited edition. Source review: 4 November 2026.", "discrepancies": [ "The Museum of One web record is dated 6 July 2026; this selected Zenodo edition gives 7 July 2026. These dates are preserved as separate records." ], "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "publisher": "Museum of One", "language": null, "isbn": null, "related_identifiers": [ { "identifier": "https://www.museumofone.art", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://zenodo.org/communities/post-interpretive-criticism", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://osf.io/zhnre/", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://works.hcommons.org/records/xv2j2-g6927", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://philpapers.org/rec/VALPCF-2", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.semanticscholar.org/author/Dorian-Vale/2380743266", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.researchcatalogue.net/profile", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://archive.org/details/the-journal-of-post-interpretive-criticism-vi", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=15tvhjAAAAAJ", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://independent.academia.edu/DorianVale", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://core.ac.uk/search/?q=post-interpretive+criticism+dorian+vale", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.base-search.net/Search/Results?lookfor=Post-Interpretive+Criticism", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://commons.datacite.org/?query=Post-Interpretive+Criticism", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://openalex.org/works?filter=title_and_abstract.search:Post-Interpretive+Criticism+Dorian+Vale", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://webarchiveweb.wayback.bac-lac.canada.ca/web/*/https://www.museumofone.art", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" } ], "alternate_identifiers": [ { "identifier": "0000000528819728" }, { "identifier": "0000000528819787" }, { "identifier": "0000000528819744" }, { "identifier": "https://www.museumofone.art" } ], "source_references": [ "https://www.museumofone.art", "https://zenodo.org/communities/post-interpretive-criticism", "https://osf.io/zhnre/", "https://works.hcommons.org/records/xv2j2-g6927", "https://philpapers.org/rec/VALPCF-2", "https://www.semanticscholar.org/author/Dorian-Vale/2380743266", "https://www.researchcatalogue.net/profile", "https://archive.org/details/the-journal-of-post-interpretive-criticism-vi", "https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=15tvhjAAAAAJ", "https://independent.academia.edu/DorianVale", "https://core.ac.uk/search/?q=post-interpretive+criticism+dorian+vale", "https://www.base-search.net/Search/Results?lookfor=Post-Interpretive+Criticism", "https://commons.datacite.org/?query=Post-Interpretive+Criticism", "https://openalex.org/works?filter=title_and_abstract.search:Post-Interpretive+Criticism+Dorian+Vale", "https://webarchiveweb.wayback.bac-lac.canada.ca/web/*/https://www.museumofone.art" ], "source_journal": { "title": "Journal of Post-Interpretive Criticism" }, "source_imprint": null, "source_contributors": [], "source_created": "2026-07-07T13:45:10.371458+00:00", "source_modified": "2026-07-07T13:45:10.791243+00:00", "source_description_html": "

This article examines the work of Emirati artist Hassan Sharif, focusing on his handmade accumulations known as Objects. Set against the backdrop of the rapid modernization and industrial spectacle of the United Arab Emirates in the 1980s, Sharif’s practice is analyzed as a profound exercise in \"ethical repetition\" and civic asceticism. By meticulously folding, binding, and assembling discarded everyday materials—such as rope, wire, newspaper, and cardboard—Sharif cultivated a \"theology of the banal\" that both mirrors and inverts the hierarchies of Western conceptual minimalism.

\n

The paper argues that Sharif's deliberate manual exhaustion serves as a critique of hyper-consumption and an act of solidarity with the invisible physical labor that built the modern Gulf. Furthermore, the inherent fragility and inevitable decay of his perishable works are explored as deliberate challenges to museum conservation and the commodification of the global art market. Ultimately, the article posits that Sharif’s continuous, \"skill-less\" repetition transcends mere aesthetic endeavor to become a moral act of resistance, transforming mundane drudgery into a lasting meditation on presence, humanity, and conscience.

\n
\n

Dorian Vale is a chosen pseudonym, not to obscure identity, but to preserve clarity of voice and integrity of message. It creates distance between the writer and the work, allowing the philosophy to stand unclouded by biography. The name exists not to hide, but to honor the seriousness of the task: to speak without spectacle, and to build without needing to be seen.

\n
\n
\n

Post-Interpretive Criticism, Stillmark Theory, Message-Transfer Theory, MTT, Misplacement, Displacement, Aesthetic Displacement Theory, Theory of Misplacement, Absential Aesthetics, Witness Aesthetics, Hauntmark Theory, Spiritual Criticism, Presence-Based Criticism, Custodianship of Art, Art as Ontology, Aesthetic Recursion Theory, Aesthetic Recursion, Viewer as Evidence Theory, Restraint in front of art, Moral proximity, Interpretive silence, Erasure as ethics, Temporal scarcity, Silence as method, Ontology of beauty, Aesthetic mercy, Language as violence, Art encounter ethics, Epistemology of witness, Philosophy of Art, Aesthetics, Art Theory, Contemporary Aesthetics, Comparative Aesthetics, Phenomenology and Art, Ethics in Art Criticism, Interpretation and Meaning, Criticism and Reception Theory, Epistemology of Art, Visual Culture Studies, Dorian Vale, Founder of Post-Interpretive Criticism, Post-Aesthetic Critic, Independent Philosopher of Art, Museum of One, Art Writer and Theorist, Aesthetic Philosopher, Custodian of Witness Aesthetics, Spiritual Aesthetics Movement, The Doctrine of Post-Interpretive Criticism, The Custodian’s Oath, The Canon of Witnesses, Art as Truth, Art as Presence, The Viewer as Evidence, Interpretation vs. Witnessing, Language as Custody, Erasure as Afterlife, Museum of One Manifesto, Alternative art criticism, New art criticism movement, Ethical art theory, Criticism beyond interpretation, Slow looking philosophy, Quiet philosophy of art, Radical art restraint, Witness over interpretation, Interpretive Restraint, The Journal of Post-Interpretive criticism, The Journal of Post-Interpretive criticism ISSN 2819-7232), The Journal of Post-Interpretive Criticism (Q136530009), Epoché Fidelity Index (EFI) (Q138018710), Phenomenological Phase Alignment Score (PPAS) (Q138018807), Residue Engagement Restraint Ratio (RERR) (Q138018901), Quasi-Subject Agency Recognition Index (QSARI) (Q138018929), Dialectical Circulation Index (DCI) (Q138018950)

\n
\n
 
", "provenance": { "repository": "Zenodo REST API response supplied in query.json", "retrieved": "2026-11-04", "editorial_fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "source_snapshot": "source/21241866.json", "institutional_review": "Reviewed page-level title, author and repository links in saved public institutional HTML, 2026-11-04." }, "source_review": "2026-11-04", "relations": [ { "identifier": "https://www.museumofone.art", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://zenodo.org/communities/post-interpretive-criticism", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://osf.io/zhnre/", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://works.hcommons.org/records/xv2j2-g6927", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://philpapers.org/rec/VALPCF-2", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.semanticscholar.org/author/Dorian-Vale/2380743266", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.researchcatalogue.net/profile", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://archive.org/details/the-journal-of-post-interpretive-criticism-vi", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=15tvhjAAAAAJ", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://independent.academia.edu/DorianVale", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://core.ac.uk/search/?q=post-interpretive+criticism+dorian+vale", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.base-search.net/Search/Results?lookfor=Post-Interpretive+Criticism", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://commons.datacite.org/?query=Post-Interpretive+Criticism", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://openalex.org/works?filter=title_and_abstract.search:Post-Interpretive+Criticism+Dorian+Vale", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://webarchiveweb.wayback.bac-lac.canada.ca/web/*/https://www.museumofone.art", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" } ], "institutional_metadata": { "title": "Hassan Sharif’s Objects: The Ascetic of the Everyday", "author": "Dorian Vale", "web_publication": "2026-07-06T17:10:08.000Z", "web_updated": "2026-11-03T00:41:51.000Z", "linked_zenodo_dois": [ "10.5281/zenodo.21241865" ], "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/" }, "research_programmes": [ { "title": "Witness, Material Presence, and Cultural Memory", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/", "status": "Continuing research", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "relation": "Related field essay on material presence, the visibility of labour and the responsibilities of preserving fragile work.", "relation_label": "Related field essay on material presence, the visibility of labour and the responsibilities of preserving fragile work." } ], "record_level": "Item", "record_status": "Published source; selected catalogue record", "digital_formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "extent": "1 digital file; 1077820 bytes", "medium": "Digital document", "record_reviewed": "2026-11-04", "date_precision": "day", "alternate_titles": [ { "title": "Hassan Sharif’s Objects: The Ascetic of the Everyday", "kind": "institutional_web_record_title", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/" } ], "digital_extent": { "file_count": 1, "total_bytes": 1077820, "formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "checksums": [ { "filename": "Hassan Sharif’s Objects- The Ascetic of the Everyday .pdf", "algorithm": "md5", "value": "3e92afe450b57ddd845ec65ec3e2ab1b", "syntax_valid": true, "verification": "source_checksum_transcription; bytes not independently recomputed" } ], "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21241866", "derivation": "File count and total bytes calculated from repository file metadata; MIME inferred from filename when absent." }, "identifier_validation": { "orcid": { "source_value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "ISO 7064 MOD 11-2 checksum only; this is not a live registry verification." }, "isbn": [], "doi": { "source_value": "10.5281/zenodo.21241866", "syntax_valid": true, "note": "Syntax check only; repository snapshot supplies the identifier." } }, "isbn_applicability": "not_supplied", "serial": null, "contributor_roles": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": "Museum of One", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21241866" } ], "authority_links": [], "metadata_profile": { "name": "Museum of One source-qualified catalogue profile", "version": "3.0.0", "url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/metadata-profile.json", "source_snapshot_preserved": true }, "reading_copy": { "id": "21241866", "title": "Hassan Sharif's Objects: The Ascetic of the Everyday", "accession": "MOO-CAT-008", "pdf_url": "../assets/documents/21241866.pdf", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/21241866/files/Hassan%20Sharif%E2%80%99s%20Objects-%20The%20Ascetic%20of%20the%20Everyday%20.pdf/content", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21241866", "source_filename": "Hassan Sharif’s Objects- The Ascetic of the Everyday .pdf", "checksum": "md5:3e92afe450b57ddd845ec65ec3e2ab1b", "sha256": "f3ada77ced8d8a82c11d99f6c5c9409176b81c45f11adcd3f959107b31567923", "bytes": 1077820, "page_count": 7, "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "checksum_match": true, "rights": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "role": "Local reading copy; original repository file retained unchanged" }, "page_count": 7, "field_assertions": [ { "field": "title", "value": "Hassan Sharif's Objects: The Ascetic of the Everyday", "status": "catalogue_title", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "note": "Local display title; the deposited title is retained separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_title", "value": "Hassan Sharif's Objects: The Ascetic of the Everyday", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21241866", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "doi", "value": "10.5281/zenodo.21241866", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21241866", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "date", "value": "2026-07-07", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21241866", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "conceptdoi", "value": "10.5281/zenodo.21241865", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21241866", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "creators", "value": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "affiliation": "Museum of One", "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21241866", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "keywords", "value": [ "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Stillmark Theory", "Message-Transfer Theory", "Displacement", "Misplacement", "Aesthetic Displacement Theory", "Theory of Misplacement", "Absential Aesthetics", "Witness Aesthetics", "Hauntmark Theory", "Presence-Based Criticism", "Custodianship of Art", "Art as Ontology", "Aesthetic Recursion Theory", "Aesthetic Recursion", "Viewer as Evidence Theory", "Interpretive Load Index (ILI)", "Viewer Displacement Ratio (VDR)", "Ethical Proximity Score (EPS)", "Institutional Alignment Indicator (IAI)", "Epoché Fidelity Index (EFI)", "Phenomenological Phase Alignment Score (PPAS)", "Residue Engagement Restraint Ratio (RERR)", "Quasi-Subject Agency Recognition Index (QSARI)", "Dialectical Circulation Index (DCI)", "Restraint in front of art", "Moral proximity", "Interpretive silence", "Temporal scarcity", "Erasure as ethics", "Silence as method", "Ontology of beauty", "Aesthetic mercy", "Art encounter ethics", "Language as violence", "Epistemology of witness", "Philosophy of Art", "Aesthetics", "Art Theory", "Contemporary Aesthetics", "Comparative Aesthetics", "Phenomenology and Art", "Phenomenology", "Aesthetic Phenomenology", "Phenomenology of Aesthetic", "post-hermeneutics phenomenology", "Ethics in Art Criticism", "Interpretation and Meaning", "Criticism and Reception Theory", "Epistemology of Art", "Visual Culture Studies", "Dorian Vale", "Founder of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Post-Aesthetic Critic", "Independent Philosopher of Art", "Museum of One", "Art Writer and Theorist", "Aesthetic Philosopher", "Custodian of Witness Aesthetics", "Post-Interpretive Lexicon", "Museum of One Manifesto", "Erasure as Afterlife", "Language as Custody", "Interpretation vs. Witnessing", "The Viewer as Evidence", "Art as Presence", "Art as Truth", "The Canon of Witnesses", "The Custodian's Oath", "The Doctrine of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Interpretive Restraint", "Witness over interpretation", "Radical art restraint", "Quiet philosophy of art", "Slow looking philosophy", "Ethical art theory", "Criticism beyond interpretationNew art criticism movement", "Alternative art criticism", "Hassan Sharif", "Middle Eastern Modernism", "Conceptual Art", "Ethical Repetition", "Theology of the Banal", "Asceticism", "Anti-monumentality" ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21241866", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "license", "value": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21241866", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "files", "value": [ { "name": "Hassan Sharif’s Objects- The Ascetic of the Everyday .pdf", "url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/21241866/files/Hassan%20Sharif%E2%80%99s%20Objects-%20The%20Ascetic%20of%20the%20Everyday%20.pdf/content", "size": 1077820, "size_label": "1053 KB", "checksum": "md5:3e92afe450b57ddd845ec65ec3e2ab1b", "mimetype": "application/pdf" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21241866", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_created", "value": "2026-07-07T13:45:10.371458+00:00", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21241866", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_modified", "value": "2026-07-07T13:45:10.791243+00:00", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21241866", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "record_modified", "value": "2026-11-04", "status": "derived_from_description_history", "note": "Latest documented local description event; not a publication, repository or source-review date.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_review", "value": "2026-11-04", "status": "catalogue_source_review", "note": "Review of descriptive sources; not the creation or modification date of the work or repository record.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "author", "value": "Dorian Vale", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "note": "Institutional responsibility statement; original repository creator roles remain separate.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "publisher", "value": "Museum of One", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "note": "Institutional responsibility statement; original repository creator roles remain separate.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "orcid", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "source_linked_identifier", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "note": "Creator identifier supplied by the linked sources; no affiliation or endorsement is inferred.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "orcid_authority", "value": { "scheme": "ORCID", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "evidence_urls": [ "https://www.museumofone.art/archives-scholarly-infrastructure/", "https://eprints.rclis.org/47182/", "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ], "access_note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "evidence_receipt": "data/source/authority-review-2026-11-04.json" }, "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "source_url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "summary", "value": "An essay on Hassan Sharif’s handmade accumulations of ordinary materials, examining repetition, labour, consumption, and the ethical implications of material fragility.", "status": "editorial_enrichment", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "note": "Catalogue-editor summary based on the linked work; not an original publisher abstract.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "subjects", "value": [ "Hassan Sharif", "Emirati art", "Repetition and labour", "Material practice" ], "status": "editorial_enrichment", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "note": "Local discovery terms; no controlled-vocabulary assignment is claimed.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "collection", "value": "Essays & research", "status": "editorial_grouping", "note": "A local browsing collection, not an original repository collection.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "corroboration", "value": "Museum of One’s matching publication page confirms Dorian Vale’s authorship and the work’s institutional context. Its repository links and publication dates are retained separately from this selected Zenodo edition. Web-record dates are not treated as dates of the deposited edition. Source review: 4 November 2026.", "status": "catalogue_review_note", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "discrepancies", "value": [ "The Museum of One web record is dated 6 July 2026; this selected Zenodo edition gives 7 July 2026. These dates are preserved as separate records." ], "status": "catalogue_review_note", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "alternate_titles", "value": [ { "title": "Hassan Sharif’s Objects: The Ascetic of the Everyday", "kind": "institutional_web_record_title", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/" } ], "status": "source_qualified_title_variants", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "note": "Each variant retains its own source and scope; a web page title is not a title-page transcription.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "date_precision", "value": "day", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21241866", "note": "Precision reported exactly as supplied; missing month or day is not filled.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "medium", "value": "Digital document", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21241866", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "digital_formats", "value": [ "application/pdf" ], "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21241866", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "extent", "value": "1 digital file; 1077820 bytes", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21241866", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "digital_extent", "value": { "file_count": 1, "total_bytes": 1077820, "formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "checksums": [ { "filename": "Hassan Sharif’s Objects- The Ascetic of the Everyday .pdf", "algorithm": "md5", "value": "3e92afe450b57ddd845ec65ec3e2ab1b", "syntax_valid": true, "verification": "source_checksum_transcription; bytes not independently recomputed" } ], "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21241866", "derivation": "File count and total bytes calculated from repository file metadata; MIME inferred from filename when absent." }, "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21241866", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "identifier_validation", "value": { "orcid": { "source_value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "ISO 7064 MOD 11-2 checksum only; this is not a live registry verification." }, "isbn": [], "doi": { "source_value": "10.5281/zenodo.21241866", "syntax_valid": true, "note": "Syntax check only; repository snapshot supplies the identifier." } }, "status": "local_syntax_validation", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21241866", "note": "Checksum/syntax validation does not verify registration, assignment or edition applicability.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "contributor_roles", "value": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": "Museum of One", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21241866" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21241866", "note": "Creator and contributor roles are transcribed, not inferred from names or affiliations.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "research_programme:https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/", "value": { "title": "Witness, Material Presence, and Cultural Memory", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/", "status": "Continuing research", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "relation": "Related field essay on material presence, the visibility of labour and the responsibilities of preserving fragile work.", "relation_label": "Related field essay on material presence, the visibility of labour and the responsibilities of preserving fragile work." }, "status": "institutional_work_relationship", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "note": "Programme relationship and stage follow the work-specific institutional badge; publication does not imply a completed programme or collaboration.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "entity_link:dorian-vale:author", "value": { "id": "dorian-vale", "label": "Dorian Vale", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "author", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author.", "variants": [ "Vale, Dorian" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:df5e6746cebd1c7fb5d27b459f7e3c90cb61d14d0e3674ea6bbbe6ac1e7f3a1a", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21241866.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." } }, { "field": "entity_link:museum-of-one:publisher", "value": { "id": "museum-of-one", "label": "Museum of One", "entity_type": "Organization", "relation": "publisher", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record.", "variants": [ "MuseumofOne", "MUSEUM OF ONE" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:eaa1ddcb3f97d1813de0a0dcefaa03edd85e3be155b646f8ab738557e6d1ba80", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21241866.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." } }, { "field": "entity_link:hassan-sharif:artist discussed", "value": { "id": "hassan-sharif", "label": "Hassan Sharif", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "artist discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "note": "The essay studies Sharif’s Objects and captions Shopping Bags and Plastic Funnel and Aluminium Foil.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:aba1e680cb8c8e2dee5413473942a23b24708bc3e170e29a8217d83786938d0c", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21241866.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/hassan-sharif.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay studies Sharif’s Objects and captions Shopping Bags and Plastic Funnel and Aluminium Foil." } }, { "field": "entity_link:shopping-bags:artwork discussed", "value": { "id": "shopping-bags", "label": "Shopping Bags", "entity_type": "Artwork", "relation": "artwork discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "note": "Named in the image caption as a work by Hassan Sharif.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:bb26cfc9eda391e450c0a2eb560352bceff28be2ca67097a9170acaea98b4946", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21241866.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/shopping-bags.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "Named in the image caption as a work by Hassan Sharif." } }, { "field": "entity_link:plastic-funnel-and-aluminium-foil:artwork discussed", "value": { "id": "plastic-funnel-and-aluminium-foil", "label": "Plastic Funnel and Aluminium Foil", "entity_type": "Artwork", "relation": "artwork discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "note": "Named in the image caption as a work by Hassan Sharif.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:ef9e15b527daa15e8893223c368f928529145e22157df07ec15b1554163d3e11", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21241866.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/plastic-funnel-and-aluminium-foil.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "Named in the image caption as a work by Hassan Sharif." } }, { "field": "controlled_subjects", "value": [ { "id": "hassan-sharif", "label": "Hassan Sharif", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#hassan-sharif", "url": "vocabulary.html#hassan-sharif", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:hassan-sharif", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Named-subject access point for publications discussing the artist Hassan Sharif.", "scope_note": "This local heading supports subject discovery. Identity and external authority assertions belong in the separate entity register.", "kind": "named-subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "emirati-art", "label": "Emirati art", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#emirati-art", "url": "vocabulary.html#emirati-art", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:emirati-art", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Art discussed in relation to the United Arab Emirates.", "scope_note": "A contextual subject heading, not a statement of any individual’s citizenship or an external geographic authority assignment.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "repetition-and-labour", "label": "Repetition and labour", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#repetition-and-labour", "url": "vocabulary.html#repetition-and-labour", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:repetition-and-labour", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Repetition and labor" ], "definition": "Repeated making and the work involved in artistic production.", "scope_note": "Use when repetition and labour are discussed together, particularly in the Hassan Sharif essay; not a universal synonym for either concept alone.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "material-practice" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "material-practice", "label": "Material practice", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#material-practice", "url": "vocabulary.html#material-practice", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:material-practice", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Artistic working with materials and their properties, histories, or uses.", "scope_note": "Use as a broad subject for material processes; techniques such as Assemblage may be assigned separately.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "assemblage", "repetition-and-labour" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Local preferred terms with definitions and synonyms. External alignment is scoped in the vocabulary register." }, { "field": "genre_terms", "value": [ { "id": "genre-journal-article", "label": "Journal article", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#genre-journal-article", "url": "vocabulary.html#genre-journal-article", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:genre-journal-article", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Journal articles" ], "definition": "A contribution issued as part of a journal or periodical.", "scope_note": "Describes publication genre based on the catalogued source record; peer-review status is a separate question.", "kind": "genre", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "verified_mapping", "external_mappings": [ { "vocabulary": "Getty Art & Architecture Thesaurus", "label": "articles", "uri": "http://vocab.getty.edu/aat/300048715", "source_url": "https://www.getty.edu/vow/AATFullDisplay?find=&logic=AND¬e=&subjectid=300048715", "relation": "broadMatch", "status": "verified", "verified_on": "2026-11-04", "note": "Getty’s articles concept includes contributions to magazines, newspapers, encyclopedias, and other works; journal article is the narrower local genre." } ], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "type", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Local resource-genre classification. Digital file format is recorded separately." }, { "field": "archival_context", "value": { "description_profile": "moo-description-policy-1.0", "catalogue_snapshot_date": "2026-11-04", "snapshot_note": "Selected catalogue snapshot; not a live repository synchronisation.", "record_category": "Published library and repository material", "reference_code_status": "Stable local catalogue reference; not evidence of an archival acquisition or a previous catalogue accession.", "source_repository": { "name": "Zenodo", "record_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21241866" }, "institutional_context_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "source_metadata_retrieved": "2026-11-04", "source_metadata_retrieval_status": "Documented in catalogue source provenance", "source_snapshot": "source/21241866.json", "source_filenames": [ "Hassan Sharif’s Objects- The Ascetic of the Everyday .pdf" ], "selection_basis": "Local descriptive selection of publicly published material; public availability does not establish ownership of originals.", "custodial_history": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No donation, physical transfer, acquisition agreement or chain of custody is documented by this catalogue. Zenodo remains the source repository for the deposited version." }, "original_order": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No original archival order is asserted. Current browsing groupings are local editorial arrangement." }, "arrangement": { "status": "local_editorial", "grouping": "Essays & research", "statement": "A browsing grouping, not an original fonds or archival series." }, "responsible_service": { "name": "Museum of One", "service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "website": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "email": "research@museumofone.art" }, "description_method": "Source-based description with automated drafting and metadata assistance. Responsibility for the public catalogue rests with Museum of One; automated assistance does not constitute independent scholarly or curatorial review.", "policy_url": "policies.html", "correction_email": "research@museumofone.art", "access_copy": { "role": "Local digital reading copy of the deposited file", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/21241866/files/Hassan%20Sharif%E2%80%99s%20Objects-%20The%20Ascetic%20of%20the%20Everyday%20.pdf/content", "source_filename": "Hassan Sharif’s Objects- The Ascetic of the Everyday .pdf", "local_path": "assets/documents/21241866.pdf", "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "source_checksum_match": true, "sha256": "f3ada77ced8d8a82c11d99f6c5c9409176b81c45f11adcd3f959107b31567923", "statement": "Access copy only; no ownership or physical custody transfer is implied." } }, "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Provenance records what is documented and leaves unknown custody and original order explicit." }, { "field": "description_history", "value": [ { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Source-based catalogue description", "note": "Local description assembled from the identified public repository record and available institutional work record. Source metadata remains separately identifiable.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/21241866", "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Qualified descriptive enrichment", "note": "Local editorial description, arrangement and source-qualified bibliographic context recorded alongside source metadata. Unknown or disputed values remain qualified.", "fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/21241866", "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Automated file checksum and PDF inspection", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Digital reading copy verified", "note": "Downloaded access-copy MD5 matched the source checksum; local SHA-256 and PDF file-page count are recorded in the file manifest. This event does not describe transfer of custody.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/api/records/21241866/files/Hassan%20Sharif%E2%80%99s%20Objects-%20The%20Ascetic%20of%20the%20Everyday%20.pdf/content" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Description policy and provenance context adopted", "note": "Responsible service, source repository, local access-copy role, unknown custody and original order, correction route and dated description history made explicit under moo-description-policy-1.0.", "sources": [ "policies.html" ] }, { "event_id": "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Unify graph identities and qualify exported relationships and citations", "note": "Local graph projection now uses one contextual identity per entity, distinguishes work-level institutional matches from selected-edition links, retains title-level ISBN uncertainty, and derives citations from the source title. Typed relation assertions and a versioned validation profile are introduced. No publication date, original source snapshot or PDF changed.", "fields": [ "metadata_profile", "relationship_assertions", "identity", "institutional_match_scope", "citation_projection" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Source-based metadata implementation and regression validation", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication, source review or acquisition date", "sources": [ "metadata/metadata-profile.json" ] }, { "event_id": "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Record inspected public ORCID profile evidence", "note": "The official ORCID public person API returned the credited name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website. This confirms a matching public profile, not independently verified biographical or affiliation claims. Original creator arrays and source snapshots are unchanged.", "fields": [ "orcid_authority" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Read-only official public API inspection", "date_kind": "Local authority review and catalogue description event; not a publication or original creation date", "sources": [ "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ] } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Catalogue description events; these are not work publication dates or acquisition dates." }, { "field": "pirr_references", "value": [ { "programme_key": "research-witness-material-memory", "programme_title": "Witness, Material Presence, and Cultural Memory", "programme_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/", "programme_stage": "Continuing research", "registry_url": "research-registry.html#research-witness-material-memory", "identifiers": [ { "scheme": "PIRR project ID", "value": "pir-prj-dd7kt5rw", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/#programme-record" } ], "relation": "Related field essay on material presence, the visibility of labour and the responsibilities of preserving fragile work.", "relation_note": "Related field essay on material presence, the visibility of labour and the responsibilities of preserving fragile work.", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/" } ], "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "PIRR project IDs and programme references identify research records, not publication versions or independent chapter deposits." }, { "field": "relationship_assertions", "value": [ { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:df5e6746cebd1c7fb5d27b459f7e3c90cb61d14d0e3674ea6bbbe6ac1e7f3a1a", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21241866.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:eaa1ddcb3f97d1813de0a0dcefaa03edd85e3be155b646f8ab738557e6d1ba80", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21241866.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:aba1e680cb8c8e2dee5413473942a23b24708bc3e170e29a8217d83786938d0c", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21241866.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/hassan-sharif.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay studies Sharif’s Objects and captions Shopping Bags and Plastic Funnel and Aluminium Foil." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:bb26cfc9eda391e450c0a2eb560352bceff28be2ca67097a9170acaea98b4946", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21241866.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/shopping-bags.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "Named in the image caption as a work by Hassan Sharif." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:ef9e15b527daa15e8893223c368f928529145e22157df07ec15b1554163d3e11", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21241866.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/plastic-funnel-and-aluminium-foil.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "Named in the image caption as a work by Hassan Sharif." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:a743848150c330d98f8d3f8b935d2d8cbdf30f74bfbaa2b5ca3f358dd733f5fa", "subject": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#describes", "object": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21241865", "scope": "version_family", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "source_location": { "kind": "metadata_field", "field": "linked_zenodo_dois", "values": [ "10.5281/zenodo.21241865" ] }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "Exact-edition matching requires the selected DOI in the reviewed page metadata; other matches retain their wider scope." } ], "status": "typed_evidence_projection", "note": "Stable, typed assertions retain source scope and explicit unknown review metadata." }, { "field": "reading_copy", "value": { "id": "21241866", "title": "Hassan Sharif's Objects: The Ascetic of the Everyday", "accession": "MOO-CAT-008", "pdf_url": "../assets/documents/21241866.pdf", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/21241866/files/Hassan%20Sharif%E2%80%99s%20Objects-%20The%20Ascetic%20of%20the%20Everyday%20.pdf/content", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21241866", "source_filename": "Hassan Sharif’s Objects- The Ascetic of the Everyday .pdf", "checksum": "md5:3e92afe450b57ddd845ec65ec3e2ab1b", "sha256": "f3ada77ced8d8a82c11d99f6c5c9409176b81c45f11adcd3f959107b31567923", "bytes": 1077820, "page_count": 7, "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "checksum_match": true, "rights": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "role": "Local reading copy; original repository file retained unchanged" }, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/21241866/files/Hassan%20Sharif%E2%80%99s%20Objects-%20The%20Ascetic%20of%20the%20Everyday%20.pdf/content", "status": "derived_file_inspection", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "note": "Byte-identical local access copy. Source MD5 was recomputed and matched; SHA-256 and page count were measured from the downloaded PDF. This is not a preservation-deposit claim." }, { "field": "page_count", "value": 7, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/21241866/files/Hassan%20Sharif%E2%80%99s%20Objects-%20The%20Ascetic%20of%20the%20Everyday%20.pdf/content", "status": "derived_file_inspection", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "note": "Total PDF file pages measured from the deposited file, including cover and unnumbered pages. Not a claim about printed pagination." } ], "entity_links": [ { "id": "dorian-vale", "label": "Dorian Vale", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "author", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author.", "variants": [ "Vale, Dorian" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "museum-of-one", "label": "Museum of One", "entity_type": "Organization", "relation": "publisher", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record.", "variants": [ "MuseumofOne", "MUSEUM OF ONE" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "hassan-sharif", "label": "Hassan Sharif", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "artist discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "note": "The essay studies Sharif’s Objects and captions Shopping Bags and Plastic Funnel and Aluminium Foil.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "shopping-bags", "label": "Shopping Bags", "entity_type": "Artwork", "relation": "artwork discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "note": "Named in the image caption as a work by Hassan Sharif.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "plastic-funnel-and-aluminium-foil", "label": "Plastic Funnel and Aluminium Foil", "entity_type": "Artwork", "relation": "artwork discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "note": "Named in the image caption as a work by Hassan Sharif.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" } ], "contents": [], "controlled_subjects": [ { "id": "hassan-sharif", "label": "Hassan Sharif", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#hassan-sharif", "url": "vocabulary.html#hassan-sharif", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:hassan-sharif", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Named-subject access point for publications discussing the artist Hassan Sharif.", "scope_note": "This local heading supports subject discovery. Identity and external authority assertions belong in the separate entity register.", "kind": "named-subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "emirati-art", "label": "Emirati art", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#emirati-art", "url": "vocabulary.html#emirati-art", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:emirati-art", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Art discussed in relation to the United Arab Emirates.", "scope_note": "A contextual subject heading, not a statement of any individual’s citizenship or an external geographic authority assignment.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "repetition-and-labour", "label": "Repetition and labour", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#repetition-and-labour", "url": "vocabulary.html#repetition-and-labour", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:repetition-and-labour", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Repetition and labor" ], "definition": "Repeated making and the work involved in artistic production.", "scope_note": "Use when repetition and labour are discussed together, particularly in the Hassan Sharif essay; not a universal synonym for either concept alone.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "material-practice" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "material-practice", "label": "Material practice", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#material-practice", "url": "vocabulary.html#material-practice", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:material-practice", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Artistic working with materials and their properties, histories, or uses.", "scope_note": "Use as a broad subject for material processes; techniques such as Assemblage may be assigned separately.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "assemblage", "repetition-and-labour" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "genre_terms": [ { "id": "genre-journal-article", "label": "Journal article", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#genre-journal-article", "url": "vocabulary.html#genre-journal-article", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:genre-journal-article", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Journal articles" ], "definition": "A contribution issued as part of a journal or periodical.", "scope_note": "Describes publication genre based on the catalogued source record; peer-review status is a separate question.", "kind": "genre", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "verified_mapping", "external_mappings": [ { "vocabulary": "Getty Art & Architecture Thesaurus", "label": "articles", "uri": "http://vocab.getty.edu/aat/300048715", "source_url": "https://www.getty.edu/vow/AATFullDisplay?find=&logic=AND¬e=&subjectid=300048715", "relation": "broadMatch", "status": "verified", "verified_on": "2026-11-04", "note": "Getty’s articles concept includes contributions to magazines, newspapers, encyclopedias, and other works; journal article is the narrower local genre." } ], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "type", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "vocabulary_version": 4, "description_history": [ { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Source-based catalogue description", "note": "Local description assembled from the identified public repository record and available institutional work record. Source metadata remains separately identifiable.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/21241866", "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Qualified descriptive enrichment", "note": "Local editorial description, arrangement and source-qualified bibliographic context recorded alongside source metadata. Unknown or disputed values remain qualified.", "fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/21241866", "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Automated file checksum and PDF inspection", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Digital reading copy verified", "note": "Downloaded access-copy MD5 matched the source checksum; local SHA-256 and PDF file-page count are recorded in the file manifest. This event does not describe transfer of custody.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/api/records/21241866/files/Hassan%20Sharif%E2%80%99s%20Objects-%20The%20Ascetic%20of%20the%20Everyday%20.pdf/content" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Description policy and provenance context adopted", "note": "Responsible service, source repository, local access-copy role, unknown custody and original order, correction route and dated description history made explicit under moo-description-policy-1.0.", "sources": [ "policies.html" ] }, { "event_id": "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Unify graph identities and qualify exported relationships and citations", "note": "Local graph projection now uses one contextual identity per entity, distinguishes work-level institutional matches from selected-edition links, retains title-level ISBN uncertainty, and derives citations from the source title. Typed relation assertions and a versioned validation profile are introduced. No publication date, original source snapshot or PDF changed.", "fields": [ "metadata_profile", "relationship_assertions", "identity", "institutional_match_scope", "citation_projection" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Source-based metadata implementation and regression validation", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication, source review or acquisition date", "sources": [ "metadata/metadata-profile.json" ] }, { "event_id": "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Record inspected public ORCID profile evidence", "note": "The official ORCID public person API returned the credited name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website. This confirms a matching public profile, not independently verified biographical or affiliation claims. Original creator arrays and source snapshots are unchanged.", "fields": [ "orcid_authority" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Read-only official public API inspection", "date_kind": "Local authority review and catalogue description event; not a publication or original creation date", "sources": [ "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ] } ], "record_modified": "2026-11-04", "record_modified_provenance": { "status": "derived_from_description_history", "event_ids": [ "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04" ], "note": "Latest documented local description event; not a publication, repository or source-review date." }, "archival_context": { "description_profile": "moo-description-policy-1.0", "catalogue_snapshot_date": "2026-11-04", "snapshot_note": "Selected catalogue snapshot; not a live repository synchronisation.", "record_category": "Published library and repository material", "reference_code_status": "Stable local catalogue reference; not evidence of an archival acquisition or a previous catalogue accession.", "source_repository": { "name": "Zenodo", "record_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21241866" }, "institutional_context_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "source_metadata_retrieved": "2026-11-04", "source_metadata_retrieval_status": "Documented in catalogue source provenance", "source_snapshot": "source/21241866.json", "source_filenames": [ "Hassan Sharif’s Objects- The Ascetic of the Everyday .pdf" ], "selection_basis": "Local descriptive selection of publicly published material; public availability does not establish ownership of originals.", "custodial_history": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No donation, physical transfer, acquisition agreement or chain of custody is documented by this catalogue. Zenodo remains the source repository for the deposited version." }, "original_order": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No original archival order is asserted. Current browsing groupings are local editorial arrangement." }, "arrangement": { "status": "local_editorial", "grouping": "Essays & research", "statement": "A browsing grouping, not an original fonds or archival series." }, "responsible_service": { "name": "Museum of One", "service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "website": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "email": "research@museumofone.art" }, "description_method": "Source-based description with automated drafting and metadata assistance. Responsibility for the public catalogue rests with Museum of One; automated assistance does not constitute independent scholarly or curatorial review.", "policy_url": "policies.html", "correction_email": "research@museumofone.art", "access_copy": { "role": "Local digital reading copy of the deposited file", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/21241866/files/Hassan%20Sharif%E2%80%99s%20Objects-%20The%20Ascetic%20of%20the%20Everyday%20.pdf/content", "source_filename": "Hassan Sharif’s Objects- The Ascetic of the Everyday .pdf", "local_path": "assets/documents/21241866.pdf", "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "source_checksum_match": true, "sha256": "f3ada77ced8d8a82c11d99f6c5c9409176b81c45f11adcd3f959107b31567923", "statement": "Access copy only; no ownership or physical custody transfer is implied." } }, "description_policy_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "pirr_references": [ { "programme_key": "research-witness-material-memory", "programme_title": "Witness, Material Presence, and Cultural Memory", "programme_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/", "programme_stage": "Continuing research", "registry_url": "research-registry.html#research-witness-material-memory", "identifiers": [ { "scheme": "PIRR project ID", "value": "pir-prj-dd7kt5rw", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/#programme-record" } ], "relation": "Related field essay on material presence, the visibility of labour and the responsibilities of preserving fragile work.", "relation_note": "Related field essay on material presence, the visibility of labour and the responsibilities of preserving fragile work.", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/" } ], "pirr_work_identity": { "archive_reference": "MOO-CAT-008", "edition_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.21241866", "zenodo_record_id": "21241866", "identifier_scope": "Publication identity; PIRR identifiers in programme relationships identify research records, not this publication." }, "metadata_origin": "https://archive.museumofone.art", "identity": { "work": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21241866.html#work", "edition": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21241866", "version_family": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21241865", "catalogue_record": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21241866.html#catalogue-record" }, "institutional_match_scope": "version_family", "relationship_assertions": [ { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:df5e6746cebd1c7fb5d27b459f7e3c90cb61d14d0e3674ea6bbbe6ac1e7f3a1a", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21241866.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:eaa1ddcb3f97d1813de0a0dcefaa03edd85e3be155b646f8ab738557e6d1ba80", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21241866.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:aba1e680cb8c8e2dee5413473942a23b24708bc3e170e29a8217d83786938d0c", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21241866.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/hassan-sharif.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay studies Sharif’s Objects and captions Shopping Bags and Plastic Funnel and Aluminium Foil." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:bb26cfc9eda391e450c0a2eb560352bceff28be2ca67097a9170acaea98b4946", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21241866.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/shopping-bags.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "Named in the image caption as a work by Hassan Sharif." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:ef9e15b527daa15e8893223c368f928529145e22157df07ec15b1554163d3e11", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21241866.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/plastic-funnel-and-aluminium-foil.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "Named in the image caption as a work by Hassan Sharif." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:a743848150c330d98f8d3f8b935d2d8cbdf30f74bfbaa2b5ca3f358dd733f5fa", "subject": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#describes", "object": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21241865", "scope": "version_family", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/hassan-sharifs-objects-the-ascetic-of-the-everyday/", "source_location": { "kind": "metadata_field", "field": "linked_zenodo_dois", "values": [ "10.5281/zenodo.21241865" ] }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "Exact-edition matching requires the selected DOI in the reviewed page metadata; other matches retain their wider scope." } ], "orcid_authority": { "scheme": "ORCID", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "evidence_urls": [ "https://www.museumofone.art/archives-scholarly-infrastructure/", "https://eprints.rclis.org/47182/", "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ], "access_note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "evidence_receipt": "data/source/authority-review-2026-11-04.json" } }, { "id": "20593003", "accession": "MOO-CAT-009", "title": "El Anatsui's Man's Cloth Series: Redemption of Waste as Modern Eucharist", "source_title": "El Anatsui's Man's Cloth Series: Redemption of Waste as Modern Eucharist", "short_title": "El Anatsui’s Man’s Cloth Series", "author": "Dorian Vale", "creators": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "affiliation": "Museum of One", "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094" } ], "doi": "10.5281/zenodo.20593003", "conceptdoi": "10.5281/zenodo.20593002", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20593003", "date": "2026-06-08", "type": "Journal article", "source_resource_type": { "title": "Journal article", "type": "publication", "subtype": "article" }, "version": "", "collection": "Essays & research", "summary": "An essay on El Anatsui’s bottle-cap assemblages, linking discarded materials and collaborative labour with historical memory, installation practices, and the author’s account of reparation.", "subjects": [ "El Anatsui", "Assemblage", "Material practice", "Historical memory" ], "keywords": [ "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Stillmark Theory", "Message-Transfer Theory", "Misplacement", "Displacement", "Aesthetic Displacement Theory", "Theory of Misplacement", "Absential Aesthetics", "Witness Aesthetics", "Hauntmark Theory", "Presence-Based Criticism", "Custodianship of Art", "Art as Ontology", "Aesthetic Recursion Theory", "Aesthetic Recursion", "Viewer as Evidence Theory", "Interpretive Load Index (ILI)", "Viewer Displacement Ratio (VDR)", "Ethical Proximity Score (EPS)", "Institutional Alignment Indicator (IAI)", "Epoché Fidelity Index (EFI)", "Phenomenological Phase Alignment Score (PPAS)", "Residue Engagement Restraint Ratio (RERR)", "Quasi-Subject Agency Recognition Index (QSARI)", "Dialectical Circulation Index (DCI)", "Restraint in front of art", "Moral proximity", "Interpretive silence", "Erasure as ethics", "Temporal scarcity", "Silence as method", "Ontology of beauty", "Aesthetic mercy", "Language as violence", "Art encounter ethics", "Epistemology of witness", "Aesthetics", "Philosophy of Art", "Art Theory", "Contemporary Aesthetics", "Comparative Aesthetics", "Phenomenology and Art", "Phenomenology", "Aesthetic Phenomenology", "Phenomenology of Aesthetic", "post-hermeneutics phenomenology", "Ethics in Art Criticism", "Interpretation and Meaning", "Criticism and Reception Theory", "Epistemology of Art", "Visual Culture Studies", "Dorian Vale", "Founder of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Post-Aesthetic Critic", "Independent Philosopher of Art", "Museum of One", "Art Writer and Theorist", "Aesthetic Philosopher", "Custodian of Witness Aesthetics", "The Doctrine of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "The Custodian's Oath", "The Canon of Witnesses", "Art as Truth", "Art as Presence", "The Viewer as Evidence", "Interpretation vs. Witnessing", "Language as Custody", "Erasure as Afterlife", "Museum of One Manifesto", "Post-Interpretive Lexicon", "Alternative art criticism", "New art criticism movement", "Ethical art theory", "Criticism beyond interpretation", "Slow looking philosophy", "Contemporary sacred aesthetics", "Quiet philosophy of art", "Radical art restraint", "Witness over interpretation", "Interpretive Restraint" ], "license": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "files": [ { "name": "El Anatsui’s Man’s Cloth Series; Redemption of Waste as Modern Eucharist.pdf", "url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/20593003/files/El%20Anatsui%E2%80%99s%20Man%E2%80%99s%20Cloth%20Series;%20Redemption%20of%20Waste%20as%20Modern%20Eucharist.pdf/content", "size": 360669, "size_label": "352 KB", "checksum": "md5:e92667e9ca21506ec2846700a323c12e", "mimetype": "application/pdf" } ], "institutional_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "corroboration": "Museum of One’s matching publication page confirms Dorian Vale’s authorship and the work’s institutional context. Its repository links and publication dates are retained separately from this selected Zenodo edition. Web-record dates are not treated as dates of the deposited edition. Source review: 4 November 2026.", "discrepancies": [], "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "publisher": "Museum of One", "language": null, "isbn": null, "related_identifiers": [ { "identifier": "https://www.museumofone.art", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://zenodo.org/communities/post-interpretive-criticism", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://osf.io/zhnre/", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://works.hcommons.org/records/xv2j2-g6927", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://philpapers.org/rec/VALPCF-2", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.semanticscholar.org/author/Dorian-Vale/2380743266", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.researchcatalogue.net/profile", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://archive.org/details/the-journal-of-post-interpretive-criticism-vi", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=15tvhjAAAAAJ", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://independent.academia.edu/DorianVale", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.zotero.org/groups/6279725/post-interpretive-criticism", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://core.ac.uk/search/?q=post-interpretive+criticism+dorian+vale", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.base-search.net/Search/Results?lookfor=Post-Interpretive+Criticism", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://commons.datacite.org/?query=Post-Interpretive+Criticism", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://openalex.org/works?filter=title_and_abstract.search:Post-Interpretive+Criticism+Dorian+Vale", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://webarchiveweb.wayback.bac-lac.canada.ca/web/*/https://www.museumofone.art", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" } ], "alternate_identifiers": [ { "identifier": "0000000528819728" }, { "identifier": "0000000528819787" }, { "identifier": "0000000528819744" }, { "identifier": "https://www.museumofone.art" } ], "source_references": [ "https://www.museumofone.art", "https://zenodo.org/communities/post-interpretive-criticism", "https://osf.io/zhnre/", "https://works.hcommons.org/records/xv2j2-g6927", "https://philpapers.org/rec/VALPCF-2", "https://www.semanticscholar.org/author/Dorian-Vale/2380743266", "https://www.researchcatalogue.net/profile", "https://archive.org/details/the-journal-of-post-interpretive-criticism-vi", "https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=15tvhjAAAAAJ", "https://independent.academia.edu/DorianVale", "https://www.zotero.org/groups/6279725/post-interpretive-criticism", "https://core.ac.uk/search/?q=post-interpretive+criticism+dorian+vale", "https://www.base-search.net/Search/Results?lookfor=Post-Interpretive+Criticism", "https://commons.datacite.org/?query=Post-Interpretive+Criticism", "https://openalex.org/works?filter=title_and_abstract.search:Post-Interpretive+Criticism+Dorian+Vale", "https://webarchiveweb.wayback.bac-lac.canada.ca/web/*/https://www.museumofone.art" ], "source_journal": { "title": "Journal of Post-Interpretive Critiism" }, "source_imprint": null, "source_contributors": [], "source_created": "2026-06-08T11:37:51.610402+00:00", "source_modified": "2026-06-08T11:37:51.823356+00:00", "source_description_html": "

This article examines El Anatsui's Man's Cloth Series (c. 1999–) as a sustained practice of material redemption, tracing the ethical and aesthetic logic by which discarded liquor bottle caps, residues of the Atlantic trade economy, are transformed into monumental textile-like assemblages. Drawing on Post-Interpretive Criticism, the essay argues that Anatsui's work enacts what PIC terms the ethics of reparation: the restoration of moral and material dignity to objects declared worthless by colonial and capitalist systems. The analysis attends to the formal conditions of this transformation, collective studio labour, the retention of legible brand markings, the open-ended installation protocols Anatsui extends to curators and preparators, and reads these not as curatorial gestures but as structural enactments of repair. The piece further situates Man's Cloth within Anatsui's broader bottle-cap practice and his Ewe-Kente inheritance, arguing that the series produces what might be called a new aesthetic theology: one in which beauty is diagnostic rather than decorative, and continuity of historical record is treated as a moral obligation of form. The essay concludes by considering Anatsui's institutional presence, from the British Museum's Sainsbury African Galleries to Tate Modern's Turbine Hall, and the capacity of these works to resist capture even within spaces of preservation and prestige.

\n

 

\n

Dorian Vale is a chosen pseudonym, not to obscure identity, but to preserve clarity of voice and integrity of message. It creates distance between the writer and the work, allowing the philosophy to stand unclouded by biography. The name exists not to hide, but to honor the seriousness of the task: to speak without spectacle, and to build without needing to be seen. This name is used for all official publications, essays, and theoretical works indexed through DOI-linked repositories including Zenodo, OSF, PhilPapers, and SSRN.

\n

 

\n

\n

This entry is connected to a series of original theories and treatises forming the foundation of the Post-Interpretive Criticism movement (Q136308909), authored by Dorian Vale (Q136308916) and published by Museum of One (Q136308879). These include: Stillmark Theory (Q136328254), Hauntmark Theory (Q136328273), Absential Aesthetic Theory (Q136328330), Viewer-as-Evidence Theory (Q136328828), Message-Transfer Theory (Q136329002), Aesthetic Displacement Theory (Q136329014), Theory of Misplacement (Q136329054), and Art as Truth: A Treatise (Q136329071), Aesthetic Recursion Theory (Q136339843), The Journal of Post-Interpretive Criticism (Q136530009), Canon of Witnesses (Q136565881),Interpretive Load Index (ILI) (Q137709526), Viewer Displacement Ratio (VDR) (Q137709583) , Ethical Proximity Score (EPS) (Q137709600) , Institutional Alignment Indicator (IAI) (Q137709608), Post-Hermeneutic Phenomenology (Q137711946)

", "provenance": { "repository": "Zenodo REST API response supplied in query.json", "retrieved": "2026-11-04", "editorial_fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "source_snapshot": "source/20593003.json", "institutional_review": "Reviewed page-level title, author and repository links in saved public institutional HTML, 2026-11-04." }, "source_review": "2026-11-04", "relations": [ { "identifier": "https://www.museumofone.art", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://zenodo.org/communities/post-interpretive-criticism", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://osf.io/zhnre/", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://works.hcommons.org/records/xv2j2-g6927", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://philpapers.org/rec/VALPCF-2", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.semanticscholar.org/author/Dorian-Vale/2380743266", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.researchcatalogue.net/profile", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://archive.org/details/the-journal-of-post-interpretive-criticism-vi", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=15tvhjAAAAAJ", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://independent.academia.edu/DorianVale", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.zotero.org/groups/6279725/post-interpretive-criticism", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://core.ac.uk/search/?q=post-interpretive+criticism+dorian+vale", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.base-search.net/Search/Results?lookfor=Post-Interpretive+Criticism", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://commons.datacite.org/?query=Post-Interpretive+Criticism", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://openalex.org/works?filter=title_and_abstract.search:Post-Interpretive+Criticism+Dorian+Vale", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://webarchiveweb.wayback.bac-lac.canada.ca/web/*/https://www.museumofone.art", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" } ], "institutional_metadata": { "title": "El Anatsui’s Man’s Cloth Series: Redemption of Waste as Modern Eucharist", "author": "Dorian Vale", "web_publication": "2026-06-08T11:42:36.000Z", "web_updated": "2026-11-03T00:38:45.000Z", "linked_zenodo_dois": [ "10.5281/zenodo.20593002" ], "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/" }, "research_programmes": [ { "title": "Witness, Material Presence, and Cultural Memory", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/", "status": "Continuing research", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "relation": "Related field essay on material residue, collective making and the continuing consequences of an artwork's presentation.", "relation_label": "Related field essay on material residue, collective making and the continuing consequences of an artwork's presentation." } ], "record_level": "Item", "record_status": "Published source; selected catalogue record", "digital_formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "extent": "1 digital file; 360669 bytes", "medium": "Digital document", "record_reviewed": "2026-11-04", "date_precision": "day", "alternate_titles": [ { "title": "El Anatsui’s Man’s Cloth Series: Redemption of Waste as Modern Eucharist", "kind": "institutional_web_record_title", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/" } ], "digital_extent": { "file_count": 1, "total_bytes": 360669, "formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "checksums": [ { "filename": "El Anatsui’s Man’s Cloth Series; Redemption of Waste as Modern Eucharist.pdf", "algorithm": "md5", "value": "e92667e9ca21506ec2846700a323c12e", "syntax_valid": true, "verification": "source_checksum_transcription; bytes not independently recomputed" } ], "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20593003", "derivation": "File count and total bytes calculated from repository file metadata; MIME inferred from filename when absent." }, "identifier_validation": { "orcid": { "source_value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "ISO 7064 MOD 11-2 checksum only; this is not a live registry verification." }, "isbn": [], "doi": { "source_value": "10.5281/zenodo.20593003", "syntax_valid": true, "note": "Syntax check only; repository snapshot supplies the identifier." } }, "isbn_applicability": "not_supplied", "serial": null, "contributor_roles": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": "Museum of One", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20593003" } ], "authority_links": [], "metadata_profile": { "name": "Museum of One source-qualified catalogue profile", "version": "3.0.0", "url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/metadata-profile.json", "source_snapshot_preserved": true }, "reading_copy": { "id": "20593003", "title": "El Anatsui's Man's Cloth Series: Redemption of Waste as Modern Eucharist", "accession": "MOO-CAT-009", "pdf_url": "../assets/documents/20593003.pdf", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/20593003/files/El%20Anatsui%E2%80%99s%20Man%E2%80%99s%20Cloth%20Series;%20Redemption%20of%20Waste%20as%20Modern%20Eucharist.pdf/content", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20593003", "source_filename": "El Anatsui’s Man’s Cloth Series; Redemption of Waste as Modern Eucharist.pdf", "checksum": "md5:e92667e9ca21506ec2846700a323c12e", "sha256": "2d042e0c2cdc2e8db76802fc763618a76ac27aa7898b9f5049ff1d862be76c85", "bytes": 360669, "page_count": 6, "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "checksum_match": true, "rights": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "role": "Local reading copy; original repository file retained unchanged" }, "page_count": 6, "field_assertions": [ { "field": "title", "value": "El Anatsui's Man's Cloth Series: Redemption of Waste as Modern Eucharist", "status": "catalogue_title", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "note": "Local display title; the deposited title is retained separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_title", "value": "El Anatsui's Man's Cloth Series: Redemption of Waste as Modern Eucharist", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20593003", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "doi", "value": "10.5281/zenodo.20593003", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20593003", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "date", "value": "2026-06-08", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20593003", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "conceptdoi", "value": "10.5281/zenodo.20593002", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20593003", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "creators", "value": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "affiliation": "Museum of One", "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20593003", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "keywords", "value": [ "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Stillmark Theory", "Message-Transfer Theory", "Misplacement", "Displacement", "Aesthetic Displacement Theory", "Theory of Misplacement", "Absential Aesthetics", "Witness Aesthetics", "Hauntmark Theory", "Presence-Based Criticism", "Custodianship of Art", "Art as Ontology", "Aesthetic Recursion Theory", "Aesthetic Recursion", "Viewer as Evidence Theory", "Interpretive Load Index (ILI)", "Viewer Displacement Ratio (VDR)", "Ethical Proximity Score (EPS)", "Institutional Alignment Indicator (IAI)", "Epoché Fidelity Index (EFI)", "Phenomenological Phase Alignment Score (PPAS)", "Residue Engagement Restraint Ratio (RERR)", "Quasi-Subject Agency Recognition Index (QSARI)", "Dialectical Circulation Index (DCI)", "Restraint in front of art", "Moral proximity", "Interpretive silence", "Erasure as ethics", "Temporal scarcity", "Silence as method", "Ontology of beauty", "Aesthetic mercy", "Language as violence", "Art encounter ethics", "Epistemology of witness", "Aesthetics", "Philosophy of Art", "Art Theory", "Contemporary Aesthetics", "Comparative Aesthetics", "Phenomenology and Art", "Phenomenology", "Aesthetic Phenomenology", "Phenomenology of Aesthetic", "post-hermeneutics phenomenology", "Ethics in Art Criticism", "Interpretation and Meaning", "Criticism and Reception Theory", "Epistemology of Art", "Visual Culture Studies", "Dorian Vale", "Founder of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Post-Aesthetic Critic", "Independent Philosopher of Art", "Museum of One", "Art Writer and Theorist", "Aesthetic Philosopher", "Custodian of Witness Aesthetics", "The Doctrine of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "The Custodian's Oath", "The Canon of Witnesses", "Art as Truth", "Art as Presence", "The Viewer as Evidence", "Interpretation vs. Witnessing", "Language as Custody", "Erasure as Afterlife", "Museum of One Manifesto", "Post-Interpretive Lexicon", "Alternative art criticism", "New art criticism movement", "Ethical art theory", "Criticism beyond interpretation", "Slow looking philosophy", "Contemporary sacred aesthetics", "Quiet philosophy of art", "Radical art restraint", "Witness over interpretation", "Interpretive Restraint" ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20593003", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "license", "value": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20593003", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "files", "value": [ { "name": "El Anatsui’s Man’s Cloth Series; Redemption of Waste as Modern Eucharist.pdf", "url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/20593003/files/El%20Anatsui%E2%80%99s%20Man%E2%80%99s%20Cloth%20Series;%20Redemption%20of%20Waste%20as%20Modern%20Eucharist.pdf/content", "size": 360669, "size_label": "352 KB", "checksum": "md5:e92667e9ca21506ec2846700a323c12e", "mimetype": "application/pdf" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20593003", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_created", "value": "2026-06-08T11:37:51.610402+00:00", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20593003", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_modified", "value": "2026-06-08T11:37:51.823356+00:00", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20593003", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "record_modified", "value": "2026-11-04", "status": "derived_from_description_history", "note": "Latest documented local description event; not a publication, repository or source-review date.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_review", "value": "2026-11-04", "status": "catalogue_source_review", "note": "Review of descriptive sources; not the creation or modification date of the work or repository record.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "author", "value": "Dorian Vale", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "note": "Institutional responsibility statement; original repository creator roles remain separate.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "publisher", "value": "Museum of One", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "note": "Institutional responsibility statement; original repository creator roles remain separate.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "orcid", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "source_linked_identifier", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "note": "Creator identifier supplied by the linked sources; no affiliation or endorsement is inferred.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "orcid_authority", "value": { "scheme": "ORCID", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "evidence_urls": [ "https://www.museumofone.art/archives-scholarly-infrastructure/", "https://eprints.rclis.org/47182/", "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ], "access_note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "evidence_receipt": "data/source/authority-review-2026-11-04.json" }, "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "source_url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "summary", "value": "An essay on El Anatsui’s bottle-cap assemblages, linking discarded materials and collaborative labour with historical memory, installation practices, and the author’s account of reparation.", "status": "editorial_enrichment", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "note": "Catalogue-editor summary based on the linked work; not an original publisher abstract.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "subjects", "value": [ "El Anatsui", "Assemblage", "Material practice", "Historical memory" ], "status": "editorial_enrichment", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "note": "Local discovery terms; no controlled-vocabulary assignment is claimed.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "collection", "value": "Essays & research", "status": "editorial_grouping", "note": "A local browsing collection, not an original repository collection.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "corroboration", "value": "Museum of One’s matching publication page confirms Dorian Vale’s authorship and the work’s institutional context. Its repository links and publication dates are retained separately from this selected Zenodo edition. Web-record dates are not treated as dates of the deposited edition. Source review: 4 November 2026.", "status": "catalogue_review_note", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "alternate_titles", "value": [ { "title": "El Anatsui’s Man’s Cloth Series: Redemption of Waste as Modern Eucharist", "kind": "institutional_web_record_title", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/" } ], "status": "source_qualified_title_variants", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "note": "Each variant retains its own source and scope; a web page title is not a title-page transcription.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "date_precision", "value": "day", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20593003", "note": "Precision reported exactly as supplied; missing month or day is not filled.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "medium", "value": "Digital document", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20593003", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "digital_formats", "value": [ "application/pdf" ], "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20593003", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "extent", "value": "1 digital file; 360669 bytes", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20593003", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "digital_extent", "value": { "file_count": 1, "total_bytes": 360669, "formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "checksums": [ { "filename": "El Anatsui’s Man’s Cloth Series; Redemption of Waste as Modern Eucharist.pdf", "algorithm": "md5", "value": "e92667e9ca21506ec2846700a323c12e", "syntax_valid": true, "verification": "source_checksum_transcription; bytes not independently recomputed" } ], "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20593003", "derivation": "File count and total bytes calculated from repository file metadata; MIME inferred from filename when absent." }, "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20593003", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "identifier_validation", "value": { "orcid": { "source_value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "ISO 7064 MOD 11-2 checksum only; this is not a live registry verification." }, "isbn": [], "doi": { "source_value": "10.5281/zenodo.20593003", "syntax_valid": true, "note": "Syntax check only; repository snapshot supplies the identifier." } }, "status": "local_syntax_validation", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20593003", "note": "Checksum/syntax validation does not verify registration, assignment or edition applicability.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "contributor_roles", "value": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": "Museum of One", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20593003" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20593003", "note": "Creator and contributor roles are transcribed, not inferred from names or affiliations.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "research_programme:https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/", "value": { "title": "Witness, Material Presence, and Cultural Memory", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/", "status": "Continuing research", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "relation": "Related field essay on material residue, collective making and the continuing consequences of an artwork's presentation.", "relation_label": "Related field essay on material residue, collective making and the continuing consequences of an artwork's presentation." }, "status": "institutional_work_relationship", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "note": "Programme relationship and stage follow the work-specific institutional badge; publication does not imply a completed programme or collaboration.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "entity_link:dorian-vale:author", "value": { "id": "dorian-vale", "label": "Dorian Vale", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "author", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author.", "variants": [ "Vale, Dorian" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:49b40b66256cd5f3c388244f99aa81436206f0e0c955d141166bc316918b8182", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/20593003.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." } }, { "field": "entity_link:museum-of-one:publisher", "value": { "id": "museum-of-one", "label": "Museum of One", "entity_type": "Organization", "relation": "publisher", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record.", "variants": [ "MuseumofOne", "MUSEUM OF ONE" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:68e334abdedda2703924535a6ebba584873542f760e07f04bf5058472679dee4", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/20593003.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." } }, { "field": "entity_link:el-anatsui:artist discussed", "value": { "id": "el-anatsui", "label": "El Anatsui", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "artist discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "note": "The essay studies the Man’s Cloth series and captions Old Man’s Cloth.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:a867afe2644dd6ed805c0829c63ffe7720945acaa012caa57e4e5163249f08a0", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/20593003.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/el-anatsui.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay studies the Man’s Cloth series and captions Old Man’s Cloth." } }, { "field": "entity_link:old-mans-cloth:artwork discussed", "value": { "id": "old-mans-cloth", "label": "Old Man’s Cloth", "entity_type": "Artwork", "relation": "artwork discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "note": "Named in the image caption as a work by El Anatsui.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:f49d12e86bd8e006dbcd74f759d1c4b6d0099fdbc40c26bb40405d5944eb8d12", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/20593003.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/old-mans-cloth.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "Named in the image caption as a work by El Anatsui." } }, { "field": "controlled_subjects", "value": [ { "id": "el-anatsui", "label": "El Anatsui", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#el-anatsui", "url": "vocabulary.html#el-anatsui", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:el-anatsui", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Named-subject access point for publications discussing the artist El Anatsui.", "scope_note": "This local heading supports subject discovery. Identity and external authority assertions belong in the separate entity register.", "kind": "named-subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "assemblage", "label": "Assemblage", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#assemblage", "url": "vocabulary.html#assemblage", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:assemblage", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Artistic practice involving the combination of existing objects or materials.", "scope_note": "In this catalogue, used for discussion of El Anatsui’s material constructions; does not classify the deposited PDF as an artwork.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "material-practice" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "material-practice", "label": "Material practice", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#material-practice", "url": "vocabulary.html#material-practice", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:material-practice", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Artistic working with materials and their properties, histories, or uses.", "scope_note": "Use as a broad subject for material processes; techniques such as Assemblage may be assigned separately.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "assemblage", "repetition-and-labour" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "historical-memory", "label": "Historical memory", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#historical-memory", "url": "vocabulary.html#historical-memory", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:historical-memory", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "The retention and mediation of the past through art and its material histories.", "scope_note": "Used for studies linking an artwork’s materials or practices to remembered histories; related to the broader subject Memory.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [ "memory" ], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Local preferred terms with definitions and synonyms. External alignment is scoped in the vocabulary register." }, { "field": "genre_terms", "value": [ { "id": "genre-journal-article", "label": "Journal article", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#genre-journal-article", "url": "vocabulary.html#genre-journal-article", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:genre-journal-article", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Journal articles" ], "definition": "A contribution issued as part of a journal or periodical.", "scope_note": "Describes publication genre based on the catalogued source record; peer-review status is a separate question.", "kind": "genre", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "verified_mapping", "external_mappings": [ { "vocabulary": "Getty Art & Architecture Thesaurus", "label": "articles", "uri": "http://vocab.getty.edu/aat/300048715", "source_url": "https://www.getty.edu/vow/AATFullDisplay?find=&logic=AND¬e=&subjectid=300048715", "relation": "broadMatch", "status": "verified", "verified_on": "2026-11-04", "note": "Getty’s articles concept includes contributions to magazines, newspapers, encyclopedias, and other works; journal article is the narrower local genre." } ], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "type", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Local resource-genre classification. Digital file format is recorded separately." }, { "field": "archival_context", "value": { "description_profile": "moo-description-policy-1.0", "catalogue_snapshot_date": "2026-11-04", "snapshot_note": "Selected catalogue snapshot; not a live repository synchronisation.", "record_category": "Published library and repository material", "reference_code_status": "Stable local catalogue reference; not evidence of an archival acquisition or a previous catalogue accession.", "source_repository": { "name": "Zenodo", "record_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20593003" }, "institutional_context_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "source_metadata_retrieved": "2026-11-04", "source_metadata_retrieval_status": "Documented in catalogue source provenance", "source_snapshot": "source/20593003.json", "source_filenames": [ "El Anatsui’s Man’s Cloth Series; Redemption of Waste as Modern Eucharist.pdf" ], "selection_basis": "Local descriptive selection of publicly published material; public availability does not establish ownership of originals.", "custodial_history": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No donation, physical transfer, acquisition agreement or chain of custody is documented by this catalogue. Zenodo remains the source repository for the deposited version." }, "original_order": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No original archival order is asserted. Current browsing groupings are local editorial arrangement." }, "arrangement": { "status": "local_editorial", "grouping": "Essays & research", "statement": "A browsing grouping, not an original fonds or archival series." }, "responsible_service": { "name": "Museum of One", "service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "website": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "email": "research@museumofone.art" }, "description_method": "Source-based description with automated drafting and metadata assistance. Responsibility for the public catalogue rests with Museum of One; automated assistance does not constitute independent scholarly or curatorial review.", "policy_url": "policies.html", "correction_email": "research@museumofone.art", "access_copy": { "role": "Local digital reading copy of the deposited file", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/20593003/files/El%20Anatsui%E2%80%99s%20Man%E2%80%99s%20Cloth%20Series;%20Redemption%20of%20Waste%20as%20Modern%20Eucharist.pdf/content", "source_filename": "El Anatsui’s Man’s Cloth Series; Redemption of Waste as Modern Eucharist.pdf", "local_path": "assets/documents/20593003.pdf", "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "source_checksum_match": true, "sha256": "2d042e0c2cdc2e8db76802fc763618a76ac27aa7898b9f5049ff1d862be76c85", "statement": "Access copy only; no ownership or physical custody transfer is implied." } }, "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Provenance records what is documented and leaves unknown custody and original order explicit." }, { "field": "description_history", "value": [ { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Source-based catalogue description", "note": "Local description assembled from the identified public repository record and available institutional work record. Source metadata remains separately identifiable.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/20593003", "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Qualified descriptive enrichment", "note": "Local editorial description, arrangement and source-qualified bibliographic context recorded alongside source metadata. Unknown or disputed values remain qualified.", "fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/20593003", "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Automated file checksum and PDF inspection", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Digital reading copy verified", "note": "Downloaded access-copy MD5 matched the source checksum; local SHA-256 and PDF file-page count are recorded in the file manifest. This event does not describe transfer of custody.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/api/records/20593003/files/El%20Anatsui%E2%80%99s%20Man%E2%80%99s%20Cloth%20Series;%20Redemption%20of%20Waste%20as%20Modern%20Eucharist.pdf/content" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Description policy and provenance context adopted", "note": "Responsible service, source repository, local access-copy role, unknown custody and original order, correction route and dated description history made explicit under moo-description-policy-1.0.", "sources": [ "policies.html" ] }, { "event_id": "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Unify graph identities and qualify exported relationships and citations", "note": "Local graph projection now uses one contextual identity per entity, distinguishes work-level institutional matches from selected-edition links, retains title-level ISBN uncertainty, and derives citations from the source title. Typed relation assertions and a versioned validation profile are introduced. No publication date, original source snapshot or PDF changed.", "fields": [ "metadata_profile", "relationship_assertions", "identity", "institutional_match_scope", "citation_projection" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Source-based metadata implementation and regression validation", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication, source review or acquisition date", "sources": [ "metadata/metadata-profile.json" ] }, { "event_id": "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Record inspected public ORCID profile evidence", "note": "The official ORCID public person API returned the credited name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website. This confirms a matching public profile, not independently verified biographical or affiliation claims. Original creator arrays and source snapshots are unchanged.", "fields": [ "orcid_authority" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Read-only official public API inspection", "date_kind": "Local authority review and catalogue description event; not a publication or original creation date", "sources": [ "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ] } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Catalogue description events; these are not work publication dates or acquisition dates." }, { "field": "pirr_references", "value": [ { "programme_key": "research-witness-material-memory", "programme_title": "Witness, Material Presence, and Cultural Memory", "programme_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/", "programme_stage": "Continuing research", "registry_url": "research-registry.html#research-witness-material-memory", "identifiers": [ { "scheme": "PIRR project ID", "value": "pir-prj-dd7kt5rw", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/#programme-record" } ], "relation": "Related field essay on material residue, collective making and the continuing consequences of an artwork's presentation.", "relation_note": "Related field essay on material residue, collective making and the continuing consequences of an artwork's presentation.", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/" } ], "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "PIRR project IDs and programme references identify research records, not publication versions or independent chapter deposits." }, { "field": "relationship_assertions", "value": [ { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:49b40b66256cd5f3c388244f99aa81436206f0e0c955d141166bc316918b8182", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/20593003.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:68e334abdedda2703924535a6ebba584873542f760e07f04bf5058472679dee4", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/20593003.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:a867afe2644dd6ed805c0829c63ffe7720945acaa012caa57e4e5163249f08a0", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/20593003.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/el-anatsui.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay studies the Man’s Cloth series and captions Old Man’s Cloth." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:f49d12e86bd8e006dbcd74f759d1c4b6d0099fdbc40c26bb40405d5944eb8d12", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/20593003.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/old-mans-cloth.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "Named in the image caption as a work by El Anatsui." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:77936a1e4449108b5c6636d578b48a6c07dd5bdb0c967aed7a314087a1376ca0", "subject": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#describes", "object": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20593002", "scope": "version_family", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "source_location": { "kind": "metadata_field", "field": "linked_zenodo_dois", "values": [ "10.5281/zenodo.20593002" ] }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "Exact-edition matching requires the selected DOI in the reviewed page metadata; other matches retain their wider scope." } ], "status": "typed_evidence_projection", "note": "Stable, typed assertions retain source scope and explicit unknown review metadata." }, { "field": "reading_copy", "value": { "id": "20593003", "title": "El Anatsui's Man's Cloth Series: Redemption of Waste as Modern Eucharist", "accession": "MOO-CAT-009", "pdf_url": "../assets/documents/20593003.pdf", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/20593003/files/El%20Anatsui%E2%80%99s%20Man%E2%80%99s%20Cloth%20Series;%20Redemption%20of%20Waste%20as%20Modern%20Eucharist.pdf/content", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20593003", "source_filename": "El Anatsui’s Man’s Cloth Series; Redemption of Waste as Modern Eucharist.pdf", "checksum": "md5:e92667e9ca21506ec2846700a323c12e", "sha256": "2d042e0c2cdc2e8db76802fc763618a76ac27aa7898b9f5049ff1d862be76c85", "bytes": 360669, "page_count": 6, "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "checksum_match": true, "rights": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "role": "Local reading copy; original repository file retained unchanged" }, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/20593003/files/El%20Anatsui%E2%80%99s%20Man%E2%80%99s%20Cloth%20Series;%20Redemption%20of%20Waste%20as%20Modern%20Eucharist.pdf/content", "status": "derived_file_inspection", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "note": "Byte-identical local access copy. Source MD5 was recomputed and matched; SHA-256 and page count were measured from the downloaded PDF. This is not a preservation-deposit claim." }, { "field": "page_count", "value": 6, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/20593003/files/El%20Anatsui%E2%80%99s%20Man%E2%80%99s%20Cloth%20Series;%20Redemption%20of%20Waste%20as%20Modern%20Eucharist.pdf/content", "status": "derived_file_inspection", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "note": "Total PDF file pages measured from the deposited file, including cover and unnumbered pages. Not a claim about printed pagination." } ], "entity_links": [ { "id": "dorian-vale", "label": "Dorian Vale", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "author", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author.", "variants": [ "Vale, Dorian" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "museum-of-one", "label": "Museum of One", "entity_type": "Organization", "relation": "publisher", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record.", "variants": [ "MuseumofOne", "MUSEUM OF ONE" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "el-anatsui", "label": "El Anatsui", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "artist discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "note": "The essay studies the Man’s Cloth series and captions Old Man’s Cloth.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "old-mans-cloth", "label": "Old Man’s Cloth", "entity_type": "Artwork", "relation": "artwork discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "note": "Named in the image caption as a work by El Anatsui.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" } ], "contents": [], "controlled_subjects": [ { "id": "el-anatsui", "label": "El Anatsui", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#el-anatsui", "url": "vocabulary.html#el-anatsui", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:el-anatsui", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Named-subject access point for publications discussing the artist El Anatsui.", "scope_note": "This local heading supports subject discovery. Identity and external authority assertions belong in the separate entity register.", "kind": "named-subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "assemblage", "label": "Assemblage", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#assemblage", "url": "vocabulary.html#assemblage", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:assemblage", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Artistic practice involving the combination of existing objects or materials.", "scope_note": "In this catalogue, used for discussion of El Anatsui’s material constructions; does not classify the deposited PDF as an artwork.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "material-practice" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "material-practice", "label": "Material practice", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#material-practice", "url": "vocabulary.html#material-practice", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:material-practice", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Artistic working with materials and their properties, histories, or uses.", "scope_note": "Use as a broad subject for material processes; techniques such as Assemblage may be assigned separately.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "assemblage", "repetition-and-labour" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "historical-memory", "label": "Historical memory", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#historical-memory", "url": "vocabulary.html#historical-memory", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:historical-memory", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "The retention and mediation of the past through art and its material histories.", "scope_note": "Used for studies linking an artwork’s materials or practices to remembered histories; related to the broader subject Memory.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [ "memory" ], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "genre_terms": [ { "id": "genre-journal-article", "label": "Journal article", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#genre-journal-article", "url": "vocabulary.html#genre-journal-article", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:genre-journal-article", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Journal articles" ], "definition": "A contribution issued as part of a journal or periodical.", "scope_note": "Describes publication genre based on the catalogued source record; peer-review status is a separate question.", "kind": "genre", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "verified_mapping", "external_mappings": [ { "vocabulary": "Getty Art & Architecture Thesaurus", "label": "articles", "uri": "http://vocab.getty.edu/aat/300048715", "source_url": "https://www.getty.edu/vow/AATFullDisplay?find=&logic=AND¬e=&subjectid=300048715", "relation": "broadMatch", "status": "verified", "verified_on": "2026-11-04", "note": "Getty’s articles concept includes contributions to magazines, newspapers, encyclopedias, and other works; journal article is the narrower local genre." } ], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "type", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "vocabulary_version": 4, "description_history": [ { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Source-based catalogue description", "note": "Local description assembled from the identified public repository record and available institutional work record. Source metadata remains separately identifiable.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/20593003", "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Qualified descriptive enrichment", "note": "Local editorial description, arrangement and source-qualified bibliographic context recorded alongside source metadata. Unknown or disputed values remain qualified.", "fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/20593003", "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Automated file checksum and PDF inspection", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Digital reading copy verified", "note": "Downloaded access-copy MD5 matched the source checksum; local SHA-256 and PDF file-page count are recorded in the file manifest. This event does not describe transfer of custody.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/api/records/20593003/files/El%20Anatsui%E2%80%99s%20Man%E2%80%99s%20Cloth%20Series;%20Redemption%20of%20Waste%20as%20Modern%20Eucharist.pdf/content" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Description policy and provenance context adopted", "note": "Responsible service, source repository, local access-copy role, unknown custody and original order, correction route and dated description history made explicit under moo-description-policy-1.0.", "sources": [ "policies.html" ] }, { "event_id": "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Unify graph identities and qualify exported relationships and citations", "note": "Local graph projection now uses one contextual identity per entity, distinguishes work-level institutional matches from selected-edition links, retains title-level ISBN uncertainty, and derives citations from the source title. Typed relation assertions and a versioned validation profile are introduced. No publication date, original source snapshot or PDF changed.", "fields": [ "metadata_profile", "relationship_assertions", "identity", "institutional_match_scope", "citation_projection" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Source-based metadata implementation and regression validation", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication, source review or acquisition date", "sources": [ "metadata/metadata-profile.json" ] }, { "event_id": "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Record inspected public ORCID profile evidence", "note": "The official ORCID public person API returned the credited name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website. This confirms a matching public profile, not independently verified biographical or affiliation claims. Original creator arrays and source snapshots are unchanged.", "fields": [ "orcid_authority" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Read-only official public API inspection", "date_kind": "Local authority review and catalogue description event; not a publication or original creation date", "sources": [ "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ] } ], "record_modified": "2026-11-04", "record_modified_provenance": { "status": "derived_from_description_history", "event_ids": [ "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04" ], "note": "Latest documented local description event; not a publication, repository or source-review date." }, "archival_context": { "description_profile": "moo-description-policy-1.0", "catalogue_snapshot_date": "2026-11-04", "snapshot_note": "Selected catalogue snapshot; not a live repository synchronisation.", "record_category": "Published library and repository material", "reference_code_status": "Stable local catalogue reference; not evidence of an archival acquisition or a previous catalogue accession.", "source_repository": { "name": "Zenodo", "record_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20593003" }, "institutional_context_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "source_metadata_retrieved": "2026-11-04", "source_metadata_retrieval_status": "Documented in catalogue source provenance", "source_snapshot": "source/20593003.json", "source_filenames": [ "El Anatsui’s Man’s Cloth Series; Redemption of Waste as Modern Eucharist.pdf" ], "selection_basis": "Local descriptive selection of publicly published material; public availability does not establish ownership of originals.", "custodial_history": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No donation, physical transfer, acquisition agreement or chain of custody is documented by this catalogue. Zenodo remains the source repository for the deposited version." }, "original_order": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No original archival order is asserted. Current browsing groupings are local editorial arrangement." }, "arrangement": { "status": "local_editorial", "grouping": "Essays & research", "statement": "A browsing grouping, not an original fonds or archival series." }, "responsible_service": { "name": "Museum of One", "service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "website": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "email": "research@museumofone.art" }, "description_method": "Source-based description with automated drafting and metadata assistance. Responsibility for the public catalogue rests with Museum of One; automated assistance does not constitute independent scholarly or curatorial review.", "policy_url": "policies.html", "correction_email": "research@museumofone.art", "access_copy": { "role": "Local digital reading copy of the deposited file", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/20593003/files/El%20Anatsui%E2%80%99s%20Man%E2%80%99s%20Cloth%20Series;%20Redemption%20of%20Waste%20as%20Modern%20Eucharist.pdf/content", "source_filename": "El Anatsui’s Man’s Cloth Series; Redemption of Waste as Modern Eucharist.pdf", "local_path": "assets/documents/20593003.pdf", "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "source_checksum_match": true, "sha256": "2d042e0c2cdc2e8db76802fc763618a76ac27aa7898b9f5049ff1d862be76c85", "statement": "Access copy only; no ownership or physical custody transfer is implied." } }, "description_policy_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "pirr_references": [ { "programme_key": "research-witness-material-memory", "programme_title": "Witness, Material Presence, and Cultural Memory", "programme_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/", "programme_stage": "Continuing research", "registry_url": "research-registry.html#research-witness-material-memory", "identifiers": [ { "scheme": "PIRR project ID", "value": "pir-prj-dd7kt5rw", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/#programme-record" } ], "relation": "Related field essay on material residue, collective making and the continuing consequences of an artwork's presentation.", "relation_note": "Related field essay on material residue, collective making and the continuing consequences of an artwork's presentation.", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/" } ], "pirr_work_identity": { "archive_reference": "MOO-CAT-009", "edition_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.20593003", "zenodo_record_id": "20593003", "identifier_scope": "Publication identity; PIRR identifiers in programme relationships identify research records, not this publication." }, "metadata_origin": "https://archive.museumofone.art", "identity": { "work": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/20593003.html#work", "edition": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20593003", "version_family": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20593002", "catalogue_record": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/20593003.html#catalogue-record" }, "institutional_match_scope": "version_family", "relationship_assertions": [ { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:49b40b66256cd5f3c388244f99aa81436206f0e0c955d141166bc316918b8182", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/20593003.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:68e334abdedda2703924535a6ebba584873542f760e07f04bf5058472679dee4", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/20593003.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:a867afe2644dd6ed805c0829c63ffe7720945acaa012caa57e4e5163249f08a0", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/20593003.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/el-anatsui.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay studies the Man’s Cloth series and captions Old Man’s Cloth." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:f49d12e86bd8e006dbcd74f759d1c4b6d0099fdbc40c26bb40405d5944eb8d12", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/20593003.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/old-mans-cloth.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "Named in the image caption as a work by El Anatsui." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:77936a1e4449108b5c6636d578b48a6c07dd5bdb0c967aed7a314087a1376ca0", "subject": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#describes", "object": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20593002", "scope": "version_family", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/el-anatsuis-mans-cloth-series-redemption-of-waste-as-modern-eucharist/", "source_location": { "kind": "metadata_field", "field": "linked_zenodo_dois", "values": [ "10.5281/zenodo.20593002" ] }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "Exact-edition matching requires the selected DOI in the reviewed page metadata; other matches retain their wider scope." } ], "orcid_authority": { "scheme": "ORCID", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "evidence_urls": [ "https://www.museumofone.art/archives-scholarly-infrastructure/", "https://eprints.rclis.org/47182/", "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ], "access_note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "evidence_receipt": "data/source/authority-review-2026-11-04.json" } }, { "id": "19963428", "accession": "MOO-CAT-010", "title": "The Curator's Shadow: The Unspoken Authorship Behind Neutrality.", "source_title": "The Curator's Shadow: The Unspoken Authorship Behind Neutrality.", "short_title": "The Curator’s Shadow", "author": "Dorian Vale", "creators": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "affiliation": "Museum of One", "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094" }, { "name": "Museum of One", "affiliation": null } ], "doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19963428", "conceptdoi": "10.5281/zenodo.19957859", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19963428", "date": "2025-05-01", "type": "Journal article", "source_resource_type": { "title": "Journal article", "type": "publication", "subtype": "article" }, "version": "", "collection": "Essays & research", "summary": "A study of curatorial authorship and the claim of neutrality. It attends to the choices of sequence, lighting, distance, and omission through which exhibitions structure an encounter.", "subjects": [ "Curatorial practice", "Exhibition design", "Institutional critique", "Authorship" ], "keywords": [ "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Stillmark Theory", "Message-Transfer Theory", "MTT", "Misplacement", "Displacement", "Aesthetic Displacement Theory", "Theory of Misplacement", "Absential Aesthetics", "Witness Aesthetics", "Hauntmark Theory", "Presence-Based Criticism", "Custodianship of Art", "Art as Ontology", "Aesthetic Recursion Theory", "Aesthetic Recursion", "Viewer as Evidence Theory", "Interpretive Load Index (ILI)", "Viewer Displacement Ratio (VDR)", "Ethical Proximity Score (EPS)", "Institutional Alignment Indicator (IAI)", "Epoché Fidelity Index (EFI)", "Phenomenological Phase Alignment Score (PPAS)", "Residue Engagement Restraint Ratio (RERR)", "Quasi-Subject Agency Recognition Index (QSARI)", "Dialectical Circulation Index (DCI)", "Restraint in front of art", "Moral proximity", "Interpretive silence", "Erasure as ethics", "Temporal scarcity", "Silence as method", "Ontology of beauty", "Aesthetic mercy", "Language as violence", "Art encounter ethics", "Epistemology of witness", "Philosophy of Art", "Aesthetics", "Art Theory", "Contemporary Aesthetics", "Comparative Aesthetics", "Phenomenology and Art", "Phenomenology", "Aesthetic Phenomenology", "'Phenomenology of Aesthetic", "post-hermeneutics phenomenology", "Ethics in Art Criticism", "Interpretation and Meaning", "Criticism and Reception Theory", "Epistemology of Art", "Visual Culture Studies", "Dorian Vale", "Founder of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Independent Philosopher of Art", "Post-Aesthetic Critic", "Museum of One", "Art Writer and Theorist", "Aesthetic Philosopher", "Custodian of Witness Aesthetics", "The Doctrine of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "The Custodian's Oath", "The Canon of Witnesses", "Art as TruthArt as Presence", "The Viewer as Evidence", "Interpretation vs. Witnessing", "Erasure as Afterlife", "Language as Custody", "Museum of One Manifesto", "Post-Interpretive Lexicon", "New art criticism movement", "Alternative art criticism", "Ethical art theory", "Criticism beyond interpretation", "Slow looking philosophy", "Quiet philosophy of art", "Radical art restraint", "Witness over interpretationInterpretive Restraint" ], "license": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "files": [ { "name": "The Curator’s Shadow – the unspoken authorship behind neutrality.pdf", "url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19963428/files/The%20Curator%E2%80%99s%20Shadow%20%E2%80%93%20the%20unspoken%20authorship%20behind%20neutrality.pdf/content", "size": 400025, "size_label": "391 KB", "checksum": "md5:60e68ced54424e21fcd7d42f6f3c8bf5", "mimetype": "application/pdf" } ], "institutional_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "corroboration": "Museum of One’s matching publication page confirms Dorian Vale’s authorship and the work’s institutional context. Its repository links and publication dates are retained separately from this selected Zenodo edition. Web-record dates are not treated as dates of the deposited edition. Source review: 4 November 2026.", "discrepancies": [ "The repository also lists organizational or URL-form creator entries. The catalogue displays Dorian Vale as bibliographic author while retaining the deposited creator list separately." ], "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "publisher": "Museum of One", "language": null, "isbn": null, "related_identifiers": [ { "identifier": "https://www.museumofone.art", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://zenodo.org/communities/post-interpretive-criticism", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://osf.io/zhnre/", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://works.hcommons.org/records/xv2j2-g6927", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://philpapers.org/rec/VALPCF-2", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.semanticscholar.org/author/Dorian-Vale/2380743266", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.researchcatalogue.net/profile", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://archive.org/details/the-journal-of-post-interpretive-criticism-vi", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=15tvhjAAAAAJ", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://independent.academia.edu/DorianVale", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.zotero.org/groups/6279725/post-interpretive-criticism", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://core.ac.uk/search/?q=post-interpretive+criticism+dorian+vale", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.base-search.net/Search/Results?lookfor=Post-Interpretive+Criticism", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://commons.datacite.org/?query=Post-Interpretive+Criticism", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://openalex.org/works?filter=title_and_abstract.search:Post-Interpretive+Criticism+Dorian+Vale", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://webarchiveweb.wayback.bac-lac.canada.ca/web/*/https://www.museumofone.art", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" } ], "alternate_identifiers": [ { "identifier": "2819-7232" }, { "identifier": "0000000528819728" }, { "identifier": "0000000528819787" }, { "identifier": "0000000528819744" }, { "identifier": "https://www.museumofone.art" }, { "identifier": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/" } ], "source_references": [ "https://www.museumofone.art", "https://zenodo.org/communities/post-interpretive-criticism", "https://osf.io/zhnre/", "https://works.hcommons.org/records/xv2j2-g6927", "https://philpapers.org/rec/VALPCF-2", "https://www.semanticscholar.org/author/Dorian-Vale/2380743266", "https://archive.org/details/the-journal-of-post-interpretive-criticism-vi", "https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=15tvhjAAAAAJ", "https://independent.academia.edu/DorianVale", "https://www.zotero.org/groups/6279725/post-interpretive-criticism", "https://core.ac.uk/search/?q=post-interpretive+criticism+dorian+vale", "https://www.base-search.net/Search/Results?lookfor=Post-Interpretive+Criticism", "https://commons.datacite.org/?query=Post-Interpretive+Criticism", "https://openalex.org/works?filter=title_and_abstract.search:Post-Interpretive+Criticism+Dorian+Vale", "https://webarchiveweb.wayback.bac-lac.canada.ca/web/*/https://www.museumofone.art", "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/" ], "source_journal": { "title": "Journal of Post-Interpretive Criticism" }, "source_imprint": null, "source_contributors": [], "source_created": "2026-05-02T00:09:25.313806+00:00", "source_modified": "2026-05-02T00:09:25.743533+00:00", "source_description_html": "

The Curator’s Shadow: The Unspoken Authorship Behind Neutrality examines the persistent fiction of curatorial neutrality within modern and contemporary museology, reframing the curator as an invisible yet decisive author of the exhibitionary encounter. Drawing on historical analysis from Enlightenment-era taxonomic displays to contemporary global curatorial practice, the article argues that neutrality operates not as absence, but as a rhetorical and institutional posture that conceals authorship while intensifying its power. Through a Post-Interpretive Criticism framework, the exhibition is reconceived as a spatial text in which sequencing, lighting, distance, and omission function as syntactic and ethical decisions rather than logistical ones.

\n

The study traces how curatorial authority evolved from custodianship of objects to governance of narrative, revealing the exhibition as a structured field of visibility shaped by ideological, architectural, and institutional inheritances, including colonial epistemologies and modernist claims to universality. By analyzing the curatorial role as a form of “moral choreography,” the article foregrounds how exhibition design mediates the viewer’s encounter with trauma, beauty, and knowledge, determining whether the experience produces reverence, detachment, or consumption.

\n

Engaging key figures such as Harald Szeemann, Okwui Enwezor, and Hans-Ulrich Obrist, the article situates the shift from curatorial invisibility to auteurship, identifying the contemporary challenge as neither neutrality nor self-display, but the cultivation of disciplined authorship. Within this context, Post-Interpretive Criticism proposes an ethical reorientation: the curator as witness rather than interpreter, whose task is to preserve the conditions of meaning rather than impose it.

\n

The article further introduces the concept of “curatorial shadow” as a diagnostic lens for evaluating institutional power, where silence, absence, and spatial arrangement are treated as forms of authorship with measurable ethical consequences. It argues for a redefinition of neutrality as ego-restraint rather than objectivity, and for the transformation of exhibition-making into an ethics of care grounded in humility, proximity, and responsibility.

\n

Ultimately, the article positions curatorial practice as a threshold condition—an act of structuring encounter without closure—where the success of an exhibition is measured not by the clarity of its message, but by its capacity to sustain the viewer’s presence without domination. In doing so, it contributes to the broader Post-Interpretive movement by extending its principles beyond criticism into the architecture of display, offering a philosophical and methodological foundation for ethically attuned exhibition-making in the twenty-first century.

\n

Dorian Vale is a chosen pseudonym, not to obscure identity, but to preserve clarity of voice and integrity of message. It creates distance between the writer and the work, allowing the philosophy to stand unclouded by biography. The name exists not to hide, but to honor the seriousness of the task: to speak without spectacle, and to build without needing to be seen. This name is used for all official publications, essays, and theoretical works indexed through DOI-linked repositories including Zenodo, OSF, PhilPapers, and SSRN.

\n

Post-Interpretive Criticism, Stillmark Theory, Message-Transfer Theory, MTT, Misplacement, Displacement, Aesthetic Displacement Theory, Theory of Misplacement, Absential Aesthetics, Witness Aesthetics, Adab for Art, Hauntmark Theory, Spiritual Criticism, Presence-Based Criticism, Custodianship of Art, Art as Ontology, Aesthetic Recursion Theory, Aesthetic Recursion, Viewer as Evidence Theory, Restraint in front of art, Moral proximity, Interpretive silence, Erasure as ethics, Temporal scarcity, Silence as method, Ontology of beauty, Aesthetic mercy, Language as violence, Art encounter ethics, Epistemology of witness, Philosophy of Art, Aesthetics, Art Theory, Contemporary Aesthetics, Comparative Aesthetics, Phenomenology and Art, Ethics in Art Criticism, Interpretation and Meaning, Criticism and Reception Theory, Epistemology of Art, Visual Culture Studies, Dorian Vale, Founder of Post-Interpretive Criticism, Post-Aesthetic Critic, Independent Philosopher of Art, Museum of One, Art Writer and Theorist, Aesthetic Philosopher, Custodian of Witness Aesthetics, Spiritual Aesthetics Movement, The Doctrine of Post-Interpretive Criticism, The Custodian’s Oath, The Canon of Witnesses, Art as Truth, Art as Presence, The Viewer as Evidence, Interpretation vs. Witnessing, Language as Custody, Erasure as Afterlife, Museum of One Manifesto, Alternative art criticism, New art criticism movement, Ethical art theory, Criticism beyond interpretation, Slow looking philosophy, Quiet philosophy of art, Radical art restraint, Witness over interpretation, Interpretive Restraint, The Journal of Post-Interpretive criticism, The Journal of Post-Interpretive criticism ISSN 2819-7232), The Journal of Post-Interpretive Criticism (Q136530009),  Interpretive Load Index (ILI) (Q137709526), Viewer Displacement Ratio (VDR) (Q137709583) , Ethical Proximity Score (EPS) (Q137709600) , Institutional Alignment Indicator (IAI) (Q137709608),

", "provenance": { "repository": "Zenodo REST API response supplied in query.json", "retrieved": "2026-11-04", "editorial_fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "source_snapshot": "source/19963428.json", "institutional_review": "Reviewed page-level title, author and repository links in saved public institutional HTML, 2026-11-04." }, "source_review": "2026-11-04", "relations": [ { "identifier": "https://www.museumofone.art", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://zenodo.org/communities/post-interpretive-criticism", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://osf.io/zhnre/", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://works.hcommons.org/records/xv2j2-g6927", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://philpapers.org/rec/VALPCF-2", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.semanticscholar.org/author/Dorian-Vale/2380743266", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.researchcatalogue.net/profile", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://archive.org/details/the-journal-of-post-interpretive-criticism-vi", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=15tvhjAAAAAJ", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://independent.academia.edu/DorianVale", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.zotero.org/groups/6279725/post-interpretive-criticism", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://core.ac.uk/search/?q=post-interpretive+criticism+dorian+vale", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.base-search.net/Search/Results?lookfor=Post-Interpretive+Criticism", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://commons.datacite.org/?query=Post-Interpretive+Criticism", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://openalex.org/works?filter=title_and_abstract.search:Post-Interpretive+Criticism+Dorian+Vale", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://webarchiveweb.wayback.bac-lac.canada.ca/web/*/https://www.museumofone.art", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" } ], "institutional_metadata": { "title": "The Curator's Shadow: The Unspoken Authorship Behind Neutrality.", "author": "Dorian Vale", "web_publication": "2026-05-01T19:13:04.000Z", "web_updated": "2026-11-03T00:48:27.000Z", "linked_zenodo_dois": [ "10.5281/zenodo.19957859" ], "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/" }, "research_programmes": [ { "title": "Witness, Material Presence, and Cultural Memory", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/", "status": "Continuing research", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "relation": "Related field essay on how exhibition arrangements shape the conditions and responsibilities of witnessing.", "relation_label": "Related field essay on how exhibition arrangements shape the conditions and responsibilities of witnessing." } ], "record_level": "Item", "record_status": "Published source; selected catalogue record", "digital_formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "extent": "1 digital file; 400025 bytes", "medium": "Digital document", "record_reviewed": "2026-11-04", "date_precision": "day", "alternate_titles": [], "digital_extent": { "file_count": 1, "total_bytes": 400025, "formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "checksums": [ { "filename": "The Curator’s Shadow – the unspoken authorship behind neutrality.pdf", "algorithm": "md5", "value": "60e68ced54424e21fcd7d42f6f3c8bf5", "syntax_valid": true, "verification": "source_checksum_transcription; bytes not independently recomputed" } ], "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19963428", "derivation": "File count and total bytes calculated from repository file metadata; MIME inferred from filename when absent." }, "identifier_validation": { "orcid": { "source_value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "ISO 7064 MOD 11-2 checksum only; this is not a live registry verification." }, "isbn": [], "doi": { "source_value": "10.5281/zenodo.19963428", "syntax_valid": true, "note": "Syntax check only; repository snapshot supplies the identifier." } }, "isbn_applicability": "not_supplied", "serial": null, "contributor_roles": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": "Museum of One", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19963428" }, { "name": "Museum of One", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": null, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19963428" } ], "authority_links": [], "metadata_profile": { "name": "Museum of One source-qualified catalogue profile", "version": "3.0.0", "url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/metadata-profile.json", "source_snapshot_preserved": true }, "reading_copy": { "id": "19963428", "title": "The Curator's Shadow: The Unspoken Authorship Behind Neutrality.", "accession": "MOO-CAT-010", "pdf_url": "../assets/documents/19963428.pdf", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19963428/files/The%20Curator%E2%80%99s%20Shadow%20%E2%80%93%20the%20unspoken%20authorship%20behind%20neutrality.pdf/content", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19963428", "source_filename": "The Curator’s Shadow – the unspoken authorship behind neutrality.pdf", "checksum": "md5:60e68ced54424e21fcd7d42f6f3c8bf5", "sha256": "020a9a33056674df08b8ac699ff0976cda380ede6e5b9684368ce8dc53c6be7c", "bytes": 400025, "page_count": 6, "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "checksum_match": true, "rights": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "role": "Local reading copy; original repository file retained unchanged" }, "page_count": 6, "field_assertions": [ { "field": "title", "value": "The Curator's Shadow: The Unspoken Authorship Behind Neutrality.", "status": "catalogue_title", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "note": "Local display title; the deposited title is retained separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_title", "value": "The Curator's Shadow: The Unspoken Authorship Behind Neutrality.", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19963428", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "doi", "value": "10.5281/zenodo.19963428", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19963428", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "date", "value": "2025-05-01", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19963428", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "conceptdoi", "value": "10.5281/zenodo.19957859", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19963428", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "creators", "value": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "affiliation": "Museum of One", "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094" }, { "name": "Museum of One", "affiliation": null } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19963428", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "keywords", "value": [ "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Stillmark Theory", "Message-Transfer Theory", "MTT", "Misplacement", "Displacement", "Aesthetic Displacement Theory", "Theory of Misplacement", "Absential Aesthetics", "Witness Aesthetics", "Hauntmark Theory", "Presence-Based Criticism", "Custodianship of Art", "Art as Ontology", "Aesthetic Recursion Theory", "Aesthetic Recursion", "Viewer as Evidence Theory", "Interpretive Load Index (ILI)", "Viewer Displacement Ratio (VDR)", "Ethical Proximity Score (EPS)", "Institutional Alignment Indicator (IAI)", "Epoché Fidelity Index (EFI)", "Phenomenological Phase Alignment Score (PPAS)", "Residue Engagement Restraint Ratio (RERR)", "Quasi-Subject Agency Recognition Index (QSARI)", "Dialectical Circulation Index (DCI)", "Restraint in front of art", "Moral proximity", "Interpretive silence", "Erasure as ethics", "Temporal scarcity", "Silence as method", "Ontology of beauty", "Aesthetic mercy", "Language as violence", "Art encounter ethics", "Epistemology of witness", "Philosophy of Art", "Aesthetics", "Art Theory", "Contemporary Aesthetics", "Comparative Aesthetics", "Phenomenology and Art", "Phenomenology", "Aesthetic Phenomenology", "'Phenomenology of Aesthetic", "post-hermeneutics phenomenology", "Ethics in Art Criticism", "Interpretation and Meaning", "Criticism and Reception Theory", "Epistemology of Art", "Visual Culture Studies", "Dorian Vale", "Founder of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Independent Philosopher of Art", "Post-Aesthetic Critic", "Museum of One", "Art Writer and Theorist", "Aesthetic Philosopher", "Custodian of Witness Aesthetics", "The Doctrine of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "The Custodian's Oath", "The Canon of Witnesses", "Art as TruthArt as Presence", "The Viewer as Evidence", "Interpretation vs. Witnessing", "Erasure as Afterlife", "Language as Custody", "Museum of One Manifesto", "Post-Interpretive Lexicon", "New art criticism movement", "Alternative art criticism", "Ethical art theory", "Criticism beyond interpretation", "Slow looking philosophy", "Quiet philosophy of art", "Radical art restraint", "Witness over interpretationInterpretive Restraint" ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19963428", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "license", "value": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19963428", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "files", "value": [ { "name": "The Curator’s Shadow – the unspoken authorship behind neutrality.pdf", "url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19963428/files/The%20Curator%E2%80%99s%20Shadow%20%E2%80%93%20the%20unspoken%20authorship%20behind%20neutrality.pdf/content", "size": 400025, "size_label": "391 KB", "checksum": "md5:60e68ced54424e21fcd7d42f6f3c8bf5", "mimetype": "application/pdf" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19963428", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_created", "value": "2026-05-02T00:09:25.313806+00:00", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19963428", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_modified", "value": "2026-05-02T00:09:25.743533+00:00", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19963428", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "record_modified", "value": "2026-11-04", "status": "derived_from_description_history", "note": "Latest documented local description event; not a publication, repository or source-review date.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_review", "value": "2026-11-04", "status": "catalogue_source_review", "note": "Review of descriptive sources; not the creation or modification date of the work or repository record.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "author", "value": "Dorian Vale", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "note": "Institutional responsibility statement; original repository creator roles remain separate.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "publisher", "value": "Museum of One", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "note": "Institutional responsibility statement; original repository creator roles remain separate.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "orcid", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "source_linked_identifier", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "note": "Creator identifier supplied by the linked sources; no affiliation or endorsement is inferred.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "orcid_authority", "value": { "scheme": "ORCID", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "evidence_urls": [ "https://www.museumofone.art/archives-scholarly-infrastructure/", "https://eprints.rclis.org/47182/", "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ], "access_note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "evidence_receipt": "data/source/authority-review-2026-11-04.json" }, "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "source_url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "summary", "value": "A study of curatorial authorship and the claim of neutrality. It attends to the choices of sequence, lighting, distance, and omission through which exhibitions structure an encounter.", "status": "editorial_enrichment", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "note": "Catalogue-editor summary based on the linked work; not an original publisher abstract.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "subjects", "value": [ "Curatorial practice", "Exhibition design", "Institutional critique", "Authorship" ], "status": "editorial_enrichment", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "note": "Local discovery terms; no controlled-vocabulary assignment is claimed.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "collection", "value": "Essays & research", "status": "editorial_grouping", "note": "A local browsing collection, not an original repository collection.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "corroboration", "value": "Museum of One’s matching publication page confirms Dorian Vale’s authorship and the work’s institutional context. Its repository links and publication dates are retained separately from this selected Zenodo edition. Web-record dates are not treated as dates of the deposited edition. Source review: 4 November 2026.", "status": "catalogue_review_note", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "discrepancies", "value": [ "The repository also lists organizational or URL-form creator entries. The catalogue displays Dorian Vale as bibliographic author while retaining the deposited creator list separately." ], "status": "catalogue_review_note", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "date_precision", "value": "day", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19963428", "note": "Precision reported exactly as supplied; missing month or day is not filled.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "medium", "value": "Digital document", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19963428", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "digital_formats", "value": [ "application/pdf" ], "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19963428", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "extent", "value": "1 digital file; 400025 bytes", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19963428", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "digital_extent", "value": { "file_count": 1, "total_bytes": 400025, "formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "checksums": [ { "filename": "The Curator’s Shadow – the unspoken authorship behind neutrality.pdf", "algorithm": "md5", "value": "60e68ced54424e21fcd7d42f6f3c8bf5", "syntax_valid": true, "verification": "source_checksum_transcription; bytes not independently recomputed" } ], "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19963428", "derivation": "File count and total bytes calculated from repository file metadata; MIME inferred from filename when absent." }, "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19963428", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "identifier_validation", "value": { "orcid": { "source_value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "ISO 7064 MOD 11-2 checksum only; this is not a live registry verification." }, "isbn": [], "doi": { "source_value": "10.5281/zenodo.19963428", "syntax_valid": true, "note": "Syntax check only; repository snapshot supplies the identifier." } }, "status": "local_syntax_validation", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19963428", "note": "Checksum/syntax validation does not verify registration, assignment or edition applicability.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "contributor_roles", "value": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": "Museum of One", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19963428" }, { "name": "Museum of One", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": null, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19963428" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19963428", "note": "Creator and contributor roles are transcribed, not inferred from names or affiliations.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "research_programme:https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/", "value": { "title": "Witness, Material Presence, and Cultural Memory", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/", "status": "Continuing research", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "relation": "Related field essay on how exhibition arrangements shape the conditions and responsibilities of witnessing.", "relation_label": "Related field essay on how exhibition arrangements shape the conditions and responsibilities of witnessing." }, "status": "institutional_work_relationship", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "note": "Programme relationship and stage follow the work-specific institutional badge; publication does not imply a completed programme or collaboration.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "entity_link:dorian-vale:author", "value": { "id": "dorian-vale", "label": "Dorian Vale", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "author", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author.", "variants": [ "Vale, Dorian" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:b1fc0214d7ba6bd6dec4c30d6becdc507e76ad5feff110efeca30651b8992565", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19963428.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." } }, { "field": "entity_link:museum-of-one:publisher", "value": { "id": "museum-of-one", "label": "Museum of One", "entity_type": "Organization", "relation": "publisher", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record.", "variants": [ "MuseumofOne", "MUSEUM OF ONE" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:8e59c0c3c5e7f89055ffb62d584b2be914d50ea6815ed0a5482992868fdd543b", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19963428.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." } }, { "field": "entity_link:harald-szeemann:curator discussed", "value": { "id": "harald-szeemann", "label": "Harald Szeemann", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "curator discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "note": "The essay connects Szeemann with When Attitudes Become Form; this is critical discussion, not an institutional affiliation.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:52ce0ee6f3de295963f6146d4f6b8e53c8f52b62dff1cd6db4e2e3d6ebd51444", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19963428.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-curator", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/harald-szeemann.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay connects Szeemann with When Attitudes Become Form; this is critical discussion, not an institutional affiliation." } }, { "field": "entity_link:okwui-enwezor:curator discussed", "value": { "id": "okwui-enwezor", "label": "Okwui Enwezor", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "curator discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "note": "The essay connects Enwezor with Documenta 11; this is critical discussion, not an institutional affiliation.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:6d9d6ff8b15d09af97a340f0a6768679501c1d772502d0ebc2c6501563ceffcb", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19963428.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-curator", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/okwui-enwezor.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay connects Enwezor with Documenta 11; this is critical discussion, not an institutional affiliation." } }, { "field": "entity_link:when-attitudes-become-form:exhibition discussed", "value": { "id": "when-attitudes-become-form", "label": "When Attitudes Become Form", "entity_type": "Exhibition", "relation": "exhibition discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "note": "The essay names this exhibition in its discussion of Harald Szeemann and curatorial authorship.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:ae27631460b3184cbbe509b4569e54a6af92305e92b7785990e042dac530358a", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19963428.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-exhibition", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/when-attitudes-become-form.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay names this exhibition in its discussion of Harald Szeemann and curatorial authorship." } }, { "field": "entity_link:documenta-11:exhibition discussed", "value": { "id": "documenta-11", "label": "Documenta 11", "entity_type": "Exhibition", "relation": "exhibition discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "note": "The essay names this exhibition in its discussion of Okwui Enwezor and curatorial context.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:faa993379ffc2be27ec67d700b7310dfed04a6b119cda954ef0504094d0c4f91", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19963428.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-exhibition", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/documenta-11.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay names this exhibition in its discussion of Okwui Enwezor and curatorial context." } }, { "field": "controlled_subjects", "value": [ { "id": "curatorial-practice", "label": "Curatorial practice", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#curatorial-practice", "url": "vocabulary.html#curatorial-practice", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:curatorial-practice", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "The selection, organisation, and presentation of art in exhibitions.", "scope_note": "Use for inquiry into curatorial decisions and their effects on an encounter with art.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [ "exhibition-design" ], "related": [ "institutional-critique" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "exhibition-design", "label": "Exhibition design", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#exhibition-design", "url": "vocabulary.html#exhibition-design", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:exhibition-design", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "The spatial and material arrangements through which exhibitions present works.", "scope_note": "Use for analysis of sequence, lighting, distance, and other presentation decisions.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [ "curatorial-practice" ], "narrower": [], "related": [ "spatial-experience" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "institutional-critique", "label": "Institutional critique", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#institutional-critique", "url": "vocabulary.html#institutional-critique", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:institutional-critique", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Critical examination of the authority and practices of art institutions.", "scope_note": "Use as a subject heading for inquiry into institutional framing; it does not classify a deposited essay as an artwork in that tradition.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "curatorial-practice" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "authorship", "label": "Authorship", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#authorship", "url": "vocabulary.html#authorship", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:authorship", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "The attribution and exercise of creative or intellectual agency.", "scope_note": "Use for discussion of curatorial or critical authorship; named creators belong in agent authority records.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Local preferred terms with definitions and synonyms. External alignment is scoped in the vocabulary register." }, { "field": "genre_terms", "value": [ { "id": "genre-journal-article", "label": "Journal article", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#genre-journal-article", "url": "vocabulary.html#genre-journal-article", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:genre-journal-article", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Journal articles" ], "definition": "A contribution issued as part of a journal or periodical.", "scope_note": "Describes publication genre based on the catalogued source record; peer-review status is a separate question.", "kind": "genre", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "verified_mapping", "external_mappings": [ { "vocabulary": "Getty Art & Architecture Thesaurus", "label": "articles", "uri": "http://vocab.getty.edu/aat/300048715", "source_url": "https://www.getty.edu/vow/AATFullDisplay?find=&logic=AND¬e=&subjectid=300048715", "relation": "broadMatch", "status": "verified", "verified_on": "2026-11-04", "note": "Getty’s articles concept includes contributions to magazines, newspapers, encyclopedias, and other works; journal article is the narrower local genre." } ], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "type", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Local resource-genre classification. Digital file format is recorded separately." }, { "field": "archival_context", "value": { "description_profile": "moo-description-policy-1.0", "catalogue_snapshot_date": "2026-11-04", "snapshot_note": "Selected catalogue snapshot; not a live repository synchronisation.", "record_category": "Published library and repository material", "reference_code_status": "Stable local catalogue reference; not evidence of an archival acquisition or a previous catalogue accession.", "source_repository": { "name": "Zenodo", "record_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19963428" }, "institutional_context_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "source_metadata_retrieved": "2026-11-04", "source_metadata_retrieval_status": "Documented in catalogue source provenance", "source_snapshot": "source/19963428.json", "source_filenames": [ "The Curator’s Shadow – the unspoken authorship behind neutrality.pdf" ], "selection_basis": "Local descriptive selection of publicly published material; public availability does not establish ownership of originals.", "custodial_history": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No donation, physical transfer, acquisition agreement or chain of custody is documented by this catalogue. Zenodo remains the source repository for the deposited version." }, "original_order": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No original archival order is asserted. Current browsing groupings are local editorial arrangement." }, "arrangement": { "status": "local_editorial", "grouping": "Essays & research", "statement": "A browsing grouping, not an original fonds or archival series." }, "responsible_service": { "name": "Museum of One", "service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "website": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "email": "research@museumofone.art" }, "description_method": "Source-based description with automated drafting and metadata assistance. Responsibility for the public catalogue rests with Museum of One; automated assistance does not constitute independent scholarly or curatorial review.", "policy_url": "policies.html", "correction_email": "research@museumofone.art", "access_copy": { "role": "Local digital reading copy of the deposited file", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19963428/files/The%20Curator%E2%80%99s%20Shadow%20%E2%80%93%20the%20unspoken%20authorship%20behind%20neutrality.pdf/content", "source_filename": "The Curator’s Shadow – the unspoken authorship behind neutrality.pdf", "local_path": "assets/documents/19963428.pdf", "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "source_checksum_match": true, "sha256": "020a9a33056674df08b8ac699ff0976cda380ede6e5b9684368ce8dc53c6be7c", "statement": "Access copy only; no ownership or physical custody transfer is implied." } }, "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Provenance records what is documented and leaves unknown custody and original order explicit." }, { "field": "description_history", "value": [ { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Source-based catalogue description", "note": "Local description assembled from the identified public repository record and available institutional work record. Source metadata remains separately identifiable.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/19963428", "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Qualified descriptive enrichment", "note": "Local editorial description, arrangement and source-qualified bibliographic context recorded alongside source metadata. Unknown or disputed values remain qualified.", "fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/19963428", "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Automated file checksum and PDF inspection", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Digital reading copy verified", "note": "Downloaded access-copy MD5 matched the source checksum; local SHA-256 and PDF file-page count are recorded in the file manifest. This event does not describe transfer of custody.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19963428/files/The%20Curator%E2%80%99s%20Shadow%20%E2%80%93%20the%20unspoken%20authorship%20behind%20neutrality.pdf/content" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Description policy and provenance context adopted", "note": "Responsible service, source repository, local access-copy role, unknown custody and original order, correction route and dated description history made explicit under moo-description-policy-1.0.", "sources": [ "policies.html" ] }, { "event_id": "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Unify graph identities and qualify exported relationships and citations", "note": "Local graph projection now uses one contextual identity per entity, distinguishes work-level institutional matches from selected-edition links, retains title-level ISBN uncertainty, and derives citations from the source title. Typed relation assertions and a versioned validation profile are introduced. No publication date, original source snapshot or PDF changed.", "fields": [ "metadata_profile", "relationship_assertions", "identity", "institutional_match_scope", "citation_projection" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Source-based metadata implementation and regression validation", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication, source review or acquisition date", "sources": [ "metadata/metadata-profile.json" ] }, { "event_id": "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Record inspected public ORCID profile evidence", "note": "The official ORCID public person API returned the credited name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website. This confirms a matching public profile, not independently verified biographical or affiliation claims. Original creator arrays and source snapshots are unchanged.", "fields": [ "orcid_authority" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Read-only official public API inspection", "date_kind": "Local authority review and catalogue description event; not a publication or original creation date", "sources": [ "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ] } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Catalogue description events; these are not work publication dates or acquisition dates." }, { "field": "pirr_references", "value": [ { "programme_key": "research-witness-material-memory", "programme_title": "Witness, Material Presence, and Cultural Memory", "programme_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/", "programme_stage": "Continuing research", "registry_url": "research-registry.html#research-witness-material-memory", "identifiers": [ { "scheme": "PIRR project ID", "value": "pir-prj-dd7kt5rw", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/#programme-record" } ], "relation": "Related field essay on how exhibition arrangements shape the conditions and responsibilities of witnessing.", "relation_note": "Related field essay on how exhibition arrangements shape the conditions and responsibilities of witnessing.", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/" } ], "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "PIRR project IDs and programme references identify research records, not publication versions or independent chapter deposits." }, { "field": "relationship_assertions", "value": [ { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:b1fc0214d7ba6bd6dec4c30d6becdc507e76ad5feff110efeca30651b8992565", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19963428.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:8e59c0c3c5e7f89055ffb62d584b2be914d50ea6815ed0a5482992868fdd543b", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19963428.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:52ce0ee6f3de295963f6146d4f6b8e53c8f52b62dff1cd6db4e2e3d6ebd51444", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19963428.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-curator", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/harald-szeemann.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay connects Szeemann with When Attitudes Become Form; this is critical discussion, not an institutional affiliation." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:6d9d6ff8b15d09af97a340f0a6768679501c1d772502d0ebc2c6501563ceffcb", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19963428.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-curator", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/okwui-enwezor.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay connects Enwezor with Documenta 11; this is critical discussion, not an institutional affiliation." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:ae27631460b3184cbbe509b4569e54a6af92305e92b7785990e042dac530358a", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19963428.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-exhibition", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/when-attitudes-become-form.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay names this exhibition in its discussion of Harald Szeemann and curatorial authorship." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:faa993379ffc2be27ec67d700b7310dfed04a6b119cda954ef0504094d0c4f91", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19963428.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-exhibition", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/documenta-11.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay names this exhibition in its discussion of Okwui Enwezor and curatorial context." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:b3e7685c393201e94e6d0330b72223f6ba6c78a86817a98c68547204026685f0", "subject": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#describes", "object": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19957859", "scope": "version_family", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "source_location": { "kind": "metadata_field", "field": "linked_zenodo_dois", "values": [ "10.5281/zenodo.19957859" ] }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "Exact-edition matching requires the selected DOI in the reviewed page metadata; other matches retain their wider scope." } ], "status": "typed_evidence_projection", "note": "Stable, typed assertions retain source scope and explicit unknown review metadata." }, { "field": "reading_copy", "value": { "id": "19963428", "title": "The Curator's Shadow: The Unspoken Authorship Behind Neutrality.", "accession": "MOO-CAT-010", "pdf_url": "../assets/documents/19963428.pdf", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19963428/files/The%20Curator%E2%80%99s%20Shadow%20%E2%80%93%20the%20unspoken%20authorship%20behind%20neutrality.pdf/content", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19963428", "source_filename": "The Curator’s Shadow – the unspoken authorship behind neutrality.pdf", "checksum": "md5:60e68ced54424e21fcd7d42f6f3c8bf5", "sha256": "020a9a33056674df08b8ac699ff0976cda380ede6e5b9684368ce8dc53c6be7c", "bytes": 400025, "page_count": 6, "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "checksum_match": true, "rights": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "role": "Local reading copy; original repository file retained unchanged" }, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19963428/files/The%20Curator%E2%80%99s%20Shadow%20%E2%80%93%20the%20unspoken%20authorship%20behind%20neutrality.pdf/content", "status": "derived_file_inspection", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "note": "Byte-identical local access copy. Source MD5 was recomputed and matched; SHA-256 and page count were measured from the downloaded PDF. This is not a preservation-deposit claim." }, { "field": "page_count", "value": 6, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19963428/files/The%20Curator%E2%80%99s%20Shadow%20%E2%80%93%20the%20unspoken%20authorship%20behind%20neutrality.pdf/content", "status": "derived_file_inspection", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "note": "Total PDF file pages measured from the deposited file, including cover and unnumbered pages. Not a claim about printed pagination." } ], "entity_links": [ { "id": "dorian-vale", "label": "Dorian Vale", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "author", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author.", "variants": [ "Vale, Dorian" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "museum-of-one", "label": "Museum of One", "entity_type": "Organization", "relation": "publisher", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record.", "variants": [ "MuseumofOne", "MUSEUM OF ONE" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "harald-szeemann", "label": "Harald Szeemann", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "curator discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "note": "The essay connects Szeemann with When Attitudes Become Form; this is critical discussion, not an institutional affiliation.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "okwui-enwezor", "label": "Okwui Enwezor", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "curator discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "note": "The essay connects Enwezor with Documenta 11; this is critical discussion, not an institutional affiliation.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "when-attitudes-become-form", "label": "When Attitudes Become Form", "entity_type": "Exhibition", "relation": "exhibition discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "note": "The essay names this exhibition in its discussion of Harald Szeemann and curatorial authorship.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "documenta-11", "label": "Documenta 11", "entity_type": "Exhibition", "relation": "exhibition discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "note": "The essay names this exhibition in its discussion of Okwui Enwezor and curatorial context.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" } ], "contents": [], "controlled_subjects": [ { "id": "curatorial-practice", "label": "Curatorial practice", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#curatorial-practice", "url": "vocabulary.html#curatorial-practice", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:curatorial-practice", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "The selection, organisation, and presentation of art in exhibitions.", "scope_note": "Use for inquiry into curatorial decisions and their effects on an encounter with art.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [ "exhibition-design" ], "related": [ "institutional-critique" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "exhibition-design", "label": "Exhibition design", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#exhibition-design", "url": "vocabulary.html#exhibition-design", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:exhibition-design", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "The spatial and material arrangements through which exhibitions present works.", "scope_note": "Use for analysis of sequence, lighting, distance, and other presentation decisions.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [ "curatorial-practice" ], "narrower": [], "related": [ "spatial-experience" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "institutional-critique", "label": "Institutional critique", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#institutional-critique", "url": "vocabulary.html#institutional-critique", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:institutional-critique", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Critical examination of the authority and practices of art institutions.", "scope_note": "Use as a subject heading for inquiry into institutional framing; it does not classify a deposited essay as an artwork in that tradition.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "curatorial-practice" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "authorship", "label": "Authorship", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#authorship", "url": "vocabulary.html#authorship", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:authorship", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "The attribution and exercise of creative or intellectual agency.", "scope_note": "Use for discussion of curatorial or critical authorship; named creators belong in agent authority records.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "genre_terms": [ { "id": "genre-journal-article", "label": "Journal article", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#genre-journal-article", "url": "vocabulary.html#genre-journal-article", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:genre-journal-article", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Journal articles" ], "definition": "A contribution issued as part of a journal or periodical.", "scope_note": "Describes publication genre based on the catalogued source record; peer-review status is a separate question.", "kind": "genre", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "verified_mapping", "external_mappings": [ { "vocabulary": "Getty Art & Architecture Thesaurus", "label": "articles", "uri": "http://vocab.getty.edu/aat/300048715", "source_url": "https://www.getty.edu/vow/AATFullDisplay?find=&logic=AND¬e=&subjectid=300048715", "relation": "broadMatch", "status": "verified", "verified_on": "2026-11-04", "note": "Getty’s articles concept includes contributions to magazines, newspapers, encyclopedias, and other works; journal article is the narrower local genre." } ], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "type", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "vocabulary_version": 4, "description_history": [ { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Source-based catalogue description", "note": "Local description assembled from the identified public repository record and available institutional work record. Source metadata remains separately identifiable.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/19963428", "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Qualified descriptive enrichment", "note": "Local editorial description, arrangement and source-qualified bibliographic context recorded alongside source metadata. Unknown or disputed values remain qualified.", "fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/19963428", "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Automated file checksum and PDF inspection", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Digital reading copy verified", "note": "Downloaded access-copy MD5 matched the source checksum; local SHA-256 and PDF file-page count are recorded in the file manifest. This event does not describe transfer of custody.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19963428/files/The%20Curator%E2%80%99s%20Shadow%20%E2%80%93%20the%20unspoken%20authorship%20behind%20neutrality.pdf/content" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Description policy and provenance context adopted", "note": "Responsible service, source repository, local access-copy role, unknown custody and original order, correction route and dated description history made explicit under moo-description-policy-1.0.", "sources": [ "policies.html" ] }, { "event_id": "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Unify graph identities and qualify exported relationships and citations", "note": "Local graph projection now uses one contextual identity per entity, distinguishes work-level institutional matches from selected-edition links, retains title-level ISBN uncertainty, and derives citations from the source title. Typed relation assertions and a versioned validation profile are introduced. No publication date, original source snapshot or PDF changed.", "fields": [ "metadata_profile", "relationship_assertions", "identity", "institutional_match_scope", "citation_projection" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Source-based metadata implementation and regression validation", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication, source review or acquisition date", "sources": [ "metadata/metadata-profile.json" ] }, { "event_id": "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Record inspected public ORCID profile evidence", "note": "The official ORCID public person API returned the credited name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website. This confirms a matching public profile, not independently verified biographical or affiliation claims. Original creator arrays and source snapshots are unchanged.", "fields": [ "orcid_authority" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Read-only official public API inspection", "date_kind": "Local authority review and catalogue description event; not a publication or original creation date", "sources": [ "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ] } ], "record_modified": "2026-11-04", "record_modified_provenance": { "status": "derived_from_description_history", "event_ids": [ "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04" ], "note": "Latest documented local description event; not a publication, repository or source-review date." }, "archival_context": { "description_profile": "moo-description-policy-1.0", "catalogue_snapshot_date": "2026-11-04", "snapshot_note": "Selected catalogue snapshot; not a live repository synchronisation.", "record_category": "Published library and repository material", "reference_code_status": "Stable local catalogue reference; not evidence of an archival acquisition or a previous catalogue accession.", "source_repository": { "name": "Zenodo", "record_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19963428" }, "institutional_context_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "source_metadata_retrieved": "2026-11-04", "source_metadata_retrieval_status": "Documented in catalogue source provenance", "source_snapshot": "source/19963428.json", "source_filenames": [ "The Curator’s Shadow – the unspoken authorship behind neutrality.pdf" ], "selection_basis": "Local descriptive selection of publicly published material; public availability does not establish ownership of originals.", "custodial_history": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No donation, physical transfer, acquisition agreement or chain of custody is documented by this catalogue. Zenodo remains the source repository for the deposited version." }, "original_order": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No original archival order is asserted. Current browsing groupings are local editorial arrangement." }, "arrangement": { "status": "local_editorial", "grouping": "Essays & research", "statement": "A browsing grouping, not an original fonds or archival series." }, "responsible_service": { "name": "Museum of One", "service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "website": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "email": "research@museumofone.art" }, "description_method": "Source-based description with automated drafting and metadata assistance. Responsibility for the public catalogue rests with Museum of One; automated assistance does not constitute independent scholarly or curatorial review.", "policy_url": "policies.html", "correction_email": "research@museumofone.art", "access_copy": { "role": "Local digital reading copy of the deposited file", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19963428/files/The%20Curator%E2%80%99s%20Shadow%20%E2%80%93%20the%20unspoken%20authorship%20behind%20neutrality.pdf/content", "source_filename": "The Curator’s Shadow – the unspoken authorship behind neutrality.pdf", "local_path": "assets/documents/19963428.pdf", "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "source_checksum_match": true, "sha256": "020a9a33056674df08b8ac699ff0976cda380ede6e5b9684368ce8dc53c6be7c", "statement": "Access copy only; no ownership or physical custody transfer is implied." } }, "description_policy_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "pirr_references": [ { "programme_key": "research-witness-material-memory", "programme_title": "Witness, Material Presence, and Cultural Memory", "programme_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/", "programme_stage": "Continuing research", "registry_url": "research-registry.html#research-witness-material-memory", "identifiers": [ { "scheme": "PIRR project ID", "value": "pir-prj-dd7kt5rw", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-witness-material-memory/#programme-record" } ], "relation": "Related field essay on how exhibition arrangements shape the conditions and responsibilities of witnessing.", "relation_note": "Related field essay on how exhibition arrangements shape the conditions and responsibilities of witnessing.", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/" } ], "pirr_work_identity": { "archive_reference": "MOO-CAT-010", "edition_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19963428", "zenodo_record_id": "19963428", "identifier_scope": "Publication identity; PIRR identifiers in programme relationships identify research records, not this publication." }, "metadata_origin": "https://archive.museumofone.art", "identity": { "work": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19963428.html#work", "edition": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19963428", "version_family": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19957859", "catalogue_record": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19963428.html#catalogue-record" }, "institutional_match_scope": "version_family", "relationship_assertions": [ { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:b1fc0214d7ba6bd6dec4c30d6becdc507e76ad5feff110efeca30651b8992565", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19963428.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:8e59c0c3c5e7f89055ffb62d584b2be914d50ea6815ed0a5482992868fdd543b", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19963428.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:52ce0ee6f3de295963f6146d4f6b8e53c8f52b62dff1cd6db4e2e3d6ebd51444", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19963428.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-curator", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/harald-szeemann.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay connects Szeemann with When Attitudes Become Form; this is critical discussion, not an institutional affiliation." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:6d9d6ff8b15d09af97a340f0a6768679501c1d772502d0ebc2c6501563ceffcb", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19963428.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-curator", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/okwui-enwezor.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay connects Enwezor with Documenta 11; this is critical discussion, not an institutional affiliation." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:ae27631460b3184cbbe509b4569e54a6af92305e92b7785990e042dac530358a", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19963428.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-exhibition", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/when-attitudes-become-form.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay names this exhibition in its discussion of Harald Szeemann and curatorial authorship." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:faa993379ffc2be27ec67d700b7310dfed04a6b119cda954ef0504094d0c4f91", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19963428.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-exhibition", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/documenta-11.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay names this exhibition in its discussion of Okwui Enwezor and curatorial context." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:b3e7685c393201e94e6d0330b72223f6ba6c78a86817a98c68547204026685f0", "subject": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#describes", "object": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19957859", "scope": "version_family", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-curators-shadow-the-unspoken-authorship-behind-neutrality/", "source_location": { "kind": "metadata_field", "field": "linked_zenodo_dois", "values": [ "10.5281/zenodo.19957859" ] }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "Exact-edition matching requires the selected DOI in the reviewed page metadata; other matches retain their wider scope." } ], "orcid_authority": { "scheme": "ORCID", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "evidence_urls": [ "https://www.museumofone.art/archives-scholarly-infrastructure/", "https://eprints.rclis.org/47182/", "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ], "access_note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "evidence_receipt": "data/source/authority-review-2026-11-04.json" } }, { "id": "20100136", "accession": "MOO-CAT-011", "title": "Diagnostics Without Possession: An Operational Manual for Post-Interpretive Criticism (Operational reference for inter-rater reliability)", "source_title": "Diagnostics Without Possession: An Operational Manual for Post-Interpretive Criticism (Operational reference for inter-rater reliability)", "short_title": "Diagnostics Without Possession", "author": "Dorian Vale", "creators": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "affiliation": "Museum of One", "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094" }, { "name": "Museum of One", "affiliation": null } ], "doi": "10.5281/zenodo.20100136", "conceptdoi": "10.5281/zenodo.20099594", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136", "date": "2026-02-09", "type": "Dataset", "source_resource_type": { "title": "Dataset", "type": "dataset" }, "version": "", "collection": "Theory & treatises", "summary": "An operational manual for applying the diagnostic indices of Post-Interpretive Criticism across coding, comparative study, and self-audit. Procedures for testing agreement are distinct from completed reliability findings.", "subjects": [ "Research methods", "Critical language", "Coding procedures", "Inter-rater reliability" ], "keywords": [ "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Stillmark Theory", "Message-Transfer Theory", "Aesthetic Displacement Theory", "Theory of Misplacement", "Absential Aesthetics", "Witness Aesthetics", "Hauntmark Theory", "Presence-Based Criticism", "Custodianship of Art", "Art as Ontology", "Aesthetic Recursion Theory", "Aesthetic Recursion", "Viewer as Evidence Theory", "Interpretive Load Index (ILI)", "Viewer Displacement Ratio (VDR)", "Ethical Proximity Score (EPS)", "Institutional Alignment Indicator (IAI)", "Epoché Fidelity Index (EFI)", "Phenomenological Phase Alignment Score (PPAS)", "Residue Engagement Restraint Ratio (RERR)", "Quasi-Subject Agency Recognition Index (QSARI)", "Dialectical Circulation Index (DCI)", "Restraint in front of art", "Moral proximity", "Interpretive silence", "Erasure as ethics", "Temporal scarcity", "Silence as method", "Ontology of beauty", "Aesthetic mercy", "Language as violence", "Art encounter ethics", "Epistemology of witness", "Philosophy of Art", "Aesthetics", "Art TheoryContemporary Aesthetics", "Comparative Aesthetics", "Phenomenology and Art", "Aesthetic Phenomenology", "Phenomenology", "Phenomenology of Aesthetic", "post-hermeneutics phenomenology", "Ethics in Art Criticism", "Interpretation and Meaning", "Criticism and Reception Theory", "Epistemology of Art", "Visual Culture Studies", "Dorian Vale", "Founder of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Post-Aesthetic Critic", "Independent Philosopher of Art", "Museum of One", "Art Writer and Theorist", "Aesthetic Philosopher", "Custodian of Witness Aesthetics", "The Doctrine of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "The Custodian's Oath", "The Canon of Witnesses", "Art as Truth", "Art as Presence", "The Viewer as Evidence", "Interpretation vs. Witnessing", "Language as Custody", "Erasure as Afterlife", "Museum of One Manifesto", "Post-Interpretive Lexicon", "Alternative art criticism", "New art criticism movement", "Ethical art theory", "Criticism beyond interpretation", "\\Slow looking philosophy", "Quiet philosophy of art", "Radical art restraint", "Interpretive Restraint" ], "license": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "files": [ { "name": "Diagnostics Without Possession - An Operational Manual for Post-Interpretive Criticism.pdf", "url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/20100136/files/Diagnostics%20Without%20Possession%20-%20An%20Operational%20Manual%20for%20Post-Interpretive%20Criticism.pdf/content", "size": 525965, "size_label": "514 KB", "checksum": "md5:2dc93b7125bb645e67fba4b0f54696e5", "mimetype": "application/pdf" } ], "institutional_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/", "corroboration": "Museum of One’s matching publication page confirms Dorian Vale’s authorship and the work’s institutional context. Its repository links and publication dates are retained separately from this selected Zenodo edition. Web-record dates are not treated as dates of the deposited edition. Source review: 4 November 2026.", "discrepancies": [ "The repository also lists organizational or URL-form creator entries. The catalogue displays Dorian Vale as bibliographic author while retaining the deposited creator list separately.", "Zenodo classifies this deposited operational manual as a dataset. That repository classification is retained; the editorial collection describes its methodological function." ], "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "publisher": "Museum of One", "language": null, "isbn": null, "related_identifiers": [ { "identifier": "https://www.museumofone.art", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://zenodo.org/communities/post-interpretive-criticism", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://osf.io/zhnre/", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://works.hcommons.org/records/xv2j2-g6927", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://philpapers.org/rec/VALPCF-2", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.semanticscholar.org/author/Dorian-Vale/2380743266", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.researchcatalogue.net/profile", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://archive.org/details/the-journal-of-post-interpretive-criticism-vi", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=15tvhjAAAAAJ", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://independent.academia.edu/DorianVale", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.zotero.org/groups/6279725/post-interpretive-criticism", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://core.ac.uk/search/?q=post-interpretive+criticism+dorian+vale", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.base-search.net/Search/Results?lookfor=Post-Interpretive+Criticism", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://commons.datacite.org/?query=Post-Interpretive+Criticism", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://openalex.org/works?filter=title_and_abstract.search:Post-Interpretive+Criticism+Dorian+Vale", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://webarchiveweb.wayback.bac-lac.canada.ca/web/*/https://www.museumofone.art", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" } ], "alternate_identifiers": [ { "identifier": "2819-7232" }, { "identifier": "978-1-06-982030-3" }, { "identifier": "978-1-06-982031-0" }, { "identifier": "978-1-06-982032-7" }, { "identifier": "0000000528819728" }, { "identifier": "0000000528819787" }, { "identifier": "0000000528819744" } ], "source_references": [ "https://www.museumofone.art", "https://zenodo.org/communities/post-interpretive-criticism", "https://osf.io/zhnre/", "https://works.hcommons.org/records/xv2j2-g6927", "https://philpapers.org/rec/VALPCF-2", "https://www.semanticscholar.org/author/Dorian-Vale/2380743266", "https://www.researchcatalogue.net/profile", "https://archive.org/details/the-journal-of-post-interpretive-criticism-vi", "https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=15tvhjAAAAAJ", "https://independent.academia.edu/DorianVale", "https://www.zotero.org/groups/6279725/post-interpretive-criticism", "https://core.ac.uk/search/?q=post-interpretive+criticism+dorian+vale", "https://www.base-search.net/Search/Results?lookfor=Post-Interpretive+Criticism", "https://openalex.org/works?filter=title_and_abstract.search:Post-Interpretive+Criticism+Dorian+Vale", "https://commons.datacite.org/?query=Post-Interpretive+Criticism", "https://webarchiveweb.wayback.bac-lac.canada.ca/web/*/https://www.museumofone.art" ], "source_journal": { "title": "Journal of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "volume": "4" }, "source_imprint": null, "source_contributors": [], "source_created": "2026-05-09T19:04:52.528705+00:00", "source_modified": "2026-05-09T19:04:52.862725+00:00", "source_description_html": "

This manual operationalises the ten diagnostic indices of Post-Interpretive Criticism (PIC) for consistent application across coders, supporting inter-rater reliability work, comparative corpus studies, and self-audit by individual critics. It is an operational reference rather than a theoretical exposition; the foundational arguments are set out in the published v.2 specifications and are not rehearsed here except where required for procedural clarity.

\n

The framework is structured in two layers. Layer A — Ethical / Postural Indices (RD, ILI, VDR, EPS, IAI) — diagnoses how much force a critical text applies and where it lands. Layer B — Phenomenological Fidelity Indices (EFI, PPAS, RERR, QSARI, DCI) — diagnoses which phenomenological operations the text honours or violates, grounded in Husserl's epoché and Dufrenne's three-phase model of aesthetic experience (presence, representation, reflection / feeling) together with his three-layer architecture of work, aesthetic object, and residue.

\n

Part I establishes general coding principles, including coding units, the Direction of Force matrices (MAC/EBS, RM/CA), exclusion rules, the zero-denominator convention, genre awareness, and the PIC Constraint, which forbids single-index posture diagnoses. Parts II and III specify each index — definition, coding unit, calculation, criteria, disambiguation rules, and behavioural bands — and define Layer A postures (Forensic, Colonising, Poetic, Institutionalist) and Layer B postures (Witness-Aligned, Extractive, Institutionally Overdetermined, Unstable). Part IV addresses composite profiles and reporting protocols; Part V addresses methodological considerations including reliability targets (Cohen's κ ≥ 0.80; ICC ≥ 0.85), context sensitivity, and cultural specificity. Three appendices cover operational terminology, reliability calculation, and a standard coding workflow.

\n
\n

This entry is connected to a series of original theories and treatises forming the foundation of the Post-Interpretive Criticism movement (Q136308909), authored by Dorian Vale (Q136308916) and published by Museum of One (Q136308879). These include: Stillmark Theory (Q136328254), Hauntmark Theory (Q136328273), Absential Aesthetic Theory (Q136328330), Viewer-as-Evidence Theory (Q136328828), Message-Transfer Theory (Q136329002), Aesthetic Displacement Theory (Q136329014), Theory of Misplacement (Q136329054), and Art as Truth: A Treatise (Q136329071), Aesthetic Recursion Theory (Q136339843), The Journal of Post-Interpretive Criticism (Q136530009), Canon of Witnesses (Q136565881),Interpretive Load Index (ILI) (Q137709526), Viewer Displacement Ratio (VDR) (Q137709583) , Ethical Proximity Score (EPS) (Q137709600) , Institutional Alignment Indicator (IAI) (Q137709608), Post-Hermeneutic Phenomenology (Q137711946)

\n
\n
\n
\n

Dorian Vale is a chosen pseudonym, not to obscure identity, but to preserve clarity of voice and integrity of message. It creates distance between the writer and the work, allowing the philosophy to stand unclouded by biography. The name exists not to hide, but to honor the seriousness of the task: to speak without spectacle, and to build without needing to be seen.

\n
\n
\n

 

\n
\n
", "provenance": { "repository": "Zenodo REST API response supplied in query.json", "retrieved": "2026-11-04", "editorial_fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "source_snapshot": "source/20100136.json", "institutional_review": "Reviewed page-level title, author and repository links in saved public institutional HTML, 2026-11-04." }, "source_review": "2026-11-04", "relations": [ { "identifier": "https://www.museumofone.art", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://zenodo.org/communities/post-interpretive-criticism", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://osf.io/zhnre/", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://works.hcommons.org/records/xv2j2-g6927", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://philpapers.org/rec/VALPCF-2", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.semanticscholar.org/author/Dorian-Vale/2380743266", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.researchcatalogue.net/profile", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://archive.org/details/the-journal-of-post-interpretive-criticism-vi", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=15tvhjAAAAAJ", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://independent.academia.edu/DorianVale", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.zotero.org/groups/6279725/post-interpretive-criticism", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://core.ac.uk/search/?q=post-interpretive+criticism+dorian+vale", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.base-search.net/Search/Results?lookfor=Post-Interpretive+Criticism", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://commons.datacite.org/?query=Post-Interpretive+Criticism", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://openalex.org/works?filter=title_and_abstract.search:Post-Interpretive+Criticism+Dorian+Vale", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://webarchiveweb.wayback.bac-lac.canada.ca/web/*/https://www.museumofone.art", "relation": "isDescribedBy", "scheme": "url" } ], "institutional_metadata": { "title": "Diagnostics Without Possession: An Operational Manual for Post-Interpretive Criticism (Operational reference for inter-rater reliability)", "author": "Dorian Vale", "web_publication": "2026-05-09T18:39:02.000Z", "web_updated": "2026-11-03T00:38:08.000Z", "linked_zenodo_dois": [ "10.5281/zenodo.18155622", "10.5281/zenodo.18205916", "10.5281/zenodo.18498483", "10.5281/zenodo.20099594" ], "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/", "publication_title": "Diagnostics Without Possession: An Operational Manual for Post-Interpretive Criticism (Operational reference for inter-rater reliability)", "publication_status": "Published operational manual", "publication_date": "2026", "edition": null }, "research_programmes": [ { "title": "Phenomenological Methods and Diagnostic Reading", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-methods/", "status": "Continuing research", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/", "relation": "Published operational manual in this programme.", "relation_label": "Published operational manual in this programme." } ], "record_level": "Item", "record_status": "Published source; selected catalogue record", "digital_formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "extent": "1 digital file; 525965 bytes", "medium": "Digital document", "record_reviewed": "2026-11-04", "date_precision": "day", "alternate_titles": [], "digital_extent": { "file_count": 1, "total_bytes": 525965, "formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "checksums": [ { "filename": "Diagnostics Without Possession - An Operational Manual for Post-Interpretive Criticism.pdf", "algorithm": "md5", "value": "2dc93b7125bb645e67fba4b0f54696e5", "syntax_valid": true, "verification": "source_checksum_transcription; bytes not independently recomputed" } ], "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136", "derivation": "File count and total bytes calculated from repository file metadata; MIME inferred from filename when absent." }, "identifier_validation": { "orcid": { "source_value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "ISO 7064 MOD 11-2 checksum only; this is not a live registry verification." }, "isbn": [ { "source_value": "978-1-06-982030-3", "normalized": "9781069820303", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "Checksum validation tests the identifier syntax only; it does not verify assignment, format or edition applicability.", "scope": "source_alternate_identifier; applicability to this item unverified", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136" }, { "source_value": "978-1-06-982031-0", "normalized": "9781069820310", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "Checksum validation tests the identifier syntax only; it does not verify assignment, format or edition applicability.", "scope": "source_alternate_identifier; applicability to this item unverified", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136" }, { "source_value": "978-1-06-982032-7", "normalized": "9781069820327", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "Checksum validation tests the identifier syntax only; it does not verify assignment, format or edition applicability.", "scope": "source_alternate_identifier; applicability to this item unverified", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136" } ], "doi": { "source_value": "10.5281/zenodo.20100136", "syntax_valid": true, "note": "Syntax check only; repository snapshot supplies the identifier." }, "isbn_note": "ISBNs listed in repository alternate identifiers refer to other publications or lack item-level applicability. They are retained as source identifiers, not asserted as this item’s ISBN." }, "isbn_applicability": "unverified", "source_identifiers": [ { "scheme": "isbn", "value": "978-1-06-982030-3", "scope": "source_alternate_identifier; applicability to this item unverified", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136" }, { "scheme": "isbn", "value": "978-1-06-982031-0", "scope": "source_alternate_identifier; applicability to this item unverified", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136" }, { "scheme": "isbn", "value": "978-1-06-982032-7", "scope": "source_alternate_identifier; applicability to this item unverified", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136" } ], "serial": null, "contributor_roles": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": "Museum of One", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136" }, { "name": "Museum of One", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": null, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136" } ], "authority_links": [], "metadata_profile": { "name": "Museum of One source-qualified catalogue profile", "version": "3.0.0", "url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/metadata-profile.json", "source_snapshot_preserved": true }, "reading_copy": { "id": "20100136", "title": "Diagnostics Without Possession: An Operational Manual for Post-Interpretive Criticism (Operational reference for inter-rater reliability)", "accession": "MOO-CAT-011", "pdf_url": "../assets/documents/20100136.pdf", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/20100136/files/Diagnostics%20Without%20Possession%20-%20An%20Operational%20Manual%20for%20Post-Interpretive%20Criticism.pdf/content", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136", "source_filename": "Diagnostics Without Possession - An Operational Manual for Post-Interpretive Criticism.pdf", "checksum": "md5:2dc93b7125bb645e67fba4b0f54696e5", "sha256": "05ae5249a7c8d7cf67cac93ac1fbdf18888800606411312ec5762765353b9c42", "bytes": 525965, "page_count": 30, "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "checksum_match": true, "rights": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "role": "Local reading copy; original repository file retained unchanged" }, "page_count": 30, "field_assertions": [ { "field": "title", "value": "Diagnostics Without Possession: An Operational Manual for Post-Interpretive Criticism (Operational reference for inter-rater reliability)", "status": "catalogue_title", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/", "note": "Local display title; the deposited title is retained separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_title", "value": "Diagnostics Without Possession: An Operational Manual for Post-Interpretive Criticism (Operational reference for inter-rater reliability)", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "doi", "value": "10.5281/zenodo.20100136", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "date", "value": "2026-02-09", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "conceptdoi", "value": "10.5281/zenodo.20099594", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "creators", "value": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "affiliation": "Museum of One", "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094" }, { "name": "Museum of One", "affiliation": null } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "keywords", "value": [ "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Stillmark Theory", "Message-Transfer Theory", "Aesthetic Displacement Theory", "Theory of Misplacement", "Absential Aesthetics", "Witness Aesthetics", "Hauntmark Theory", "Presence-Based Criticism", "Custodianship of Art", "Art as Ontology", "Aesthetic Recursion Theory", "Aesthetic Recursion", "Viewer as Evidence Theory", "Interpretive Load Index (ILI)", "Viewer Displacement Ratio (VDR)", "Ethical Proximity Score (EPS)", "Institutional Alignment Indicator (IAI)", "Epoché Fidelity Index (EFI)", "Phenomenological Phase Alignment Score (PPAS)", "Residue Engagement Restraint Ratio (RERR)", "Quasi-Subject Agency Recognition Index (QSARI)", "Dialectical Circulation Index (DCI)", "Restraint in front of art", "Moral proximity", "Interpretive silence", "Erasure as ethics", "Temporal scarcity", "Silence as method", "Ontology of beauty", "Aesthetic mercy", "Language as violence", "Art encounter ethics", "Epistemology of witness", "Philosophy of Art", "Aesthetics", "Art TheoryContemporary Aesthetics", "Comparative Aesthetics", "Phenomenology and Art", "Aesthetic Phenomenology", "Phenomenology", "Phenomenology of Aesthetic", "post-hermeneutics phenomenology", "Ethics in Art Criticism", "Interpretation and Meaning", "Criticism and Reception Theory", "Epistemology of Art", "Visual Culture Studies", "Dorian Vale", "Founder of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Post-Aesthetic Critic", "Independent Philosopher of Art", "Museum of One", "Art Writer and Theorist", "Aesthetic Philosopher", "Custodian of Witness Aesthetics", "The Doctrine of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "The Custodian's Oath", "The Canon of Witnesses", "Art as Truth", "Art as Presence", "The Viewer as Evidence", "Interpretation vs. Witnessing", "Language as Custody", "Erasure as Afterlife", "Museum of One Manifesto", "Post-Interpretive Lexicon", "Alternative art criticism", "New art criticism movement", "Ethical art theory", "Criticism beyond interpretation", "\\Slow looking philosophy", "Quiet philosophy of art", "Radical art restraint", "Interpretive Restraint" ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "license", "value": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "files", "value": [ { "name": "Diagnostics Without Possession - An Operational Manual for Post-Interpretive Criticism.pdf", "url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/20100136/files/Diagnostics%20Without%20Possession%20-%20An%20Operational%20Manual%20for%20Post-Interpretive%20Criticism.pdf/content", "size": 525965, "size_label": "514 KB", "checksum": "md5:2dc93b7125bb645e67fba4b0f54696e5", "mimetype": "application/pdf" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_created", "value": "2026-05-09T19:04:52.528705+00:00", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_modified", "value": "2026-05-09T19:04:52.862725+00:00", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "record_modified", "value": "2026-11-04", "status": "derived_from_description_history", "note": "Latest documented local description event; not a publication, repository or source-review date.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_review", "value": "2026-11-04", "status": "catalogue_source_review", "note": "Review of descriptive sources; not the creation or modification date of the work or repository record.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "author", "value": "Dorian Vale", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/", "note": "Institutional responsibility statement; original repository creator roles remain separate.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "publisher", "value": "Museum of One", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/", "note": "Institutional responsibility statement; original repository creator roles remain separate.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "orcid", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "source_linked_identifier", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/", "note": "Creator identifier supplied by the linked sources; no affiliation or endorsement is inferred.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "orcid_authority", "value": { "scheme": "ORCID", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "evidence_urls": [ "https://www.museumofone.art/archives-scholarly-infrastructure/", "https://eprints.rclis.org/47182/", "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ], "access_note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "evidence_receipt": "data/source/authority-review-2026-11-04.json" }, "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "source_url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "summary", "value": "An operational manual for applying the diagnostic indices of Post-Interpretive Criticism across coding, comparative study, and self-audit. Procedures for testing agreement are distinct from completed reliability findings.", "status": "editorial_enrichment", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/", "note": "Catalogue-editor summary based on the linked work; not an original publisher abstract.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "subjects", "value": [ "Research methods", "Critical language", "Coding procedures", "Inter-rater reliability" ], "status": "editorial_enrichment", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/", "note": "Local discovery terms; no controlled-vocabulary assignment is claimed.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "collection", "value": "Theory & treatises", "status": "editorial_grouping", "note": "A local browsing collection, not an original repository collection.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "corroboration", "value": "Museum of One’s matching publication page confirms Dorian Vale’s authorship and the work’s institutional context. Its repository links and publication dates are retained separately from this selected Zenodo edition. Web-record dates are not treated as dates of the deposited edition. Source review: 4 November 2026.", "status": "catalogue_review_note", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "discrepancies", "value": [ "The repository also lists organizational or URL-form creator entries. The catalogue displays Dorian Vale as bibliographic author while retaining the deposited creator list separately.", "Zenodo classifies this deposited operational manual as a dataset. That repository classification is retained; the editorial collection describes its methodological function." ], "status": "catalogue_review_note", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "date_precision", "value": "day", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136", "note": "Precision reported exactly as supplied; missing month or day is not filled.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "medium", "value": "Digital document", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "digital_formats", "value": [ "application/pdf" ], "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "extent", "value": "1 digital file; 525965 bytes", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "digital_extent", "value": { "file_count": 1, "total_bytes": 525965, "formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "checksums": [ { "filename": "Diagnostics Without Possession - An Operational Manual for Post-Interpretive Criticism.pdf", "algorithm": "md5", "value": "2dc93b7125bb645e67fba4b0f54696e5", "syntax_valid": true, "verification": "source_checksum_transcription; bytes not independently recomputed" } ], "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136", "derivation": "File count and total bytes calculated from repository file metadata; MIME inferred from filename when absent." }, "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "identifier_validation", "value": { "orcid": { "source_value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "ISO 7064 MOD 11-2 checksum only; this is not a live registry verification." }, "isbn": [ { "source_value": "978-1-06-982030-3", "normalized": "9781069820303", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "Checksum validation tests the identifier syntax only; it does not verify assignment, format or edition applicability.", "scope": "source_alternate_identifier; applicability to this item unverified", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136" }, { "source_value": "978-1-06-982031-0", "normalized": "9781069820310", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "Checksum validation tests the identifier syntax only; it does not verify assignment, format or edition applicability.", "scope": "source_alternate_identifier; applicability to this item unverified", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136" }, { "source_value": "978-1-06-982032-7", "normalized": "9781069820327", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "Checksum validation tests the identifier syntax only; it does not verify assignment, format or edition applicability.", "scope": "source_alternate_identifier; applicability to this item unverified", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136" } ], "doi": { "source_value": "10.5281/zenodo.20100136", "syntax_valid": true, "note": "Syntax check only; repository snapshot supplies the identifier." }, "isbn_note": "ISBNs listed in repository alternate identifiers refer to other publications or lack item-level applicability. They are retained as source identifiers, not asserted as this item’s ISBN." }, "status": "local_syntax_validation", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136", "note": "Checksum/syntax validation does not verify registration, assignment or edition applicability.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_identifiers", "value": [ { "scheme": "isbn", "value": "978-1-06-982030-3", "scope": "source_alternate_identifier; applicability to this item unverified", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136" }, { "scheme": "isbn", "value": "978-1-06-982031-0", "scope": "source_alternate_identifier; applicability to this item unverified", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136" }, { "scheme": "isbn", "value": "978-1-06-982032-7", "scope": "source_alternate_identifier; applicability to this item unverified", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136", "note": "Retained source identifiers with applicability notes; not automatically identifiers of this item.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "contributor_roles", "value": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": "Museum of One", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136" }, { "name": "Museum of One", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": null, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136", "note": "Creator and contributor roles are transcribed, not inferred from names or affiliations.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "research_programme:https://www.museumofone.art/research-methods/", "value": { "title": "Phenomenological Methods and Diagnostic Reading", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-methods/", "status": "Continuing research", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/", "relation": "Published operational manual in this programme.", "relation_label": "Published operational manual in this programme." }, "status": "institutional_work_relationship", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/", "note": "Programme relationship and stage follow the work-specific institutional badge; publication does not imply a completed programme or collaboration.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "entity_link:dorian-vale:author", "value": { "id": "dorian-vale", "label": "Dorian Vale", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "author", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/", "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author.", "variants": [ "Vale, Dorian" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:a3bb5172a9a431903a7f5cd3d5847fcba7258f2bfe00684dd45df575dc1fe812", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/20100136.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." } }, { "field": "entity_link:museum-of-one:publisher", "value": { "id": "museum-of-one", "label": "Museum of One", "entity_type": "Organization", "relation": "publisher", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/", "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record.", "variants": [ "MuseumofOne", "MUSEUM OF ONE" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:927aca40fca883c2dba85e6b5fd3b82fb2898fd883a9d6442107e7c1c6aab5cc", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/20100136.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." } }, { "field": "controlled_subjects", "value": [ { "id": "research-methods", "label": "Research methods", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#research-methods", "url": "vocabulary.html#research-methods", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:research-methods", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Procedures for conducting, documenting, or evaluating an inquiry.", "scope_note": "Use for methodological discussion; narrower local terms distinguish coding, agreement, and exploratory study.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [ "coding-procedures", "inter-rater-reliability", "pilot-study" ], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "critical-language", "label": "Critical language", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#critical-language", "url": "vocabulary.html#critical-language", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:critical-language", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "The terms and linguistic choices through which critical claims are made.", "scope_note": "Use for publications examining wording, descriptive authority, restraint, or the circulation of interpretation.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "art-writing", "museum-cataloguing" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "coding-procedures", "label": "Coding procedures", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#coding-procedures", "url": "vocabulary.html#coding-procedures", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:coding-procedures", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Documented rules for assigning analytical codes to research material.", "scope_note": "Use for methodological instructions, not as evidence that their reliability has been established.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [ "research-methods" ], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "inter-rater-reliability", "label": "Inter-rater reliability", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#inter-rater-reliability", "url": "vocabulary.html#inter-rater-reliability", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:inter-rater-reliability", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Interrater reliability", "Inter rater reliability" ], "definition": "Agreement between independent coders applying a shared analytical procedure.", "scope_note": "Use for research methods addressing such agreement. Assignment does not state that independent testing or successful validation has occurred.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [ "research-methods" ], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Local preferred terms with definitions and synonyms. External alignment is scoped in the vocabulary register." }, { "field": "genre_terms", "value": [ { "id": "genre-dataset", "label": "Dataset", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#genre-dataset", "url": "vocabulary.html#genre-dataset", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:genre-dataset", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Datasets" ], "definition": "A deposited body of research data, potentially accompanied by a report.", "scope_note": "Describes the resource genre. This selected deposit includes a PDF report; the label does not promise machine-readable tabular files.", "kind": "genre", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "type", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Local resource-genre classification. Digital file format is recorded separately." }, { "field": "archival_context", "value": { "description_profile": "moo-description-policy-1.0", "catalogue_snapshot_date": "2026-11-04", "snapshot_note": "Selected catalogue snapshot; not a live repository synchronisation.", "record_category": "Published library and repository material", "reference_code_status": "Stable local catalogue reference; not evidence of an archival acquisition or a previous catalogue accession.", "source_repository": { "name": "Zenodo", "record_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136" }, "institutional_context_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/", "source_metadata_retrieved": "2026-11-04", "source_metadata_retrieval_status": "Documented in catalogue source provenance", "source_snapshot": "source/20100136.json", "source_filenames": [ "Diagnostics Without Possession - An Operational Manual for Post-Interpretive Criticism.pdf" ], "selection_basis": "Local descriptive selection of publicly published material; public availability does not establish ownership of originals.", "custodial_history": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No donation, physical transfer, acquisition agreement or chain of custody is documented by this catalogue. Zenodo remains the source repository for the deposited version." }, "original_order": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No original archival order is asserted. Current browsing groupings are local editorial arrangement." }, "arrangement": { "status": "local_editorial", "grouping": "Theory & treatises", "statement": "A browsing grouping, not an original fonds or archival series." }, "responsible_service": { "name": "Museum of One", "service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "website": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "email": "research@museumofone.art" }, "description_method": "Source-based description with automated drafting and metadata assistance. Responsibility for the public catalogue rests with Museum of One; automated assistance does not constitute independent scholarly or curatorial review.", "policy_url": "policies.html", "correction_email": "research@museumofone.art", "access_copy": { "role": "Local digital reading copy of the deposited file", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/20100136/files/Diagnostics%20Without%20Possession%20-%20An%20Operational%20Manual%20for%20Post-Interpretive%20Criticism.pdf/content", "source_filename": "Diagnostics Without Possession - An Operational Manual for Post-Interpretive Criticism.pdf", "local_path": "assets/documents/20100136.pdf", "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "source_checksum_match": true, "sha256": "05ae5249a7c8d7cf67cac93ac1fbdf18888800606411312ec5762765353b9c42", "statement": "Access copy only; no ownership or physical custody transfer is implied." } }, "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Provenance records what is documented and leaves unknown custody and original order explicit." }, { "field": "description_history", "value": [ { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Source-based catalogue description", "note": "Local description assembled from the identified public repository record and available institutional work record. Source metadata remains separately identifiable.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136", "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Qualified descriptive enrichment", "note": "Local editorial description, arrangement and source-qualified bibliographic context recorded alongside source metadata. Unknown or disputed values remain qualified.", "fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136", "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Automated file checksum and PDF inspection", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Digital reading copy verified", "note": "Downloaded access-copy MD5 matched the source checksum; local SHA-256 and PDF file-page count are recorded in the file manifest. This event does not describe transfer of custody.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/api/records/20100136/files/Diagnostics%20Without%20Possession%20-%20An%20Operational%20Manual%20for%20Post-Interpretive%20Criticism.pdf/content" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Description policy and provenance context adopted", "note": "Responsible service, source repository, local access-copy role, unknown custody and original order, correction route and dated description history made explicit under moo-description-policy-1.0.", "sources": [ "policies.html" ] }, { "event_id": "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Unify graph identities and qualify exported relationships and citations", "note": "Local graph projection now uses one contextual identity per entity, distinguishes work-level institutional matches from selected-edition links, retains title-level ISBN uncertainty, and derives citations from the source title. Typed relation assertions and a versioned validation profile are introduced. No publication date, original source snapshot or PDF changed.", "fields": [ "metadata_profile", "relationship_assertions", "identity", "institutional_match_scope", "citation_projection" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Source-based metadata implementation and regression validation", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication, source review or acquisition date", "sources": [ "metadata/metadata-profile.json" ] }, { "event_id": "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Record inspected public ORCID profile evidence", "note": "The official ORCID public person API returned the credited name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website. This confirms a matching public profile, not independently verified biographical or affiliation claims. Original creator arrays and source snapshots are unchanged.", "fields": [ "orcid_authority" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Read-only official public API inspection", "date_kind": "Local authority review and catalogue description event; not a publication or original creation date", "sources": [ "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ] } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Catalogue description events; these are not work publication dates or acquisition dates." }, { "field": "pirr_references", "value": [ { "programme_key": "research-methods", "programme_title": "Phenomenological Methods and Diagnostic Reading", "programme_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-methods/", "programme_stage": "Continuing research", "registry_url": "research-registry.html#research-methods", "identifiers": [ { "scheme": "PIRR project ID", "value": "pir-prj-pyp5yx3w", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-methods/#programme-record" } ], "relation": "Published operational manual in this programme.", "relation_note": "Published operational manual in this programme.", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/" } ], "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "PIRR project IDs and programme references identify research records, not publication versions or independent chapter deposits." }, { "field": "relationship_assertions", "value": [ { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:a3bb5172a9a431903a7f5cd3d5847fcba7258f2bfe00684dd45df575dc1fe812", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/20100136.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:927aca40fca883c2dba85e6b5fd3b82fb2898fd883a9d6442107e7c1c6aab5cc", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/20100136.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:35da461ec6ed97b150a211f06ae79f3b59265c374bf2aea515207a5410eb9e8a", "subject": "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#describes", "object": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20099594", "scope": "version_family", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/", "source_location": { "kind": "metadata_field", "field": "linked_zenodo_dois", "values": [ "10.5281/zenodo.18155622", "10.5281/zenodo.18205916", "10.5281/zenodo.18498483", "10.5281/zenodo.20099594" ] }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "Exact-edition matching requires the selected DOI in the reviewed page metadata; other matches retain their wider scope." } ], "status": "typed_evidence_projection", "note": "Stable, typed assertions retain source scope and explicit unknown review metadata." }, { "field": "reading_copy", "value": { "id": "20100136", "title": "Diagnostics Without Possession: An Operational Manual for Post-Interpretive Criticism (Operational reference for inter-rater reliability)", "accession": "MOO-CAT-011", "pdf_url": "../assets/documents/20100136.pdf", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/20100136/files/Diagnostics%20Without%20Possession%20-%20An%20Operational%20Manual%20for%20Post-Interpretive%20Criticism.pdf/content", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136", "source_filename": "Diagnostics Without Possession - An Operational Manual for Post-Interpretive Criticism.pdf", "checksum": "md5:2dc93b7125bb645e67fba4b0f54696e5", "sha256": "05ae5249a7c8d7cf67cac93ac1fbdf18888800606411312ec5762765353b9c42", "bytes": 525965, "page_count": 30, "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "checksum_match": true, "rights": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "role": "Local reading copy; original repository file retained unchanged" }, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/20100136/files/Diagnostics%20Without%20Possession%20-%20An%20Operational%20Manual%20for%20Post-Interpretive%20Criticism.pdf/content", "status": "derived_file_inspection", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "note": "Byte-identical local access copy. Source MD5 was recomputed and matched; SHA-256 and page count were measured from the downloaded PDF. This is not a preservation-deposit claim." }, { "field": "page_count", "value": 30, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/20100136/files/Diagnostics%20Without%20Possession%20-%20An%20Operational%20Manual%20for%20Post-Interpretive%20Criticism.pdf/content", "status": "derived_file_inspection", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "note": "Total PDF file pages measured from the deposited file, including cover and unnumbered pages. Not a claim about printed pagination." } ], "entity_links": [ { "id": "dorian-vale", "label": "Dorian Vale", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "author", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/", "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author.", "variants": [ "Vale, Dorian" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "museum-of-one", "label": "Museum of One", "entity_type": "Organization", "relation": "publisher", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/", "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record.", "variants": [ "MuseumofOne", "MUSEUM OF ONE" ], "evidence_scope": "work" } ], "contents": [], "controlled_subjects": [ { "id": "research-methods", "label": "Research methods", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#research-methods", "url": "vocabulary.html#research-methods", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:research-methods", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Procedures for conducting, documenting, or evaluating an inquiry.", "scope_note": "Use for methodological discussion; narrower local terms distinguish coding, agreement, and exploratory study.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [ "coding-procedures", "inter-rater-reliability", "pilot-study" ], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "critical-language", "label": "Critical language", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#critical-language", "url": "vocabulary.html#critical-language", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:critical-language", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "The terms and linguistic choices through which critical claims are made.", "scope_note": "Use for publications examining wording, descriptive authority, restraint, or the circulation of interpretation.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "art-writing", "museum-cataloguing" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "coding-procedures", "label": "Coding procedures", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#coding-procedures", "url": "vocabulary.html#coding-procedures", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:coding-procedures", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Documented rules for assigning analytical codes to research material.", "scope_note": "Use for methodological instructions, not as evidence that their reliability has been established.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [ "research-methods" ], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "inter-rater-reliability", "label": "Inter-rater reliability", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#inter-rater-reliability", "url": "vocabulary.html#inter-rater-reliability", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:inter-rater-reliability", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Interrater reliability", "Inter rater reliability" ], "definition": "Agreement between independent coders applying a shared analytical procedure.", "scope_note": "Use for research methods addressing such agreement. Assignment does not state that independent testing or successful validation has occurred.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [ "research-methods" ], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "genre_terms": [ { "id": "genre-dataset", "label": "Dataset", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#genre-dataset", "url": "vocabulary.html#genre-dataset", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:genre-dataset", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Datasets" ], "definition": "A deposited body of research data, potentially accompanied by a report.", "scope_note": "Describes the resource genre. This selected deposit includes a PDF report; the label does not promise machine-readable tabular files.", "kind": "genre", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "type", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "vocabulary_version": 4, "description_history": [ { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Source-based catalogue description", "note": "Local description assembled from the identified public repository record and available institutional work record. Source metadata remains separately identifiable.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136", "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Qualified descriptive enrichment", "note": "Local editorial description, arrangement and source-qualified bibliographic context recorded alongside source metadata. Unknown or disputed values remain qualified.", "fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136", "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Automated file checksum and PDF inspection", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Digital reading copy verified", "note": "Downloaded access-copy MD5 matched the source checksum; local SHA-256 and PDF file-page count are recorded in the file manifest. This event does not describe transfer of custody.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/api/records/20100136/files/Diagnostics%20Without%20Possession%20-%20An%20Operational%20Manual%20for%20Post-Interpretive%20Criticism.pdf/content" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Description policy and provenance context adopted", "note": "Responsible service, source repository, local access-copy role, unknown custody and original order, correction route and dated description history made explicit under moo-description-policy-1.0.", "sources": [ "policies.html" ] }, { "event_id": "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Unify graph identities and qualify exported relationships and citations", "note": "Local graph projection now uses one contextual identity per entity, distinguishes work-level institutional matches from selected-edition links, retains title-level ISBN uncertainty, and derives citations from the source title. Typed relation assertions and a versioned validation profile are introduced. No publication date, original source snapshot or PDF changed.", "fields": [ "metadata_profile", "relationship_assertions", "identity", "institutional_match_scope", "citation_projection" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Source-based metadata implementation and regression validation", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication, source review or acquisition date", "sources": [ "metadata/metadata-profile.json" ] }, { "event_id": "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Record inspected public ORCID profile evidence", "note": "The official ORCID public person API returned the credited name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website. This confirms a matching public profile, not independently verified biographical or affiliation claims. Original creator arrays and source snapshots are unchanged.", "fields": [ "orcid_authority" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Read-only official public API inspection", "date_kind": "Local authority review and catalogue description event; not a publication or original creation date", "sources": [ "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ] } ], "record_modified": "2026-11-04", "record_modified_provenance": { "status": "derived_from_description_history", "event_ids": [ "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04" ], "note": "Latest documented local description event; not a publication, repository or source-review date." }, "archival_context": { "description_profile": "moo-description-policy-1.0", "catalogue_snapshot_date": "2026-11-04", "snapshot_note": "Selected catalogue snapshot; not a live repository synchronisation.", "record_category": "Published library and repository material", "reference_code_status": "Stable local catalogue reference; not evidence of an archival acquisition or a previous catalogue accession.", "source_repository": { "name": "Zenodo", "record_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100136" }, "institutional_context_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/", "source_metadata_retrieved": "2026-11-04", "source_metadata_retrieval_status": "Documented in catalogue source provenance", "source_snapshot": "source/20100136.json", "source_filenames": [ "Diagnostics Without Possession - An Operational Manual for Post-Interpretive Criticism.pdf" ], "selection_basis": "Local descriptive selection of publicly published material; public availability does not establish ownership of originals.", "custodial_history": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No donation, physical transfer, acquisition agreement or chain of custody is documented by this catalogue. Zenodo remains the source repository for the deposited version." }, "original_order": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No original archival order is asserted. Current browsing groupings are local editorial arrangement." }, "arrangement": { "status": "local_editorial", "grouping": "Theory & treatises", "statement": "A browsing grouping, not an original fonds or archival series." }, "responsible_service": { "name": "Museum of One", "service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "website": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "email": "research@museumofone.art" }, "description_method": "Source-based description with automated drafting and metadata assistance. Responsibility for the public catalogue rests with Museum of One; automated assistance does not constitute independent scholarly or curatorial review.", "policy_url": "policies.html", "correction_email": "research@museumofone.art", "access_copy": { "role": "Local digital reading copy of the deposited file", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/20100136/files/Diagnostics%20Without%20Possession%20-%20An%20Operational%20Manual%20for%20Post-Interpretive%20Criticism.pdf/content", "source_filename": "Diagnostics Without Possession - An Operational Manual for Post-Interpretive Criticism.pdf", "local_path": "assets/documents/20100136.pdf", "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "source_checksum_match": true, "sha256": "05ae5249a7c8d7cf67cac93ac1fbdf18888800606411312ec5762765353b9c42", "statement": "Access copy only; no ownership or physical custody transfer is implied." } }, "description_policy_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "pirr_references": [ { "programme_key": "research-methods", "programme_title": "Phenomenological Methods and Diagnostic Reading", "programme_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-methods/", "programme_stage": "Continuing research", "registry_url": "research-registry.html#research-methods", "identifiers": [ { "scheme": "PIRR project ID", "value": "pir-prj-pyp5yx3w", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-methods/#programme-record" } ], "relation": "Published operational manual in this programme.", "relation_note": "Published operational manual in this programme.", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/" } ], "pirr_work_identity": { "archive_reference": "MOO-CAT-011", "edition_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.20100136", "zenodo_record_id": "20100136", "identifier_scope": "Publication identity; PIRR identifiers in programme relationships identify research records, not this publication." }, "metadata_origin": "https://archive.museumofone.art", "identity": { "work": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/20100136.html#work", "edition": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20100136", "version_family": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20099594", "catalogue_record": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/20100136.html#catalogue-record" }, "institutional_match_scope": "version_family", "relationship_assertions": [ { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:a3bb5172a9a431903a7f5cd3d5847fcba7258f2bfe00684dd45df575dc1fe812", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/20100136.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:927aca40fca883c2dba85e6b5fd3b82fb2898fd883a9d6442107e7c1c6aab5cc", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/20100136.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:35da461ec6ed97b150a211f06ae79f3b59265c374bf2aea515207a5410eb9e8a", "subject": "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#describes", "object": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20099594", "scope": "version_family", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/diagnostics-without-possession-an-operational-manual-for-post-interpretive-criticism-operational-reference-for-inter-rater-reliability/", "source_location": { "kind": "metadata_field", "field": "linked_zenodo_dois", "values": [ "10.5281/zenodo.18155622", "10.5281/zenodo.18205916", "10.5281/zenodo.18498483", "10.5281/zenodo.20099594" ] }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "Exact-edition matching requires the selected DOI in the reviewed page metadata; other matches retain their wider scope." } ], "orcid_authority": { "scheme": "ORCID", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "evidence_urls": [ "https://www.museumofone.art/archives-scholarly-infrastructure/", "https://eprints.rclis.org/47182/", "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ], "access_note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "evidence_receipt": "data/source/authority-review-2026-11-04.json" } }, { "id": "20100139", "accession": "MOO-CAT-012", "title": "A Quantitative Analysis of Critical Posture in Art Writing, 1980-2025 (Dataset - 20 Critical Texts 1980–2025) v.2", "source_title": "A Quantitative Analysis of Critical Posture in Art Writing, 1980-2025 (Dataset - 20 Critical Texts 1980–2025) v.2", "short_title": "A Quantitative Analysis of Critical Posture", "author": "Dorian Vale", "creators": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "affiliation": "Museum of One", "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094" } ], "doi": "10.5281/zenodo.20100139", "conceptdoi": "10.5281/zenodo.18205642", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100139", "date": "2026-02-09", "type": "Dataset", "source_resource_type": { "title": "Dataset", "type": "dataset" }, "version": "", "collection": "Essays & research", "summary": "A deposited dataset and report examining twenty critical texts through five diagnostic indices. The institutional tools page characterizes the associated work as a single-coder pilot, rather than independent validation.", "subjects": [ "Art criticism", "Research methods", "Critical language", "Pilot study" ], "keywords": [ "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Stillmark Theory", "Message-Transfer Theory", "MTT", "Misplacement", "Displacement", "Aesthetic Displacement Theory", "Theory of Misplacement", "Absential Aesthetics", "Witness Aesthetics", "Hauntmark Theory", "Presence-Based Criticism", "Custodianship of Art", "Art as Ontology", "Aesthetic Recursion Theory", "Aesthetic Recursion", "Viewer as Evidence Theory", "Interpretive Load Index (ILI)", "Viewer Displacement Ratio (VDR)", "Ethical Proximity Score (EPS)", "Institutional Alignment Indicator (IAI)", "Restraint in front of art", "Moral proximity", "Interpretive silence", "Erasure as ethics", "Temporal scarcity", "Silence as method", "Ontology of beauty", "Aesthetic mercy", "Language as violence", "Art encounter ethics", "Epistemology of witness", "Philosophy of Art", "Aesthetics", "Art Theory", "Contemporary Aesthetics", "Comparative Aesthetics", "Phenomenology and Art", "Ethics in Art Criticism", "Interpretation and Meaning", "Criticism and Reception Theory", "Epistemology of Art", "Visual Culture Studies", "Dorian Vale", "Founder of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Post-Aesthetic Critic", "Independent Philosopher of Art", "Museum of One", "Art Writer and Theorist", "Aesthetic Philosopher", "Custodian of Witness Aesthetics", "The Doctrine of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "The Custodian's Oath", "The Canon of Witnesses", "Art as Truth", "Art as Presence", "The Viewer as Evidence", "Interpretation vs. Witnessing", "Language as Custody", "Erasure as Afterlife", "Museum of One Manifesto", "Post-Interpretive Lexicon", "Alternative art criticism", "New art criticism movement", "Criticism beyond interpretation", "Ethical art theory", "Slow looking philosophy", "Contemporary sacred aesthetics", "Quiet philosophy of art", "Radical art restraint", "Witness over interpretation", "Interpretive Restraint", "This entry is connected to a series of original theories and treatises forming the foundation of the Post-Interpretive Criticism movement (Q136308909), authored by Dorian Vale (Q136308916) and published by Museum of One (Q136308879). These include: Stillmark Theory (Q136328254), Hauntmark Theory (Q136328273), Absential Aesthetic Theory (Q136328330), Viewer-as-Evidence Theory (Q136328828), Message-Transfer Theory (Q136329002), Aesthetic Displacement Theory (Q136329014), Theory of Misplacement (Q136329054), and _Art as Truth: A Treatise_ (Q136329071), _Aesthetic Recursion Theory_ (Q136339843), The Journal of Post-Interpretive Criticism (Q136530009), Canon of Witnesses (Q136565881),Interpretive Load Index (ILI) (Q137709526), Viewer Displacement Ratio (VDR) (Q137709583) , Ethical Proximity Score (EPS) (Q137709600) , Institutional Alignment Indicator (IAI) (Q137709608), Post-Hermeneutic Phenomenology (Q137711946)" ], "license": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "files": [ { "name": "A Quantitative Analysis of Critical Posture in Art Writing, 1981–2025 (v.2).pdf", "url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/20100139/files/A%20Quantitative%20Analysis%20of%20Critical%20Posture%20in%20Art%20Writing,%201981%E2%80%932025%20(v.2).pdf/content", "size": 506516, "size_label": "495 KB", "checksum": "md5:10d88e31592df0f1a2470ec95b96bb1c", "mimetype": "application/pdf" } ], "institutional_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/a-quantitative-analysis-of-critical-posture-in-art-writing-1980-2025-dataset-20-critical-texts-1980-2025/", "corroboration": "Museum of One’s matching publication page confirms Dorian Vale’s authorship and the work’s institutional context. It links the selected Zenodo edition DOI. Web-record dates are not treated as dates of the deposited edition. Source review: 4 November 2026.", "discrepancies": [ "The source title describes 1980–2025; deposited filenames use 1981–2025. These source variants are retained without silently harmonizing the coverage dates." ], "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "publisher": "Museum of One", "language": null, "isbn": null, "related_identifiers": [ { "identifier": "https://hcommons.org/members/dorianvale/", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://philpeople.org/profiles/dorian-vale", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://independent.academia.edu/DorianVale", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "10.5281/zenodo.17069115", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "10.5281/zenodo.17078847", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "https://scholar.google.com/citations?hl=en&authuser=1&user=15tvhjAAAAAJ", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://works.hcommons.org/records/xv2j2-g6927", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.semanticscholar.org/author/Dorian-Vale/2380743266", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.researchcatalogue.net/profile/?person=3919333", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://osf.io/gpwnq", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://osf.io/xa5jw/", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://osf.io/zhnre/", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://archive.org/details/osf-registrations-kve9y-v1", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "10.17605/OSF.IO/KVE9Y", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "10.17605/OSF.IO/ZHNRE", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "https://core.ac.uk/works/299793749/?t=ccf14485c84f6196dcddf51a8410bc88-299793749", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://core.ac.uk/works/299795319/?t=ccf14485c84f6196dcddf51a8410bc88-299795319", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://core.ac.uk/search/?q=post-interpretive+criticism+dorian+vale&page=1", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" } ], "alternate_identifiers": [ { "identifier": "https://hcommons.org/members/dorianvale/" }, { "identifier": "https://philpeople.org/profiles/dorian-vale" }, { "identifier": "https://www.museumofone.art/" }, { "identifier": "https://independent.academia.edu/DorianVale" }, { "identifier": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17069115" }, { "identifier": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17078847" }, { "identifier": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094" }, { "identifier": "https://scholar.google.com/citations?hl=en&authuser=1&user=15tvhjAAAAAJ" }, { "identifier": "https://works.hcommons.org/records/xv2j2-g6927" }, { "identifier": "https://www.semanticscholar.org/author/Dorian-Vale/2380743266" }, { "identifier": "https://www.researchcatalogue.net/profile/?person=3919333" }, { "identifier": "https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/ZHNRE" }, { "identifier": "https://archive.org/details/osf-registrations-kve9y-v1" }, { "identifier": "2819-7232" }, { "identifier": "0000000528819728" }, { "identifier": "0000000528819787" }, { "identifier": "0000000528819744" } ], "source_references": [ "https://www.museumofone.art/", "https://www.museumofone.art/tag/diagnostic-reading/", "https://www.museumofone.art/measuring-proximity-a-post-interpretive-diagnostic-experiment-in-art-criticism-post-hermeneutic-phenomenology/" ], "source_journal": null, "source_imprint": null, "source_contributors": [], "source_created": "2026-05-09T19:05:37.382757+00:00", "source_modified": "2026-10-22T19:57:04.870933+00:00", "source_description_html": "

Title: A Quantitative Analysis of Critical Posture in Art Ariting, 1980-2025 (Dataset - 20 Critical Texts 1980–2025)

\n


Author:Dorian Vale

\n


Affiliation: Museum of One

\n


This dataset presents a quantitative diagnostic analysis of critical posture in contemporary art writing across a forty-five-year span (1980–2025). Using the Post-Interpretive Criticism (PIC) diagnostic framework, twenty influential texts drawn from journals, newspapers, magazines, institutional press releases, and exhibition discourse were coded sentence-by-sentence to examine how critical language positions itself in relation to artworks, viewers, and institutional authority. Five indices were applied: Rhetorical Density (RD), Interpretive Load Index (ILI), Viewer Displacement Ratio (VDR), Ethical Proximity Score (EPS), and Institutional Alignment Indicator (IAI).

\n

Rather than evaluating interpretive correctness or aesthetic value, the framework isolates how critical claims are produced—measuring the balance between descriptive encounter and explanatory force, the degree of viewer displacement, the presence or absence of linguistic restraint, and the extent of institutional mediation. The dataset demonstrates that high rhetorical intensity does not necessarily correlate with high interpretive extraction, and that ostensibly “plain” theoretical language frequently produces maximal displacement. Across historical periods, the results reveal recurring postures—verdict-driven criticism, theory-dominated explanation, affective populism, and market-aligned promotion—each identifiable through distinct metric profiles.

\n

The findings provide quantitative support for a central claim of Post-Interpretive Criticism: that the ethical stakes of art writing reside not in what criticism concludes, but in how closely it remains to the conditions of encounter. This dataset is offered as a reflective and exploratory diagnostic resource, not a prescriptive model, contributing a formal complement to phenomenological and post-hermeneutic approaches in contemporary aesthetics.

\n

 

\n

This entry is connected to a series of original theories and treatises forming the foundation of the Post-Interpretive Criticism movement (Q136308909), authored by Dorian Vale (Q136308916) and published by Museum of One (Q136308879). These include: Stillmark Theory (Q136328254), Hauntmark Theory (Q136328273), Absential Aesthetic Theory (Q136328330), Viewer-as-Evidence Theory (Q136328828), Message-Transfer Theory (Q136329002), Aesthetic Displacement Theory (Q136329014), Theory of Misplacement (Q136329054), and _Art as Truth: A Treatise_ (Q136329071), _Aesthetic Recursion Theory_ (Q136339843), The Journal of Post-Interpretive Criticism (Q136530009), Canon of Witnesses (Q136565881),Interpretive Load Index (ILI) (Q137709526), Viewer Displacement Ratio (VDR) (Q137709583) , Ethical Proximity Score (EPS) (Q137709600) , Institutional Alignment Indicator (IAI) (Q137709608), Post-Hermeneutic Phenomenology (Q137711946)

\n

ISSN 2819-7232

\n

Dorian Vale is a chosen pseudonym, not to obscure identity, but to preserve clarity of voice and integrity of message. It creates distance between the writer and the work, allowing the philosophy to stand unclouded by biography. The name exists not to hide, but to honor the seriousness of the task: to speak without spectacle, and to build without needing to be seen. This name is used for all official publications, essays, and theoretical works indexed through DOI-linked repositories including Zenodo, OSF, PhilPapers, and SSRN.

\n

ORCID: 0009-0004-7737-5094

", "provenance": { "repository": "Zenodo REST API response supplied in query.json", "retrieved": "2026-11-04", "editorial_fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "source_snapshot": "source/20100139.json", "institutional_review": "Reviewed page-level title, author and repository links in saved public institutional HTML, 2026-11-04." }, "source_review": "2026-11-04", "relations": [ { "identifier": "https://hcommons.org/members/dorianvale/", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://philpeople.org/profiles/dorian-vale", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://independent.academia.edu/DorianVale", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "10.5281/zenodo.17069115", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "10.5281/zenodo.17078847", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "https://scholar.google.com/citations?hl=en&authuser=1&user=15tvhjAAAAAJ", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://works.hcommons.org/records/xv2j2-g6927", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.semanticscholar.org/author/Dorian-Vale/2380743266", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.researchcatalogue.net/profile/?person=3919333", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://osf.io/gpwnq", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://osf.io/xa5jw/", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://osf.io/zhnre/", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://archive.org/details/osf-registrations-kve9y-v1", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "10.17605/OSF.IO/KVE9Y", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "10.17605/OSF.IO/ZHNRE", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "https://core.ac.uk/works/299793749/?t=ccf14485c84f6196dcddf51a8410bc88-299793749", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://core.ac.uk/works/299795319/?t=ccf14485c84f6196dcddf51a8410bc88-299795319", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://core.ac.uk/search/?q=post-interpretive+criticism+dorian+vale&page=1", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" } ], "institutional_metadata": { "title": "A Quantitative Analysis of Critical Posture in Art Writing, 1980-2025 (Dataset - 20 Critical Texts 1980–2025) v.2", "author": "Dorian Vale", "web_publication": "2026-03-01T09:39:00.000Z", "web_updated": "2026-11-03T00:28:41.000Z", "linked_zenodo_dois": [ "10.5281/zenodo.18155622", "10.5281/zenodo.18205642", "10.5281/zenodo.18498483", "10.5281/zenodo.20100139" ], "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/a-quantitative-analysis-of-critical-posture-in-art-writing-1980-2025-dataset-20-critical-texts-1980-2025/" }, "research_programmes": [], "record_level": "Item", "record_status": "Published source; selected catalogue record", "digital_formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "extent": "1 digital file; 506516 bytes", "medium": "Digital document", "record_reviewed": "2026-11-04", "date_precision": "day", "alternate_titles": [], "digital_extent": { "file_count": 1, "total_bytes": 506516, "formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "checksums": [ { "filename": "A Quantitative Analysis of Critical Posture in Art Writing, 1981–2025 (v.2).pdf", "algorithm": "md5", "value": "10d88e31592df0f1a2470ec95b96bb1c", "syntax_valid": true, "verification": "source_checksum_transcription; bytes not independently recomputed" } ], "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100139", "derivation": "File count and total bytes calculated from repository file metadata; MIME inferred from filename when absent." }, "identifier_validation": { "orcid": { "source_value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "ISO 7064 MOD 11-2 checksum only; this is not a live registry verification." }, "isbn": [], "doi": { "source_value": "10.5281/zenodo.20100139", "syntax_valid": true, "note": "Syntax check only; repository snapshot supplies the identifier." } }, "isbn_applicability": "not_supplied", "serial": null, "contributor_roles": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": "Museum of One", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100139" } ], "authority_links": [], "metadata_profile": { "name": "Museum of One source-qualified catalogue profile", "version": "3.0.0", "url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/metadata-profile.json", "source_snapshot_preserved": true }, "reading_copy": { "id": "20100139", "title": "A Quantitative Analysis of Critical Posture in Art Writing, 1980-2025 (Dataset - 20 Critical Texts 1980–2025) v.2", "accession": "MOO-CAT-012", "pdf_url": "../assets/documents/20100139.pdf", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/20100139/files/A%20Quantitative%20Analysis%20of%20Critical%20Posture%20in%20Art%20Writing,%201981%E2%80%932025%20(v.2).pdf/content", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100139", "source_filename": "A Quantitative Analysis of Critical Posture in Art Writing, 1981–2025 (v.2).pdf", "checksum": "md5:10d88e31592df0f1a2470ec95b96bb1c", "sha256": "223c4cf7b6d70c207c37d38df3165b553eb589743cc5ad6d658c7a1c49412c92", "bytes": 506516, "page_count": 45, "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "checksum_match": true, "rights": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "role": "Local reading copy; original repository file retained unchanged" }, "page_count": 45, "field_assertions": [ { "field": "title", "value": "A Quantitative Analysis of Critical Posture in Art Writing, 1980-2025 (Dataset - 20 Critical Texts 1980–2025) v.2", "status": "catalogue_title", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/a-quantitative-analysis-of-critical-posture-in-art-writing-1980-2025-dataset-20-critical-texts-1980-2025/", "note": "Local display title; the deposited title is retained separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_title", "value": "A Quantitative Analysis of Critical Posture in Art Writing, 1980-2025 (Dataset - 20 Critical Texts 1980–2025) v.2", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100139", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "doi", "value": "10.5281/zenodo.20100139", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100139", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "date", "value": "2026-02-09", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100139", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "conceptdoi", "value": "10.5281/zenodo.18205642", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100139", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "creators", "value": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "affiliation": "Museum of One", "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100139", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "keywords", "value": [ "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Stillmark Theory", "Message-Transfer Theory", "MTT", "Misplacement", "Displacement", "Aesthetic Displacement Theory", "Theory of Misplacement", "Absential Aesthetics", "Witness Aesthetics", "Hauntmark Theory", "Presence-Based Criticism", "Custodianship of Art", "Art as Ontology", "Aesthetic Recursion Theory", "Aesthetic Recursion", "Viewer as Evidence Theory", "Interpretive Load Index (ILI)", "Viewer Displacement Ratio (VDR)", "Ethical Proximity Score (EPS)", "Institutional Alignment Indicator (IAI)", "Restraint in front of art", "Moral proximity", "Interpretive silence", "Erasure as ethics", "Temporal scarcity", "Silence as method", "Ontology of beauty", "Aesthetic mercy", "Language as violence", "Art encounter ethics", "Epistemology of witness", "Philosophy of Art", "Aesthetics", "Art Theory", "Contemporary Aesthetics", "Comparative Aesthetics", "Phenomenology and Art", "Ethics in Art Criticism", "Interpretation and Meaning", "Criticism and Reception Theory", "Epistemology of Art", "Visual Culture Studies", "Dorian Vale", "Founder of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Post-Aesthetic Critic", "Independent Philosopher of Art", "Museum of One", "Art Writer and Theorist", "Aesthetic Philosopher", "Custodian of Witness Aesthetics", "The Doctrine of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "The Custodian's Oath", "The Canon of Witnesses", "Art as Truth", "Art as Presence", "The Viewer as Evidence", "Interpretation vs. Witnessing", "Language as Custody", "Erasure as Afterlife", "Museum of One Manifesto", "Post-Interpretive Lexicon", "Alternative art criticism", "New art criticism movement", "Criticism beyond interpretation", "Ethical art theory", "Slow looking philosophy", "Contemporary sacred aesthetics", "Quiet philosophy of art", "Radical art restraint", "Witness over interpretation", "Interpretive Restraint", "This entry is connected to a series of original theories and treatises forming the foundation of the Post-Interpretive Criticism movement (Q136308909), authored by Dorian Vale (Q136308916) and published by Museum of One (Q136308879). These include: Stillmark Theory (Q136328254), Hauntmark Theory (Q136328273), Absential Aesthetic Theory (Q136328330), Viewer-as-Evidence Theory (Q136328828), Message-Transfer Theory (Q136329002), Aesthetic Displacement Theory (Q136329014), Theory of Misplacement (Q136329054), and _Art as Truth: A Treatise_ (Q136329071), _Aesthetic Recursion Theory_ (Q136339843), The Journal of Post-Interpretive Criticism (Q136530009), Canon of Witnesses (Q136565881),Interpretive Load Index (ILI) (Q137709526), Viewer Displacement Ratio (VDR) (Q137709583) , Ethical Proximity Score (EPS) (Q137709600) , Institutional Alignment Indicator (IAI) (Q137709608), Post-Hermeneutic Phenomenology (Q137711946)" ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100139", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "license", "value": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100139", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "files", "value": [ { "name": "A Quantitative Analysis of Critical Posture in Art Writing, 1981–2025 (v.2).pdf", "url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/20100139/files/A%20Quantitative%20Analysis%20of%20Critical%20Posture%20in%20Art%20Writing,%201981%E2%80%932025%20(v.2).pdf/content", "size": 506516, "size_label": "495 KB", "checksum": "md5:10d88e31592df0f1a2470ec95b96bb1c", "mimetype": "application/pdf" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100139", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_created", "value": "2026-05-09T19:05:37.382757+00:00", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100139", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_modified", "value": "2026-10-22T19:57:04.870933+00:00", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100139", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "record_modified", "value": "2026-11-04", "status": "derived_from_description_history", "note": "Latest documented local description event; not a publication, repository or source-review date.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_review", "value": "2026-11-04", "status": "catalogue_source_review", "note": "Review of descriptive sources; not the creation or modification date of the work or repository record.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "author", "value": "Dorian Vale", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/a-quantitative-analysis-of-critical-posture-in-art-writing-1980-2025-dataset-20-critical-texts-1980-2025/", "note": "Institutional responsibility statement; original repository creator roles remain separate.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "publisher", "value": "Museum of One", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/a-quantitative-analysis-of-critical-posture-in-art-writing-1980-2025-dataset-20-critical-texts-1980-2025/", "note": "Institutional responsibility statement; original repository creator roles remain separate.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "orcid", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "source_linked_identifier", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/a-quantitative-analysis-of-critical-posture-in-art-writing-1980-2025-dataset-20-critical-texts-1980-2025/", "note": "Creator identifier supplied by the linked sources; no affiliation or endorsement is inferred.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "orcid_authority", "value": { "scheme": "ORCID", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "evidence_urls": [ "https://www.museumofone.art/archives-scholarly-infrastructure/", "https://eprints.rclis.org/47182/", "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ], "access_note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "evidence_receipt": "data/source/authority-review-2026-11-04.json" }, "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "source_url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "summary", "value": "A deposited dataset and report examining twenty critical texts through five diagnostic indices. The institutional tools page characterizes the associated work as a single-coder pilot, rather than independent validation.", "status": "editorial_enrichment", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/a-quantitative-analysis-of-critical-posture-in-art-writing-1980-2025-dataset-20-critical-texts-1980-2025/", "note": "Catalogue-editor summary based on the linked work; not an original publisher abstract.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "subjects", "value": [ "Art criticism", "Research methods", "Critical language", "Pilot study" ], "status": "editorial_enrichment", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/a-quantitative-analysis-of-critical-posture-in-art-writing-1980-2025-dataset-20-critical-texts-1980-2025/", "note": "Local discovery terms; no controlled-vocabulary assignment is claimed.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "collection", "value": "Essays & research", "status": "editorial_grouping", "note": "A local browsing collection, not an original repository collection.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "corroboration", "value": "Museum of One’s matching publication page confirms Dorian Vale’s authorship and the work’s institutional context. It links the selected Zenodo edition DOI. Web-record dates are not treated as dates of the deposited edition. Source review: 4 November 2026.", "status": "catalogue_review_note", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/a-quantitative-analysis-of-critical-posture-in-art-writing-1980-2025-dataset-20-critical-texts-1980-2025/", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "discrepancies", "value": [ "The source title describes 1980–2025; deposited filenames use 1981–2025. These source variants are retained without silently harmonizing the coverage dates." ], "status": "catalogue_review_note", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/a-quantitative-analysis-of-critical-posture-in-art-writing-1980-2025-dataset-20-critical-texts-1980-2025/", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "date_precision", "value": "day", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100139", "note": "Precision reported exactly as supplied; missing month or day is not filled.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "medium", "value": "Digital document", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100139", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "digital_formats", "value": [ "application/pdf" ], "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100139", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "extent", "value": "1 digital file; 506516 bytes", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100139", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "digital_extent", "value": { "file_count": 1, "total_bytes": 506516, "formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "checksums": [ { "filename": "A Quantitative Analysis of Critical Posture in Art Writing, 1981–2025 (v.2).pdf", "algorithm": "md5", "value": "10d88e31592df0f1a2470ec95b96bb1c", "syntax_valid": true, "verification": "source_checksum_transcription; bytes not independently recomputed" } ], "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100139", "derivation": "File count and total bytes calculated from repository file metadata; MIME inferred from filename when absent." }, "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100139", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "identifier_validation", "value": { "orcid": { "source_value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "ISO 7064 MOD 11-2 checksum only; this is not a live registry verification." }, "isbn": [], "doi": { "source_value": "10.5281/zenodo.20100139", "syntax_valid": true, "note": "Syntax check only; repository snapshot supplies the identifier." } }, "status": "local_syntax_validation", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100139", "note": "Checksum/syntax validation does not verify registration, assignment or edition applicability.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "contributor_roles", "value": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": "Museum of One", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100139" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100139", "note": "Creator and contributor roles are transcribed, not inferred from names or affiliations.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "entity_link:dorian-vale:author", "value": { "id": "dorian-vale", "label": "Dorian Vale", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "author", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/a-quantitative-analysis-of-critical-posture-in-art-writing-1980-2025-dataset-20-critical-texts-1980-2025/", "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author.", "variants": [ "Vale, Dorian" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/a-quantitative-analysis-of-critical-posture-in-art-writing-1980-2025-dataset-20-critical-texts-1980-2025/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:5547506b00dc3b4ecb8d9042f31bb4afbe68f28f1b61745a90f0e942c38052a6", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/20100139.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/a-quantitative-analysis-of-critical-posture-in-art-writing-1980-2025-dataset-20-critical-texts-1980-2025/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/a-quantitative-analysis-of-critical-posture-in-art-writing-1980-2025-dataset-20-critical-texts-1980-2025/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." } }, { "field": "entity_link:museum-of-one:publisher", "value": { "id": "museum-of-one", "label": "Museum of One", "entity_type": "Organization", "relation": "publisher", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/a-quantitative-analysis-of-critical-posture-in-art-writing-1980-2025-dataset-20-critical-texts-1980-2025/", "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record.", "variants": [ "MuseumofOne", "MUSEUM OF ONE" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/a-quantitative-analysis-of-critical-posture-in-art-writing-1980-2025-dataset-20-critical-texts-1980-2025/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:4aea9e1eec2f4442cf3711822906d80b9c6e8ed2ae391a2a1355d431d54127ef", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/20100139.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/a-quantitative-analysis-of-critical-posture-in-art-writing-1980-2025-dataset-20-critical-texts-1980-2025/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/a-quantitative-analysis-of-critical-posture-in-art-writing-1980-2025-dataset-20-critical-texts-1980-2025/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." } }, { "field": "controlled_subjects", "value": [ { "id": "art-criticism", "label": "Art criticism", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#art-criticism", "url": "vocabulary.html#art-criticism", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:art-criticism", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Art Criticism" ], "definition": "Critical examination and discussion of artworks and encounters with art.", "scope_note": "Use for publications addressing criticism as a practice, method, or ethical responsibility.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "art-writing", "interpretation" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "research-methods", "label": "Research methods", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#research-methods", "url": "vocabulary.html#research-methods", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:research-methods", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Procedures for conducting, documenting, or evaluating an inquiry.", "scope_note": "Use for methodological discussion; narrower local terms distinguish coding, agreement, and exploratory study.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [ "coding-procedures", "inter-rater-reliability", "pilot-study" ], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "critical-language", "label": "Critical language", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#critical-language", "url": "vocabulary.html#critical-language", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:critical-language", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "The terms and linguistic choices through which critical claims are made.", "scope_note": "Use for publications examining wording, descriptive authority, restraint, or the circulation of interpretation.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "art-writing", "museum-cataloguing" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "pilot-study", "label": "Pilot study", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#pilot-study", "url": "vocabulary.html#pilot-study", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:pilot-study", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "An exploratory study used to investigate a research approach on a limited sample.", "scope_note": "For this corpus, retain the source qualification that the quantitative study is a single-coder pilot; do not imply independent validation.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [ "research-methods" ], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Local preferred terms with definitions and synonyms. External alignment is scoped in the vocabulary register." }, { "field": "genre_terms", "value": [ { "id": "genre-dataset", "label": "Dataset", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#genre-dataset", "url": "vocabulary.html#genre-dataset", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:genre-dataset", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Datasets" ], "definition": "A deposited body of research data, potentially accompanied by a report.", "scope_note": "Describes the resource genre. This selected deposit includes a PDF report; the label does not promise machine-readable tabular files.", "kind": "genre", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "type", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Local resource-genre classification. Digital file format is recorded separately." }, { "field": "archival_context", "value": { "description_profile": "moo-description-policy-1.0", "catalogue_snapshot_date": "2026-11-04", "snapshot_note": "Selected catalogue snapshot; not a live repository synchronisation.", "record_category": "Published library and repository material", "reference_code_status": "Stable local catalogue reference; not evidence of an archival acquisition or a previous catalogue accession.", "source_repository": { "name": "Zenodo", "record_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100139" }, "institutional_context_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/a-quantitative-analysis-of-critical-posture-in-art-writing-1980-2025-dataset-20-critical-texts-1980-2025/", "source_metadata_retrieved": "2026-11-04", "source_metadata_retrieval_status": "Documented in catalogue source provenance", "source_snapshot": "source/20100139.json", "source_filenames": [ "A Quantitative Analysis of Critical Posture in Art Writing, 1981–2025 (v.2).pdf" ], "selection_basis": "Local descriptive selection of publicly published material; public availability does not establish ownership of originals.", "custodial_history": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No donation, physical transfer, acquisition agreement or chain of custody is documented by this catalogue. Zenodo remains the source repository for the deposited version." }, "original_order": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No original archival order is asserted. Current browsing groupings are local editorial arrangement." }, "arrangement": { "status": "local_editorial", "grouping": "Essays & research", "statement": "A browsing grouping, not an original fonds or archival series." }, "responsible_service": { "name": "Museum of One", "service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "website": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "email": "research@museumofone.art" }, "description_method": "Source-based description with automated drafting and metadata assistance. Responsibility for the public catalogue rests with Museum of One; automated assistance does not constitute independent scholarly or curatorial review.", "policy_url": "policies.html", "correction_email": "research@museumofone.art", "access_copy": { "role": "Local digital reading copy of the deposited file", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/20100139/files/A%20Quantitative%20Analysis%20of%20Critical%20Posture%20in%20Art%20Writing,%201981%E2%80%932025%20(v.2).pdf/content", "source_filename": "A Quantitative Analysis of Critical Posture in Art Writing, 1981–2025 (v.2).pdf", "local_path": "assets/documents/20100139.pdf", "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "source_checksum_match": true, "sha256": "223c4cf7b6d70c207c37d38df3165b553eb589743cc5ad6d658c7a1c49412c92", "statement": "Access copy only; no ownership or physical custody transfer is implied." } }, "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Provenance records what is documented and leaves unknown custody and original order explicit." }, { "field": "description_history", "value": [ { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Source-based catalogue description", "note": "Local description assembled from the identified public repository record and available institutional work record. Source metadata remains separately identifiable.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/20100139", "https://www.museumofone.art/a-quantitative-analysis-of-critical-posture-in-art-writing-1980-2025-dataset-20-critical-texts-1980-2025/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Qualified descriptive enrichment", "note": "Local editorial description, arrangement and source-qualified bibliographic context recorded alongside source metadata. Unknown or disputed values remain qualified.", "fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/20100139", "https://www.museumofone.art/a-quantitative-analysis-of-critical-posture-in-art-writing-1980-2025-dataset-20-critical-texts-1980-2025/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Automated file checksum and PDF inspection", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Digital reading copy verified", "note": "Downloaded access-copy MD5 matched the source checksum; local SHA-256 and PDF file-page count are recorded in the file manifest. This event does not describe transfer of custody.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/api/records/20100139/files/A%20Quantitative%20Analysis%20of%20Critical%20Posture%20in%20Art%20Writing,%201981%E2%80%932025%20(v.2).pdf/content" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Description policy and provenance context adopted", "note": "Responsible service, source repository, local access-copy role, unknown custody and original order, correction route and dated description history made explicit under moo-description-policy-1.0.", "sources": [ "policies.html" ] }, { "event_id": "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Unify graph identities and qualify exported relationships and citations", "note": "Local graph projection now uses one contextual identity per entity, distinguishes work-level institutional matches from selected-edition links, retains title-level ISBN uncertainty, and derives citations from the source title. Typed relation assertions and a versioned validation profile are introduced. No publication date, original source snapshot or PDF changed.", "fields": [ "metadata_profile", "relationship_assertions", "identity", "institutional_match_scope", "citation_projection" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Source-based metadata implementation and regression validation", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication, source review or acquisition date", "sources": [ "metadata/metadata-profile.json" ] }, { "event_id": "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Record inspected public ORCID profile evidence", "note": "The official ORCID public person API returned the credited name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website. This confirms a matching public profile, not independently verified biographical or affiliation claims. Original creator arrays and source snapshots are unchanged.", "fields": [ "orcid_authority" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Read-only official public API inspection", "date_kind": "Local authority review and catalogue description event; not a publication or original creation date", "sources": [ "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ] } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Catalogue description events; these are not work publication dates or acquisition dates." }, { "field": "relationship_assertions", "value": [ { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:5547506b00dc3b4ecb8d9042f31bb4afbe68f28f1b61745a90f0e942c38052a6", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/20100139.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/a-quantitative-analysis-of-critical-posture-in-art-writing-1980-2025-dataset-20-critical-texts-1980-2025/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/a-quantitative-analysis-of-critical-posture-in-art-writing-1980-2025-dataset-20-critical-texts-1980-2025/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:4aea9e1eec2f4442cf3711822906d80b9c6e8ed2ae391a2a1355d431d54127ef", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/20100139.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/a-quantitative-analysis-of-critical-posture-in-art-writing-1980-2025-dataset-20-critical-texts-1980-2025/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/a-quantitative-analysis-of-critical-posture-in-art-writing-1980-2025-dataset-20-critical-texts-1980-2025/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:f79446136cb12824df8214726f0b3aa0197087b7fb23d9a4726bff7308e26e2b", "subject": "https://www.museumofone.art/a-quantitative-analysis-of-critical-posture-in-art-writing-1980-2025-dataset-20-critical-texts-1980-2025/", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#describes", "object": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20100139", "scope": "exact_edition", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/a-quantitative-analysis-of-critical-posture-in-art-writing-1980-2025-dataset-20-critical-texts-1980-2025/", "source_location": { "kind": "metadata_field", "field": "linked_zenodo_dois", "values": [ "10.5281/zenodo.18155622", "10.5281/zenodo.18205642", "10.5281/zenodo.18498483", "10.5281/zenodo.20100139" ] }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "Exact-edition matching requires the selected DOI in the reviewed page metadata; other matches retain their wider scope." } ], "status": "typed_evidence_projection", "note": "Stable, typed assertions retain source scope and explicit unknown review metadata." }, { "field": "reading_copy", "value": { "id": "20100139", "title": "A Quantitative Analysis of Critical Posture in Art Writing, 1980-2025 (Dataset - 20 Critical Texts 1980–2025) v.2", "accession": "MOO-CAT-012", "pdf_url": "../assets/documents/20100139.pdf", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/20100139/files/A%20Quantitative%20Analysis%20of%20Critical%20Posture%20in%20Art%20Writing,%201981%E2%80%932025%20(v.2).pdf/content", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100139", "source_filename": "A Quantitative Analysis of Critical Posture in Art Writing, 1981–2025 (v.2).pdf", "checksum": "md5:10d88e31592df0f1a2470ec95b96bb1c", "sha256": "223c4cf7b6d70c207c37d38df3165b553eb589743cc5ad6d658c7a1c49412c92", "bytes": 506516, "page_count": 45, "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "checksum_match": true, "rights": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "role": "Local reading copy; original repository file retained unchanged" }, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/20100139/files/A%20Quantitative%20Analysis%20of%20Critical%20Posture%20in%20Art%20Writing,%201981%E2%80%932025%20(v.2).pdf/content", "status": "derived_file_inspection", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "note": "Byte-identical local access copy. Source MD5 was recomputed and matched; SHA-256 and page count were measured from the downloaded PDF. This is not a preservation-deposit claim." }, { "field": "page_count", "value": 45, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/20100139/files/A%20Quantitative%20Analysis%20of%20Critical%20Posture%20in%20Art%20Writing,%201981%E2%80%932025%20(v.2).pdf/content", "status": "derived_file_inspection", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "note": "Total PDF file pages measured from the deposited file, including cover and unnumbered pages. Not a claim about printed pagination." } ], "entity_links": [ { "id": "dorian-vale", "label": "Dorian Vale", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "author", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/a-quantitative-analysis-of-critical-posture-in-art-writing-1980-2025-dataset-20-critical-texts-1980-2025/", "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author.", "variants": [ "Vale, Dorian" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "museum-of-one", "label": "Museum of One", "entity_type": "Organization", "relation": "publisher", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/a-quantitative-analysis-of-critical-posture-in-art-writing-1980-2025-dataset-20-critical-texts-1980-2025/", "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record.", "variants": [ "MuseumofOne", "MUSEUM OF ONE" ], "evidence_scope": "work" } ], "contents": [], "controlled_subjects": [ { "id": "art-criticism", "label": "Art criticism", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#art-criticism", "url": "vocabulary.html#art-criticism", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:art-criticism", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Art Criticism" ], "definition": "Critical examination and discussion of artworks and encounters with art.", "scope_note": "Use for publications addressing criticism as a practice, method, or ethical responsibility.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "art-writing", "interpretation" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "research-methods", "label": "Research methods", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#research-methods", "url": "vocabulary.html#research-methods", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:research-methods", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Procedures for conducting, documenting, or evaluating an inquiry.", "scope_note": "Use for methodological discussion; narrower local terms distinguish coding, agreement, and exploratory study.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [ "coding-procedures", "inter-rater-reliability", "pilot-study" ], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "critical-language", "label": "Critical language", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#critical-language", "url": "vocabulary.html#critical-language", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:critical-language", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "The terms and linguistic choices through which critical claims are made.", "scope_note": "Use for publications examining wording, descriptive authority, restraint, or the circulation of interpretation.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "art-writing", "museum-cataloguing" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "pilot-study", "label": "Pilot study", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#pilot-study", "url": "vocabulary.html#pilot-study", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:pilot-study", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "An exploratory study used to investigate a research approach on a limited sample.", "scope_note": "For this corpus, retain the source qualification that the quantitative study is a single-coder pilot; do not imply independent validation.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [ "research-methods" ], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "genre_terms": [ { "id": "genre-dataset", "label": "Dataset", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#genre-dataset", "url": "vocabulary.html#genre-dataset", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:genre-dataset", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Datasets" ], "definition": "A deposited body of research data, potentially accompanied by a report.", "scope_note": "Describes the resource genre. This selected deposit includes a PDF report; the label does not promise machine-readable tabular files.", "kind": "genre", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "type", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "vocabulary_version": 4, "description_history": [ { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Source-based catalogue description", "note": "Local description assembled from the identified public repository record and available institutional work record. Source metadata remains separately identifiable.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/20100139", "https://www.museumofone.art/a-quantitative-analysis-of-critical-posture-in-art-writing-1980-2025-dataset-20-critical-texts-1980-2025/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Qualified descriptive enrichment", "note": "Local editorial description, arrangement and source-qualified bibliographic context recorded alongside source metadata. Unknown or disputed values remain qualified.", "fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/20100139", "https://www.museumofone.art/a-quantitative-analysis-of-critical-posture-in-art-writing-1980-2025-dataset-20-critical-texts-1980-2025/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Automated file checksum and PDF inspection", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Digital reading copy verified", "note": "Downloaded access-copy MD5 matched the source checksum; local SHA-256 and PDF file-page count are recorded in the file manifest. This event does not describe transfer of custody.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/api/records/20100139/files/A%20Quantitative%20Analysis%20of%20Critical%20Posture%20in%20Art%20Writing,%201981%E2%80%932025%20(v.2).pdf/content" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Description policy and provenance context adopted", "note": "Responsible service, source repository, local access-copy role, unknown custody and original order, correction route and dated description history made explicit under moo-description-policy-1.0.", "sources": [ "policies.html" ] }, { "event_id": "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Unify graph identities and qualify exported relationships and citations", "note": "Local graph projection now uses one contextual identity per entity, distinguishes work-level institutional matches from selected-edition links, retains title-level ISBN uncertainty, and derives citations from the source title. Typed relation assertions and a versioned validation profile are introduced. No publication date, original source snapshot or PDF changed.", "fields": [ "metadata_profile", "relationship_assertions", "identity", "institutional_match_scope", "citation_projection" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Source-based metadata implementation and regression validation", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication, source review or acquisition date", "sources": [ "metadata/metadata-profile.json" ] }, { "event_id": "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Record inspected public ORCID profile evidence", "note": "The official ORCID public person API returned the credited name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website. This confirms a matching public profile, not independently verified biographical or affiliation claims. Original creator arrays and source snapshots are unchanged.", "fields": [ "orcid_authority" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Read-only official public API inspection", "date_kind": "Local authority review and catalogue description event; not a publication or original creation date", "sources": [ "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ] } ], "record_modified": "2026-11-04", "record_modified_provenance": { "status": "derived_from_description_history", "event_ids": [ "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04" ], "note": "Latest documented local description event; not a publication, repository or source-review date." }, "archival_context": { "description_profile": "moo-description-policy-1.0", "catalogue_snapshot_date": "2026-11-04", "snapshot_note": "Selected catalogue snapshot; not a live repository synchronisation.", "record_category": "Published library and repository material", "reference_code_status": "Stable local catalogue reference; not evidence of an archival acquisition or a previous catalogue accession.", "source_repository": { "name": "Zenodo", "record_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/20100139" }, "institutional_context_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/a-quantitative-analysis-of-critical-posture-in-art-writing-1980-2025-dataset-20-critical-texts-1980-2025/", "source_metadata_retrieved": "2026-11-04", "source_metadata_retrieval_status": "Documented in catalogue source provenance", "source_snapshot": "source/20100139.json", "source_filenames": [ "A Quantitative Analysis of Critical Posture in Art Writing, 1981–2025 (v.2).pdf" ], "selection_basis": "Local descriptive selection of publicly published material; public availability does not establish ownership of originals.", "custodial_history": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No donation, physical transfer, acquisition agreement or chain of custody is documented by this catalogue. Zenodo remains the source repository for the deposited version." }, "original_order": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No original archival order is asserted. Current browsing groupings are local editorial arrangement." }, "arrangement": { "status": "local_editorial", "grouping": "Essays & research", "statement": "A browsing grouping, not an original fonds or archival series." }, "responsible_service": { "name": "Museum of One", "service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "website": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "email": "research@museumofone.art" }, "description_method": "Source-based description with automated drafting and metadata assistance. Responsibility for the public catalogue rests with Museum of One; automated assistance does not constitute independent scholarly or curatorial review.", "policy_url": "policies.html", "correction_email": "research@museumofone.art", "access_copy": { "role": "Local digital reading copy of the deposited file", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/20100139/files/A%20Quantitative%20Analysis%20of%20Critical%20Posture%20in%20Art%20Writing,%201981%E2%80%932025%20(v.2).pdf/content", "source_filename": "A Quantitative Analysis of Critical Posture in Art Writing, 1981–2025 (v.2).pdf", "local_path": "assets/documents/20100139.pdf", "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "source_checksum_match": true, "sha256": "223c4cf7b6d70c207c37d38df3165b553eb589743cc5ad6d658c7a1c49412c92", "statement": "Access copy only; no ownership or physical custody transfer is implied." } }, "description_policy_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "pirr_references": [], "pirr_work_identity": { "archive_reference": "MOO-CAT-012", "edition_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.20100139", "zenodo_record_id": "20100139", "identifier_scope": "Publication identity; PIRR identifiers in programme relationships identify research records, not this publication." }, "metadata_origin": "https://archive.museumofone.art", "identity": { "work": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/20100139.html#work", "edition": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20100139", "version_family": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.18205642", "catalogue_record": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/20100139.html#catalogue-record" }, "institutional_match_scope": "exact_edition", "relationship_assertions": [ { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:5547506b00dc3b4ecb8d9042f31bb4afbe68f28f1b61745a90f0e942c38052a6", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/20100139.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/a-quantitative-analysis-of-critical-posture-in-art-writing-1980-2025-dataset-20-critical-texts-1980-2025/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/a-quantitative-analysis-of-critical-posture-in-art-writing-1980-2025-dataset-20-critical-texts-1980-2025/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:4aea9e1eec2f4442cf3711822906d80b9c6e8ed2ae391a2a1355d431d54127ef", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/20100139.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/a-quantitative-analysis-of-critical-posture-in-art-writing-1980-2025-dataset-20-critical-texts-1980-2025/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/a-quantitative-analysis-of-critical-posture-in-art-writing-1980-2025-dataset-20-critical-texts-1980-2025/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:f79446136cb12824df8214726f0b3aa0197087b7fb23d9a4726bff7308e26e2b", "subject": "https://www.museumofone.art/a-quantitative-analysis-of-critical-posture-in-art-writing-1980-2025-dataset-20-critical-texts-1980-2025/", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#describes", "object": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20100139", "scope": "exact_edition", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/a-quantitative-analysis-of-critical-posture-in-art-writing-1980-2025-dataset-20-critical-texts-1980-2025/", "source_location": { "kind": "metadata_field", "field": "linked_zenodo_dois", "values": [ "10.5281/zenodo.18155622", "10.5281/zenodo.18205642", "10.5281/zenodo.18498483", "10.5281/zenodo.20100139" ] }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "Exact-edition matching requires the selected DOI in the reviewed page metadata; other matches retain their wider scope." } ], "orcid_authority": { "scheme": "ORCID", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "evidence_urls": [ "https://www.museumofone.art/archives-scholarly-infrastructure/", "https://eprints.rclis.org/47182/", "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ], "access_note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "evidence_receipt": "data/source/authority-review-2026-11-04.json" } }, { "id": "21786998", "accession": "MOO-CAT-013", "title": "Interpretation at Risk: Post-Interpretive Criticism After the 20th Century", "source_title": "Interpretation at Risk: Post-Interpretive Criticism After the 20th Century", "short_title": "Interpretation at Risk", "author": "Dorian Vale", "creators": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "affiliation": "Museum of One", "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094" } ], "doi": "10.5281/zenodo.21786998", "conceptdoi": "10.5281/zenodo.18104019", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21786998", "date": "2025-12-31", "type": "Journal article", "source_resource_type": { "title": "Journal article", "type": "publication", "subtype": "article" }, "version": "", "collection": "Theory & treatises", "summary": "An early theoretical essay that questions the assumption that interpretation provides a neutral foundation for aesthetic meaning, proposing instead that mediation carries ethical consequences.", "subjects": [ "Aesthetic theory", "Interpretation", "Critical language", "Post-Interpretive Criticism" ], "keywords": [ "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "interpretation", "aesthetics", "phenomenology", "art criticism", "ethics of witnessing" ], "license": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "files": [ { "name": "Interpretation at Risk Post-Interpretive Criticism After the 20th Century.pdf", "url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/21786998/files/Interpretation%20at%20Risk%20Post-Interpretive%20Criticism%20After%20the%2020th%20Century.pdf/content", "size": 229568, "size_label": "224 KB", "checksum": "md5:d18570c20f85fd773c64d6f7730443d3", "mimetype": "application/pdf" } ], "institutional_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/interpretation-at-risk-post-interpretive-criticism-after-the-20th-century/", "corroboration": "Museum of One’s matching publication page confirms Dorian Vale’s authorship and the work’s institutional context. Its repository links and publication dates are retained separately from this selected Zenodo edition. Web-record dates are not treated as dates of the deposited edition. Source review: 4 November 2026.", "discrepancies": [], "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "publisher": "Museum of One", "language": null, "isbn": null, "related_identifiers": [ { "identifier": "2819-7232", "relation": "isPublishedIn", "scheme": "issn" } ], "alternate_identifiers": [], "source_references": [], "source_journal": { "title": "Post-interpretive criticism" }, "source_imprint": null, "source_contributors": [ { "name": "Museum of One", "affiliation": null, "type": "HostingInstitution" } ], "source_created": "2026-08-04T07:48:39.211908+00:00", "source_modified": "2026-10-15T12:20:13.956799+00:00", "source_description_html": "

Title:

\n

Interpretation at Risk: Post‑Interpretive Criticism After the 20th Century

\n

Author:

\n

Dorian Vale

\n

Affiliation:

\n

Museum of One — Registered Archive and Independent Research Institute for Contemporary Aesthetics

\n

Abstract:

\n

This essay establishes Post‑Interpretive Criticism as a formal break with the dominant aesthetic consensus of the late twentieth century, which treated meaning as something produced through mediation rather than encountered through structure. Surveying post‑1950 traditions across structuralism, hermeneutics, phenomenology, critical theory, and post‑structuralism, the essay identifies a shared assumption underlying their disagreements: interpretation functions as the necessary and ethically justified ground of meaning. Post‑Interpretive Criticism rejects this premise not by proposing an alternative theory of meaning‑production, but by questioning whether production itself is the correct frame.

\n

The essay argues that interpretation is not neutral, inevitable, or inherently liberatory, but structurally hazardous. Language, when introduced prematurely or excessively, alters the proportions of the aesthetic encounter, collapsing interval, crowding distance, and displacing presence with discourse. Meaning, on this account, does not originate in interpretation but in a relational field between work and witness that possesses structure prior to mediation. Interpretation is therefore recast as an intervention rather than a foundation—one that must justify itself ethically by preserving proportion rather than overwhelming it.

\n

Positioning Post‑Interpretive Criticism against the historical conditions that necessitated interpretive excess in the post‑war period, the essay argues that contemporary aesthetics now faces the inverse problem: interpretive saturation. Where interpretation once functioned as moral responsibility, it now frequently preempts encounter, substituting commentary for perception. Drawing careful distinctions from phenomenological aesthetics, the essay emphasizes that description of experience is insufficient without a discipline governing speech. Post‑Interpretive Criticism introduces restraint as method, silence as ethical posture, and proportion as evaluative criterion.

\n

The essay concludes by outlining the institutional, pedagogical, and critical consequences of adopting Post‑Interpretive Criticism, including reduced interpretive authority, contraction of discourse, and the re‑training of attention prior to articulation. It does not argue for universal application, but claims necessity under specific contemporary conditions. Interpretation, once required, is now placed at risk—not because meaning has vanished, but because the encounter has returned as the primary site of aesthetic responsibility.

\n

Dorian Vale is a chosen pseudonym, not to obscure identity, but to preserve clarity of voice and integrity of message. It creates distance between the writer and the work, allowing the philosophy to stand unclouded by biography. The name exists not to hide, but to honor the seriousness of the task: to speak without spectacle, and to build without needing to be seen.

\n

First published by Museum of One on 31 December 2025. Stable work DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.18104019

", "provenance": { "repository": "Zenodo REST API response supplied in query.json", "retrieved": "2026-11-04", "editorial_fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "source_snapshot": "source/21786998.json", "institutional_review": "Reviewed page-level title, author and repository links in saved public institutional HTML, 2026-11-04." }, "source_review": "2026-11-04", "relations": [ { "identifier": "2819-7232", "relation": "isPublishedIn", "scheme": "issn" } ], "institutional_metadata": { "title": "Interpretation at Risk: Post-Interpretive Criticism After the 20th Century", "author": "Dorian Vale", "web_publication": "2025-12-31T06:13:00.000Z", "web_updated": "2026-11-03T00:42:11.000Z", "linked_zenodo_dois": [ "10.5281/zenodo.18104019" ], "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/interpretation-at-risk-post-interpretive-criticism-after-the-20th-century/" }, "research_programmes": [], "record_level": "Item", "record_status": "Published source; selected catalogue record", "digital_formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "extent": "1 digital file; 229568 bytes", "medium": "Digital document", "record_reviewed": "2026-11-04", "date_precision": "day", "alternate_titles": [], "digital_extent": { "file_count": 1, "total_bytes": 229568, "formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "checksums": [ { "filename": "Interpretation at Risk Post-Interpretive Criticism After the 20th Century.pdf", "algorithm": "md5", "value": "d18570c20f85fd773c64d6f7730443d3", "syntax_valid": true, "verification": "source_checksum_transcription; bytes not independently recomputed" } ], "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21786998", "derivation": "File count and total bytes calculated from repository file metadata; MIME inferred from filename when absent." }, "identifier_validation": { "orcid": { "source_value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "ISO 7064 MOD 11-2 checksum only; this is not a live registry verification." }, "isbn": [], "doi": { "source_value": "10.5281/zenodo.21786998", "syntax_valid": true, "note": "Syntax check only; repository snapshot supplies the identifier." }, "issn": { "source_value": "2819-7232", "checksum_valid": true, "scope": "serial identifier, not item DOI or ISBN", "note": "Checksum only; source relationship and authority-record status are documented separately." } }, "isbn_applicability": "not_supplied", "serial": { "title": "Post-interpretive criticism", "issn": "2819-7232", "url": "https://portal.issn.org/resource/ISSN/2819-7232", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21786998", "source_relation": "isPublishedIn", "authority_status": "independent_authority_record_metadata_observed_in_search_index" }, "contributor_roles": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": "Museum of One", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21786998" }, { "name": "Museum of One", "source_category": "contributor", "source_role": "HostingInstitution", "role_label": "HostingInstitution", "affiliation_as_supplied": null, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21786998" } ], "authority_links": [], "metadata_profile": { "name": "Museum of One source-qualified catalogue profile", "version": "3.0.0", "url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/metadata-profile.json", "source_snapshot_preserved": true }, "reading_copy": { "id": "21786998", "title": "Interpretation at Risk: Post-Interpretive Criticism After the 20th Century", "accession": "MOO-CAT-013", "pdf_url": "../assets/documents/21786998.pdf", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/21786998/files/Interpretation%20at%20Risk%20Post-Interpretive%20Criticism%20After%20the%2020th%20Century.pdf/content", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21786998", "source_filename": "Interpretation at Risk Post-Interpretive Criticism After the 20th Century.pdf", "checksum": "md5:d18570c20f85fd773c64d6f7730443d3", "sha256": "925b0b72d3349f32d6dbbc595baea96390439e36275d576a6d33fa4ce1fe3ff8", "bytes": 229568, "page_count": 6, "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "checksum_match": true, "rights": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "role": "Local reading copy; original repository file retained unchanged" }, "page_count": 6, "field_assertions": [ { "field": "title", "value": "Interpretation at Risk: Post-Interpretive Criticism After the 20th Century", "status": "catalogue_title", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/interpretation-at-risk-post-interpretive-criticism-after-the-20th-century/", "note": "Local display title; the deposited title is retained separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_title", "value": "Interpretation at Risk: Post-Interpretive Criticism After the 20th Century", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21786998", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "doi", "value": "10.5281/zenodo.21786998", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21786998", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "date", "value": "2025-12-31", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21786998", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "conceptdoi", "value": "10.5281/zenodo.18104019", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21786998", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "creators", "value": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "affiliation": "Museum of One", "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21786998", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "keywords", "value": [ "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "interpretation", "aesthetics", "phenomenology", "art criticism", "ethics of witnessing" ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21786998", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "license", "value": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21786998", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "files", "value": [ { "name": "Interpretation at Risk Post-Interpretive Criticism After the 20th Century.pdf", "url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/21786998/files/Interpretation%20at%20Risk%20Post-Interpretive%20Criticism%20After%20the%2020th%20Century.pdf/content", "size": 229568, "size_label": "224 KB", "checksum": "md5:d18570c20f85fd773c64d6f7730443d3", "mimetype": "application/pdf" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21786998", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_created", "value": "2026-08-04T07:48:39.211908+00:00", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21786998", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_modified", "value": "2026-10-15T12:20:13.956799+00:00", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21786998", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "record_modified", "value": "2026-11-04", "status": "derived_from_description_history", "note": "Latest documented local description event; not a publication, repository or source-review date.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_review", "value": "2026-11-04", "status": "catalogue_source_review", "note": "Review of descriptive sources; not the creation or modification date of the work or repository record.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "author", "value": "Dorian Vale", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/interpretation-at-risk-post-interpretive-criticism-after-the-20th-century/", "note": "Institutional responsibility statement; original repository creator roles remain separate.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "publisher", "value": "Museum of One", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/interpretation-at-risk-post-interpretive-criticism-after-the-20th-century/", "note": "Institutional responsibility statement; original repository creator roles remain separate.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "orcid", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "source_linked_identifier", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/interpretation-at-risk-post-interpretive-criticism-after-the-20th-century/", "note": "Creator identifier supplied by the linked sources; no affiliation or endorsement is inferred.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "orcid_authority", "value": { "scheme": "ORCID", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "evidence_urls": [ "https://www.museumofone.art/archives-scholarly-infrastructure/", "https://eprints.rclis.org/47182/", "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ], "access_note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "evidence_receipt": "data/source/authority-review-2026-11-04.json" }, "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "source_url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "summary", "value": "An early theoretical essay that questions the assumption that interpretation provides a neutral foundation for aesthetic meaning, proposing instead that mediation carries ethical consequences.", "status": "editorial_enrichment", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/interpretation-at-risk-post-interpretive-criticism-after-the-20th-century/", "note": "Catalogue-editor summary based on the linked work; not an original publisher abstract.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "subjects", "value": [ "Aesthetic theory", "Interpretation", "Critical language", "Post-Interpretive Criticism" ], "status": "editorial_enrichment", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/interpretation-at-risk-post-interpretive-criticism-after-the-20th-century/", "note": "Local discovery terms; no controlled-vocabulary assignment is claimed.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "collection", "value": "Theory & treatises", "status": "editorial_grouping", "note": "A local browsing collection, not an original repository collection.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "corroboration", "value": "Museum of One’s matching publication page confirms Dorian Vale’s authorship and the work’s institutional context. Its repository links and publication dates are retained separately from this selected Zenodo edition. Web-record dates are not treated as dates of the deposited edition. Source review: 4 November 2026.", "status": "catalogue_review_note", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/interpretation-at-risk-post-interpretive-criticism-after-the-20th-century/", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "date_precision", "value": "day", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21786998", "note": "Precision reported exactly as supplied; missing month or day is not filled.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "medium", "value": "Digital document", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21786998", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "digital_formats", "value": [ "application/pdf" ], "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21786998", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "extent", "value": "1 digital file; 229568 bytes", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21786998", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "digital_extent", "value": { "file_count": 1, "total_bytes": 229568, "formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "checksums": [ { "filename": "Interpretation at Risk Post-Interpretive Criticism After the 20th Century.pdf", "algorithm": "md5", "value": "d18570c20f85fd773c64d6f7730443d3", "syntax_valid": true, "verification": "source_checksum_transcription; bytes not independently recomputed" } ], "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21786998", "derivation": "File count and total bytes calculated from repository file metadata; MIME inferred from filename when absent." }, "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21786998", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "identifier_validation", "value": { "orcid": { "source_value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "ISO 7064 MOD 11-2 checksum only; this is not a live registry verification." }, "isbn": [], "doi": { "source_value": "10.5281/zenodo.21786998", "syntax_valid": true, "note": "Syntax check only; repository snapshot supplies the identifier." }, "issn": { "source_value": "2819-7232", "checksum_valid": true, "scope": "serial identifier, not item DOI or ISBN", "note": "Checksum only; source relationship and authority-record status are documented separately." } }, "status": "local_syntax_validation", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21786998", "note": "Checksum/syntax validation does not verify registration, assignment or edition applicability.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "contributor_roles", "value": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": "Museum of One", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21786998" }, { "name": "Museum of One", "source_category": "contributor", "source_role": "HostingInstitution", "role_label": "HostingInstitution", "affiliation_as_supplied": null, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21786998" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21786998", "note": "Creator and contributor roles are transcribed, not inferred from names or affiliations.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "serial", "value": { "title": "Post-interpretive criticism", "issn": "2819-7232", "url": "https://portal.issn.org/resource/ISSN/2819-7232", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21786998", "source_relation": "isPublishedIn", "authority_status": "independent_authority_record_metadata_observed_in_search_index" }, "status": "source_declared_relationship", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21786998", "note": "Serial context is attached only where the repository declares the ISSN relationship.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "entity_link:dorian-vale:author", "value": { "id": "dorian-vale", "label": "Dorian Vale", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "author", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/interpretation-at-risk-post-interpretive-criticism-after-the-20th-century/", "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author.", "variants": [ "Vale, Dorian" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/interpretation-at-risk-post-interpretive-criticism-after-the-20th-century/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:13b099ea17921d86fa2d30001802f28fa817f5d987c066afdf55d18ad421aeb5", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21786998.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/interpretation-at-risk-post-interpretive-criticism-after-the-20th-century/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/interpretation-at-risk-post-interpretive-criticism-after-the-20th-century/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." } }, { "field": "entity_link:museum-of-one:publisher", "value": { "id": "museum-of-one", "label": "Museum of One", "entity_type": "Organization", "relation": "publisher", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/interpretation-at-risk-post-interpretive-criticism-after-the-20th-century/", "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record.", "variants": [ "MuseumofOne", "MUSEUM OF ONE" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/interpretation-at-risk-post-interpretive-criticism-after-the-20th-century/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:e4fa74277e141b7594a3929de1a6a60faf1b409d1bdcfa61f33f37545e504209", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21786998.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/interpretation-at-risk-post-interpretive-criticism-after-the-20th-century/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/interpretation-at-risk-post-interpretive-criticism-after-the-20th-century/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." } }, { "field": "controlled_subjects", "value": [ { "id": "aesthetic-theory", "label": "Aesthetic theory", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#aesthetic-theory", "url": "vocabulary.html#aesthetic-theory", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:aesthetic-theory", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Theoretical propositions about how art is encountered, understood, or valued.", "scope_note": "Use for explicit theoretical argument; distinguish the wider field of Aesthetics.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [ "aesthetics" ], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "interpretation", "label": "Interpretation", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#interpretation", "url": "vocabulary.html#interpretation", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:interpretation", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "The production and negotiation of meaning in encounters with art.", "scope_note": "Use for discussion of interpretive activity and its limits; separate from the specific local Post-Interpretive Criticism framework.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "art-criticism" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "critical-language", "label": "Critical language", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#critical-language", "url": "vocabulary.html#critical-language", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:critical-language", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "The terms and linguistic choices through which critical claims are made.", "scope_note": "Use for publications examining wording, descriptive authority, restraint, or the circulation of interpretation.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "art-writing", "museum-cataloguing" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "post-interpretive-criticism", "label": "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#post-interpretive-criticism", "url": "vocabulary.html#post-interpretive-criticism", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:post-interpretive-criticism", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "PIC", "Post Interpretive Criticism" ], "definition": "The critical framework named and developed in the Museum of One publications.", "scope_note": "Local named intellectual framework. Used for records explicitly concerned with it; no Getty, Library of Congress, or other external equivalence is asserted.", "kind": "local-framework-concept", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "custodianship", "ethics-of-witnessing", "foundational-writings", "moral-proximity" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Local preferred terms with definitions and synonyms. External alignment is scoped in the vocabulary register." }, { "field": "genre_terms", "value": [ { "id": "genre-journal-article", "label": "Journal article", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#genre-journal-article", "url": "vocabulary.html#genre-journal-article", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:genre-journal-article", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Journal articles" ], "definition": "A contribution issued as part of a journal or periodical.", "scope_note": "Describes publication genre based on the catalogued source record; peer-review status is a separate question.", "kind": "genre", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "verified_mapping", "external_mappings": [ { "vocabulary": "Getty Art & Architecture Thesaurus", "label": "articles", "uri": "http://vocab.getty.edu/aat/300048715", "source_url": "https://www.getty.edu/vow/AATFullDisplay?find=&logic=AND¬e=&subjectid=300048715", "relation": "broadMatch", "status": "verified", "verified_on": "2026-11-04", "note": "Getty’s articles concept includes contributions to magazines, newspapers, encyclopedias, and other works; journal article is the narrower local genre." } ], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "type", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Local resource-genre classification. Digital file format is recorded separately." }, { "field": "archival_context", "value": { "description_profile": "moo-description-policy-1.0", "catalogue_snapshot_date": "2026-11-04", "snapshot_note": "Selected catalogue snapshot; not a live repository synchronisation.", "record_category": "Published library and repository material", "reference_code_status": "Stable local catalogue reference; not evidence of an archival acquisition or a previous catalogue accession.", "source_repository": { "name": "Zenodo", "record_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21786998" }, "institutional_context_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/interpretation-at-risk-post-interpretive-criticism-after-the-20th-century/", "source_metadata_retrieved": "2026-11-04", "source_metadata_retrieval_status": "Documented in catalogue source provenance", "source_snapshot": "source/21786998.json", "source_filenames": [ "Interpretation at Risk Post-Interpretive Criticism After the 20th Century.pdf" ], "selection_basis": "Local descriptive selection of publicly published material; public availability does not establish ownership of originals.", "custodial_history": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No donation, physical transfer, acquisition agreement or chain of custody is documented by this catalogue. Zenodo remains the source repository for the deposited version." }, "original_order": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No original archival order is asserted. Current browsing groupings are local editorial arrangement." }, "arrangement": { "status": "local_editorial", "grouping": "Theory & treatises", "statement": "A browsing grouping, not an original fonds or archival series." }, "responsible_service": { "name": "Museum of One", "service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "website": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "email": "research@museumofone.art" }, "description_method": "Source-based description with automated drafting and metadata assistance. Responsibility for the public catalogue rests with Museum of One; automated assistance does not constitute independent scholarly or curatorial review.", "policy_url": "policies.html", "correction_email": "research@museumofone.art", "access_copy": { "role": "Local digital reading copy of the deposited file", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/21786998/files/Interpretation%20at%20Risk%20Post-Interpretive%20Criticism%20After%20the%2020th%20Century.pdf/content", "source_filename": "Interpretation at Risk Post-Interpretive Criticism After the 20th Century.pdf", "local_path": "assets/documents/21786998.pdf", "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "source_checksum_match": true, "sha256": "925b0b72d3349f32d6dbbc595baea96390439e36275d576a6d33fa4ce1fe3ff8", "statement": "Access copy only; no ownership or physical custody transfer is implied." } }, "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Provenance records what is documented and leaves unknown custody and original order explicit." }, { "field": "description_history", "value": [ { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Source-based catalogue description", "note": "Local description assembled from the identified public repository record and available institutional work record. Source metadata remains separately identifiable.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/21786998", "https://www.museumofone.art/interpretation-at-risk-post-interpretive-criticism-after-the-20th-century/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Qualified descriptive enrichment", "note": "Local editorial description, arrangement and source-qualified bibliographic context recorded alongside source metadata. Unknown or disputed values remain qualified.", "fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/21786998", "https://www.museumofone.art/interpretation-at-risk-post-interpretive-criticism-after-the-20th-century/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Automated file checksum and PDF inspection", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Digital reading copy verified", "note": "Downloaded access-copy MD5 matched the source checksum; local SHA-256 and PDF file-page count are recorded in the file manifest. This event does not describe transfer of custody.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/api/records/21786998/files/Interpretation%20at%20Risk%20Post-Interpretive%20Criticism%20After%20the%2020th%20Century.pdf/content" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Description policy and provenance context adopted", "note": "Responsible service, source repository, local access-copy role, unknown custody and original order, correction route and dated description history made explicit under moo-description-policy-1.0.", "sources": [ "policies.html" ] }, { "event_id": "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Unify graph identities and qualify exported relationships and citations", "note": "Local graph projection now uses one contextual identity per entity, distinguishes work-level institutional matches from selected-edition links, retains title-level ISBN uncertainty, and derives citations from the source title. Typed relation assertions and a versioned validation profile are introduced. No publication date, original source snapshot or PDF changed.", "fields": [ "metadata_profile", "relationship_assertions", "identity", "institutional_match_scope", "citation_projection" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Source-based metadata implementation and regression validation", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication, source review or acquisition date", "sources": [ "metadata/metadata-profile.json" ] }, { "event_id": "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Record inspected public ORCID profile evidence", "note": "The official ORCID public person API returned the credited name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website. This confirms a matching public profile, not independently verified biographical or affiliation claims. Original creator arrays and source snapshots are unchanged.", "fields": [ "orcid_authority" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Read-only official public API inspection", "date_kind": "Local authority review and catalogue description event; not a publication or original creation date", "sources": [ "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ] } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Catalogue description events; these are not work publication dates or acquisition dates." }, { "field": "relationship_assertions", "value": [ { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:13b099ea17921d86fa2d30001802f28fa817f5d987c066afdf55d18ad421aeb5", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21786998.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/interpretation-at-risk-post-interpretive-criticism-after-the-20th-century/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/interpretation-at-risk-post-interpretive-criticism-after-the-20th-century/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:e4fa74277e141b7594a3929de1a6a60faf1b409d1bdcfa61f33f37545e504209", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21786998.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/interpretation-at-risk-post-interpretive-criticism-after-the-20th-century/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/interpretation-at-risk-post-interpretive-criticism-after-the-20th-century/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:7d1c2884b41c70421f274214204a17de0a8af9c36435e9069bcf864172d69f08", "subject": "https://www.museumofone.art/interpretation-at-risk-post-interpretive-criticism-after-the-20th-century/", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#describes", "object": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.18104019", "scope": "version_family", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/interpretation-at-risk-post-interpretive-criticism-after-the-20th-century/", "source_location": { "kind": "metadata_field", "field": "linked_zenodo_dois", "values": [ "10.5281/zenodo.18104019" ] }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "Exact-edition matching requires the selected DOI in the reviewed page metadata; other matches retain their wider scope." } ], "status": "typed_evidence_projection", "note": "Stable, typed assertions retain source scope and explicit unknown review metadata." }, { "field": "reading_copy", "value": { "id": "21786998", "title": "Interpretation at Risk: Post-Interpretive Criticism After the 20th Century", "accession": "MOO-CAT-013", "pdf_url": "../assets/documents/21786998.pdf", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/21786998/files/Interpretation%20at%20Risk%20Post-Interpretive%20Criticism%20After%20the%2020th%20Century.pdf/content", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21786998", "source_filename": "Interpretation at Risk Post-Interpretive Criticism After the 20th Century.pdf", "checksum": "md5:d18570c20f85fd773c64d6f7730443d3", "sha256": "925b0b72d3349f32d6dbbc595baea96390439e36275d576a6d33fa4ce1fe3ff8", "bytes": 229568, "page_count": 6, "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "checksum_match": true, "rights": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "role": "Local reading copy; original repository file retained unchanged" }, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/21786998/files/Interpretation%20at%20Risk%20Post-Interpretive%20Criticism%20After%20the%2020th%20Century.pdf/content", "status": "derived_file_inspection", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "note": "Byte-identical local access copy. Source MD5 was recomputed and matched; SHA-256 and page count were measured from the downloaded PDF. This is not a preservation-deposit claim." }, { "field": "page_count", "value": 6, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/21786998/files/Interpretation%20at%20Risk%20Post-Interpretive%20Criticism%20After%20the%2020th%20Century.pdf/content", "status": "derived_file_inspection", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "note": "Total PDF file pages measured from the deposited file, including cover and unnumbered pages. Not a claim about printed pagination." } ], "entity_links": [ { "id": "dorian-vale", "label": "Dorian Vale", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "author", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/interpretation-at-risk-post-interpretive-criticism-after-the-20th-century/", "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author.", "variants": [ "Vale, Dorian" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "museum-of-one", "label": "Museum of One", "entity_type": "Organization", "relation": "publisher", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/interpretation-at-risk-post-interpretive-criticism-after-the-20th-century/", "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record.", "variants": [ "MuseumofOne", "MUSEUM OF ONE" ], "evidence_scope": "work" } ], "contents": [], "controlled_subjects": [ { "id": "aesthetic-theory", "label": "Aesthetic theory", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#aesthetic-theory", "url": "vocabulary.html#aesthetic-theory", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:aesthetic-theory", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Theoretical propositions about how art is encountered, understood, or valued.", "scope_note": "Use for explicit theoretical argument; distinguish the wider field of Aesthetics.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [ "aesthetics" ], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "interpretation", "label": "Interpretation", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#interpretation", "url": "vocabulary.html#interpretation", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:interpretation", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "The production and negotiation of meaning in encounters with art.", "scope_note": "Use for discussion of interpretive activity and its limits; separate from the specific local Post-Interpretive Criticism framework.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "art-criticism" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "critical-language", "label": "Critical language", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#critical-language", "url": "vocabulary.html#critical-language", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:critical-language", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "The terms and linguistic choices through which critical claims are made.", "scope_note": "Use for publications examining wording, descriptive authority, restraint, or the circulation of interpretation.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "art-writing", "museum-cataloguing" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "post-interpretive-criticism", "label": "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#post-interpretive-criticism", "url": "vocabulary.html#post-interpretive-criticism", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:post-interpretive-criticism", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "PIC", "Post Interpretive Criticism" ], "definition": "The critical framework named and developed in the Museum of One publications.", "scope_note": "Local named intellectual framework. Used for records explicitly concerned with it; no Getty, Library of Congress, or other external equivalence is asserted.", "kind": "local-framework-concept", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "custodianship", "ethics-of-witnessing", "foundational-writings", "moral-proximity" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "genre_terms": [ { "id": "genre-journal-article", "label": "Journal article", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#genre-journal-article", "url": "vocabulary.html#genre-journal-article", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:genre-journal-article", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Journal articles" ], "definition": "A contribution issued as part of a journal or periodical.", "scope_note": "Describes publication genre based on the catalogued source record; peer-review status is a separate question.", "kind": "genre", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "verified_mapping", "external_mappings": [ { "vocabulary": "Getty Art & Architecture Thesaurus", "label": "articles", "uri": "http://vocab.getty.edu/aat/300048715", "source_url": "https://www.getty.edu/vow/AATFullDisplay?find=&logic=AND¬e=&subjectid=300048715", "relation": "broadMatch", "status": "verified", "verified_on": "2026-11-04", "note": "Getty’s articles concept includes contributions to magazines, newspapers, encyclopedias, and other works; journal article is the narrower local genre." } ], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "type", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "vocabulary_version": 4, "description_history": [ { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Source-based catalogue description", "note": "Local description assembled from the identified public repository record and available institutional work record. Source metadata remains separately identifiable.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/21786998", "https://www.museumofone.art/interpretation-at-risk-post-interpretive-criticism-after-the-20th-century/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Qualified descriptive enrichment", "note": "Local editorial description, arrangement and source-qualified bibliographic context recorded alongside source metadata. Unknown or disputed values remain qualified.", "fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/21786998", "https://www.museumofone.art/interpretation-at-risk-post-interpretive-criticism-after-the-20th-century/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Automated file checksum and PDF inspection", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Digital reading copy verified", "note": "Downloaded access-copy MD5 matched the source checksum; local SHA-256 and PDF file-page count are recorded in the file manifest. This event does not describe transfer of custody.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/api/records/21786998/files/Interpretation%20at%20Risk%20Post-Interpretive%20Criticism%20After%20the%2020th%20Century.pdf/content" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Description policy and provenance context adopted", "note": "Responsible service, source repository, local access-copy role, unknown custody and original order, correction route and dated description history made explicit under moo-description-policy-1.0.", "sources": [ "policies.html" ] }, { "event_id": "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Unify graph identities and qualify exported relationships and citations", "note": "Local graph projection now uses one contextual identity per entity, distinguishes work-level institutional matches from selected-edition links, retains title-level ISBN uncertainty, and derives citations from the source title. Typed relation assertions and a versioned validation profile are introduced. No publication date, original source snapshot or PDF changed.", "fields": [ "metadata_profile", "relationship_assertions", "identity", "institutional_match_scope", "citation_projection" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Source-based metadata implementation and regression validation", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication, source review or acquisition date", "sources": [ "metadata/metadata-profile.json" ] }, { "event_id": "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Record inspected public ORCID profile evidence", "note": "The official ORCID public person API returned the credited name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website. This confirms a matching public profile, not independently verified biographical or affiliation claims. Original creator arrays and source snapshots are unchanged.", "fields": [ "orcid_authority" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Read-only official public API inspection", "date_kind": "Local authority review and catalogue description event; not a publication or original creation date", "sources": [ "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ] } ], "record_modified": "2026-11-04", "record_modified_provenance": { "status": "derived_from_description_history", "event_ids": [ "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04" ], "note": "Latest documented local description event; not a publication, repository or source-review date." }, "archival_context": { "description_profile": "moo-description-policy-1.0", "catalogue_snapshot_date": "2026-11-04", "snapshot_note": "Selected catalogue snapshot; not a live repository synchronisation.", "record_category": "Published library and repository material", "reference_code_status": "Stable local catalogue reference; not evidence of an archival acquisition or a previous catalogue accession.", "source_repository": { "name": "Zenodo", "record_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/21786998" }, "institutional_context_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/interpretation-at-risk-post-interpretive-criticism-after-the-20th-century/", "source_metadata_retrieved": "2026-11-04", "source_metadata_retrieval_status": "Documented in catalogue source provenance", "source_snapshot": "source/21786998.json", "source_filenames": [ "Interpretation at Risk Post-Interpretive Criticism After the 20th Century.pdf" ], "selection_basis": "Local descriptive selection of publicly published material; public availability does not establish ownership of originals.", "custodial_history": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No donation, physical transfer, acquisition agreement or chain of custody is documented by this catalogue. Zenodo remains the source repository for the deposited version." }, "original_order": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No original archival order is asserted. Current browsing groupings are local editorial arrangement." }, "arrangement": { "status": "local_editorial", "grouping": "Theory & treatises", "statement": "A browsing grouping, not an original fonds or archival series." }, "responsible_service": { "name": "Museum of One", "service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "website": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "email": "research@museumofone.art" }, "description_method": "Source-based description with automated drafting and metadata assistance. Responsibility for the public catalogue rests with Museum of One; automated assistance does not constitute independent scholarly or curatorial review.", "policy_url": "policies.html", "correction_email": "research@museumofone.art", "access_copy": { "role": "Local digital reading copy of the deposited file", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/21786998/files/Interpretation%20at%20Risk%20Post-Interpretive%20Criticism%20After%20the%2020th%20Century.pdf/content", "source_filename": "Interpretation at Risk Post-Interpretive Criticism After the 20th Century.pdf", "local_path": "assets/documents/21786998.pdf", "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "source_checksum_match": true, "sha256": "925b0b72d3349f32d6dbbc595baea96390439e36275d576a6d33fa4ce1fe3ff8", "statement": "Access copy only; no ownership or physical custody transfer is implied." } }, "description_policy_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "pirr_references": [], "pirr_work_identity": { "archive_reference": "MOO-CAT-013", "edition_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.21786998", "zenodo_record_id": "21786998", "identifier_scope": "Publication identity; PIRR identifiers in programme relationships identify research records, not this publication." }, "metadata_origin": "https://archive.museumofone.art", "identity": { "work": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21786998.html#work", "edition": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21786998", "version_family": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.18104019", "catalogue_record": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21786998.html#catalogue-record" }, "institutional_match_scope": "version_family", "relationship_assertions": [ { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:13b099ea17921d86fa2d30001802f28fa817f5d987c066afdf55d18ad421aeb5", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21786998.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/interpretation-at-risk-post-interpretive-criticism-after-the-20th-century/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/interpretation-at-risk-post-interpretive-criticism-after-the-20th-century/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:e4fa74277e141b7594a3929de1a6a60faf1b409d1bdcfa61f33f37545e504209", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/21786998.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/interpretation-at-risk-post-interpretive-criticism-after-the-20th-century/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/interpretation-at-risk-post-interpretive-criticism-after-the-20th-century/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:7d1c2884b41c70421f274214204a17de0a8af9c36435e9069bcf864172d69f08", "subject": "https://www.museumofone.art/interpretation-at-risk-post-interpretive-criticism-after-the-20th-century/", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#describes", "object": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.18104019", "scope": "version_family", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/interpretation-at-risk-post-interpretive-criticism-after-the-20th-century/", "source_location": { "kind": "metadata_field", "field": "linked_zenodo_dois", "values": [ "10.5281/zenodo.18104019" ] }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "Exact-edition matching requires the selected DOI in the reviewed page metadata; other matches retain their wider scope." } ], "orcid_authority": { "scheme": "ORCID", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "evidence_urls": [ "https://www.museumofone.art/archives-scholarly-infrastructure/", "https://eprints.rclis.org/47182/", "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ], "access_note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "evidence_receipt": "data/source/authority-review-2026-11-04.json" } }, { "id": "19863790", "accession": "MOO-CAT-014", "title": "Moral Proximity: Ethics as Method in Post-Interpretive Criticism", "source_title": "Moral Proximity: Ethics as Method in Post-Interpretive Criticism", "short_title": "Moral Proximity", "author": "Dorian Vale", "creators": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "affiliation": "MuseumofOne", "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094" }, { "name": "Museum Of One", "affiliation": "https://www.museumofone.art/" } ], "doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19863790", "conceptdoi": "10.5281/zenodo.17076246", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863790", "date": "2026", "type": "Journal article", "source_resource_type": { "title": "Journal article", "type": "publication", "subtype": "article" }, "version": "", "collection": "Theory & treatises", "summary": "An essay developing moral proximity as a method of critical responsibility. It considers the relation between descriptive restraint, custodianship, and encounters with works concerned with trauma or absence.", "subjects": [ "Ethics of witnessing", "Art criticism", "Moral proximity", "Post-Interpretive Criticism" ], "keywords": [ "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Stillmark Theory", "Absential Aesthetics", "Witness Aesthetics", "Hauntmark Theory", "Presence-Based Criticism", "Custodianship of Art", "Restraint in front of art", "Moral proximity", "Interpretive silence", "Erasure as ethics", "Silence as method", "Language as violence", "Art encounter ethics", "Epistemology of witness", "Philosophy of Art", "Aesthetics", "Art Theory", "Contemporary Aesthetics", "Comparative Aesthetics", "Phenomenology and Art", "Ethics in Art Criticism", "Interpretation and Meaning", "Criticism and Reception Theory", "Epistemology of Art", "Visual Culture Studies", "Dorian Vale", "Founder of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Post-Aesthetic Critic", "Independent Philosopher of Art", "Museum of One", "Art Writer and Theorist", "Aesthetic Philosopher", "Custodian of Witness Aesthetics", "The Doctrine of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "The Custodian's Oath", "The Canon of Witnesses", "Art as Truth", "Art as Presence", "The Viewer as Evidence", "Interpretation vs. Witnessing", "Language as Custody", "Erasure as Afterlife", "Post-Interpretive Lexicon", "Alternative art criticism", "New art criticism movement", "Ethical art theory", "Criticism beyond interpretation", "Quiet philosophy of art", "Radical art restraint", "Witness over interpretation", "Interpretive Restraint", "Art Criticism Ethics", "Museum Of One", "https://www.museumofone.art/", "https://hcommons.org/members/dorianvale/", "https://philpeople.org/profiles/dorian-vale", "https://osf.io/xa5jw/", "https://independent.academia.edu/DorianVale", "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17112807", "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17078847", "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17069115", "https://figshare.com/authors/Dorian_Vale/22186984", "Part of the Post-Interpretive Criticism movement (Q136308909), published by Museum of One (Q136308879), authored by Dorian Vale (Q136308916).", "Q136308909", "Q136308879", "Q136308916", "https://zenodo.org/communities/post-interpretive-criticism", "https://www.semanticscholar.org/author/Dorian-Vale/2380743266", "https://scholar.google.com/citations?hl=en&authuser=1&user=15tvhjAAAAAJ" ], "license": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "files": [ { "name": "Moral Proximity - Ethics as Method in Post - Interpretive Criticism.pdf", "url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19863790/files/Moral%20Proximity%20-%20Ethics%20as%20Method%20in%20Post%20-%20Interpretive%20Criticism.pdf/content", "size": 224701, "size_label": "219 KB", "checksum": "md5:b7c66d06af57f17ddbf35cc4ee2d9e01", "mimetype": "application/pdf" } ], "institutional_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "corroboration": "Museum of One’s matching publication page confirms Dorian Vale’s authorship and the work’s institutional context. Its repository links and publication dates are retained separately from this selected Zenodo edition. Web-record dates are not treated as dates of the deposited edition. Source review: 4 November 2026.", "discrepancies": [ "The repository also lists organizational or URL-form creator entries. The catalogue displays Dorian Vale as bibliographic author while retaining the deposited creator list separately.", "The source description includes a 2025 citation and an earlier DOI. The selected Zenodo record has a 2026 publication-date field; a web-publication date is not substituted for that deposited date.", "The institutional page does not explicitly link this selected edition DOI in its saved HTML. The match is at work level through title, authorship, and publication context; the catalogue preserves the exact repository edition separately." ], "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "publisher": "Museum of One", "language": null, "isbn": null, "related_identifiers": [ { "identifier": "10.5281/zenodo.17069115", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "resource_type": "publication-section", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "relation": "cites", "resource_type": "publication", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://hcommons.org/members/dorianvale/", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://philpeople.org/profiles/dorian-vale", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://osf.io/xa5jw/", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://independent.academia.edu/DorianVale", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "10.5281/zenodo.17112807", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "10.5281/zenodo.17078847", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "https://archive.org/details/osf-registrations-kve9y-v1", "relation": "cites", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Post-Interprative-Criticism%3A-Foundational-Essays-Vale/09538ab14a89022e2886f9cccaf133e8d5c9cf7d", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://zenodo.org/communities/post-interpretive-criticism", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.semanticscholar.org/author/Dorian-Vale/2380743266", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://scholar.google.com/citations?hl=en&authuser=1&user=15tvhjAAAAAJ", "relation": "cites", "scheme": "url" } ], "alternate_identifiers": [ { "identifier": "https://www.museumofone.art/" }, { "identifier": "https://hcommons.org/members/dorianvale/" }, { "identifier": "https://philpeople.org/profiles/dorian-vale" }, { "identifier": "https://osf.io/xa5jw/" }, { "identifier": "https://independent.academia.edu/DorianVale" }, { "identifier": "10.5281/zenodo.17112807" }, { "identifier": "10.5281/zenodo.17078847" }, { "identifier": "10.5281/zenodo.17069115" }, { "identifier": "https://figshare.com/authors/Dorian_Vale/22186984" }, { "identifier": "https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Post-Interprative-Criticism%3A-Foundational-Essays-Vale/09538ab14a89022e2886f9cccaf133e8d5c9cf7d" }, { "identifier": "https://www.semanticscholar.org/author/Dorian-Vale/2380743266" }, { "identifier": "https://zenodo.org/communities/post-interpretive-criticism" }, { "identifier": "https://scholar.google.com/citations?hl=en&authuser=1&user=15tvhjAAAAAJ" } ], "source_references": [ "https://www.museumofone.art/", "https://hcommons.org/members/dorianvale/", "https://philpeople.org/profiles/dorian-vale", "https://osf.io/xa5jw/", "https://independent.academia.edu/DorianVale", "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17112807", "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17078847", "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17069115", "https://archive.org/details/osf-registrations-kve9y-v1", "https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/KVE9Y", "https://figshare.com/authors/Dorian_Vale/22186984", "osf.io/zhnre", "Q136308909", "Q136308879", "Q136308916", "https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Post-Interprative-Criticism%3A-Foundational-Essays-Vale/09538ab14a89022e2886f9cccaf133e8d5c9cf7d", "https://www.semanticscholar.org/author/Dorian-Vale/2380743266", "https://zenodo.org/communities/post-interpretive-criticism", "https://scholar.google.com/citations?hl=en&authuser=1&user=15tvhjAAAAAJ" ], "source_journal": { "title": "Museum of One" }, "source_imprint": null, "source_contributors": [ { "name": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "affiliation": "Museum Of One", "type": null } ], "source_created": "2026-04-28T18:51:44.977265+00:00", "source_modified": "2026-04-28T18:51:45.522186+00:00", "source_description_html": "

Moral Proximity: Ethics as Method in Post-Interpretive Criticism

\n

By Dorian Vale

\n

In this defining essay, Dorian Vale articulates moral proximity as the central method of Post-Interpretive Criticism (PIC). Departing from frameworks that prioritize interpretation, context, or theoretical discourse, this piece reframes criticism itself as an ethical position, not an intellectual act.

\n

 

\n

Moral proximity is the discipline of standing near a work—especially works born of trauma, exile, or silence—without consuming it. It demands neither resolution nor analysis, but a custodial presence rooted in humility, restraint, and witness. The critic is not a translator but a steward of what cannot be said without distortion.

\n

 

\n

Drawing upon Vale’s broader doctrines—including the Viewer as Evidence, Absential Aesthetics, and Hauntmark Theory—this essay positions moral nearness as the irreducible truth in art writing. It becomes the difference between exploitation and reverence, between performance and presence.

\n

 

\n

Vale, Dorian. Moral Proximity: Ethics as Method in Post-Interpretive Criticism. Museum of One, 2025. DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17076247

\n

Dorian Vale is a chosen pseudonym, not to obscure identity, but to preserve clarity of voice and integrity of message. It creates distance between the writer and the work, allowing the philosophy to stand unclouded by biography. The name exists not to hide, but to honor the seriousness of the task: to speak without spectacle, and to build without needing to be seen. This name is used for all official publications, essays, and theoretical works indexed through DOI-linked repositories including Zenodo, OSF, PhilPapers, and SSRN.

\n

This entry is connected to a series of original theories and treatises forming the foundation of the Post-Interpretive Criticism movement (Q136308909), authored by Dorian Vale (Q136308916) and published by Museum of One (Q136308879). These include: Stillmark Theory (Q136328254), Hauntmark Theory (Q136328273), Absential Aesthetic Theory (Q136328330), Viewer-as-Evidence Theory (Q136328828), Message-Transfer Theory (Q136329002), Aesthetic Displacement Theory (Q136329014), Theory of Misplacement (Q136329054), and Art as Truth: A Treatise (Q136329071), Aesthetic Recursion Theory (Q136339843)

\n

Post-Interpretive Criticism, Dorian Vale, moral proximity, ethics in art criticism, witnessing art, aesthetic ethics, viewer presence, non-extractive criticism, trauma-informed aesthetics, silent art, ethical presence, affective encounter, restraint in criticism

", "provenance": { "repository": "Zenodo REST API response supplied in query.json", "retrieved": "2026-11-04", "editorial_fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "source_snapshot": "source/19863790.json", "institutional_review": "Reviewed page-level title, author and repository links in saved public institutional HTML, 2026-11-04." }, "source_review": "2026-11-04", "relations": [ { "identifier": "10.5281/zenodo.17069115", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "resource_type": "publication-section", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "relation": "cites", "resource_type": "publication", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://hcommons.org/members/dorianvale/", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://philpeople.org/profiles/dorian-vale", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://osf.io/xa5jw/", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://independent.academia.edu/DorianVale", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "10.5281/zenodo.17112807", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "10.5281/zenodo.17078847", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "https://archive.org/details/osf-registrations-kve9y-v1", "relation": "cites", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Post-Interprative-Criticism%3A-Foundational-Essays-Vale/09538ab14a89022e2886f9cccaf133e8d5c9cf7d", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://zenodo.org/communities/post-interpretive-criticism", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.semanticscholar.org/author/Dorian-Vale/2380743266", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://scholar.google.com/citations?hl=en&authuser=1&user=15tvhjAAAAAJ", "relation": "cites", "scheme": "url" } ], "institutional_metadata": { "title": "Moral Proximity: Ethics as Method in Post-Interpretive Criticism", "author": "Dorian Vale", "web_publication": "2025-10-16T03:33:00.000Z", "web_updated": "2026-11-03T00:43:06.000Z", "linked_zenodo_dois": [ "10.5281/zenodo.17076247" ], "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/" }, "research_programmes": [], "record_level": "Item", "record_status": "Published source; selected catalogue record", "digital_formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "extent": "1 digital file; 224701 bytes", "medium": "Digital document", "record_reviewed": "2026-11-04", "date_precision": "year", "alternate_titles": [], "digital_extent": { "file_count": 1, "total_bytes": 224701, "formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "checksums": [ { "filename": "Moral Proximity - Ethics as Method in Post - Interpretive Criticism.pdf", "algorithm": "md5", "value": "b7c66d06af57f17ddbf35cc4ee2d9e01", "syntax_valid": true, "verification": "source_checksum_transcription; bytes not independently recomputed" } ], "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863790", "derivation": "File count and total bytes calculated from repository file metadata; MIME inferred from filename when absent." }, "identifier_validation": { "orcid": { "source_value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "ISO 7064 MOD 11-2 checksum only; this is not a live registry verification." }, "isbn": [], "doi": { "source_value": "10.5281/zenodo.19863790", "syntax_valid": true, "note": "Syntax check only; repository snapshot supplies the identifier." } }, "isbn_applicability": "not_supplied", "serial": null, "contributor_roles": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": "MuseumofOne", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863790" }, { "name": "Museum Of One", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863790" }, { "name": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "source_category": "contributor", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": "Museum Of One", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863790" } ], "authority_links": [], "metadata_profile": { "name": "Museum of One source-qualified catalogue profile", "version": "3.0.0", "url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/metadata-profile.json", "source_snapshot_preserved": true }, "reading_copy": { "id": "19863790", "title": "Moral Proximity: Ethics as Method in Post-Interpretive Criticism", "accession": "MOO-CAT-014", "pdf_url": "../assets/documents/19863790.pdf", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19863790/files/Moral%20Proximity%20-%20Ethics%20as%20Method%20in%20Post%20-%20Interpretive%20Criticism.pdf/content", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863790", "source_filename": "Moral Proximity - Ethics as Method in Post - Interpretive Criticism.pdf", "checksum": "md5:b7c66d06af57f17ddbf35cc4ee2d9e01", "sha256": "01dd4f6727c08692c5df59af23ef817535a15a57ca4551b930827ee8dac917fa", "bytes": 224701, "page_count": 5, "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "checksum_match": true, "rights": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "role": "Local reading copy; original repository file retained unchanged" }, "page_count": 5, "field_assertions": [ { "field": "title", "value": "Moral Proximity: Ethics as Method in Post-Interpretive Criticism", "status": "catalogue_title", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "Local display title; the deposited title is retained separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_title", "value": "Moral Proximity: Ethics as Method in Post-Interpretive Criticism", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863790", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "doi", "value": "10.5281/zenodo.19863790", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863790", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "date", "value": "2026", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863790", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "conceptdoi", "value": "10.5281/zenodo.17076246", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863790", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "creators", "value": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "affiliation": "MuseumofOne", "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094" }, { "name": "Museum Of One", "affiliation": "https://www.museumofone.art/" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863790", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "keywords", "value": [ "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Stillmark Theory", "Absential Aesthetics", "Witness Aesthetics", "Hauntmark Theory", "Presence-Based Criticism", "Custodianship of Art", "Restraint in front of art", "Moral proximity", "Interpretive silence", "Erasure as ethics", "Silence as method", "Language as violence", "Art encounter ethics", "Epistemology of witness", "Philosophy of Art", "Aesthetics", "Art Theory", "Contemporary Aesthetics", "Comparative Aesthetics", "Phenomenology and Art", "Ethics in Art Criticism", "Interpretation and Meaning", "Criticism and Reception Theory", "Epistemology of Art", "Visual Culture Studies", "Dorian Vale", "Founder of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Post-Aesthetic Critic", "Independent Philosopher of Art", "Museum of One", "Art Writer and Theorist", "Aesthetic Philosopher", "Custodian of Witness Aesthetics", "The Doctrine of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "The Custodian's Oath", "The Canon of Witnesses", "Art as Truth", "Art as Presence", "The Viewer as Evidence", "Interpretation vs. Witnessing", "Language as Custody", "Erasure as Afterlife", "Post-Interpretive Lexicon", "Alternative art criticism", "New art criticism movement", "Ethical art theory", "Criticism beyond interpretation", "Quiet philosophy of art", "Radical art restraint", "Witness over interpretation", "Interpretive Restraint", "Art Criticism Ethics", "Museum Of One", "https://www.museumofone.art/", "https://hcommons.org/members/dorianvale/", "https://philpeople.org/profiles/dorian-vale", "https://osf.io/xa5jw/", "https://independent.academia.edu/DorianVale", "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17112807", "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17078847", "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17069115", "https://figshare.com/authors/Dorian_Vale/22186984", "Part of the Post-Interpretive Criticism movement (Q136308909), published by Museum of One (Q136308879), authored by Dorian Vale (Q136308916).", "Q136308909", "Q136308879", "Q136308916", "https://zenodo.org/communities/post-interpretive-criticism", "https://www.semanticscholar.org/author/Dorian-Vale/2380743266", "https://scholar.google.com/citations?hl=en&authuser=1&user=15tvhjAAAAAJ" ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863790", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "license", "value": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863790", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "files", "value": [ { "name": "Moral Proximity - Ethics as Method in Post - Interpretive Criticism.pdf", "url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19863790/files/Moral%20Proximity%20-%20Ethics%20as%20Method%20in%20Post%20-%20Interpretive%20Criticism.pdf/content", "size": 224701, "size_label": "219 KB", "checksum": "md5:b7c66d06af57f17ddbf35cc4ee2d9e01", "mimetype": "application/pdf" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863790", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_created", "value": "2026-04-28T18:51:44.977265+00:00", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863790", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_modified", "value": "2026-04-28T18:51:45.522186+00:00", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863790", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "record_modified", "value": "2026-11-04", "status": "derived_from_description_history", "note": "Latest documented local description event; not a publication, repository or source-review date.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_review", "value": "2026-11-04", "status": "catalogue_source_review", "note": "Review of descriptive sources; not the creation or modification date of the work or repository record.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "author", "value": "Dorian Vale", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "Institutional responsibility statement; original repository creator roles remain separate.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "publisher", "value": "Museum of One", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "Institutional responsibility statement; original repository creator roles remain separate.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "orcid", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "source_linked_identifier", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "Creator identifier supplied by the linked sources; no affiliation or endorsement is inferred.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "orcid_authority", "value": { "scheme": "ORCID", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "evidence_urls": [ "https://www.museumofone.art/archives-scholarly-infrastructure/", "https://eprints.rclis.org/47182/", "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ], "access_note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "evidence_receipt": "data/source/authority-review-2026-11-04.json" }, "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "source_url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "summary", "value": "An essay developing moral proximity as a method of critical responsibility. It considers the relation between descriptive restraint, custodianship, and encounters with works concerned with trauma or absence.", "status": "editorial_enrichment", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "Catalogue-editor summary based on the linked work; not an original publisher abstract.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "subjects", "value": [ "Ethics of witnessing", "Art criticism", "Moral proximity", "Post-Interpretive Criticism" ], "status": "editorial_enrichment", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "Local discovery terms; no controlled-vocabulary assignment is claimed.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "collection", "value": "Theory & treatises", "status": "editorial_grouping", "note": "A local browsing collection, not an original repository collection.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "corroboration", "value": "Museum of One’s matching publication page confirms Dorian Vale’s authorship and the work’s institutional context. Its repository links and publication dates are retained separately from this selected Zenodo edition. Web-record dates are not treated as dates of the deposited edition. Source review: 4 November 2026.", "status": "catalogue_review_note", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "discrepancies", "value": [ "The repository also lists organizational or URL-form creator entries. The catalogue displays Dorian Vale as bibliographic author while retaining the deposited creator list separately.", "The source description includes a 2025 citation and an earlier DOI. The selected Zenodo record has a 2026 publication-date field; a web-publication date is not substituted for that deposited date.", "The institutional page does not explicitly link this selected edition DOI in its saved HTML. The match is at work level through title, authorship, and publication context; the catalogue preserves the exact repository edition separately." ], "status": "catalogue_review_note", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "date_precision", "value": "year", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863790", "note": "Precision reported exactly as supplied; missing month or day is not filled.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "medium", "value": "Digital document", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863790", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "digital_formats", "value": [ "application/pdf" ], "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863790", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "extent", "value": "1 digital file; 224701 bytes", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863790", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "digital_extent", "value": { "file_count": 1, "total_bytes": 224701, "formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "checksums": [ { "filename": "Moral Proximity - Ethics as Method in Post - Interpretive Criticism.pdf", "algorithm": "md5", "value": "b7c66d06af57f17ddbf35cc4ee2d9e01", "syntax_valid": true, "verification": "source_checksum_transcription; bytes not independently recomputed" } ], "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863790", "derivation": "File count and total bytes calculated from repository file metadata; MIME inferred from filename when absent." }, "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863790", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "identifier_validation", "value": { "orcid": { "source_value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "ISO 7064 MOD 11-2 checksum only; this is not a live registry verification." }, "isbn": [], "doi": { "source_value": "10.5281/zenodo.19863790", "syntax_valid": true, "note": "Syntax check only; repository snapshot supplies the identifier." } }, "status": "local_syntax_validation", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863790", "note": "Checksum/syntax validation does not verify registration, assignment or edition applicability.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "contributor_roles", "value": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": "MuseumofOne", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863790" }, { "name": "Museum Of One", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863790" }, { "name": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "source_category": "contributor", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": "Museum Of One", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863790" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863790", "note": "Creator and contributor roles are transcribed, not inferred from names or affiliations.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "entity_link:dorian-vale:author", "value": { "id": "dorian-vale", "label": "Dorian Vale", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "author", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author.", "variants": [ "Vale, Dorian" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:900bf7b30fa3bbc04920f1b659e47bc6bd5b1783d8626cc0f650cffb5c29a8a6", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863790.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." } }, { "field": "entity_link:museum-of-one:publisher", "value": { "id": "museum-of-one", "label": "Museum of One", "entity_type": "Organization", "relation": "publisher", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record.", "variants": [ "MuseumofOne", "MUSEUM OF ONE" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:d8b65275d21f1f54300af9605bf583a29b8760d994dd847f0739ea2c5174b498", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863790.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." } }, { "field": "entity_link:marina-abramovic:artist discussed", "value": { "id": "marina-abramovic", "label": "Marina Abramović", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "artist discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The essay discusses The Artist Is Present in its argument about moral proximity.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:2ffb91bf14bdb55ac3afdbee59721c8b417e3a03986270dfb1ae6ef7fe4ceeb7", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863790.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/marina-abramovic.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay discusses The Artist Is Present in its argument about moral proximity." } }, { "field": "controlled_subjects", "value": [ { "id": "ethics-of-witnessing", "label": "Ethics of witnessing", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#ethics-of-witnessing", "url": "vocabulary.html#ethics-of-witnessing", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:ethics-of-witnessing", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "ethics of witnessing" ], "definition": "Ethical responsibility in attending to artworks and the histories they engage.", "scope_note": "Local access term used for the Museum of One corpus. Preserve the author’s framework attribution; no equivalence with an external philosophical school is asserted.", "kind": "local-framework-concept", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "post-interpretive-criticism", "witnessing" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "art-criticism", "label": "Art criticism", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#art-criticism", "url": "vocabulary.html#art-criticism", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:art-criticism", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Art Criticism" ], "definition": "Critical examination and discussion of artworks and encounters with art.", "scope_note": "Use for publications addressing criticism as a practice, method, or ethical responsibility.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "art-writing", "interpretation" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "moral-proximity", "label": "Moral proximity", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#moral-proximity", "url": "vocabulary.html#moral-proximity", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:moral-proximity", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Moral Proximity" ], "definition": "The author’s term for ethical responsibility through closeness and restraint in criticism.", "scope_note": "Local PIC concept. Attribute claims to the author’s framework; no standard measurement or external theoretical equivalence is implied.", "kind": "local-framework-concept", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "post-interpretive-criticism" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "post-interpretive-criticism", "label": "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#post-interpretive-criticism", "url": "vocabulary.html#post-interpretive-criticism", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:post-interpretive-criticism", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "PIC", "Post Interpretive Criticism" ], "definition": "The critical framework named and developed in the Museum of One publications.", "scope_note": "Local named intellectual framework. Used for records explicitly concerned with it; no Getty, Library of Congress, or other external equivalence is asserted.", "kind": "local-framework-concept", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "custodianship", "ethics-of-witnessing", "foundational-writings", "moral-proximity" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Local preferred terms with definitions and synonyms. External alignment is scoped in the vocabulary register." }, { "field": "genre_terms", "value": [ { "id": "genre-journal-article", "label": "Journal article", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#genre-journal-article", "url": "vocabulary.html#genre-journal-article", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:genre-journal-article", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Journal articles" ], "definition": "A contribution issued as part of a journal or periodical.", "scope_note": "Describes publication genre based on the catalogued source record; peer-review status is a separate question.", "kind": "genre", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "verified_mapping", "external_mappings": [ { "vocabulary": "Getty Art & Architecture Thesaurus", "label": "articles", "uri": "http://vocab.getty.edu/aat/300048715", "source_url": "https://www.getty.edu/vow/AATFullDisplay?find=&logic=AND¬e=&subjectid=300048715", "relation": "broadMatch", "status": "verified", "verified_on": "2026-11-04", "note": "Getty’s articles concept includes contributions to magazines, newspapers, encyclopedias, and other works; journal article is the narrower local genre." } ], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "type", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Local resource-genre classification. Digital file format is recorded separately." }, { "field": "archival_context", "value": { "description_profile": "moo-description-policy-1.0", "catalogue_snapshot_date": "2026-11-04", "snapshot_note": "Selected catalogue snapshot; not a live repository synchronisation.", "record_category": "Published library and repository material", "reference_code_status": "Stable local catalogue reference; not evidence of an archival acquisition or a previous catalogue accession.", "source_repository": { "name": "Zenodo", "record_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863790" }, "institutional_context_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_metadata_retrieved": "2026-11-04", "source_metadata_retrieval_status": "Documented in catalogue source provenance", "source_snapshot": "source/19863790.json", "source_filenames": [ "Moral Proximity - Ethics as Method in Post - Interpretive Criticism.pdf" ], "selection_basis": "Local descriptive selection of publicly published material; public availability does not establish ownership of originals.", "custodial_history": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No donation, physical transfer, acquisition agreement or chain of custody is documented by this catalogue. Zenodo remains the source repository for the deposited version." }, "original_order": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No original archival order is asserted. Current browsing groupings are local editorial arrangement." }, "arrangement": { "status": "local_editorial", "grouping": "Theory & treatises", "statement": "A browsing grouping, not an original fonds or archival series." }, "responsible_service": { "name": "Museum of One", "service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "website": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "email": "research@museumofone.art" }, "description_method": "Source-based description with automated drafting and metadata assistance. Responsibility for the public catalogue rests with Museum of One; automated assistance does not constitute independent scholarly or curatorial review.", "policy_url": "policies.html", "correction_email": "research@museumofone.art", "access_copy": { "role": "Local digital reading copy of the deposited file", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19863790/files/Moral%20Proximity%20-%20Ethics%20as%20Method%20in%20Post%20-%20Interpretive%20Criticism.pdf/content", "source_filename": "Moral Proximity - Ethics as Method in Post - Interpretive Criticism.pdf", "local_path": "assets/documents/19863790.pdf", "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "source_checksum_match": true, "sha256": "01dd4f6727c08692c5df59af23ef817535a15a57ca4551b930827ee8dac917fa", "statement": "Access copy only; no ownership or physical custody transfer is implied." } }, "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Provenance records what is documented and leaves unknown custody and original order explicit." }, { "field": "description_history", "value": [ { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Source-based catalogue description", "note": "Local description assembled from the identified public repository record and available institutional work record. Source metadata remains separately identifiable.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/19863790", "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Qualified descriptive enrichment", "note": "Local editorial description, arrangement and source-qualified bibliographic context recorded alongside source metadata. Unknown or disputed values remain qualified.", "fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/19863790", "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Automated file checksum and PDF inspection", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Digital reading copy verified", "note": "Downloaded access-copy MD5 matched the source checksum; local SHA-256 and PDF file-page count are recorded in the file manifest. This event does not describe transfer of custody.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19863790/files/Moral%20Proximity%20-%20Ethics%20as%20Method%20in%20Post%20-%20Interpretive%20Criticism.pdf/content" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Description policy and provenance context adopted", "note": "Responsible service, source repository, local access-copy role, unknown custody and original order, correction route and dated description history made explicit under moo-description-policy-1.0.", "sources": [ "policies.html" ] }, { "event_id": "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Unify graph identities and qualify exported relationships and citations", "note": "Local graph projection now uses one contextual identity per entity, distinguishes work-level institutional matches from selected-edition links, retains title-level ISBN uncertainty, and derives citations from the source title. Typed relation assertions and a versioned validation profile are introduced. No publication date, original source snapshot or PDF changed.", "fields": [ "metadata_profile", "relationship_assertions", "identity", "institutional_match_scope", "citation_projection" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Source-based metadata implementation and regression validation", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication, source review or acquisition date", "sources": [ "metadata/metadata-profile.json" ] }, { "event_id": "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Record inspected public ORCID profile evidence", "note": "The official ORCID public person API returned the credited name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website. This confirms a matching public profile, not independently verified biographical or affiliation claims. Original creator arrays and source snapshots are unchanged.", "fields": [ "orcid_authority" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Read-only official public API inspection", "date_kind": "Local authority review and catalogue description event; not a publication or original creation date", "sources": [ "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ] } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Catalogue description events; these are not work publication dates or acquisition dates." }, { "field": "relationship_assertions", "value": [ { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:900bf7b30fa3bbc04920f1b659e47bc6bd5b1783d8626cc0f650cffb5c29a8a6", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863790.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:d8b65275d21f1f54300af9605bf583a29b8760d994dd847f0739ea2c5174b498", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863790.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:2ffb91bf14bdb55ac3afdbee59721c8b417e3a03986270dfb1ae6ef7fe4ceeb7", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863790.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/marina-abramovic.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay discusses The Artist Is Present in its argument about moral proximity." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:e341aa3d4b6c51e52f5bf0ab145f11e20300809f78c1f82ca4c0a5c53e4294d3", "subject": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#describes", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863790.html#work", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "metadata_field", "field": "linked_zenodo_dois", "values": [ "10.5281/zenodo.17076247" ] }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "Exact-edition matching requires the selected DOI in the reviewed page metadata; other matches retain their wider scope." } ], "status": "typed_evidence_projection", "note": "Stable, typed assertions retain source scope and explicit unknown review metadata." }, { "field": "reading_copy", "value": { "id": "19863790", "title": "Moral Proximity: Ethics as Method in Post-Interpretive Criticism", "accession": "MOO-CAT-014", "pdf_url": "../assets/documents/19863790.pdf", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19863790/files/Moral%20Proximity%20-%20Ethics%20as%20Method%20in%20Post%20-%20Interpretive%20Criticism.pdf/content", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863790", "source_filename": "Moral Proximity - Ethics as Method in Post - Interpretive Criticism.pdf", "checksum": "md5:b7c66d06af57f17ddbf35cc4ee2d9e01", "sha256": "01dd4f6727c08692c5df59af23ef817535a15a57ca4551b930827ee8dac917fa", "bytes": 224701, "page_count": 5, "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "checksum_match": true, "rights": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "role": "Local reading copy; original repository file retained unchanged" }, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19863790/files/Moral%20Proximity%20-%20Ethics%20as%20Method%20in%20Post%20-%20Interpretive%20Criticism.pdf/content", "status": "derived_file_inspection", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "note": "Byte-identical local access copy. Source MD5 was recomputed and matched; SHA-256 and page count were measured from the downloaded PDF. This is not a preservation-deposit claim." }, { "field": "page_count", "value": 5, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19863790/files/Moral%20Proximity%20-%20Ethics%20as%20Method%20in%20Post%20-%20Interpretive%20Criticism.pdf/content", "status": "derived_file_inspection", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "note": "Total PDF file pages measured from the deposited file, including cover and unnumbered pages. Not a claim about printed pagination." } ], "entity_links": [ { "id": "dorian-vale", "label": "Dorian Vale", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "author", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author.", "variants": [ "Vale, Dorian" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "museum-of-one", "label": "Museum of One", "entity_type": "Organization", "relation": "publisher", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record.", "variants": [ "MuseumofOne", "MUSEUM OF ONE" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "marina-abramovic", "label": "Marina Abramović", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "artist discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The essay discusses The Artist Is Present in its argument about moral proximity.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" } ], "contents": [], "controlled_subjects": [ { "id": "ethics-of-witnessing", "label": "Ethics of witnessing", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#ethics-of-witnessing", "url": "vocabulary.html#ethics-of-witnessing", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:ethics-of-witnessing", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "ethics of witnessing" ], "definition": "Ethical responsibility in attending to artworks and the histories they engage.", "scope_note": "Local access term used for the Museum of One corpus. Preserve the author’s framework attribution; no equivalence with an external philosophical school is asserted.", "kind": "local-framework-concept", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "post-interpretive-criticism", "witnessing" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "art-criticism", "label": "Art criticism", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#art-criticism", "url": "vocabulary.html#art-criticism", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:art-criticism", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Art Criticism" ], "definition": "Critical examination and discussion of artworks and encounters with art.", "scope_note": "Use for publications addressing criticism as a practice, method, or ethical responsibility.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "art-writing", "interpretation" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "moral-proximity", "label": "Moral proximity", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#moral-proximity", "url": "vocabulary.html#moral-proximity", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:moral-proximity", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Moral Proximity" ], "definition": "The author’s term for ethical responsibility through closeness and restraint in criticism.", "scope_note": "Local PIC concept. Attribute claims to the author’s framework; no standard measurement or external theoretical equivalence is implied.", "kind": "local-framework-concept", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "post-interpretive-criticism" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "post-interpretive-criticism", "label": "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#post-interpretive-criticism", "url": "vocabulary.html#post-interpretive-criticism", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:post-interpretive-criticism", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "PIC", "Post Interpretive Criticism" ], "definition": "The critical framework named and developed in the Museum of One publications.", "scope_note": "Local named intellectual framework. Used for records explicitly concerned with it; no Getty, Library of Congress, or other external equivalence is asserted.", "kind": "local-framework-concept", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "custodianship", "ethics-of-witnessing", "foundational-writings", "moral-proximity" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "genre_terms": [ { "id": "genre-journal-article", "label": "Journal article", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#genre-journal-article", "url": "vocabulary.html#genre-journal-article", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:genre-journal-article", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Journal articles" ], "definition": "A contribution issued as part of a journal or periodical.", "scope_note": "Describes publication genre based on the catalogued source record; peer-review status is a separate question.", "kind": "genre", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "verified_mapping", "external_mappings": [ { "vocabulary": "Getty Art & Architecture Thesaurus", "label": "articles", "uri": "http://vocab.getty.edu/aat/300048715", "source_url": "https://www.getty.edu/vow/AATFullDisplay?find=&logic=AND¬e=&subjectid=300048715", "relation": "broadMatch", "status": "verified", "verified_on": "2026-11-04", "note": "Getty’s articles concept includes contributions to magazines, newspapers, encyclopedias, and other works; journal article is the narrower local genre." } ], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "type", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "vocabulary_version": 4, "description_history": [ { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Source-based catalogue description", "note": "Local description assembled from the identified public repository record and available institutional work record. Source metadata remains separately identifiable.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/19863790", "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Qualified descriptive enrichment", "note": "Local editorial description, arrangement and source-qualified bibliographic context recorded alongside source metadata. Unknown or disputed values remain qualified.", "fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/19863790", "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Automated file checksum and PDF inspection", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Digital reading copy verified", "note": "Downloaded access-copy MD5 matched the source checksum; local SHA-256 and PDF file-page count are recorded in the file manifest. This event does not describe transfer of custody.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19863790/files/Moral%20Proximity%20-%20Ethics%20as%20Method%20in%20Post%20-%20Interpretive%20Criticism.pdf/content" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Description policy and provenance context adopted", "note": "Responsible service, source repository, local access-copy role, unknown custody and original order, correction route and dated description history made explicit under moo-description-policy-1.0.", "sources": [ "policies.html" ] }, { "event_id": "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Unify graph identities and qualify exported relationships and citations", "note": "Local graph projection now uses one contextual identity per entity, distinguishes work-level institutional matches from selected-edition links, retains title-level ISBN uncertainty, and derives citations from the source title. Typed relation assertions and a versioned validation profile are introduced. No publication date, original source snapshot or PDF changed.", "fields": [ "metadata_profile", "relationship_assertions", "identity", "institutional_match_scope", "citation_projection" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Source-based metadata implementation and regression validation", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication, source review or acquisition date", "sources": [ "metadata/metadata-profile.json" ] }, { "event_id": "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Record inspected public ORCID profile evidence", "note": "The official ORCID public person API returned the credited name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website. This confirms a matching public profile, not independently verified biographical or affiliation claims. Original creator arrays and source snapshots are unchanged.", "fields": [ "orcid_authority" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Read-only official public API inspection", "date_kind": "Local authority review and catalogue description event; not a publication or original creation date", "sources": [ "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ] } ], "record_modified": "2026-11-04", "record_modified_provenance": { "status": "derived_from_description_history", "event_ids": [ "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04" ], "note": "Latest documented local description event; not a publication, repository or source-review date." }, "archival_context": { "description_profile": "moo-description-policy-1.0", "catalogue_snapshot_date": "2026-11-04", "snapshot_note": "Selected catalogue snapshot; not a live repository synchronisation.", "record_category": "Published library and repository material", "reference_code_status": "Stable local catalogue reference; not evidence of an archival acquisition or a previous catalogue accession.", "source_repository": { "name": "Zenodo", "record_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863790" }, "institutional_context_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_metadata_retrieved": "2026-11-04", "source_metadata_retrieval_status": "Documented in catalogue source provenance", "source_snapshot": "source/19863790.json", "source_filenames": [ "Moral Proximity - Ethics as Method in Post - Interpretive Criticism.pdf" ], "selection_basis": "Local descriptive selection of publicly published material; public availability does not establish ownership of originals.", "custodial_history": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No donation, physical transfer, acquisition agreement or chain of custody is documented by this catalogue. Zenodo remains the source repository for the deposited version." }, "original_order": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No original archival order is asserted. Current browsing groupings are local editorial arrangement." }, "arrangement": { "status": "local_editorial", "grouping": "Theory & treatises", "statement": "A browsing grouping, not an original fonds or archival series." }, "responsible_service": { "name": "Museum of One", "service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "website": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "email": "research@museumofone.art" }, "description_method": "Source-based description with automated drafting and metadata assistance. Responsibility for the public catalogue rests with Museum of One; automated assistance does not constitute independent scholarly or curatorial review.", "policy_url": "policies.html", "correction_email": "research@museumofone.art", "access_copy": { "role": "Local digital reading copy of the deposited file", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19863790/files/Moral%20Proximity%20-%20Ethics%20as%20Method%20in%20Post%20-%20Interpretive%20Criticism.pdf/content", "source_filename": "Moral Proximity - Ethics as Method in Post - Interpretive Criticism.pdf", "local_path": "assets/documents/19863790.pdf", "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "source_checksum_match": true, "sha256": "01dd4f6727c08692c5df59af23ef817535a15a57ca4551b930827ee8dac917fa", "statement": "Access copy only; no ownership or physical custody transfer is implied." } }, "description_policy_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "pirr_references": [], "pirr_work_identity": { "archive_reference": "MOO-CAT-014", "edition_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19863790", "zenodo_record_id": "19863790", "identifier_scope": "Publication identity; PIRR identifiers in programme relationships identify research records, not this publication." }, "metadata_origin": "https://archive.museumofone.art", "identity": { "work": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863790.html#work", "edition": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19863790", "version_family": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17076246", "catalogue_record": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863790.html#catalogue-record" }, "institutional_match_scope": "work", "relationship_assertions": [ { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:900bf7b30fa3bbc04920f1b659e47bc6bd5b1783d8626cc0f650cffb5c29a8a6", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863790.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:d8b65275d21f1f54300af9605bf583a29b8760d994dd847f0739ea2c5174b498", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863790.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:2ffb91bf14bdb55ac3afdbee59721c8b417e3a03986270dfb1ae6ef7fe4ceeb7", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863790.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/marina-abramovic.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay discusses The Artist Is Present in its argument about moral proximity." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:e341aa3d4b6c51e52f5bf0ab145f11e20300809f78c1f82ca4c0a5c53e4294d3", "subject": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#describes", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863790.html#work", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/moral-proximity-ethics-as-method-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "metadata_field", "field": "linked_zenodo_dois", "values": [ "10.5281/zenodo.17076247" ] }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "Exact-edition matching requires the selected DOI in the reviewed page metadata; other matches retain their wider scope." } ], "orcid_authority": { "scheme": "ORCID", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "evidence_urls": [ "https://www.museumofone.art/archives-scholarly-infrastructure/", "https://eprints.rclis.org/47182/", "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ], "access_note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "evidence_receipt": "data/source/authority-review-2026-11-04.json" } }, { "id": "19863836", "accession": "MOO-CAT-015", "title": "The Afterlife of the Work: Viewer as Evidence in Post-Interpretive Criticism", "source_title": "The Afterlife of the Work: Viewer as Evidence in Post-Interpretive Criticism", "short_title": "The Afterlife of the Work", "author": "Dorian Vale", "creators": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "affiliation": "MuseumofOne", "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094" }, { "name": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "affiliation": null }, { "name": "Museum Of One", "affiliation": null } ], "doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19863836", "conceptdoi": "10.5281/zenodo.17076534", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863836", "date": "2026", "type": "Journal article", "source_resource_type": { "title": "Journal article", "type": "publication", "subtype": "article" }, "version": "", "collection": "Theory & treatises", "summary": "An essay treating the lasting effects of an encounter with art as evidence within Post-Interpretive Criticism. Its focus is the viewer’s memory, response, and continuing responsibility to the work.", "subjects": [ "Viewer response", "Ethics of witnessing", "Memory", "Post-Interpretive Criticism" ], "keywords": [ "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Stillmark Theory", "Absential Aesthetics", "Witness Aesthetics", "Hauntmark Theory", "Presence-Based Criticism", "Custodianship of Art", "Restraint in front of art", "Moral proximity", "Interpretive silence", "Erasure as ethics", "Silence as method", "Language as violence", "Art encounter ethics", "Epistemology of witness", "Philosophy of Art", "Aesthetics", "Art Theory", "Contemporary Aesthetics", "Comparative Aesthetics", "Ethics in Art Criticism", "Interpretation and Meaning", "Criticism and Reception Theory", "Visual Culture Studies", "Epistemology of Art", "Dorian Vale", "Founder of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Post-Aesthetic Critic", "Independent Philosopher of Art", "Museum of One", "Art Writer and Theorist", "Aesthetic Philosopher", "Custodian of Witness Aesthetics", "The Doctrine of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "The Custodian's Oath", "The Canon of Witnesses", "Art as Truth", "Art as Presence", "The Viewer as Evidence", "Interpretation vs. Witnessing", "Language as Custody", "Erasure as Afterlife", "Post-Interpretive Lexicon", "Alternative art criticism", "New art criticism movement", "Ethical art theory", "Criticism beyond interpretation", "Quiet philosophy of art", "Radical art restraint", "Witness over interpretation", "Art Criticism Ethics", "Interpretive Restraint", "https://hcommons.org/members/dorianvale/", "https://philpeople.org/profiles/dorian-vale", "https://osf.io/xa5jw/", "https://independent.academia.edu/DorianVale", "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17112807", "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17078847", "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17069115", "https://figshare.com/authors/Dorian_Vale/22186984", "Q136308909", "Q136308879", "Q136308916", "Part of the Post-Interpretive Criticism movement (Q136308909), published by Museum of One (Q136308879), authored by Dorian Vale (Q136308916).", "https://zenodo.org/communities/post-interpretive-criticism", "https://www.semanticscholar.org/author/Dorian-Vale/2380743266", "https://scholar.google.com/citations?hl=en&authuser=1&user=15tvhjAAAAAJ" ], "license": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "files": [ { "name": "The Afterlife of the Work -Viewer as Evidence in Post-Interpretive Criticism.pdf", "url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19863836/files/The%20Afterlife%20of%20the%20Work%20-Viewer%20as%20Evidence%20in%20Post-Interpretive%20Criticism.pdf/content", "size": 253546, "size_label": "248 KB", "checksum": "md5:3661a3d21c585f0c41bbb242cb3b8cd0", "mimetype": "application/pdf" } ], "institutional_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "corroboration": "Museum of One’s matching publication page confirms Dorian Vale’s authorship and the work’s institutional context. Its repository links and publication dates are retained separately from this selected Zenodo edition. Web-record dates are not treated as dates of the deposited edition. Source review: 4 November 2026.", "discrepancies": [ "The repository also lists organizational or URL-form creator entries. The catalogue displays Dorian Vale as bibliographic author while retaining the deposited creator list separately.", "The source description includes a 2025 citation and an earlier DOI. The selected Zenodo record has a 2026 publication-date field; a web-publication date is not substituted for that deposited date.", "The institutional page does not explicitly link this selected edition DOI in its saved HTML. The match is at work level through title, authorship, and publication context; the catalogue preserves the exact repository edition separately." ], "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "publisher": "Museum of One", "language": null, "isbn": null, "related_identifiers": [ { "identifier": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://hcommons.org/members/dorianvale/", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://philpeople.org/profiles/dorian-vale", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://osf.io/xa5jw/", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://independent.academia.edu/DorianVale", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://figshare.com/authors/Dorian_Vale/22186984", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "10.5281/zenodo.17112807", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "10.5281/zenodo.17078847", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "10.5281/zenodo.17069115", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Post-Interprative-Criticism%3A-Foundational-Essays-Vale/09538ab14a89022e2886f9cccaf133e8d5c9cf7d", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://zenodo.org/communities/post-interpretive-criticism", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.semanticscholar.org/author/Dorian-Vale/2380743266", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://scholar.google.com/citations?hl=en&authuser=1&user=15tvhjAAAAAJ", "relation": "cites", "scheme": "url" } ], "alternate_identifiers": [ { "identifier": "10.5281/zenodo.17069115" }, { "identifier": "https://www.museumofone.art/" }, { "identifier": "https://hcommons.org/members/dorianvale/" }, { "identifier": "https://philpeople.org/profiles/dorian-vale" }, { "identifier": "https://osf.io/xa5jw/" }, { "identifier": "https://independent.academia.edu/DorianVale" }, { "identifier": "https://figshare.com/authors/Dorian_Vale/22186984" }, { "identifier": "https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Post-Interprative-Criticism%3A-Foundational-Essays-Vale/09538ab14a89022e2886f9cccaf133e8d5c9cf7d" }, { "identifier": "https://www.semanticscholar.org/author/Dorian-Vale/2380743266" }, { "identifier": "https://zenodo.org/communities/post-interpretive-criticism" }, { "identifier": "https://scholar.google.com/citations?hl=en&authuser=1&user=15tvhjAAAAAJ" } ], "source_references": [ "https://www.museumofone.art/", "https://hcommons.org/members/dorianvale/", "https://philpeople.org/profiles/dorian-vale", "https://osf.io/xa5jw/", "https://independent.academia.edu/DorianVale", "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17112807", "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17078847", "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17069115", "https://figshare.com/authors/Dorian_Vale/22186984", "Q136308909", "Q136308879", "Q136308916", "https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Post-Interprative-Criticism%3A-Foundational-Essays-Vale/09538ab14a89022e2886f9cccaf133e8d5c9cf7d", "https://www.semanticscholar.org/author/Dorian-Vale/2380743266", "https://zenodo.org/communities/post-interpretive-criticism", "https://scholar.google.com/citations?hl=en&authuser=1&user=15tvhjAAAAAJ", "http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.5471149", "https://ssrn.com/abstract=5471149" ], "source_journal": { "title": "Museum of One" }, "source_imprint": null, "source_contributors": [ { "name": "Museum Of One", "affiliation": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "type": "RightsHolder" } ], "source_created": "2026-04-28T18:52:53.714810+00:00", "source_modified": "2026-04-28T18:52:54.111962+00:00", "source_description_html": "

The Afterlife of the Work: Viewer as Evidence in Post-Interpretive Criticism

\n

By Dorian Vale

\n

This essay presents one of the central epistemological pillars of Post-Interpretive Criticism (PIC): the concept of the viewer as evidence. Dorian Vale challenges the traditional hierarchy where the critic’s interpretation takes precedence over the encounter itself, proposing instead that the afterlife of the artwork—the residue it leaves in the viewer—is its most truthful legacy.

\n

 

\n

Rather than dissect the work, Vale observes what lingers after it is gone: silence, tremor, unease, reverence. These affective traces are not emotional accidents, but ethical data. The viewer’s internal shift becomes testimony, and the absence of interpretation becomes its own kind of presence.

\n

 

\n

Rooted in restraint and moral proximity, this essay reframes the act of viewing as sacred evidence collection. The artwork does not exist to be understood; it exists to be endured. And in that endurance, the viewer becomes witness, custodian, and echo.

\n
\n
 
\n
\n

Vale, Dorian. The Afterlife of the Work: Viewer as Evidence in Post-Interpretive Criticism. Museum of One, 2025. DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17076535

\n
\n
\n

Dorian Vale is a chosen pseudonym, not to obscure identity, but to preserve clarity of voice and integrity of message. It creates distance between the writer and the work, allowing the philosophy to stand unclouded by biography. The name exists not to hide, but to honor the seriousness of the task: to speak without spectacle, and to build without needing to be seen. This name is used for all official publications, essays, and theoretical works indexed through DOI-linked repositories including Zenodo, OSF, PhilPapers, and SSRN.

\n
\n
\n

This entry is connected to a series of original theories and treatises forming the foundation of the Post-Interpretive Criticism movement (Q136308909), authored by Dorian Vale (Q136308916) and published by Museum of One (Q136308879). These include: Stillmark Theory (Q136328254), Hauntmark Theory (Q136328273), Absential Aesthetic Theory (Q136328330), Viewer-as-Evidence Theory (Q136328828), Message-Transfer Theory (Q136329002), Aesthetic Displacement Theory (Q136329014), Theory of Misplacement (Q136329054), and Art as Truth: A Treatise (Q136329071), Aesthetic Recursion Theory (Q136339843)

\n
\n
\n

 

\n

Post-Interpretive Criticism, Dorian Vale, viewer as evidence, art afterlife, ethical criticism, art encounter, aesthetic presence, trauma-informed art viewing, philosophy of art, witnessing in art, moral proximity, affective criticism

", "provenance": { "repository": "Zenodo REST API response supplied in query.json", "retrieved": "2026-11-04", "editorial_fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "source_snapshot": "source/19863836.json", "institutional_review": "Reviewed page-level title, author and repository links in saved public institutional HTML, 2026-11-04." }, "source_review": "2026-11-04", "relations": [ { "identifier": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://hcommons.org/members/dorianvale/", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://philpeople.org/profiles/dorian-vale", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://osf.io/xa5jw/", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://independent.academia.edu/DorianVale", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://figshare.com/authors/Dorian_Vale/22186984", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "10.5281/zenodo.17112807", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "10.5281/zenodo.17078847", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "10.5281/zenodo.17069115", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Post-Interprative-Criticism%3A-Foundational-Essays-Vale/09538ab14a89022e2886f9cccaf133e8d5c9cf7d", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://zenodo.org/communities/post-interpretive-criticism", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.semanticscholar.org/author/Dorian-Vale/2380743266", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://scholar.google.com/citations?hl=en&authuser=1&user=15tvhjAAAAAJ", "relation": "cites", "scheme": "url" } ], "institutional_metadata": { "title": "The Afterlife of the Work: Viewer as Evidence in Post-Interpretive Criticism", "author": "Dorian Vale", "web_publication": "2025-09-01T03:33:00.000Z", "web_updated": "2026-11-03T00:48:08.000Z", "linked_zenodo_dois": [ "10.5281/zenodo.17076535" ], "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/" }, "research_programmes": [ { "title": "Alexander Viktorovich Markov: Critical Language and Lasting Correction", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-critical-language/", "status": "In development", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-critical-language/", "relation": "Earlier individual work linked as context for a developing programme; not a joint output or endorsement", "relation_label": "Earlier individual work linked as programme context" } ], "record_level": "Item", "record_status": "Published source; selected catalogue record", "digital_formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "extent": "1 digital file; 253546 bytes", "medium": "Digital document", "record_reviewed": "2026-11-04", "date_precision": "year", "alternate_titles": [], "digital_extent": { "file_count": 1, "total_bytes": 253546, "formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "checksums": [ { "filename": "The Afterlife of the Work -Viewer as Evidence in Post-Interpretive Criticism.pdf", "algorithm": "md5", "value": "3661a3d21c585f0c41bbb242cb3b8cd0", "syntax_valid": true, "verification": "source_checksum_transcription; bytes not independently recomputed" } ], "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863836", "derivation": "File count and total bytes calculated from repository file metadata; MIME inferred from filename when absent." }, "identifier_validation": { "orcid": { "source_value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "ISO 7064 MOD 11-2 checksum only; this is not a live registry verification." }, "isbn": [], "doi": { "source_value": "10.5281/zenodo.19863836", "syntax_valid": true, "note": "Syntax check only; repository snapshot supplies the identifier." } }, "isbn_applicability": "not_supplied", "serial": null, "contributor_roles": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": "MuseumofOne", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863836" }, { "name": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": null, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863836" }, { "name": "Museum Of One", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": null, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863836" }, { "name": "Museum Of One", "source_category": "contributor", "source_role": "RightsHolder", "role_label": "RightsHolder", "affiliation_as_supplied": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863836" } ], "authority_links": [], "metadata_profile": { "name": "Museum of One source-qualified catalogue profile", "version": "3.0.0", "url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/metadata-profile.json", "source_snapshot_preserved": true }, "reading_copy": { "id": "19863836", "title": "The Afterlife of the Work: Viewer as Evidence in Post-Interpretive Criticism", "accession": "MOO-CAT-015", "pdf_url": "../assets/documents/19863836.pdf", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19863836/files/The%20Afterlife%20of%20the%20Work%20-Viewer%20as%20Evidence%20in%20Post-Interpretive%20Criticism.pdf/content", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863836", "source_filename": "The Afterlife of the Work -Viewer as Evidence in Post-Interpretive Criticism.pdf", "checksum": "md5:3661a3d21c585f0c41bbb242cb3b8cd0", "sha256": "a9b72a9f10cce025300b1019d8bd84d19833404c33dc7c0f195b370ce702aa89", "bytes": 253546, "page_count": 9, "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "checksum_match": true, "rights": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "role": "Local reading copy; original repository file retained unchanged" }, "page_count": 9, "field_assertions": [ { "field": "title", "value": "The Afterlife of the Work: Viewer as Evidence in Post-Interpretive Criticism", "status": "catalogue_title", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "Local display title; the deposited title is retained separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_title", "value": "The Afterlife of the Work: Viewer as Evidence in Post-Interpretive Criticism", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863836", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "doi", "value": "10.5281/zenodo.19863836", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863836", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "date", "value": "2026", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863836", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "conceptdoi", "value": "10.5281/zenodo.17076534", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863836", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "creators", "value": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "affiliation": "MuseumofOne", "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094" }, { "name": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "affiliation": null }, { "name": "Museum Of One", "affiliation": null } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863836", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "keywords", "value": [ "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Stillmark Theory", "Absential Aesthetics", "Witness Aesthetics", "Hauntmark Theory", "Presence-Based Criticism", "Custodianship of Art", "Restraint in front of art", "Moral proximity", "Interpretive silence", "Erasure as ethics", "Silence as method", "Language as violence", "Art encounter ethics", "Epistemology of witness", "Philosophy of Art", "Aesthetics", "Art Theory", "Contemporary Aesthetics", "Comparative Aesthetics", "Ethics in Art Criticism", "Interpretation and Meaning", "Criticism and Reception Theory", "Visual Culture Studies", "Epistemology of Art", "Dorian Vale", "Founder of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Post-Aesthetic Critic", "Independent Philosopher of Art", "Museum of One", "Art Writer and Theorist", "Aesthetic Philosopher", "Custodian of Witness Aesthetics", "The Doctrine of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "The Custodian's Oath", "The Canon of Witnesses", "Art as Truth", "Art as Presence", "The Viewer as Evidence", "Interpretation vs. Witnessing", "Language as Custody", "Erasure as Afterlife", "Post-Interpretive Lexicon", "Alternative art criticism", "New art criticism movement", "Ethical art theory", "Criticism beyond interpretation", "Quiet philosophy of art", "Radical art restraint", "Witness over interpretation", "Art Criticism Ethics", "Interpretive Restraint", "https://hcommons.org/members/dorianvale/", "https://philpeople.org/profiles/dorian-vale", "https://osf.io/xa5jw/", "https://independent.academia.edu/DorianVale", "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17112807", "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17078847", "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17069115", "https://figshare.com/authors/Dorian_Vale/22186984", "Q136308909", "Q136308879", "Q136308916", "Part of the Post-Interpretive Criticism movement (Q136308909), published by Museum of One (Q136308879), authored by Dorian Vale (Q136308916).", "https://zenodo.org/communities/post-interpretive-criticism", "https://www.semanticscholar.org/author/Dorian-Vale/2380743266", "https://scholar.google.com/citations?hl=en&authuser=1&user=15tvhjAAAAAJ" ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863836", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "license", "value": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863836", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "files", "value": [ { "name": "The Afterlife of the Work -Viewer as Evidence in Post-Interpretive Criticism.pdf", "url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19863836/files/The%20Afterlife%20of%20the%20Work%20-Viewer%20as%20Evidence%20in%20Post-Interpretive%20Criticism.pdf/content", "size": 253546, "size_label": "248 KB", "checksum": "md5:3661a3d21c585f0c41bbb242cb3b8cd0", "mimetype": "application/pdf" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863836", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_created", "value": "2026-04-28T18:52:53.714810+00:00", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863836", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_modified", "value": "2026-04-28T18:52:54.111962+00:00", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863836", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "record_modified", "value": "2026-11-04", "status": "derived_from_description_history", "note": "Latest documented local description event; not a publication, repository or source-review date.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_review", "value": "2026-11-04", "status": "catalogue_source_review", "note": "Review of descriptive sources; not the creation or modification date of the work or repository record.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "author", "value": "Dorian Vale", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "Institutional responsibility statement; original repository creator roles remain separate.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "publisher", "value": "Museum of One", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "Institutional responsibility statement; original repository creator roles remain separate.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "orcid", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "source_linked_identifier", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "Creator identifier supplied by the linked sources; no affiliation or endorsement is inferred.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "orcid_authority", "value": { "scheme": "ORCID", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "evidence_urls": [ "https://www.museumofone.art/archives-scholarly-infrastructure/", "https://eprints.rclis.org/47182/", "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ], "access_note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "evidence_receipt": "data/source/authority-review-2026-11-04.json" }, "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "source_url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "summary", "value": "An essay treating the lasting effects of an encounter with art as evidence within Post-Interpretive Criticism. Its focus is the viewer’s memory, response, and continuing responsibility to the work.", "status": "editorial_enrichment", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "Catalogue-editor summary based on the linked work; not an original publisher abstract.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "subjects", "value": [ "Viewer response", "Ethics of witnessing", "Memory", "Post-Interpretive Criticism" ], "status": "editorial_enrichment", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "Local discovery terms; no controlled-vocabulary assignment is claimed.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "collection", "value": "Theory & treatises", "status": "editorial_grouping", "note": "A local browsing collection, not an original repository collection.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "corroboration", "value": "Museum of One’s matching publication page confirms Dorian Vale’s authorship and the work’s institutional context. Its repository links and publication dates are retained separately from this selected Zenodo edition. Web-record dates are not treated as dates of the deposited edition. Source review: 4 November 2026.", "status": "catalogue_review_note", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "discrepancies", "value": [ "The repository also lists organizational or URL-form creator entries. The catalogue displays Dorian Vale as bibliographic author while retaining the deposited creator list separately.", "The source description includes a 2025 citation and an earlier DOI. The selected Zenodo record has a 2026 publication-date field; a web-publication date is not substituted for that deposited date.", "The institutional page does not explicitly link this selected edition DOI in its saved HTML. The match is at work level through title, authorship, and publication context; the catalogue preserves the exact repository edition separately." ], "status": "catalogue_review_note", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "date_precision", "value": "year", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863836", "note": "Precision reported exactly as supplied; missing month or day is not filled.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "medium", "value": "Digital document", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863836", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "digital_formats", "value": [ "application/pdf" ], "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863836", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "extent", "value": "1 digital file; 253546 bytes", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863836", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "digital_extent", "value": { "file_count": 1, "total_bytes": 253546, "formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "checksums": [ { "filename": "The Afterlife of the Work -Viewer as Evidence in Post-Interpretive Criticism.pdf", "algorithm": "md5", "value": "3661a3d21c585f0c41bbb242cb3b8cd0", "syntax_valid": true, "verification": "source_checksum_transcription; bytes not independently recomputed" } ], "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863836", "derivation": "File count and total bytes calculated from repository file metadata; MIME inferred from filename when absent." }, "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863836", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "identifier_validation", "value": { "orcid": { "source_value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "ISO 7064 MOD 11-2 checksum only; this is not a live registry verification." }, "isbn": [], "doi": { "source_value": "10.5281/zenodo.19863836", "syntax_valid": true, "note": "Syntax check only; repository snapshot supplies the identifier." } }, "status": "local_syntax_validation", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863836", "note": "Checksum/syntax validation does not verify registration, assignment or edition applicability.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "contributor_roles", "value": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": "MuseumofOne", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863836" }, { "name": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": null, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863836" }, { "name": "Museum Of One", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": null, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863836" }, { "name": "Museum Of One", "source_category": "contributor", "source_role": "RightsHolder", "role_label": "RightsHolder", "affiliation_as_supplied": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863836" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863836", "note": "Creator and contributor roles are transcribed, not inferred from names or affiliations.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "research_programme:https://www.museumofone.art/research-critical-language/", "value": { "title": "Alexander Viktorovich Markov: Critical Language and Lasting Correction", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-critical-language/", "status": "In development", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-critical-language/", "relation": "Earlier individual work linked as context for a developing programme; not a joint output or endorsement", "relation_label": "Earlier individual work linked as programme context" }, "status": "institutional_work_relationship", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-critical-language/", "note": "Programme relationship and stage follow the work-specific institutional badge; publication does not imply a completed programme or collaboration.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "entity_link:dorian-vale:author", "value": { "id": "dorian-vale", "label": "Dorian Vale", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "author", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author.", "variants": [ "Vale, Dorian" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:c738640c4b8a76eef0063558a2c418eda9ea7de721b3586f2294df3c471a2643", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." } }, { "field": "entity_link:museum-of-one:publisher", "value": { "id": "museum-of-one", "label": "Museum of One", "entity_type": "Organization", "relation": "publisher", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record.", "variants": [ "MuseumofOne", "MUSEUM OF ONE" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:cf97e96b4a5b895a36aa641a8f00a239a30775d1ee98f2c306bc0af4bfb28caa", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." } }, { "field": "entity_link:doris-salcedo:artist discussed", "value": { "id": "doris-salcedo", "label": "Doris Salcedo", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "artist discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The essay discusses Atrabiliarios as a case of the continuing effect of an encounter.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:474b860c7c23dcbec43a08fe2573b5bd61b3c95d573a92887e650398e5f912c0", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/doris-salcedo.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay discusses Atrabiliarios as a case of the continuing effect of an encounter." } }, { "field": "entity_link:zarina-hashmi:artist discussed", "value": { "id": "zarina-hashmi", "label": "Zarina Hashmi", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "artist discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The essay discusses Home Is a Foreign Place.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:8fddd62abf3006b54df8b026ac77a03d4614dc71cfe315ae0f83d82554d5924a", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/zarina-hashmi.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay discusses Home Is a Foreign Place." } }, { "field": "entity_link:teresa-margolles:artist discussed", "value": { "id": "teresa-margolles", "label": "Teresa Margolles", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "artist discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The essay discusses En el aire.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:3f687e931821937c4e35c3edd6aa7a6e3384448ae7bdde54a0b05681916c47eb", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/teresa-margolles.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay discusses En el aire." } }, { "field": "entity_link:marina-abramovic:artist discussed", "value": { "id": "marina-abramovic", "label": "Marina Abramović", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "artist discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The essay discusses the performance The Artist Is Present.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:dad7b40064ef229c0dab838dd489af972beef5e77024e4b22c23a6f53b0cf856", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/marina-abramovic.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay discusses the performance The Artist Is Present." } }, { "field": "entity_link:christian-boltanski:artist discussed", "value": { "id": "christian-boltanski", "label": "Christian Boltanski", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "artist discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The essay discusses Reserve of Dead Swiss.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:21096e4a5526fbc242d7cf36c7c480986820c6aaed09bcf7dcfd1fee009cbbec", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/christian-boltanski.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay discusses Reserve of Dead Swiss." } }, { "field": "entity_link:araya-rasdjarmrearnsook:artist discussed", "value": { "id": "araya-rasdjarmrearnsook", "label": "Araya Rasdjarmrearnsook", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "artist discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The essay discusses The Class.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:9872f180ff05c53228dd77157b18844d56100ba59ebcc0d70c4c157473d72d16", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/araya-rasdjarmrearnsook.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay discusses The Class." } }, { "field": "entity_link:ana-mendieta:artist discussed", "value": { "id": "ana-mendieta", "label": "Ana Mendieta", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "artist discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The essay discusses the Silueta Series.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:ea850f4d9bca161190a2baa563085416daa312611637783fac1a3d96f0350d16", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/ana-mendieta.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay discusses the Silueta Series." } }, { "field": "entity_link:atrabiliarios:artwork discussed", "value": { "id": "atrabiliarios", "label": "Atrabiliarios", "entity_type": "Artwork", "relation": "artwork discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The essay explicitly attributes the installation to Doris Salcedo.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:b28d13a40a140b31bc2d8290a52dfc52aa8a9950cd91ebfda810afc4546d3a08", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/atrabiliarios.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay explicitly attributes the installation to Doris Salcedo." } }, { "field": "entity_link:home-is-a-foreign-place:artwork discussed", "value": { "id": "home-is-a-foreign-place", "label": "Home Is a Foreign Place", "entity_type": "Artwork", "relation": "artwork discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The essay explicitly attributes the woodcut portfolio to Zarina Hashmi.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:02652b31bb5d5a88507e7b0d29e35fe00c25d5ede293c24dd4fcee72460c6474", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/home-is-a-foreign-place.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay explicitly attributes the woodcut portfolio to Zarina Hashmi." } }, { "field": "entity_link:en-el-aire:artwork discussed", "value": { "id": "en-el-aire", "label": "En el aire", "entity_type": "Artwork", "relation": "artwork discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The essay explicitly attributes the installation to Teresa Margolles.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:3bd893581ecbb8be077f8c048b1cc44a55121944620dd4f6a7a0046d1e8ad4d4", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/en-el-aire.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay explicitly attributes the installation to Teresa Margolles." } }, { "field": "entity_link:the-artist-is-present:artwork discussed", "value": { "id": "the-artist-is-present", "label": "The Artist Is Present", "entity_type": "Artwork", "relation": "artwork discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The essay explicitly attributes the performance to Marina Abramović.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:a819aff6aca64c3466985b818d16118bfdbee06aa5c5c758d127c782f28e0703", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/the-artist-is-present.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay explicitly attributes the performance to Marina Abramović." } }, { "field": "entity_link:reserve-of-dead-swiss:artwork discussed", "value": { "id": "reserve-of-dead-swiss", "label": "Reserve of Dead Swiss", "entity_type": "Artwork", "relation": "artwork discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The essay explicitly attributes the work to Christian Boltanski.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:f91e2df2f27a7426017d385a90b87341daec09a8d9401fb65e764fd1da9edbb9", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/reserve-of-dead-swiss.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay explicitly attributes the work to Christian Boltanski." } }, { "field": "entity_link:the-class:artwork discussed", "value": { "id": "the-class", "label": "The Class", "entity_type": "Artwork", "relation": "artwork discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The essay explicitly attributes the work to Araya Rasdjarmrearnsook.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:8e0687e38978fcc4ed59835c61d1c27d085fc04684e62bef0acbf0a7604089e0", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/the-class.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay explicitly attributes the work to Araya Rasdjarmrearnsook." } }, { "field": "entity_link:silueta-series:artwork discussed", "value": { "id": "silueta-series", "label": "Silueta Series", "entity_type": "Artwork", "relation": "artwork discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The essay explicitly attributes this series to Ana Mendieta. This is a series-level contextual record.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:5ae1c30c88830d4eaf1c37329db828968c29f2e59c25d903963a623f61f99c31", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/silueta-series.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay explicitly attributes this series to Ana Mendieta. This is a series-level contextual record." } }, { "field": "controlled_subjects", "value": [ { "id": "viewer-response", "label": "Viewer response", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#viewer-response", "url": "vocabulary.html#viewer-response", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:viewer-response", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Viewer responses" ], "definition": "The effects of encountering art on its viewer.", "scope_note": "Use for response, lasting experience, and the viewer’s role within a critical account; not a claim of empirical audience research.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "memory" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "ethics-of-witnessing", "label": "Ethics of witnessing", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#ethics-of-witnessing", "url": "vocabulary.html#ethics-of-witnessing", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:ethics-of-witnessing", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "ethics of witnessing" ], "definition": "Ethical responsibility in attending to artworks and the histories they engage.", "scope_note": "Local access term used for the Museum of One corpus. Preserve the author’s framework attribution; no equivalence with an external philosophical school is asserted.", "kind": "local-framework-concept", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "post-interpretive-criticism", "witnessing" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "memory", "label": "Memory", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#memory", "url": "vocabulary.html#memory", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:memory", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "The retention and continuing effects of experiences or histories.", "scope_note": "Use for work addressing remembered encounters with art; Historical memory provides a narrower local access term.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [ "historical-memory" ], "related": [ "viewer-response" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "post-interpretive-criticism", "label": "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#post-interpretive-criticism", "url": "vocabulary.html#post-interpretive-criticism", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:post-interpretive-criticism", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "PIC", "Post Interpretive Criticism" ], "definition": "The critical framework named and developed in the Museum of One publications.", "scope_note": "Local named intellectual framework. Used for records explicitly concerned with it; no Getty, Library of Congress, or other external equivalence is asserted.", "kind": "local-framework-concept", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "custodianship", "ethics-of-witnessing", "foundational-writings", "moral-proximity" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Local preferred terms with definitions and synonyms. External alignment is scoped in the vocabulary register." }, { "field": "genre_terms", "value": [ { "id": "genre-journal-article", "label": "Journal article", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#genre-journal-article", "url": "vocabulary.html#genre-journal-article", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:genre-journal-article", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Journal articles" ], "definition": "A contribution issued as part of a journal or periodical.", "scope_note": "Describes publication genre based on the catalogued source record; peer-review status is a separate question.", "kind": "genre", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "verified_mapping", "external_mappings": [ { "vocabulary": "Getty Art & Architecture Thesaurus", "label": "articles", "uri": "http://vocab.getty.edu/aat/300048715", "source_url": "https://www.getty.edu/vow/AATFullDisplay?find=&logic=AND¬e=&subjectid=300048715", "relation": "broadMatch", "status": "verified", "verified_on": "2026-11-04", "note": "Getty’s articles concept includes contributions to magazines, newspapers, encyclopedias, and other works; journal article is the narrower local genre." } ], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "type", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Local resource-genre classification. Digital file format is recorded separately." }, { "field": "archival_context", "value": { "description_profile": "moo-description-policy-1.0", "catalogue_snapshot_date": "2026-11-04", "snapshot_note": "Selected catalogue snapshot; not a live repository synchronisation.", "record_category": "Published library and repository material", "reference_code_status": "Stable local catalogue reference; not evidence of an archival acquisition or a previous catalogue accession.", "source_repository": { "name": "Zenodo", "record_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863836" }, "institutional_context_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_metadata_retrieved": "2026-11-04", "source_metadata_retrieval_status": "Documented in catalogue source provenance", "source_snapshot": "source/19863836.json", "source_filenames": [ "The Afterlife of the Work -Viewer as Evidence in Post-Interpretive Criticism.pdf" ], "selection_basis": "Local descriptive selection of publicly published material; public availability does not establish ownership of originals.", "custodial_history": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No donation, physical transfer, acquisition agreement or chain of custody is documented by this catalogue. Zenodo remains the source repository for the deposited version." }, "original_order": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No original archival order is asserted. Current browsing groupings are local editorial arrangement." }, "arrangement": { "status": "local_editorial", "grouping": "Theory & treatises", "statement": "A browsing grouping, not an original fonds or archival series." }, "responsible_service": { "name": "Museum of One", "service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "website": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "email": "research@museumofone.art" }, "description_method": "Source-based description with automated drafting and metadata assistance. Responsibility for the public catalogue rests with Museum of One; automated assistance does not constitute independent scholarly or curatorial review.", "policy_url": "policies.html", "correction_email": "research@museumofone.art", "access_copy": { "role": "Local digital reading copy of the deposited file", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19863836/files/The%20Afterlife%20of%20the%20Work%20-Viewer%20as%20Evidence%20in%20Post-Interpretive%20Criticism.pdf/content", "source_filename": "The Afterlife of the Work -Viewer as Evidence in Post-Interpretive Criticism.pdf", "local_path": "assets/documents/19863836.pdf", "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "source_checksum_match": true, "sha256": "a9b72a9f10cce025300b1019d8bd84d19833404c33dc7c0f195b370ce702aa89", "statement": "Access copy only; no ownership or physical custody transfer is implied." } }, "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Provenance records what is documented and leaves unknown custody and original order explicit." }, { "field": "description_history", "value": [ { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Source-based catalogue description", "note": "Local description assembled from the identified public repository record and available institutional work record. Source metadata remains separately identifiable.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/19863836", "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Qualified descriptive enrichment", "note": "Local editorial description, arrangement and source-qualified bibliographic context recorded alongside source metadata. Unknown or disputed values remain qualified.", "fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/19863836", "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Automated file checksum and PDF inspection", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Digital reading copy verified", "note": "Downloaded access-copy MD5 matched the source checksum; local SHA-256 and PDF file-page count are recorded in the file manifest. This event does not describe transfer of custody.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19863836/files/The%20Afterlife%20of%20the%20Work%20-Viewer%20as%20Evidence%20in%20Post-Interpretive%20Criticism.pdf/content" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Description policy and provenance context adopted", "note": "Responsible service, source repository, local access-copy role, unknown custody and original order, correction route and dated description history made explicit under moo-description-policy-1.0.", "sources": [ "policies.html" ] }, { "event_id": "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Unify graph identities and qualify exported relationships and citations", "note": "Local graph projection now uses one contextual identity per entity, distinguishes work-level institutional matches from selected-edition links, retains title-level ISBN uncertainty, and derives citations from the source title. Typed relation assertions and a versioned validation profile are introduced. No publication date, original source snapshot or PDF changed.", "fields": [ "metadata_profile", "relationship_assertions", "identity", "institutional_match_scope", "citation_projection" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Source-based metadata implementation and regression validation", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication, source review or acquisition date", "sources": [ "metadata/metadata-profile.json" ] }, { "event_id": "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Record inspected public ORCID profile evidence", "note": "The official ORCID public person API returned the credited name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website. This confirms a matching public profile, not independently verified biographical or affiliation claims. Original creator arrays and source snapshots are unchanged.", "fields": [ "orcid_authority" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Read-only official public API inspection", "date_kind": "Local authority review and catalogue description event; not a publication or original creation date", "sources": [ "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ] } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Catalogue description events; these are not work publication dates or acquisition dates." }, { "field": "pirr_references", "value": [ { "programme_key": "research-critical-language", "programme_title": "Alexander Viktorovich Markov: Critical Language and Lasting Correction", "programme_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-critical-language/", "programme_stage": "In development", "registry_url": "research-registry.html#research-critical-language", "identifiers": [ { "scheme": "PIRR programme reference", "value": "moo-program-2b3ad664cbd92f69b862db8c", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-critical-language/#programme-record" } ], "relation": "Earlier individual work linked as programme context", "relation_note": "Earlier individual work linked as context for a developing programme; not a joint output or endorsement", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-critical-language/" } ], "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "PIRR project IDs and programme references identify research records, not publication versions or independent chapter deposits." }, { "field": "relationship_assertions", "value": [ { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:c738640c4b8a76eef0063558a2c418eda9ea7de721b3586f2294df3c471a2643", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:cf97e96b4a5b895a36aa641a8f00a239a30775d1ee98f2c306bc0af4bfb28caa", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:474b860c7c23dcbec43a08fe2573b5bd61b3c95d573a92887e650398e5f912c0", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/doris-salcedo.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay discusses Atrabiliarios as a case of the continuing effect of an encounter." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:8fddd62abf3006b54df8b026ac77a03d4614dc71cfe315ae0f83d82554d5924a", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/zarina-hashmi.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay discusses Home Is a Foreign Place." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:3f687e931821937c4e35c3edd6aa7a6e3384448ae7bdde54a0b05681916c47eb", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/teresa-margolles.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay discusses En el aire." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:dad7b40064ef229c0dab838dd489af972beef5e77024e4b22c23a6f53b0cf856", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/marina-abramovic.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay discusses the performance The Artist Is Present." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:21096e4a5526fbc242d7cf36c7c480986820c6aaed09bcf7dcfd1fee009cbbec", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/christian-boltanski.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay discusses Reserve of Dead Swiss." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:9872f180ff05c53228dd77157b18844d56100ba59ebcc0d70c4c157473d72d16", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/araya-rasdjarmrearnsook.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay discusses The Class." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:ea850f4d9bca161190a2baa563085416daa312611637783fac1a3d96f0350d16", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/ana-mendieta.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay discusses the Silueta Series." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:b28d13a40a140b31bc2d8290a52dfc52aa8a9950cd91ebfda810afc4546d3a08", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/atrabiliarios.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay explicitly attributes the installation to Doris Salcedo." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:02652b31bb5d5a88507e7b0d29e35fe00c25d5ede293c24dd4fcee72460c6474", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/home-is-a-foreign-place.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay explicitly attributes the woodcut portfolio to Zarina Hashmi." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:3bd893581ecbb8be077f8c048b1cc44a55121944620dd4f6a7a0046d1e8ad4d4", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/en-el-aire.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay explicitly attributes the installation to Teresa Margolles." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:a819aff6aca64c3466985b818d16118bfdbee06aa5c5c758d127c782f28e0703", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/the-artist-is-present.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay explicitly attributes the performance to Marina Abramović." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:f91e2df2f27a7426017d385a90b87341daec09a8d9401fb65e764fd1da9edbb9", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/reserve-of-dead-swiss.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay explicitly attributes the work to Christian Boltanski." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:8e0687e38978fcc4ed59835c61d1c27d085fc04684e62bef0acbf0a7604089e0", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/the-class.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay explicitly attributes the work to Araya Rasdjarmrearnsook." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:5ae1c30c88830d4eaf1c37329db828968c29f2e59c25d903963a623f61f99c31", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/silueta-series.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay explicitly attributes this series to Ana Mendieta. This is a series-level contextual record." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:baa1b40ea57b447b4aced4a214c9d5d9635e59823cff77f11854eb8cbfe22105", "subject": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#describes", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "metadata_field", "field": "linked_zenodo_dois", "values": [ "10.5281/zenodo.17076535" ] }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "Exact-edition matching requires the selected DOI in the reviewed page metadata; other matches retain their wider scope." } ], "status": "typed_evidence_projection", "note": "Stable, typed assertions retain source scope and explicit unknown review metadata." }, { "field": "reading_copy", "value": { "id": "19863836", "title": "The Afterlife of the Work: Viewer as Evidence in Post-Interpretive Criticism", "accession": "MOO-CAT-015", "pdf_url": "../assets/documents/19863836.pdf", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19863836/files/The%20Afterlife%20of%20the%20Work%20-Viewer%20as%20Evidence%20in%20Post-Interpretive%20Criticism.pdf/content", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863836", "source_filename": "The Afterlife of the Work -Viewer as Evidence in Post-Interpretive Criticism.pdf", "checksum": "md5:3661a3d21c585f0c41bbb242cb3b8cd0", "sha256": "a9b72a9f10cce025300b1019d8bd84d19833404c33dc7c0f195b370ce702aa89", "bytes": 253546, "page_count": 9, "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "checksum_match": true, "rights": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "role": "Local reading copy; original repository file retained unchanged" }, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19863836/files/The%20Afterlife%20of%20the%20Work%20-Viewer%20as%20Evidence%20in%20Post-Interpretive%20Criticism.pdf/content", "status": "derived_file_inspection", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "note": "Byte-identical local access copy. Source MD5 was recomputed and matched; SHA-256 and page count were measured from the downloaded PDF. This is not a preservation-deposit claim." }, { "field": "page_count", "value": 9, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19863836/files/The%20Afterlife%20of%20the%20Work%20-Viewer%20as%20Evidence%20in%20Post-Interpretive%20Criticism.pdf/content", "status": "derived_file_inspection", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "note": "Total PDF file pages measured from the deposited file, including cover and unnumbered pages. Not a claim about printed pagination." } ], "entity_links": [ { "id": "dorian-vale", "label": "Dorian Vale", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "author", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author.", "variants": [ "Vale, Dorian" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "museum-of-one", "label": "Museum of One", "entity_type": "Organization", "relation": "publisher", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record.", "variants": [ "MuseumofOne", "MUSEUM OF ONE" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "doris-salcedo", "label": "Doris Salcedo", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "artist discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The essay discusses Atrabiliarios as a case of the continuing effect of an encounter.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "zarina-hashmi", "label": "Zarina Hashmi", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "artist discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The essay discusses Home Is a Foreign Place.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "teresa-margolles", "label": "Teresa Margolles", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "artist discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The essay discusses En el aire.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "marina-abramovic", "label": "Marina Abramović", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "artist discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The essay discusses the performance The Artist Is Present.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "christian-boltanski", "label": "Christian Boltanski", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "artist discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The essay discusses Reserve of Dead Swiss.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "araya-rasdjarmrearnsook", "label": "Araya Rasdjarmrearnsook", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "artist discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The essay discusses The Class.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "ana-mendieta", "label": "Ana Mendieta", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "artist discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The essay discusses the Silueta Series.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "atrabiliarios", "label": "Atrabiliarios", "entity_type": "Artwork", "relation": "artwork discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The essay explicitly attributes the installation to Doris Salcedo.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "home-is-a-foreign-place", "label": "Home Is a Foreign Place", "entity_type": "Artwork", "relation": "artwork discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The essay explicitly attributes the woodcut portfolio to Zarina Hashmi.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "en-el-aire", "label": "En el aire", "entity_type": "Artwork", "relation": "artwork discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The essay explicitly attributes the installation to Teresa Margolles.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "the-artist-is-present", "label": "The Artist Is Present", "entity_type": "Artwork", "relation": "artwork discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The essay explicitly attributes the performance to Marina Abramović.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "reserve-of-dead-swiss", "label": "Reserve of Dead Swiss", "entity_type": "Artwork", "relation": "artwork discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The essay explicitly attributes the work to Christian Boltanski.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "the-class", "label": "The Class", "entity_type": "Artwork", "relation": "artwork discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The essay explicitly attributes the work to Araya Rasdjarmrearnsook.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "silueta-series", "label": "Silueta Series", "entity_type": "Artwork", "relation": "artwork discussed", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The essay explicitly attributes this series to Ana Mendieta. This is a series-level contextual record.", "variants": [], "evidence_scope": "work" } ], "contents": [], "controlled_subjects": [ { "id": "viewer-response", "label": "Viewer response", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#viewer-response", "url": "vocabulary.html#viewer-response", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:viewer-response", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Viewer responses" ], "definition": "The effects of encountering art on its viewer.", "scope_note": "Use for response, lasting experience, and the viewer’s role within a critical account; not a claim of empirical audience research.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "memory" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "ethics-of-witnessing", "label": "Ethics of witnessing", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#ethics-of-witnessing", "url": "vocabulary.html#ethics-of-witnessing", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:ethics-of-witnessing", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "ethics of witnessing" ], "definition": "Ethical responsibility in attending to artworks and the histories they engage.", "scope_note": "Local access term used for the Museum of One corpus. Preserve the author’s framework attribution; no equivalence with an external philosophical school is asserted.", "kind": "local-framework-concept", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "post-interpretive-criticism", "witnessing" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "memory", "label": "Memory", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#memory", "url": "vocabulary.html#memory", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:memory", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "The retention and continuing effects of experiences or histories.", "scope_note": "Use for work addressing remembered encounters with art; Historical memory provides a narrower local access term.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [ "historical-memory" ], "related": [ "viewer-response" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "post-interpretive-criticism", "label": "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#post-interpretive-criticism", "url": "vocabulary.html#post-interpretive-criticism", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:post-interpretive-criticism", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "PIC", "Post Interpretive Criticism" ], "definition": "The critical framework named and developed in the Museum of One publications.", "scope_note": "Local named intellectual framework. Used for records explicitly concerned with it; no Getty, Library of Congress, or other external equivalence is asserted.", "kind": "local-framework-concept", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "custodianship", "ethics-of-witnessing", "foundational-writings", "moral-proximity" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "genre_terms": [ { "id": "genre-journal-article", "label": "Journal article", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#genre-journal-article", "url": "vocabulary.html#genre-journal-article", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:genre-journal-article", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Journal articles" ], "definition": "A contribution issued as part of a journal or periodical.", "scope_note": "Describes publication genre based on the catalogued source record; peer-review status is a separate question.", "kind": "genre", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "verified_mapping", "external_mappings": [ { "vocabulary": "Getty Art & Architecture Thesaurus", "label": "articles", "uri": "http://vocab.getty.edu/aat/300048715", "source_url": "https://www.getty.edu/vow/AATFullDisplay?find=&logic=AND¬e=&subjectid=300048715", "relation": "broadMatch", "status": "verified", "verified_on": "2026-11-04", "note": "Getty’s articles concept includes contributions to magazines, newspapers, encyclopedias, and other works; journal article is the narrower local genre." } ], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "type", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "vocabulary_version": 4, "description_history": [ { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Source-based catalogue description", "note": "Local description assembled from the identified public repository record and available institutional work record. Source metadata remains separately identifiable.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/19863836", "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Qualified descriptive enrichment", "note": "Local editorial description, arrangement and source-qualified bibliographic context recorded alongside source metadata. Unknown or disputed values remain qualified.", "fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/19863836", "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Automated file checksum and PDF inspection", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Digital reading copy verified", "note": "Downloaded access-copy MD5 matched the source checksum; local SHA-256 and PDF file-page count are recorded in the file manifest. This event does not describe transfer of custody.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19863836/files/The%20Afterlife%20of%20the%20Work%20-Viewer%20as%20Evidence%20in%20Post-Interpretive%20Criticism.pdf/content" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Description policy and provenance context adopted", "note": "Responsible service, source repository, local access-copy role, unknown custody and original order, correction route and dated description history made explicit under moo-description-policy-1.0.", "sources": [ "policies.html" ] }, { "event_id": "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Unify graph identities and qualify exported relationships and citations", "note": "Local graph projection now uses one contextual identity per entity, distinguishes work-level institutional matches from selected-edition links, retains title-level ISBN uncertainty, and derives citations from the source title. Typed relation assertions and a versioned validation profile are introduced. No publication date, original source snapshot or PDF changed.", "fields": [ "metadata_profile", "relationship_assertions", "identity", "institutional_match_scope", "citation_projection" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Source-based metadata implementation and regression validation", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication, source review or acquisition date", "sources": [ "metadata/metadata-profile.json" ] }, { "event_id": "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Record inspected public ORCID profile evidence", "note": "The official ORCID public person API returned the credited name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website. This confirms a matching public profile, not independently verified biographical or affiliation claims. Original creator arrays and source snapshots are unchanged.", "fields": [ "orcid_authority" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Read-only official public API inspection", "date_kind": "Local authority review and catalogue description event; not a publication or original creation date", "sources": [ "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ] } ], "record_modified": "2026-11-04", "record_modified_provenance": { "status": "derived_from_description_history", "event_ids": [ "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04" ], "note": "Latest documented local description event; not a publication, repository or source-review date." }, "archival_context": { "description_profile": "moo-description-policy-1.0", "catalogue_snapshot_date": "2026-11-04", "snapshot_note": "Selected catalogue snapshot; not a live repository synchronisation.", "record_category": "Published library and repository material", "reference_code_status": "Stable local catalogue reference; not evidence of an archival acquisition or a previous catalogue accession.", "source_repository": { "name": "Zenodo", "record_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863836" }, "institutional_context_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_metadata_retrieved": "2026-11-04", "source_metadata_retrieval_status": "Documented in catalogue source provenance", "source_snapshot": "source/19863836.json", "source_filenames": [ "The Afterlife of the Work -Viewer as Evidence in Post-Interpretive Criticism.pdf" ], "selection_basis": "Local descriptive selection of publicly published material; public availability does not establish ownership of originals.", "custodial_history": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No donation, physical transfer, acquisition agreement or chain of custody is documented by this catalogue. Zenodo remains the source repository for the deposited version." }, "original_order": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No original archival order is asserted. Current browsing groupings are local editorial arrangement." }, "arrangement": { "status": "local_editorial", "grouping": "Theory & treatises", "statement": "A browsing grouping, not an original fonds or archival series." }, "responsible_service": { "name": "Museum of One", "service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "website": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "email": "research@museumofone.art" }, "description_method": "Source-based description with automated drafting and metadata assistance. Responsibility for the public catalogue rests with Museum of One; automated assistance does not constitute independent scholarly or curatorial review.", "policy_url": "policies.html", "correction_email": "research@museumofone.art", "access_copy": { "role": "Local digital reading copy of the deposited file", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19863836/files/The%20Afterlife%20of%20the%20Work%20-Viewer%20as%20Evidence%20in%20Post-Interpretive%20Criticism.pdf/content", "source_filename": "The Afterlife of the Work -Viewer as Evidence in Post-Interpretive Criticism.pdf", "local_path": "assets/documents/19863836.pdf", "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "source_checksum_match": true, "sha256": "a9b72a9f10cce025300b1019d8bd84d19833404c33dc7c0f195b370ce702aa89", "statement": "Access copy only; no ownership or physical custody transfer is implied." } }, "description_policy_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "pirr_references": [ { "programme_key": "research-critical-language", "programme_title": "Alexander Viktorovich Markov: Critical Language and Lasting Correction", "programme_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-critical-language/", "programme_stage": "In development", "registry_url": "research-registry.html#research-critical-language", "identifiers": [ { "scheme": "PIRR programme reference", "value": "moo-program-2b3ad664cbd92f69b862db8c", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-critical-language/#programme-record" } ], "relation": "Earlier individual work linked as programme context", "relation_note": "Earlier individual work linked as context for a developing programme; not a joint output or endorsement", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/research-critical-language/" } ], "pirr_work_identity": { "archive_reference": "MOO-CAT-015", "edition_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19863836", "zenodo_record_id": "19863836", "identifier_scope": "Publication identity; PIRR identifiers in programme relationships identify research records, not this publication." }, "metadata_origin": "https://archive.museumofone.art", "identity": { "work": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "edition": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19863836", "version_family": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17076534", "catalogue_record": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#catalogue-record" }, "institutional_match_scope": "work", "relationship_assertions": [ { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:c738640c4b8a76eef0063558a2c418eda9ea7de721b3586f2294df3c471a2643", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:cf97e96b4a5b895a36aa641a8f00a239a30775d1ee98f2c306bc0af4bfb28caa", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:474b860c7c23dcbec43a08fe2573b5bd61b3c95d573a92887e650398e5f912c0", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/doris-salcedo.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay discusses Atrabiliarios as a case of the continuing effect of an encounter." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:8fddd62abf3006b54df8b026ac77a03d4614dc71cfe315ae0f83d82554d5924a", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/zarina-hashmi.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay discusses Home Is a Foreign Place." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:3f687e931821937c4e35c3edd6aa7a6e3384448ae7bdde54a0b05681916c47eb", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/teresa-margolles.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay discusses En el aire." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:dad7b40064ef229c0dab838dd489af972beef5e77024e4b22c23a6f53b0cf856", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/marina-abramovic.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay discusses the performance The Artist Is Present." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:21096e4a5526fbc242d7cf36c7c480986820c6aaed09bcf7dcfd1fee009cbbec", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/christian-boltanski.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay discusses Reserve of Dead Swiss." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:9872f180ff05c53228dd77157b18844d56100ba59ebcc0d70c4c157473d72d16", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/araya-rasdjarmrearnsook.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay discusses The Class." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:ea850f4d9bca161190a2baa563085416daa312611637783fac1a3d96f0350d16", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artist", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/ana-mendieta.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay discusses the Silueta Series." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:b28d13a40a140b31bc2d8290a52dfc52aa8a9950cd91ebfda810afc4546d3a08", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/atrabiliarios.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay explicitly attributes the installation to Doris Salcedo." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:02652b31bb5d5a88507e7b0d29e35fe00c25d5ede293c24dd4fcee72460c6474", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/home-is-a-foreign-place.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay explicitly attributes the woodcut portfolio to Zarina Hashmi." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:3bd893581ecbb8be077f8c048b1cc44a55121944620dd4f6a7a0046d1e8ad4d4", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/en-el-aire.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay explicitly attributes the installation to Teresa Margolles." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:a819aff6aca64c3466985b818d16118bfdbee06aa5c5c758d127c782f28e0703", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/the-artist-is-present.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay explicitly attributes the performance to Marina Abramović." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:f91e2df2f27a7426017d385a90b87341daec09a8d9401fb65e764fd1da9edbb9", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/reserve-of-dead-swiss.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay explicitly attributes the work to Christian Boltanski." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:8e0687e38978fcc4ed59835c61d1c27d085fc04684e62bef0acbf0a7604089e0", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/the-class.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay explicitly attributes the work to Araya Rasdjarmrearnsook." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:5ae1c30c88830d4eaf1c37329db828968c29f2e59c25d903963a623f61f99c31", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#discusses-artwork", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/silueta-series.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The essay explicitly attributes this series to Ana Mendieta. This is a series-level contextual record." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:baa1b40ea57b447b4aced4a214c9d5d9635e59823cff77f11854eb8cbfe22105", "subject": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#describes", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863836.html#work", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/the-afterlife-of-the-work-viewer-as-evidence-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "metadata_field", "field": "linked_zenodo_dois", "values": [ "10.5281/zenodo.17076535" ] }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "Exact-edition matching requires the selected DOI in the reviewed page metadata; other matches retain their wider scope." } ], "orcid_authority": { "scheme": "ORCID", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "evidence_urls": [ "https://www.museumofone.art/archives-scholarly-infrastructure/", "https://eprints.rclis.org/47182/", "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ], "access_note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "evidence_receipt": "data/source/authority-review-2026-11-04.json" } }, { "id": "19863851", "accession": "MOO-CAT-016", "title": "Language as Custody — Writing Without Harm in Post-Interpretive Criticism", "source_title": "Language as Custody — Writing Without Harm in Post-Interpretive Criticism", "short_title": "Language as Custody", "author": "Dorian Vale", "creators": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "affiliation": null, "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094" } ], "doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19863851", "conceptdoi": "10.5281/zenodo.17077652", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863851", "date": "2026", "type": "Journal article", "source_resource_type": { "title": "Journal article", "type": "publication", "subtype": "article" }, "version": "", "collection": "Theory & treatises", "summary": "An essay considering how language may protect or distort the ethical force of artworks. It develops restraint in writing as a form of custodianship, particularly around trauma, silence, and exile.", "subjects": [ "Critical language", "Art writing", "Custodianship", "Post-Interpretive Criticism" ], "keywords": [ "Restraint in front of art", "Moral proximity", "Interpretive silence", "Erasure as ethics", "Silence as method", "Ontology of beauty", "Aesthetic mercy", "Language as violence", "Art encounter ethics", "Epistemology of witness", "Divine proximity in aesthetics", "Philosophy of Art", "Aesthetics", "Art Theory", "Contemporary Aesthetics", "Phenomenology and Art", "Ethics in Art Criticism", "Interpretation and Meaning", "Criticism and Reception Theory", "Visual Culture Studies", "Founder of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Post-Aesthetic Critic", "Independent Philosopher of Art", "Museum of One", "Art Writer and Theorist", "Custodian of Witness Aesthetics", "Art as Truth", "The Viewer as Evidence", "nterpretation vs. Witnessing", "Erasure as Afterlife", "Language as Custody", "Post-Interpretive Lexicon", "Alternative art criticism", "New art criticism movement", "Ethical art theory", "Criticism beyond interpretation", "Quiet philosophy of art", "Radical art restraint", "Witness over interpretation", "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Dorian Vale", "Witness Aesthetics", "Stillmark Theory", "Art as Presence", "Art Criticism Ethics", "Custodianship of Art", "Copyright © Dorian Vale. Published by Museum of One.", "https://www.museumofone.art/", "https://hcommons.org/members/dorianvale/", "https://philpeople.org/profiles/dorian-vale", "https://osf.io/xa5jw/", "https://independent.academia.edu/DorianVale", "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17078847", "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17112807", "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17069115", "https://figshare.com/authors/Dorian_Vale/22186984", "https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5443334", "http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.5443334", "http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.5443334", "Q136308909", "Q136308879", "Q136308916", "https://scholar.google.com/citations?hl=en&authuser=1&user=15tvhjAAAAAJ" ], "license": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "files": [ { "name": "Language as Custody — Writing Without Harm in Post-Interpretive Criticism.pdf", "url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19863851/files/Language%20as%20Custody%20%E2%80%94%20Writing%20Without%20Harm%20in%20Post-Interpretive%20Criticism.pdf/content", "size": 253299, "size_label": "247 KB", "checksum": "md5:634bb017af7a7d068ea135a9c85a7a57", "mimetype": "application/pdf" } ], "institutional_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/language-as-custody-writing-without-harm-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "corroboration": "Museum of One’s matching publication page confirms Dorian Vale’s authorship and the work’s institutional context. Its repository links and publication dates are retained separately from this selected Zenodo edition. Web-record dates are not treated as dates of the deposited edition. Source review: 4 November 2026.", "discrepancies": [ "The source description includes a 2025 citation and an earlier DOI. The selected Zenodo record has a 2026 publication-date field; a web-publication date is not substituted for that deposited date.", "The institutional page does not explicitly link this selected edition DOI in its saved HTML. The match is at work level through title, authorship, and publication context; the catalogue preserves the exact repository edition separately." ], "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "publisher": "Museum of One", "language": null, "isbn": null, "related_identifiers": [ { "identifier": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "relation": "cites", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://hcommons.org/members/dorianvale/", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://osf.io/xa5jw/", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://philpeople.org/profiles/dorian-vale", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://independent.academia.edu/DorianVale", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://figshare.com/authors/Dorian_Vale/22186984", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "10.5281/zenodo.17112807", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "10.5281/zenodo.17078847", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "10.5281/zenodo.17069115", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5443334", "relation": "isIdenticalTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "10.2139/ssrn.5443334", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Post-Interprative-Criticism%3A-Foundational-Essays-Vale/09538ab14a89022e2886f9cccaf133e8d5c9cf7d", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://zenodo.org/communities/post-interpretive-criticism", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.semanticscholar.org/author/Dorian-Vale/2380743266", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://scholar.google.com/citations?hl=en&authuser=1&user=15tvhjAAAAAJ", "relation": "cites", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "10.2139/ssrn.5471149", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "https://ssrn.com/abstract=5471149", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" } ], "alternate_identifiers": [ { "identifier": "https://www.museumofone.art/" }, { "identifier": "https://hcommons.org/members/dorianvale/" }, { "identifier": "https://philpeople.org/profiles/dorian-vale" }, { "identifier": "https://osf.io/xa5jw/" }, { "identifier": "https://independent.academia.edu/DorianVale" }, { "identifier": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17112807" }, { "identifier": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17078847" }, { "identifier": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17069115" }, { "identifier": "https://figshare.com/authors/Dorian_Vale/22186984" }, { "identifier": "https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5443334" }, { "identifier": "10.2139/ssrn.5443334" }, { "identifier": "https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Post-Interprative-Criticism%3A-Foundational-Essays-Vale/09538ab14a89022e2886f9cccaf133e8d5c9cf7d" }, { "identifier": "https://zenodo.org/communities/post-interpretive-criticism" }, { "identifier": "https://www.semanticscholar.org/author/Dorian-Vale/2380743266" }, { "identifier": "https://scholar.google.com/citations?hl=en&authuser=1&user=15tvhjAAAAAJ" }, { "identifier": "https://ssrn.com/abstract=5471149" }, { "identifier": "10.2139/ssrn.5471149" } ], "source_references": [ "https://www.museumofone.art/", "https://hcommons.org/members/dorianvale/", "https://philpeople.org/profiles/dorian-vale", "https://osf.io/xa5jw/", "https://independent.academia.edu/DorianVale", "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17112807", "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17078847", "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17069115", "https://figshare.com/authors/Dorian_Vale/22186984", "https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5443334", "http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.5443334", "http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.5443334", "Q136308909", "Q136308879", "Q136308916", "https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Post-Interprative-Criticism%3A-Foundational-Essays-Vale/09538ab14a89022e2886f9cccaf133e8d5c9cf7d", "https://www.semanticscholar.org/author/Dorian-Vale/2380743266", "https://zenodo.org/communities/post-interpretive-criticism", "https://scholar.google.com/citations?hl=en&authuser=1&user=15tvhjAAAAAJ", "https://ssrn.com/abstract=5471149", "http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.5471149" ], "source_journal": { "title": "Museum of One" }, "source_imprint": null, "source_contributors": [ { "name": "Museumofone.art", "affiliation": null, "type": "RightsHolder" }, { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "affiliation": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "type": "RightsHolder" } ], "source_created": "2026-04-28T18:55:23.348733+00:00", "source_modified": "2026-10-11T17:52:14.842757+00:00", "source_description_html": "

Language as Custody — Writing Without Harm in Post-Interpretive Criticism

\n

By Dorian Vale

\n

In this critical essay, Dorian Vale addresses the often overlooked violence of language in art criticism. Drawing from the philosophical core of Post-Interpretive Criticism (PIC), this work reframes writing not as interpretation, but as custody—an act of ethical stewardship over what cannot be explained without distortion.

\n

 

\n

Vale explores how clinical, ironic, or overly descriptive language can flatten the moral gravity of witness-based artworks—particularly those dealing with trauma, silence, exile, or the sacred. Instead of attempting to decode or resolve these works, the essay proposes a discipline of linguistic restraint, where words become protective vessels rather than invasive instruments.

\n

 

\n

Through real case studies and comparative language analysis, Language as Custody offers both a conceptual foundation and practical framework for how one might write without harm. The goal is not to say more, but to write in a way that holds what the work cannot say aloud.

\n

 

\n

This is not a guide for translation—it is a doctrine for presence. A refusal to violate what resists interpretation. And in that refusal, it calls for a quieter, more reverent kind of authorship.

\n

 

\n

Vale, Dorian. Language as Custody — Writing Without Harm in Post-Interpretive Criticism. Museum of One, 2025. DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17077653

\n
\n
 
\n
\n

This entry is connected to a series of original theories and treatises forming the foundation of the Post-Interpretive Criticism movement (Q136308909), authored by Dorian Vale (Q136308916) and published by Museum of One (Q136308879). These include: Stillmark Theory (Q136328254), Hauntmark Theory (Q136328273), Absential Aesthetic Theory (Q136328330), Viewer-as-Evidence Theory (Q136328828), Message-Transfer Theory (Q136329002), Aesthetic Displacement Theory (Q136329014), Theory of Misplacement (Q136329054), and Art as Truth: A Treatise (Q136329071), Aesthetic Recursion Theory (Q136339843)

\n
\n
\n

 

\n

post-interpretive criticism, Dorian Vale, study guide for art criticism, five principles of art ethics, ethical witnessing in art, presence over interpretation, restraint in criticism, moral proximity, viewer as evidence, rejecting performance, contemporary art criticism, poetic criticism, art education resources, museum pedagogy, witnessing trauma in art, art writing without interpretation, anti-interpretation philosophy, critique without harm, non-extractive art writing

", "provenance": { "repository": "Zenodo REST API response supplied in query.json", "retrieved": "2026-11-04", "editorial_fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "source_snapshot": "source/19863851.json", "institutional_review": "Reviewed page-level title, author and repository links in saved public institutional HTML, 2026-11-04." }, "institutional_metadata": { "title": "Language as Custody: Writing Without Harm in Post-Interpretive Criticism", "author": "Dorian Vale", "web_publication": "2025-10-15T03:33:00.000Z", "web_updated": "2026-11-03T00:42:43.000Z", "linked_zenodo_dois": [ "10.5281/zenodo.17077653" ], "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/language-as-custody-writing-without-harm-in-post-interpretive-criticism/" }, "source_review": "2026-11-04", "relations": [ { "identifier": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "relation": "cites", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://hcommons.org/members/dorianvale/", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://osf.io/xa5jw/", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://philpeople.org/profiles/dorian-vale", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://independent.academia.edu/DorianVale", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://figshare.com/authors/Dorian_Vale/22186984", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "10.5281/zenodo.17112807", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "10.5281/zenodo.17078847", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "10.5281/zenodo.17069115", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5443334", "relation": "isIdenticalTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "10.2139/ssrn.5443334", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Post-Interprative-Criticism%3A-Foundational-Essays-Vale/09538ab14a89022e2886f9cccaf133e8d5c9cf7d", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://zenodo.org/communities/post-interpretive-criticism", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://www.semanticscholar.org/author/Dorian-Vale/2380743266", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "https://scholar.google.com/citations?hl=en&authuser=1&user=15tvhjAAAAAJ", "relation": "cites", "scheme": "url" }, { "identifier": "10.2139/ssrn.5471149", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "doi" }, { "identifier": "https://ssrn.com/abstract=5471149", "relation": "isSupplementTo", "scheme": "url" } ], "research_programmes": [], "record_level": "Item", "record_status": "Published source; selected catalogue record", "digital_formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "extent": "1 digital file; 253299 bytes", "medium": "Digital document", "record_reviewed": "2026-11-04", "date_precision": "year", "alternate_titles": [ { "title": "Language as Custody: Writing Without Harm in Post-Interpretive Criticism", "kind": "institutional_web_record_title", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/language-as-custody-writing-without-harm-in-post-interpretive-criticism/" } ], "digital_extent": { "file_count": 1, "total_bytes": 253299, "formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "checksums": [ { "filename": "Language as Custody — Writing Without Harm in Post-Interpretive Criticism.pdf", "algorithm": "md5", "value": "634bb017af7a7d068ea135a9c85a7a57", "syntax_valid": true, "verification": "source_checksum_transcription; bytes not independently recomputed" } ], "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863851", "derivation": "File count and total bytes calculated from repository file metadata; MIME inferred from filename when absent." }, "identifier_validation": { "orcid": { "source_value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "ISO 7064 MOD 11-2 checksum only; this is not a live registry verification." }, "isbn": [], "doi": { "source_value": "10.5281/zenodo.19863851", "syntax_valid": true, "note": "Syntax check only; repository snapshot supplies the identifier." } }, "isbn_applicability": "not_supplied", "serial": null, "contributor_roles": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": null, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863851" }, { "name": "Museumofone.art", "source_category": "contributor", "source_role": "RightsHolder", "role_label": "RightsHolder", "affiliation_as_supplied": null, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863851" }, { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "source_category": "contributor", "source_role": "RightsHolder", "role_label": "RightsHolder", "affiliation_as_supplied": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863851" } ], "authority_links": [], "metadata_profile": { "name": "Museum of One source-qualified catalogue profile", "version": "3.0.0", "url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/metadata-profile.json", "source_snapshot_preserved": true }, "reading_copy": { "id": "19863851", "title": "Language as Custody — Writing Without Harm in Post-Interpretive Criticism", "accession": "MOO-CAT-016", "pdf_url": "../assets/documents/19863851.pdf", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19863851/files/Language%20as%20Custody%20%E2%80%94%20Writing%20Without%20Harm%20in%20Post-Interpretive%20Criticism.pdf/content", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863851", "source_filename": "Language as Custody — Writing Without Harm in Post-Interpretive Criticism.pdf", "checksum": "md5:634bb017af7a7d068ea135a9c85a7a57", "sha256": "19c917b77900de0fc1602c77d0ebd293a2b926a68e052ea36aca75623ed217c5", "bytes": 253299, "page_count": 4, "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "checksum_match": true, "rights": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "role": "Local reading copy; original repository file retained unchanged" }, "page_count": 4, "field_assertions": [ { "field": "title", "value": "Language as Custody — Writing Without Harm in Post-Interpretive Criticism", "status": "catalogue_title", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/language-as-custody-writing-without-harm-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "Local display title; the deposited title is retained separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_title", "value": "Language as Custody — Writing Without Harm in Post-Interpretive Criticism", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863851", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "doi", "value": "10.5281/zenodo.19863851", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863851", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "date", "value": "2026", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863851", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "conceptdoi", "value": "10.5281/zenodo.17077652", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863851", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "creators", "value": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "affiliation": null, "orcid": "0009-0004-7737-5094" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863851", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "keywords", "value": [ "Restraint in front of art", "Moral proximity", "Interpretive silence", "Erasure as ethics", "Silence as method", "Ontology of beauty", "Aesthetic mercy", "Language as violence", "Art encounter ethics", "Epistemology of witness", "Divine proximity in aesthetics", "Philosophy of Art", "Aesthetics", "Art Theory", "Contemporary Aesthetics", "Phenomenology and Art", "Ethics in Art Criticism", "Interpretation and Meaning", "Criticism and Reception Theory", "Visual Culture Studies", "Founder of Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Post-Aesthetic Critic", "Independent Philosopher of Art", "Museum of One", "Art Writer and Theorist", "Custodian of Witness Aesthetics", "Art as Truth", "The Viewer as Evidence", "nterpretation vs. Witnessing", "Erasure as Afterlife", "Language as Custody", "Post-Interpretive Lexicon", "Alternative art criticism", "New art criticism movement", "Ethical art theory", "Criticism beyond interpretation", "Quiet philosophy of art", "Radical art restraint", "Witness over interpretation", "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "Dorian Vale", "Witness Aesthetics", "Stillmark Theory", "Art as Presence", "Art Criticism Ethics", "Custodianship of Art", "Copyright © Dorian Vale. Published by Museum of One.", "https://www.museumofone.art/", "https://hcommons.org/members/dorianvale/", "https://philpeople.org/profiles/dorian-vale", "https://osf.io/xa5jw/", "https://independent.academia.edu/DorianVale", "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17078847", "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17112807", "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17069115", "https://figshare.com/authors/Dorian_Vale/22186984", "https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5443334", "http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.5443334", "http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.5443334", "Q136308909", "Q136308879", "Q136308916", "https://scholar.google.com/citations?hl=en&authuser=1&user=15tvhjAAAAAJ" ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863851", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "license", "value": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863851", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "files", "value": [ { "name": "Language as Custody — Writing Without Harm in Post-Interpretive Criticism.pdf", "url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19863851/files/Language%20as%20Custody%20%E2%80%94%20Writing%20Without%20Harm%20in%20Post-Interpretive%20Criticism.pdf/content", "size": 253299, "size_label": "247 KB", "checksum": "md5:634bb017af7a7d068ea135a9c85a7a57", "mimetype": "application/pdf" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863851", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_created", "value": "2026-04-28T18:55:23.348733+00:00", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863851", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_modified", "value": "2026-10-11T17:52:14.842757+00:00", "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863851", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "record_modified", "value": "2026-11-04", "status": "derived_from_description_history", "note": "Latest documented local description event; not a publication, repository or source-review date.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "source_review", "value": "2026-11-04", "status": "catalogue_source_review", "note": "Review of descriptive sources; not the creation or modification date of the work or repository record.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "author", "value": "Dorian Vale", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/language-as-custody-writing-without-harm-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "Institutional responsibility statement; original repository creator roles remain separate.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "publisher", "value": "Museum of One", "status": "institutional_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/language-as-custody-writing-without-harm-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "Institutional responsibility statement; original repository creator roles remain separate.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "orcid", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "source_linked_identifier", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/language-as-custody-writing-without-harm-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "Creator identifier supplied by the linked sources; no affiliation or endorsement is inferred.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "orcid_authority", "value": { "scheme": "ORCID", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "evidence_urls": [ "https://www.museumofone.art/archives-scholarly-infrastructure/", "https://eprints.rclis.org/47182/", "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ], "access_note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "evidence_receipt": "data/source/authority-review-2026-11-04.json" }, "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "source_url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "summary", "value": "An essay considering how language may protect or distort the ethical force of artworks. It develops restraint in writing as a form of custodianship, particularly around trauma, silence, and exile.", "status": "editorial_enrichment", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/language-as-custody-writing-without-harm-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "Catalogue-editor summary based on the linked work; not an original publisher abstract.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "subjects", "value": [ "Critical language", "Art writing", "Custodianship", "Post-Interpretive Criticism" ], "status": "editorial_enrichment", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/language-as-custody-writing-without-harm-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "Local discovery terms; no controlled-vocabulary assignment is claimed.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "collection", "value": "Theory & treatises", "status": "editorial_grouping", "note": "A local browsing collection, not an original repository collection.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "corroboration", "value": "Museum of One’s matching publication page confirms Dorian Vale’s authorship and the work’s institutional context. Its repository links and publication dates are retained separately from this selected Zenodo edition. Web-record dates are not treated as dates of the deposited edition. Source review: 4 November 2026.", "status": "catalogue_review_note", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/language-as-custody-writing-without-harm-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "discrepancies", "value": [ "The source description includes a 2025 citation and an earlier DOI. The selected Zenodo record has a 2026 publication-date field; a web-publication date is not substituted for that deposited date.", "The institutional page does not explicitly link this selected edition DOI in its saved HTML. The match is at work level through title, authorship, and publication context; the catalogue preserves the exact repository edition separately." ], "status": "catalogue_review_note", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/language-as-custody-writing-without-harm-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "alternate_titles", "value": [ { "title": "Language as Custody: Writing Without Harm in Post-Interpretive Criticism", "kind": "institutional_web_record_title", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/language-as-custody-writing-without-harm-in-post-interpretive-criticism/" } ], "status": "source_qualified_title_variants", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/language-as-custody-writing-without-harm-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "Each variant retains its own source and scope; a web page title is not a title-page transcription.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "date_precision", "value": "year", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863851", "note": "Precision reported exactly as supplied; missing month or day is not filled.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "medium", "value": "Digital document", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863851", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "digital_formats", "value": [ "application/pdf" ], "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863851", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "extent", "value": "1 digital file; 253299 bytes", "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863851", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "digital_extent", "value": { "file_count": 1, "total_bytes": 253299, "formats": [ "application/pdf" ], "checksums": [ { "filename": "Language as Custody — Writing Without Harm in Post-Interpretive Criticism.pdf", "algorithm": "md5", "value": "634bb017af7a7d068ea135a9c85a7a57", "syntax_valid": true, "verification": "source_checksum_transcription; bytes not independently recomputed" } ], "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863851", "derivation": "File count and total bytes calculated from repository file metadata; MIME inferred from filename when absent." }, "status": "derived_from_source", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863851", "note": "Digital medium and extent derived from repository file metadata; no physical custody is implied. MIME may be inferred from filename. Repository checksums are transcribed; reading-copy verification, where available, is recorded separately.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "identifier_validation", "value": { "orcid": { "source_value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "checksum_valid": true, "note": "ISO 7064 MOD 11-2 checksum only; this is not a live registry verification." }, "isbn": [], "doi": { "source_value": "10.5281/zenodo.19863851", "syntax_valid": true, "note": "Syntax check only; repository snapshot supplies the identifier." } }, "status": "local_syntax_validation", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863851", "note": "Checksum/syntax validation does not verify registration, assignment or edition applicability.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "contributor_roles", "value": [ { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "source_category": "creator", "source_role": null, "role_label": "Creator (role not supplied)", "affiliation_as_supplied": null, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863851" }, { "name": "Museumofone.art", "source_category": "contributor", "source_role": "RightsHolder", "role_label": "RightsHolder", "affiliation_as_supplied": null, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863851" }, { "name": "Vale, Dorian", "source_category": "contributor", "source_role": "RightsHolder", "role_label": "RightsHolder", "affiliation_as_supplied": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863851" } ], "status": "source_transcription", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863851", "note": "Creator and contributor roles are transcribed, not inferred from names or affiliations.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" }, { "field": "entity_link:dorian-vale:author", "value": { "id": "dorian-vale", "label": "Dorian Vale", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "author", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/language-as-custody-writing-without-harm-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author.", "variants": [ "Vale, Dorian" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/language-as-custody-writing-without-harm-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:080dde8f2fa50ac4386d1d99c8d0be72851b7abd618e3ce203aa51efd27cf960", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863851.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/language-as-custody-writing-without-harm-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/language-as-custody-writing-without-harm-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." } }, { "field": "entity_link:museum-of-one:publisher", "value": { "id": "museum-of-one", "label": "Museum of One", "entity_type": "Organization", "relation": "publisher", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/language-as-custody-writing-without-harm-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record.", "variants": [ "MuseumofOne", "MUSEUM OF ONE" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/language-as-custody-writing-without-harm-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "status": "institutional_context_relationship", "note": "Contextual role is source-qualified; subject artists and referenced scholars are not publication coauthors.", "assertion": { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:700f4e662e14775464ea7b821775d365895840666ba6484e3ff9ba53b3910db5", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863851.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/language-as-custody-writing-without-harm-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/language-as-custody-writing-without-harm-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." } }, { "field": "controlled_subjects", "value": [ { "id": "critical-language", "label": "Critical language", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#critical-language", "url": "vocabulary.html#critical-language", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:critical-language", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "The terms and linguistic choices through which critical claims are made.", "scope_note": "Use for publications examining wording, descriptive authority, restraint, or the circulation of interpretation.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "art-writing", "museum-cataloguing" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "art-writing", "label": "Art writing", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#art-writing", "url": "vocabulary.html#art-writing", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:art-writing", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Writing about art as a literary and critical practice.", "scope_note": "Use when the act and responsibility of writing are central; related to but distinct from Art criticism.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "art-criticism", "critical-language" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "custodianship", "label": "Custodianship", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#custodianship", "url": "vocabulary.html#custodianship", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:custodianship", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "A responsibility of care toward artworks within the author’s critical framework.", "scope_note": "Local PIC concept. This intellectual use is distinct from legal custody, repository ownership, or archival transfer.", "kind": "local-framework-concept", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "post-interpretive-criticism" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "post-interpretive-criticism", "label": "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#post-interpretive-criticism", "url": "vocabulary.html#post-interpretive-criticism", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:post-interpretive-criticism", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "PIC", "Post Interpretive Criticism" ], "definition": "The critical framework named and developed in the Museum of One publications.", "scope_note": "Local named intellectual framework. Used for records explicitly concerned with it; no Getty, Library of Congress, or other external equivalence is asserted.", "kind": "local-framework-concept", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "custodianship", "ethics-of-witnessing", "foundational-writings", "moral-proximity" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Local preferred terms with definitions and synonyms. External alignment is scoped in the vocabulary register." }, { "field": "genre_terms", "value": [ { "id": "genre-journal-article", "label": "Journal article", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#genre-journal-article", "url": "vocabulary.html#genre-journal-article", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:genre-journal-article", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Journal articles" ], "definition": "A contribution issued as part of a journal or periodical.", "scope_note": "Describes publication genre based on the catalogued source record; peer-review status is a separate question.", "kind": "genre", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "verified_mapping", "external_mappings": [ { "vocabulary": "Getty Art & Architecture Thesaurus", "label": "articles", "uri": "http://vocab.getty.edu/aat/300048715", "source_url": "https://www.getty.edu/vow/AATFullDisplay?find=&logic=AND¬e=&subjectid=300048715", "relation": "broadMatch", "status": "verified", "verified_on": "2026-11-04", "note": "Getty’s articles concept includes contributions to magazines, newspapers, encyclopedias, and other works; journal article is the narrower local genre." } ], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "type", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Local resource-genre classification. Digital file format is recorded separately." }, { "field": "archival_context", "value": { "description_profile": "moo-description-policy-1.0", "catalogue_snapshot_date": "2026-11-04", "snapshot_note": "Selected catalogue snapshot; not a live repository synchronisation.", "record_category": "Published library and repository material", "reference_code_status": "Stable local catalogue reference; not evidence of an archival acquisition or a previous catalogue accession.", "source_repository": { "name": "Zenodo", "record_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863851" }, "institutional_context_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/language-as-custody-writing-without-harm-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_metadata_retrieved": "2026-11-04", "source_metadata_retrieval_status": "Documented in catalogue source provenance", "source_snapshot": "source/19863851.json", "source_filenames": [ "Language as Custody — Writing Without Harm in Post-Interpretive Criticism.pdf" ], "selection_basis": "Local descriptive selection of publicly published material; public availability does not establish ownership of originals.", "custodial_history": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No donation, physical transfer, acquisition agreement or chain of custody is documented by this catalogue. Zenodo remains the source repository for the deposited version." }, "original_order": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No original archival order is asserted. Current browsing groupings are local editorial arrangement." }, "arrangement": { "status": "local_editorial", "grouping": "Theory & treatises", "statement": "A browsing grouping, not an original fonds or archival series." }, "responsible_service": { "name": "Museum of One", "service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "website": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "email": "research@museumofone.art" }, "description_method": "Source-based description with automated drafting and metadata assistance. Responsibility for the public catalogue rests with Museum of One; automated assistance does not constitute independent scholarly or curatorial review.", "policy_url": "policies.html", "correction_email": "research@museumofone.art", "access_copy": { "role": "Local digital reading copy of the deposited file", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19863851/files/Language%20as%20Custody%20%E2%80%94%20Writing%20Without%20Harm%20in%20Post-Interpretive%20Criticism.pdf/content", "source_filename": "Language as Custody — Writing Without Harm in Post-Interpretive Criticism.pdf", "local_path": "assets/documents/19863851.pdf", "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "source_checksum_match": true, "sha256": "19c917b77900de0fc1602c77d0ebd293a2b926a68e052ea36aca75623ed217c5", "statement": "Access copy only; no ownership or physical custody transfer is implied." } }, "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Provenance records what is documented and leaves unknown custody and original order explicit." }, { "field": "description_history", "value": [ { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Source-based catalogue description", "note": "Local description assembled from the identified public repository record and available institutional work record. Source metadata remains separately identifiable.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/19863851", "https://www.museumofone.art/language-as-custody-writing-without-harm-in-post-interpretive-criticism/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Qualified descriptive enrichment", "note": "Local editorial description, arrangement and source-qualified bibliographic context recorded alongside source metadata. Unknown or disputed values remain qualified.", "fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/19863851", "https://www.museumofone.art/language-as-custody-writing-without-harm-in-post-interpretive-criticism/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Automated file checksum and PDF inspection", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Digital reading copy verified", "note": "Downloaded access-copy MD5 matched the source checksum; local SHA-256 and PDF file-page count are recorded in the file manifest. This event does not describe transfer of custody.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19863851/files/Language%20as%20Custody%20%E2%80%94%20Writing%20Without%20Harm%20in%20Post-Interpretive%20Criticism.pdf/content" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Description policy and provenance context adopted", "note": "Responsible service, source repository, local access-copy role, unknown custody and original order, correction route and dated description history made explicit under moo-description-policy-1.0.", "sources": [ "policies.html" ] }, { "event_id": "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Unify graph identities and qualify exported relationships and citations", "note": "Local graph projection now uses one contextual identity per entity, distinguishes work-level institutional matches from selected-edition links, retains title-level ISBN uncertainty, and derives citations from the source title. Typed relation assertions and a versioned validation profile are introduced. No publication date, original source snapshot or PDF changed.", "fields": [ "metadata_profile", "relationship_assertions", "identity", "institutional_match_scope", "citation_projection" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Source-based metadata implementation and regression validation", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication, source review or acquisition date", "sources": [ "metadata/metadata-profile.json" ] }, { "event_id": "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Record inspected public ORCID profile evidence", "note": "The official ORCID public person API returned the credited name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website. This confirms a matching public profile, not independently verified biographical or affiliation claims. Original creator arrays and source snapshots are unchanged.", "fields": [ "orcid_authority" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Read-only official public API inspection", "date_kind": "Local authority review and catalogue description event; not a publication or original creation date", "sources": [ "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ] } ], "source_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "status": "editorial_description_control", "note": "Catalogue description events; these are not work publication dates or acquisition dates." }, { "field": "relationship_assertions", "value": [ { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:080dde8f2fa50ac4386d1d99c8d0be72851b7abd618e3ce203aa51efd27cf960", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863851.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/language-as-custody-writing-without-harm-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/language-as-custody-writing-without-harm-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:700f4e662e14775464ea7b821775d365895840666ba6484e3ff9ba53b3910db5", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863851.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/language-as-custody-writing-without-harm-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/language-as-custody-writing-without-harm-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:bf49ca3cb7593dfb1752ba9a3a1ee77bf4c3d28a72ee7b1cd6407c50a15fc9f4", "subject": "https://www.museumofone.art/language-as-custody-writing-without-harm-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#describes", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863851.html#work", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/language-as-custody-writing-without-harm-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "metadata_field", "field": "linked_zenodo_dois", "values": [ "10.5281/zenodo.17077653" ] }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "Exact-edition matching requires the selected DOI in the reviewed page metadata; other matches retain their wider scope." } ], "status": "typed_evidence_projection", "note": "Stable, typed assertions retain source scope and explicit unknown review metadata." }, { "field": "reading_copy", "value": { "id": "19863851", "title": "Language as Custody — Writing Without Harm in Post-Interpretive Criticism", "accession": "MOO-CAT-016", "pdf_url": "../assets/documents/19863851.pdf", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19863851/files/Language%20as%20Custody%20%E2%80%94%20Writing%20Without%20Harm%20in%20Post-Interpretive%20Criticism.pdf/content", "zenodo_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863851", "source_filename": "Language as Custody — Writing Without Harm in Post-Interpretive Criticism.pdf", "checksum": "md5:634bb017af7a7d068ea135a9c85a7a57", "sha256": "19c917b77900de0fc1602c77d0ebd293a2b926a68e052ea36aca75623ed217c5", "bytes": 253299, "page_count": 4, "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "checksum_match": true, "rights": { "label": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "role": "Local reading copy; original repository file retained unchanged" }, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19863851/files/Language%20as%20Custody%20%E2%80%94%20Writing%20Without%20Harm%20in%20Post-Interpretive%20Criticism.pdf/content", "status": "derived_file_inspection", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "note": "Byte-identical local access copy. Source MD5 was recomputed and matched; SHA-256 and page count were measured from the downloaded PDF. This is not a preservation-deposit claim." }, { "field": "page_count", "value": 4, "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19863851/files/Language%20as%20Custody%20%E2%80%94%20Writing%20Without%20Harm%20in%20Post-Interpretive%20Criticism.pdf/content", "status": "derived_file_inspection", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "note": "Total PDF file pages measured from the deposited file, including cover and unnumbered pages. Not a claim about printed pagination." } ], "entity_links": [ { "id": "dorian-vale", "label": "Dorian Vale", "entity_type": "Person", "relation": "author", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/language-as-custody-writing-without-harm-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author.", "variants": [ "Vale, Dorian" ], "evidence_scope": "work" }, { "id": "museum-of-one", "label": "Museum of One", "entity_type": "Organization", "relation": "publisher", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/language-as-custody-writing-without-harm-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record.", "variants": [ "MuseumofOne", "MUSEUM OF ONE" ], "evidence_scope": "work" } ], "contents": [], "controlled_subjects": [ { "id": "critical-language", "label": "Critical language", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#critical-language", "url": "vocabulary.html#critical-language", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:critical-language", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "The terms and linguistic choices through which critical claims are made.", "scope_note": "Use for publications examining wording, descriptive authority, restraint, or the circulation of interpretation.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "art-writing", "museum-cataloguing" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "art-writing", "label": "Art writing", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#art-writing", "url": "vocabulary.html#art-writing", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:art-writing", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "Writing about art as a literary and critical practice.", "scope_note": "Use when the act and responsibility of writing are central; related to but distinct from Art criticism.", "kind": "subject", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "art-criticism", "critical-language" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "custodianship", "label": "Custodianship", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#custodianship", "url": "vocabulary.html#custodianship", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:custodianship", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [], "definition": "A responsibility of care toward artworks within the author’s critical framework.", "scope_note": "Local PIC concept. This intellectual use is distinct from legal custody, repository ownership, or archival transfer.", "kind": "local-framework-concept", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "post-interpretive-criticism" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } }, { "id": "post-interpretive-criticism", "label": "Post-Interpretive Criticism", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#post-interpretive-criticism", "url": "vocabulary.html#post-interpretive-criticism", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:post-interpretive-criticism", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "PIC", "Post Interpretive Criticism" ], "definition": "The critical framework named and developed in the Museum of One publications.", "scope_note": "Local named intellectual framework. Used for records explicitly concerned with it; no Getty, Library of Congress, or other external equivalence is asserted.", "kind": "local-framework-concept", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [ "custodianship", "ethics-of-witnessing", "foundational-writings", "moral-proximity" ], "mapping_status": "not_asserted", "external_mappings": [], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "subjects", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "genre_terms": [ { "id": "genre-journal-article", "label": "Journal article", "uri": "https://archive.museumofone.art/vocabulary.html#genre-journal-article", "url": "vocabulary.html#genre-journal-article", "persistent_id": "urn:museum-of-one:vocabulary:genre-journal-article", "scheme": "museum-of-one-discovery-vocabulary", "scheme_version": 4, "alternative_labels": [ "Journal articles" ], "definition": "A contribution issued as part of a journal or periodical.", "scope_note": "Describes publication genre based on the catalogued source record; peer-review status is a separate question.", "kind": "genre", "broader": [], "narrower": [], "related": [], "mapping_status": "verified_mapping", "external_mappings": [ { "vocabulary": "Getty Art & Architecture Thesaurus", "label": "articles", "uri": "http://vocab.getty.edu/aat/300048715", "source_url": "https://www.getty.edu/vow/AATFullDisplay?find=&logic=AND¬e=&subjectid=300048715", "relation": "broadMatch", "status": "verified", "verified_on": "2026-11-04", "note": "Getty’s articles concept includes contributions to magazines, newspapers, encyclopedias, and other works; journal article is the narrower local genre." } ], "assignment_provenance": { "status": "local_editorial_access_term", "input_field": "type", "editorial_owner": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "reviewed": "2026-11-04" } } ], "vocabulary_version": 4, "description_history": [ { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Source-based catalogue description", "note": "Local description assembled from the identified public repository record and available institutional work record. Source metadata remains separately identifiable.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/19863851", "https://www.museumofone.art/language-as-custody-writing-without-harm-in-post-interpretive-criticism/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Qualified descriptive enrichment", "note": "Local editorial description, arrangement and source-qualified bibliographic context recorded alongside source metadata. Unknown or disputed values remain qualified.", "fields": [ "summary", "subjects", "collection", "short_title", "accession" ], "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/records/19863851", "https://www.museumofone.art/language-as-custody-writing-without-harm-in-post-interpretive-criticism/" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Automated file checksum and PDF inspection", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Digital reading copy verified", "note": "Downloaded access-copy MD5 matched the source checksum; local SHA-256 and PDF file-page count are recorded in the file manifest. This event does not describe transfer of custody.", "sources": [ "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19863851/files/Language%20as%20Custody%20%E2%80%94%20Writing%20Without%20Harm%20in%20Post-Interpretive%20Criticism.pdf/content" ] }, { "responsible_service": "Museum of One", "method": "Source-based automated description assistance", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication or acquisition date", "event_id": "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Description policy and provenance context adopted", "note": "Responsible service, source repository, local access-copy role, unknown custody and original order, correction route and dated description history made explicit under moo-description-policy-1.0.", "sources": [ "policies.html" ] }, { "event_id": "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Unify graph identities and qualify exported relationships and citations", "note": "Local graph projection now uses one contextual identity per entity, distinguishes work-level institutional matches from selected-edition links, retains title-level ISBN uncertainty, and derives citations from the source title. Typed relation assertions and a versioned validation profile are introduced. No publication date, original source snapshot or PDF changed.", "fields": [ "metadata_profile", "relationship_assertions", "identity", "institutional_match_scope", "citation_projection" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Source-based metadata implementation and regression validation", "date_kind": "Catalogue description event; not a publication, source review or acquisition date", "sources": [ "metadata/metadata-profile.json" ] }, { "event_id": "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04", "date": "2026-11-04", "action": "Record inspected public ORCID profile evidence", "note": "The official ORCID public person API returned the credited name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website. This confirms a matching public profile, not independently verified biographical or affiliation claims. Original creator arrays and source snapshots are unchanged.", "fields": [ "orcid_authority" ], "responsible_service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "method": "Read-only official public API inspection", "date_kind": "Local authority review and catalogue description event; not a publication or original creation date", "sources": [ "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ] } ], "record_modified": "2026-11-04", "record_modified_provenance": { "status": "derived_from_description_history", "event_ids": [ "public-source-description-2026-11-04", "qualified-description-2026-11-04", "access-copy-verification-2026-11-04", "description-policy-1.0-2026-11-04", "metadata-profile-3.0-2026-11-04", "orcid-public-profile-review-2026-11-04" ], "note": "Latest documented local description event; not a publication, repository or source-review date." }, "archival_context": { "description_profile": "moo-description-policy-1.0", "catalogue_snapshot_date": "2026-11-04", "snapshot_note": "Selected catalogue snapshot; not a live repository synchronisation.", "record_category": "Published library and repository material", "reference_code_status": "Stable local catalogue reference; not evidence of an archival acquisition or a previous catalogue accession.", "source_repository": { "name": "Zenodo", "record_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/19863851" }, "institutional_context_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/language-as-custody-writing-without-harm-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_metadata_retrieved": "2026-11-04", "source_metadata_retrieval_status": "Documented in catalogue source provenance", "source_snapshot": "source/19863851.json", "source_filenames": [ "Language as Custody — Writing Without Harm in Post-Interpretive Criticism.pdf" ], "selection_basis": "Local descriptive selection of publicly published material; public availability does not establish ownership of originals.", "custodial_history": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No donation, physical transfer, acquisition agreement or chain of custody is documented by this catalogue. Zenodo remains the source repository for the deposited version." }, "original_order": { "status": "not_documented", "statement": "No original archival order is asserted. Current browsing groupings are local editorial arrangement." }, "arrangement": { "status": "local_editorial", "grouping": "Theory & treatises", "statement": "A browsing grouping, not an original fonds or archival series." }, "responsible_service": { "name": "Museum of One", "service": "Museum of One Digital Archive Library", "website": "https://www.museumofone.art/", "email": "research@museumofone.art" }, "description_method": "Source-based description with automated drafting and metadata assistance. Responsibility for the public catalogue rests with Museum of One; automated assistance does not constitute independent scholarly or curatorial review.", "policy_url": "policies.html", "correction_email": "research@museumofone.art", "access_copy": { "role": "Local digital reading copy of the deposited file", "source_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/19863851/files/Language%20as%20Custody%20%E2%80%94%20Writing%20Without%20Harm%20in%20Post-Interpretive%20Criticism.pdf/content", "source_filename": "Language as Custody — Writing Without Harm in Post-Interpretive Criticism.pdf", "local_path": "assets/documents/19863851.pdf", "verified_at": "2026-11-04", "source_checksum_match": true, "sha256": "19c917b77900de0fc1602c77d0ebd293a2b926a68e052ea36aca75623ed217c5", "statement": "Access copy only; no ownership or physical custody transfer is implied." } }, "description_policy_url": "https://archive.museumofone.art/policies.html", "pirr_references": [], "pirr_work_identity": { "archive_reference": "MOO-CAT-016", "edition_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19863851", "zenodo_record_id": "19863851", "identifier_scope": "Publication identity; PIRR identifiers in programme relationships identify research records, not this publication." }, "metadata_origin": "https://archive.museumofone.art", "identity": { "work": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863851.html#work", "edition": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19863851", "version_family": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17077652", "catalogue_record": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863851.html#catalogue-record" }, "institutional_match_scope": "work", "relationship_assertions": [ { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:080dde8f2fa50ac4386d1d99c8d0be72851b7abd618e3ce203aa51efd27cf960", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863851.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#authored-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/dorian-vale.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/language-as-custody-writing-without-harm-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/language-as-custody-writing-without-harm-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The matching institutional publication record credits Dorian Vale as author." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:700f4e662e14775464ea7b821775d365895840666ba6484e3ff9ba53b3910db5", "subject": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863851.html#work", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#published-by", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/entities/museum-of-one.html#entity", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/language-as-custody-writing-without-harm-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "web_page", "url": "https://www.museumofone.art/language-as-custody-writing-without-harm-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "precision": "page" }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "The institutional work page identifies Museum of One as publisher of the web publication; repository edition details remain in the item record." }, { "id": "urn:museum-of-one:assertion:bf49ca3cb7593dfb1752ba9a3a1ee77bf4c3d28a72ee7b1cd6407c50a15fc9f4", "subject": "https://www.museumofone.art/language-as-custody-writing-without-harm-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "predicate": "https://archive.museumofone.art/metadata/relations.json#describes", "object": "https://archive.museumofone.art/items/19863851.html#work", "scope": "work", "status": "source_corroborated_context", "source_url": "https://www.museumofone.art/language-as-custody-writing-without-harm-in-post-interpretive-criticism/", "source_location": { "kind": "metadata_field", "field": "linked_zenodo_dois", "values": [ "10.5281/zenodo.17077653" ] }, "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "reviewer": null, "unknowns": [ "reviewer" ], "note": "Exact-edition matching requires the selected DOI in the reviewed page metadata; other matches retain their wider scope." } ], "orcid_authority": { "scheme": "ORCID", "value": "0009-0004-7737-5094", "url": "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7737-5094", "status": "public_orcid_profile_inspected", "evidence_urls": [ "https://www.museumofone.art/archives-scholarly-infrastructure/", "https://eprints.rclis.org/47182/", "https://pub.orcid.org/v3.0/0009-0004-7737-5094/person" ], "access_note": "Public ORCID v3 person API returned HTTP 200 on 4 November 2026. Credit name Dorian Vale and the Museum of One website URL match the local author record. Profile names and links are user-supplied; affiliation, biography and endorsement are not independently verified.", "reviewed": "2026-11-04", "evidence_receipt": "data/source/authority-review-2026-11-04.json" } } ] }